Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.09242 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Superconductivity, charge density waves, and bipolarons in the Holstein model

Benjamin Nosarzewski, Edwin W. Huang, Philip M. Dee, Ilya Esterlis, Brian Moritz, Steven Allan Kivelson, Steven Johnston, Thomas Devereaux

Published Jun 24, 2021• 39 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The electron-phonon $(e\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph})$ interaction remains of great interest in condensed matter physics and plays a vital role in realizing superconductors, charge density waves (CDW), and polarons. We study the two-dimensional Holstein model for $e\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}$ coupling using determinant quantum Monte Carlo across a wide range of its phase diagram as a function of temperature, electron density, dimensionless $e\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}$ coupling strength, and the adiabatic ratio of the phonon frequency to the Fermi energy. We describe the behavior of the CDW correlations, the competition between superconducting and CDW orders and polaron formation, the optimal conditions for superconductivity, and the transition from the weak-coupling regime to the strong-coupling regime. Superconductivity is optimized at intermediate $e\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}$ coupling strength and intermediate electron density, and the superconducting correlations increase monotonically with phonon frequency. The global maximum for superconductivity in the Holstein model occurs at large phonon frequency, the limit where an attractive Hubbard model effectively describes the physics.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.235156

Related papers

Phonon Dispersion and the Competition between Pairing and Charge Order

Natanael C. Costa, Thomas Blommel, Wei-ting Chiu +2 more

The Holstein model describes the interaction between fermions and a collection of local (dispersionless) phonon modes. In the dilute limit, the phonon degrees of freedom dress the fermions, giving rise to polaron and bipolaron formation. At higher densities, the phonons mediate collective superconducting (SC) and charge-density wave (CDW) phases. Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations have considered both these limits but have not yet focused on the physics of more general phonon spectra. Here we report QMC studies of the role of phonon dispersion on SC and CDW order in such models. We quantify the effect of finite phonon bandwidth and curvature on the critical temperature T_{cdw} for CDW order and also uncover several novel features of diagonal long-range order in the phase diagram, including a competition between charge patterns at momenta q=(π,π) and q=(0,π) which lends insight into the relationship between Fermi surface nesting and the wave vector at which charge order occurs. We also demonstrate SC order at half filling in situations where a nonzero bandwidth sufficiently suppresses T_{cdw}.

arXiv:1712.04072•Physical Review Letters•May 4, 2018•71 citations

Holstein model in infinite dimensions

James K. Freericks, Mark Jarrell, Douglas J. Scalapino

Monte Carlo simulations are performed to examine superconductivity and charge-density-wave fluctuations in the infinite-dimensional electron-phonon Holstein model. The electron-phonon system interpolates between an attractive, static, Falicov-Kimball model that always exhibits charge-density-wave order and an attractive, instantaneous, Hubbard model that always superconducts as a function of phonon frequency. The maximum charge-density-wave transition temperature at half-filling is an order of magnitude smaller than the effective electronic bandwidth and is virtually independent of the phonon frequency. The maximum superconducting transition temperature depends strongly on phonon frequency and is bounded from above by the maximum charge-density-wave transition temperature. The exact solution is compared to both weak-coupling expansions and strong-coupling expansions. The effective phonon potential becomes anharmonic and develops a double-well structure that deepens as the electron-phonon interaction increases.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1993•155 citations

Superconductivity and charge density wave order in the two-dimensional Holstein model

Owen Bradley, G. G. Batrouni, Richard T. Scalettar

The Holstein Hamiltonian describes fermions hopping on a lattice and interacting locally with dispersionless phonon degrees of freedom. In the low-density limit, dressed quasiparticles, polarons and bipolarons, propagate with an effective mass. At higher densities, pairs can condense into a low-temperature superconducting phase and, at or near commensurate filling on a bipartite lattice, to charge density wave (CDW) order. CDW formation breaks a discrete symmetry and hence occurs via a second-order (Ising) transition and therefore at a finite ${T}_{\mathrm{cdw}}$ in two dimensions. Quantum Monte Carlo calculations have determined ${T}_{\mathrm{cdw}}$ for a variety of geometries, including square, honeycomb, and Lieb lattices. The superconducting transition, on the other hand, in $d=2$ is in the Kosterlitz-Thouless universality class and is much less well characterized. In this paper we determine ${T}_{\mathrm{sc}}$ for the square lattice for several values of the density $\ensuremath{\rho}$ and phonon frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. We find that quasilong-range order sets in at ${T}_{\mathrm{sc}}\ensuremath{\lesssim}t/20$, where $t$ is the near-neighbor hopping amplitude, consistent with previous rough estimates from simulations which extrapolated to only the temperatures we reach from considerably higher $T$. We also show evidence of a discontinuous evolution of the density as the CDW transition is approached at half filling.

