Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.11045 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Differentiating Hund from Mott physics in a three-band Hubbard-Hund model: Temperature dependence of spectral, transport, and thermodynamic properties

K. M. Stadler, Gabriel Kotliar, Seung‐Sup B. Lee, Andreas Weichselbaum, Jan von Delft

Published Sep 7, 2021• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For many years, strong electronic correlations in metals have mainly been associated with `Mottness' driven by the Coulomb repulsion, which suppresses charge fluctuations. Recently, `Hundness', induced by Hund's rule coupling that affects spin dynamics, has gained recognition as another route to strong correlations. Using dynamical mean-field theory and the numerical renormalization group, the authors identify numerous fingerprints distinguishing Hundness from Mottness in the temperature dependence of various physical quantities for a minimal model of Hund metals.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.115107

Related papers

A model study of strong correlations in Hund metals

K. M. Stadler

For a long time strong electronic correlations in metals have mainly been associated with Mottness, the proximity to a Mott metal-insulator transition (MIT), where large Coulomb interactions induce the localization of charges. However, triggered by the discovery of the iron-based superconductors about ten years ago, it was realized that multi-orbital materials with only moderate Coulomb but sizeable Hund’s rule interactions – so-called Hund metals – allow for a distinct screening mechanism towards strong correlations: Hundness. Here, Hund’s rule constrains the spin rather than the charge dynamics. This discovery led to a vividly debated fundamental issue in the field of strongly correlated condensed matter systems, which is the main topic of the present thesis: what is the origin of strong correlations in the normal phase of Hund metals, Mottness or Hundness? And what are their decisive fingerprints? The goal of this dissertation is twofold. First, we present and advance our method: the numerical renormalization group (NRG) as viable real-frequency multi-band impurity solver for dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), a common approach to tackle strongly correlated systems. Second, we apply DMFT+NRG to shed light on the Hund-metal problem raised above. In the first part of this thesis we present our state-of-the-art NRG solver, which offers direct access to data with unprecedented real-frequency spectral resolution at arbitrarily low energies and temperatures in contrast to commonly used Quantum Monte Carlo solvers. It is based on matrix product states and exploits non-abelian symmetries to reduce numerical costs. In the case of orbital symmetry, this allows us to treat multi-band models with more than two bands, and thus to tackle the Hund-metal problem for the first time with NRG. For multi-band models without orbital symmetry, an “interleaved” scheme of NRG (iNRG) was recently developed, dramatically increasing the numerical efficiency. Remarkably, the accuracy of iNRG is comparable to standard NRG, as we reveal in a detailed study. This finding establishes iNRG as a promising DMFT solver for material-specific model simulations. In the second part of this thesis we study a minimal toy model for Hund metals with DMFT+NRG, the orbital-symmetric three-band Hubbard-Hund model (3HHM) close to a lattice filling of 1/3. Our major insight is “spin-orbital separation” (SOS), a Hund’s-ruleinduced two-stage Kondo-type screening process, in which orbital screening occurs at much higher energies than spin screening. In Hund metals, i.e. far from a MIT phase boundary, SOS thus causes large electron masses by strongly reducing the coherence scale below which a Fermi liquid is formed. Further, it opens up a broad incoherent and strongly particle-hole asymmetric intermediate energy regime that reaches up to bare excitation scales. This SOS regime shows fractional power-law behavior and is characterized by resilient “Hund quasiparticles” with itinerant orbital degrees of freedom coupled non-trivially to quasi-free large spins. At zero temperature, the local density of states exhibits a two-tier quasiparticle peak on top of a broad incoherent background. In contrast, in Mott-correlated metals, i.e. close to the MIT phase boundary, the SOS regime becomes negligibly small and the Hubbard bands are well separated. These findings lead to distinct signatures of Hundness and Mottness in the temperature dependence of ARPES spectra, static local susceptibilities, resistivity, thermopower and entropy, many of which were also found in realistic simulations of the archetypal Hund- and Mott-correlated materials, Sr2RuO4 and V2O3. In summary, we provide evidence that and elucidate how Hundness evokes strong correlation effects in Hund metals. This might help to better interpret experimental results and guide superconducting theories.

•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation

Quantum Phase Transition in the Two-Band Hubbard Model

Theo A. Costi, A. Liebsch

The interaction between itinerant and Mott localized electronic states in strongly correlated materials is studied within dynamical mean field theory in combination with the numerical renormalization group method. A novel nonmagnetic zero temperature quantum phase transition is found in the bad-metallic orbital-selective Mott phase of the two-band Hubbard model, for values of the Hund's exchange which are relevant to typical transition metal oxides.