arXiv:2011.11703•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 1, 2021•55 citations

Superconductivity, charge-density waves, antiferromagnetism, and phase separation in the Hubbard-Holstein model

Seher Karakuzu, Luca F. Tocchio, Sandro Sorella +1 more

By using variational wave functions and quantum Monte Carlo techniques, we investigate the interplay between electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions in the two-dimensional Hubbard-Holstein model. Here, the ground-state phase diagram is triggered by several energy scales, i.e., the electron hopping $t$, the on-site electron-electron interaction $U$, the phonon energy ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, and the electron-phonon coupling $g$. At half filling, the ground state is an antiferromagnetic insulator for $U\ensuremath{\gtrsim}2{g}^{2}/{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, while it is a charge-density-wave (or bipolaronic) insulator for $U\ensuremath{\lesssim}2{g}^{2}/{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. In addition to these phases, we find a superconducting phase that intrudes between them. For ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}/t=1$, superconductivity emerges when both $U/t$ and $2{g}^{2}/t{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$ are small; then, by increasing the value of the phonon energy ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, it extends along the transition line between antiferromagnetic and charge-density-wave insulators. Away from half filling, phase separation occurs when doping the charge-density-wave insulator, while a uniform (superconducting) ground state is found when doping the superconducting phase. In the analysis of finite-size effects, it is extremely important to average over twisted boundary conditions, especially in the weak-coupling limit and in the doped case.

arXiv:1709.00278•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 27, 2017•54 citations

Many-polaron theory for superconductivity and charge-density waves in a strongly coupled electron-phonon system with quasi-two-dimensionality: An interpolation between the adiabatic limit and the inverse-adiabatic limit

Keiichirō Nasu

The phase diagram of a two-dimensional N-site N-electron system (N\ensuremath{\gg}1) with site-diagonal electron-phonon (e-ph) coupling is studied in the context of polaron theory, so as to clarify the competition between the superconducting (SC) state and the charge-density wave (CDW) state. The Fermi surface of noninteracting electrons is assumed to be a complete circle with no nesting-type instability in the case of weak e-ph coupling, so as to focus on such a strong coupling that even the standard ``strong-coupling theory'' for superconductivity breaks down. Phonon clouds moving with electrons as well as a frozen phonon are taken into account by a variational method, combined with a mean-field theory. It covers the whole region of three basic parameters characterizing the system: the intersite transfer energy of electron T, the e-ph coupling energy S, and the phonon energy \ensuremath{\omega}. The resultant phase diagram is given in a triangular coordinate space spanned by T, S, and \ensuremath{\omega}. In the adiabatic region \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\ll}(T,S) near the T-S line of the triangle, each electron becomes a large polaron with a thin phonon cloud, and the system changes discontinuously from the SC state to the CDW state with a frozen phonon as S/T increases. In the inverse-adiabatic limit \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\gg}(T,S) near the \ensuremath{\omega} vertex of the triangle, on the other hand, each electron becomes a small polaron, and the SC state is always more stable than the CDW state, because the retardation effect is absent. Thus, the polaron radius decreases and the SC region expands in the triangle as T/\ensuremath{\omega} decreases. It is found, for the first time, that the energy gap of the SC state for a given T and S becomes maximum at the intermediate region \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}T, indicating the importance of the polaron effect. The collective excitation within the gap of the SC state is also studied by the random-phase approximation, and is found to change its nature continuously from the pair-breaking type to the superfluid type as S/T increases.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1987•57 citations

Phase diagram of the two-dimensional Hubbard-Holstein model

Natanael C. Costa, Kazuhiro Seki, Seiji Yunoki +1 more

Abstract The electron–electron and electron–phonon interactions play an important role in correlated materials, being key features for spin, charge and pair correlations. Thus, here we investigate their effects in strongly correlated systems by performing unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations in the square lattice Hubbard-Holstein model at half-filling. We study the competition and interplay between antiferromagnetism (AFM) and charge-density wave (CDW), establishing its very rich phase diagram. In the region between AFM and CDW phases, we have found an enhancement of superconducting pairing correlations, favouring (nonlocal) s-wave pairs. Our study sheds light over past inconsistencies in the literature, in particular the emergence of CDW in the pure Holstein model case.

arXiv:1910.01146•Communications Physics•May 8, 2020•72 citations
The electron-phonon (e\ensuremath-ph)(e\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph})(e\ensuremath-ph) interaction remains of great interest in condensed matter physics and plays a vital role in realizing superconductors, charge density waves (CDW), and polarons. We study the two-dimensional Holstein model for e\ensuremath-phe\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}e\ensuremath-ph coupling using determinant quantum Monte Carlo across a wide range of its phase diagram as a function of temperature, electron density, dimensionless e\ensuremath-phe\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}e\ensuremath-ph coupling strength, and the adiabatic ratio of the phonon frequency to the Fermi energy. We describe the behavior of the CDW correlations, the competition between superconducting and CDW orders and polaron formation, the optimal conditions for superconductivity, and the transition from the weak-coupling regime to the strong-coupling regime. Superconductivity is optimized at intermediate e\ensuremath-phe\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{ph}e\ensuremath-ph coupling strength and intermediate electron density, and the superconducting correlations increase monotonically with phonon frequency. The global maximum for superconductivity in the Holstein model occurs at large phonon frequency, the limit where an attractive Hubbard model effectively describes the physics.
The Holstein model describes the interaction between fermions and a collection of local (dispersionless) phonon modes. In the dilute limit, the phonon degrees of freedom dress the fermions, giving rise to polaron and bipolaron formation. At higher densities, the phonons mediate collective superconducting (SC) and charge-density wave (CDW) phases. Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations have considered both these limits but have not yet focused on the physics of more general phonon spectra. Here we report QMC studies of the role of phonon dispersion on SC and CDW order in such models. We quantify the effect of finite phonon bandwidth and curvature on the critical temperature T_{cdw} for CDW order and also uncover several novel features of diagonal long-range order in the phase diagram, including a competition between charge patterns at momenta q=(π,π) and q=(0,π) which lends insight into the relationship between Fermi surface nesting and the wave vector at which charge order occurs. We also demonstrate SC order at half filling in situations where a nonzero bandwidth sufficiently suppresses T_{cdw}.
Monte Carlo simulations are performed to examine superconductivity and charge-density-wave fluctuations in the infinite-dimensional electron-phonon Holstein model. The electron-phonon system interpolates between an attractive, static, Falicov-Kimball model that always exhibits charge-density-wave order and an attractive, instantaneous, Hubbard model that always superconducts as a function of phonon frequency. The maximum charge-density-wave transition temperature at half-filling is an order of magnitude smaller than the effective electronic bandwidth and is virtually independent of the phonon frequency. The maximum superconducting transition temperature depends strongly on phonon frequency and is bounded from above by the maximum charge-density-wave transition temperature. The exact solution is compared to both weak-coupling expansions and strong-coupling expansions. The effective phonon potential becomes anharmonic and develops a double-well structure that deepens as the electron-phonon interaction increases.
The Holstein Hamiltonian describes fermions hopping on a lattice and interacting locally with dispersionless phonon degrees of freedom. In the low-density limit, dressed quasiparticles, polarons and bipolarons, propagate with an effective mass. At higher densities, pairs can condense into a low-temperature superconducting phase and, at or near commensurate filling on a bipartite lattice, to charge density wave (CDW) order. CDW formation breaks a discrete symmetry and hence occurs via a second-order (Ising) transition and therefore at a finite Tcdw{T}_{\mathrm{cdw}}Tcdw​ in two dimensions. Quantum Monte Carlo calculations have determined Tcdw{T}_{\mathrm{cdw}}Tcdw​ for a variety of geometries, including square, honeycomb, and Lieb lattices. The superconducting transition, on the other hand, in d=2d=2d=2 is in the Kosterlitz-Thouless universality class and is much less well characterized. In this paper we determine Tsc{T}_{\mathrm{sc}}Tsc​ for the square lattice for several values of the density $\ensuremath{\rho}$ and phonon frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. We find that quasilong-range order sets in at ${T}_{\mathrm{sc}}\ensuremath{\lesssim}t/20$, where ttt is the near-neighbor hopping amplitude, consistent with previous rough estimates from simulations which extrapolated to only the temperatures we reach from considerably higher TTT. We also show evidence of a discontinuous evolution of the density as the CDW transition is approached at half filling.