arXiv:0707.4535•Physical Review Letters•Dec 7, 2007•39 citations

Frozen spin ratio and the detection of Hund correlations

Siheon Ryee, Sangkook Choi, Myung Joon Han

We propose a way to identify strongly Hund-correlated materials by unveiling a key signature of Hund correlations at the two-particle level. The defining feature is the sign of the response of the frozen spin ratio (the long-time local spin-spin correlation function divided by the instantaneous value) under variation of electron density. The underlying physical reason is that the sign is closely related to the strength of charge fluctuations between the dominant atomic multiplets and higher-spin ones in a neighboring charge subspace. It is the predominance of these fluctuations that promotes Hund metallicity. The temperature dependence of the frozen spin ratio can further reveal a non-Fermi-liquid behavior and thus the Hund metal states. We analyze both degenerate and nondegenerate multiorbital Hubbard models and corroborate our argument by taking doped ${\mathrm{La}}_{2}{\mathrm{CuO}}_{4}$ and LaFeAsO as representative material examples, respectively, of Mott and Hund metals. Our proposal should be applicable to systems with non-half-filled integer electron fillings and their doped cases provided the doping drove the electron density toward the half filling.

arXiv:2207.10421•Physical Review Research•Aug 25, 2023•8 citations

Quantum phase transition between orbital-selective Mott states in Hund's metals

Julián Rincón, Adriana Moreo, Gonzalo Álvarez +1 more

We report a quantum phase transition between orbital-selective Mott states, with different localized orbitals, in a Hund's metals model. Using the density matrix renormalization group, the phase diagram is constructed varying the electronic density and Hubbard $U$, at robust Hund's coupling. We demonstrate that this transition is preempted by charge fluctuations and the emergence of free spinless fermions, as opposed to the magnetically driven Mott transition. The Luttinger correlation exponent is shown to have a universal value in the strong-coupling phase, whereas it is interaction dependent at intermediate couplings. At weak coupling we find a second transition from a normal metal to the intermediate-coupling phase.

arXiv:1412.2174•Physical Review B•Dec 5, 2014•24 citations

Dynamic response functions for the Holstein-Hubbard model

Winfried Koller, D. Meyer, Alex C. Hewson

We present results on the dynamical correlation functions of the particle-hole symmetric Holstein-Hubbard model at zero temperature, calculated using the dynamical mean-field theory which is solved by the numerical renormalization group method. We clarify the competing influences of the electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions particularity at the different metal to insulator transitions. The Coulomb repulsion is found to dominate the behavior in large parts of the metallic regime. By suppressing charge fluctuations, it effectively decouples electrons from phonons. The phonon propagator shows a characteristic softening near the metal to bipolaronic transition but there is very little softening on the approach to the Mott transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/0404328•Physical Review B•Oct 12, 2004•67 citations

Mott transition in three-orbital Hubbard model with orbital splitting

Tomoko Kita, Takuma Ohashi, Norio Kawakami

We study the Mott transition in the three-orbital Hubbard model. To investigate how the orbital level splitting and the Ising-type Hund's coupling affect the Mott transition in the case of two electrons per site, we use the dynamical mean-field theory combined with continuous-time quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The calculation of the double occupancy reveals that the critical interaction strength separating a metallic phase and two kinds of insulating phases shows a nonmonotonic behavior as a function of the level splitting. We find that this behavior is characteristic for $1/3$ filling, in comparison with the preceding results for different fillings and for two-orbital models. Strong competition between the two insulators results in an intriguing first-order transition to an insulating phase having intermediate characters between Mott and band insulators. It is also found that the two insulators show different behaviors in the phase boundary with the metallic phase in the interaction-temperature plane, which is reflected in a difference in the quasiparticle behavior around the transition. We also discuss the orbital selective Mott transition for larger Hund's coupling, which is compared with previous study at zero temperature.