By using variational wave functions and quantum Monte Carlo techniques, we investigate the interplay between electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions in the two-dimensional Hubbard-Holstein model. Here, the ground-state phase diagram is triggered by several energy scales, i.e., the electron hopping ttt, the on-site electron-electron interaction UUU, the phonon energy ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, and the electron-phonon coupling ggg. At half filling, the ground state is an antiferromagnetic insulator for $U\ensuremath{\gtrsim}2{g}^{2}/{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, while it is a charge-density-wave (or bipolaronic) insulator for $U\ensuremath{\lesssim}2{g}^{2}/{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$. In addition to these phases, we find a superconducting phase that intrudes between them. For ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}/t=1$, superconductivity emerges when both U/tU/tU/t and $2{g}^{2}/t{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$ are small; then, by increasing the value of the phonon energy ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{0}$, it extends along the transition line between antiferromagnetic and charge-density-wave insulators. Away from half filling, phase separation occurs when doping the charge-density-wave insulator, while a uniform (superconducting) ground state is found when doping the superconducting phase. In the analysis of finite-size effects, it is extremely important to average over twisted boundary conditions, especially in the weak-coupling limit and in the doped case.
The phase diagram of a two-dimensional N-site N-electron system (N\ensuremath{\gg}1) with site-diagonal electron-phonon (e-ph) coupling is studied in the context of polaron theory, so as to clarify the competition between the superconducting (SC) state and the charge-density wave (CDW) state. The Fermi surface of noninteracting electrons is assumed to be a complete circle with no nesting-type instability in the case of weak e-ph coupling, so as to focus on such a strong coupling that even the standard ``strong-coupling theory'' for superconductivity breaks down. Phonon clouds moving with electrons as well as a frozen phonon are taken into account by a variational method, combined with a mean-field theory. It covers the whole region of three basic parameters characterizing the system: the intersite transfer energy of electron T, the e-ph coupling energy S, and the phonon energy \ensuremath{\omega}. The resultant phase diagram is given in a triangular coordinate space spanned by T, S, and \ensuremath{\omega}. In the adiabatic region \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\ll}(T,S) near the T-S line of the triangle, each electron becomes a large polaron with a thin phonon cloud, and the system changes discontinuously from the SC state to the CDW state with a frozen phonon as S/T increases. In the inverse-adiabatic limit \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\gg}(T,S) near the \ensuremath{\omega} vertex of the triangle, on the other hand, each electron becomes a small polaron, and the SC state is always more stable than the CDW state, because the retardation effect is absent. Thus, the polaron radius decreases and the SC region expands in the triangle as T/\ensuremath{\omega} decreases. It is found, for the first time, that the energy gap of the SC state for a given T and S becomes maximum at the intermediate region \ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}T, indicating the importance of the polaron effect. The collective excitation within the gap of the SC state is also studied by the random-phase approximation, and is found to change its nature continuously from the pair-breaking type to the superfluid type as S/T increases.
Abstract The electron–electron and electron–phonon interactions play an important role in correlated materials, being key features for spin, charge and pair correlations. Thus, here we investigate their effects in strongly correlated systems by performing unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations in the square lattice Hubbard-Holstein model at half-filling. We study the competition and interplay between antiferromagnetism (AFM) and charge-density wave (CDW), establishing its very rich phase diagram. In the region between AFM and CDW phases, we have found an enhancement of superconducting pairing correlations, favouring (nonlocal) s-wave pairs. Our study sheds light over past inconsistencies in the literature, in particular the emergence of CDW in the pure Holstein model case.