Physical Review B•Nov 28, 2011•26 citations
For many years, strong electronic correlations in metals have mainly been associated with Mottness' driven by the Coulomb repulsion, which suppresses charge fluctuations. Recently, Hundness', induced by Hund's rule coupling that affects spin dynamics, has gained recognition as another route to strong correlations. Using dynamical mean-field theory and the numerical renormalization group, the authors identify numerous fingerprints distinguishing Hundness from Mottness in the temperature dependence of various physical quantities for a minimal model of Hund metals.
For a long time strong electronic correlations in metals have mainly been associated with Mottness, the proximity to a Mott metal-insulator transition (MIT), where large Coulomb interactions induce the localization of charges. However, triggered by the discovery of the iron-based superconductors about ten years ago, it was realized that multi-orbital materials with only moderate Coulomb but sizeable Hund’s rule interactions – so-called Hund metals – allow for a distinct screening mechanism towards strong correlations: Hundness. Here, Hund’s rule constrains the spin rather than the charge dynamics. This discovery led to a vividly debated fundamental issue in the field of strongly correlated condensed matter systems, which is the main topic of the present thesis: what is the origin of strong correlations in the normal phase of Hund metals, Mottness or Hundness? And what are their decisive fingerprints? The goal of this dissertation is twofold. First, we present and advance our method: the numerical renormalization group (NRG) as viable real-frequency multi-band impurity solver for dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), a common approach to tackle strongly correlated systems. Second, we apply DMFT+NRG to shed light on the Hund-metal problem raised above. In the first part of this thesis we present our state-of-the-art NRG solver, which offers direct access to data with unprecedented real-frequency spectral resolution at arbitrarily low energies and temperatures in contrast to commonly used Quantum Monte Carlo solvers. It is based on matrix product states and exploits non-abelian symmetries to reduce numerical costs. In the case of orbital symmetry, this allows us to treat multi-band models with more than two bands, and thus to tackle the Hund-metal problem for the first time with NRG. For multi-band models without orbital symmetry, an “interleaved” scheme of NRG (iNRG) was recently developed, dramatically increasing the numerical efficiency. Remarkably, the accuracy of iNRG is comparable to standard NRG, as we reveal in a detailed study. This finding establishes iNRG as a promising DMFT solver for material-specific model simulations. In the second part of this thesis we study a minimal toy model for Hund metals with DMFT+NRG, the orbital-symmetric three-band Hubbard-Hund model (3HHM) close to a lattice filling of 1/3. Our major insight is “spin-orbital separation” (SOS), a Hund’s-ruleinduced two-stage Kondo-type screening process, in which orbital screening occurs at much higher energies than spin screening. In Hund metals, i.e. far from a MIT phase boundary, SOS thus causes large electron masses by strongly reducing the coherence scale below which a Fermi liquid is formed. Further, it opens up a broad incoherent and strongly particle-hole asymmetric intermediate energy regime that reaches up to bare excitation scales. This SOS regime shows fractional power-law behavior and is characterized by resilient “Hund quasiparticles” with itinerant orbital degrees of freedom coupled non-trivially to quasi-free large spins. At zero temperature, the local density of states exhibits a two-tier quasiparticle peak on top of a broad incoherent background. In contrast, in Mott-correlated metals, i.e. close to the MIT phase boundary, the SOS regime becomes negligibly small and the Hubbard bands are well separated. These findings lead to distinct signatures of Hundness and Mottness in the temperature dependence of ARPES spectra, static local susceptibilities, resistivity, thermopower and entropy, many of which were also found in realistic simulations of the archetypal Hund- and Mott-correlated materials, Sr2RuO4 and V2O3. In summary, we provide evidence that and elucidate how Hundness evokes strong correlation effects in Hund metals. This might help to better interpret experimental results and guide superconducting theories.
We propose a way to identify strongly Hund-correlated materials by unveiling a key signature of Hund correlations at the two-particle level. The defining feature is the sign of the response of the frozen spin ratio (the long-time local spin-spin correlation function divided by the instantaneous value) under variation of electron density. The underlying physical reason is that the sign is closely related to the strength of charge fluctuations between the dominant atomic multiplets and higher-spin ones in a neighboring charge subspace. It is the predominance of these fluctuations that promotes Hund metallicity. The temperature dependence of the frozen spin ratio can further reveal a non-Fermi-liquid behavior and thus the Hund metal states. We analyze both degenerate and nondegenerate multiorbital Hubbard models and corroborate our argument by taking doped La2CuO4{\mathrm{La}}_{2}{\mathrm{CuO}}_{4}La2​CuO4​ and LaFeAsO as representative material examples, respectively, of Mott and Hund metals. Our proposal should be applicable to systems with non-half-filled integer electron fillings and their doped cases provided the doping drove the electron density toward the half filling.
We report a quantum phase transition between orbital-selective Mott states, with different localized orbitals, in a Hund's metals model. Using the density matrix renormalization group, the phase diagram is constructed varying the electronic density and Hubbard UUU, at robust Hund's coupling. We demonstrate that this transition is preempted by charge fluctuations and the emergence of free spinless fermions, as opposed to the magnetically driven Mott transition. The Luttinger correlation exponent is shown to have a universal value in the strong-coupling phase, whereas it is interaction dependent at intermediate couplings. At weak coupling we find a second transition from a normal metal to the intermediate-coupling phase.
We present results on the dynamical correlation functions of the particle-hole symmetric Holstein-Hubbard model at zero temperature, calculated using the dynamical mean-field theory which is solved by the numerical renormalization group method. We clarify the competing influences of the electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions particularity at the different metal to insulator transitions. The Coulomb repulsion is found to dominate the behavior in large parts of the metallic regime. By suppressing charge fluctuations, it effectively decouples electrons from phonons. The phonon propagator shows a characteristic softening near the metal to bipolaronic transition but there is very little softening on the approach to the Mott transition.
We study the Mott transition in the three-orbital Hubbard model. To investigate how the orbital level splitting and the Ising-type Hund's coupling affect the Mott transition in the case of two electrons per site, we use the dynamical mean-field theory combined with continuous-time quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The calculation of the double occupancy reveals that the critical interaction strength separating a metallic phase and two kinds of insulating phases shows a nonmonotonic behavior as a function of the level splitting. We find that this behavior is characteristic for 1/31/31/3 filling, in comparison with the preceding results for different fillings and for two-orbital models. Strong competition between the two insulators results in an intriguing first-order transition to an insulating phase having intermediate characters between Mott and band insulators. It is also found that the two insulators show different behaviors in the phase boundary with the metallic phase in the interaction-temperature plane, which is reflected in a difference in the quasiparticle behavior around the transition. We also discuss the orbital selective Mott transition for larger Hund's coupling, which is compared with previous study at zero temperature.