Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.06731 · Annals of Physics

Entanglement of classical and quantum short-range dynamics in mean-field systems

J.-B. Bru, W. de Siqueira Pedra

Published Oct 13, 2021• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The relationship between classical and quantum mechanics is usually understood via the limit ħ→0. This is the underlying idea behind the quantization of classical objects. The apparent incompatibility of general relativity with quantum mechanics and quantum field theory has challenged for many decades this basic idea. We recently showed (Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 0000; Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 2021 [46,47]) the emergence of classical dynamics for very general quantum lattice systems with mean-field interactions, without (complete) suppression of its quantum features, in the infinite volume limit. This leads to a theoretical framework in which the classical and quantum worlds are entangled. Such an entanglement is noteworthy and is a consequence of the highly non-local character of mean-field interactions. Therefore, this phenomenon should not be restricted to systems with mean-field interactions only, but should also appear in presence of interactions that are sufficiently long-range, yielding effective, classical background fields, in the spirit of the Higgs mechanism of quantum field theory. In order to present the result in a less abstract way than in its original version, here we apply it to a concrete, physically relevant, example and discuss, by this means, various important aspects of our general approach. The model we consider is not exactly solvable and the particular results obtained are new.

DOI
10.1016/j.aop.2021.168643

Related papers

Out-of-equilibrium dynamics of quantum many-body systems with long-range interactions

Nicolò Defenu, Alessio Lerose, Silvia Pappalardi

Experimental progress in atomic, molecular, and optical platforms in the last decade has stimulated strong and broad interest in the quantum coherent dynamics of many long-range interacting particles. The prominent collective character of these systems enables novel non-equilibrium phenomena with no counterpart in conventional quantum systems with local interactions. Much of the theory work in this area either focussed on the impact of variable-range interaction tails on the physics of local interactions or relied on mean-field-like descriptions based on the opposite limit of all-to-all infinite-range interactions. In this Report, we present a systematic and organic review of recent advances in the field. Working with prototypical interacting quantum spin lattices without disorder, our presentation hinges upon a versatile theoretical formalism that interpolates between the few-body mean-field physics and the many-body physics of quasi-local interactions. Such a formalism allows us to connect these two regimes, providing both a formal quantitative tool and basic physical intuition. We leverage this unifying framework to review several findings of the last decade, including the peculiar non-ballistic spreading of quantum correlations, counter-intuitive slowdown of entanglement dynamics, suppression of thermalization and equilibration, anomalous scaling of defects upon traversing criticality, dynamical phase transitions, and genuinely non-equilibrium phases stabilized by periodic driving. The style of this Report is on the pedagogical side, which makes it accessible to readers without previous experience in the subject matter.

arXiv:2307.04802•Physics Reports•May 9, 2024•92 citations

Applicability of Mean-Field Theory for Time-Dependent Open Quantum Systems with Infinite-Range Interactions

Federico Carollo, Igor Lesanovsky

Understanding quantum many-body systems with long-range or infinite-range interactions is of relevance across a broad set of physical disciplines, including quantum optics, nuclear magnetic resonance, and nuclear physics. From a theoretical viewpoint, these systems are appealing since they can be efficiently studied with numerics, and in the thermodynamic limit are expected to be governed by mean-field equations of motion. Over the past years the capabilities to experimentally create long-range interacting systems have dramatically improved permitting their control in space and time. This allows us to induce and explore a plethora of nonequilibrium dynamical phases, including time crystals and even chaotic regimes. However, establishing the emergence of these phases from numerical simulations turns out to be surprisingly challenging. This difficulty led to the assertion that mean-field theory may not be applicable to time-dependent infinite-range interacting systems. Here, we rigorously prove that mean-field theory in fact exactly captures their dynamics, in the thermodynamic limit. We further provide bounds for finite-size effects and their dependence on the evolution time.

arXiv:2403.17163•Physical Review Letters•Oct 8, 2024•10 citations

Quantum Interacting Particle Systems

Luigi Accardi, Franco Fagnola

The problem of extending ideas and results on the dynamics of infinite classical lattice systems to the quantum domain naturally arises in different branches of physics (nonequilibrium statistical mechanics, quantum optics, solid state, ...) and new momentum from the development of quantum computer and quantum neural networks (which are in fact interacting arrays of binary systems) has been found. The stochastic limit of quantum theory allowed to deduce, as limits of the usual Hamiltonian systems, a new class of quantum stochastic flows which, when restricted to an appropriate Abelian subalgebra, produces precisely those interacting particle systems studied in classical statistical mechanics. Moreover, in many interesting cases, the underlying classical process "drives" the quantum one, at least as far as ergodicity or convergence to equilibrium are concerned. Thus many deep results concerning classical systems can be directly applied to carry information on the corresponding quantum system. The thermodynamic limit itself is obtained thanks to a technique (the four-semigroup method, new even in the classical case) which reduces the infinitesimal structure of a stochastic flow to that of four semigroups canonically associated to it (Chap. 1). Simple and effective methods to analyze qualitatively the ergodic behavior of quantum Markov semigroups are discussed in Chap. 2. Powerful estimates used to control the infinite volume limit, ergodic behavior and the spectral gap (Gaussian, exponential and hypercontractive bounds, classical and quantum logarithmic Sobolev inequalities, ...) are discussed in Chap. 3

QP-PQ, quantum probability and white noise analysis•Jul 1, 2002•29 citations

An Operator-Algebraic Exposition of the Thirring-Wehrl Theory of the Quasi-Spin BCS Model

Yoshitsugu Sekine

This expository review reformulates the BCS analyses of Haag, Emch--Guenin, and Thirring--Wehrl, together with subsequent operator-algebraic mean-field results of Bóna, Raggio--Werner, and Bru--de Siqueira Pedra, in the language of quasi-local $C^{\ast}$-algebras and state decompositions. The quasi-spin model is realized on the UHF algebra of type $2^{\infty}$, with product sectors described by von Neumann's incomplete infinite tensor products. This framework distinguishes strong limits of intensive observables, domain-restricted limits of extensive observables, and sectorwise Bogoliubov--Haag limits, including their operator criterion, gap equation, and limiting dynamics. In the degenerate model, the ground-state and thermal gauge averages admit central direct-integral decompositions over the gauge circle, and the thermal decomposition converges to the ground-state decomposition at zero temperature. Adjoining the gauge phase as a central classical variable combines the phase-dependent Bogoliubov dynamics into one automorphism group on $C(\mathbb{S}^{1},\mathcal{A})$.

arXiv:2607.21158•Jul 23, 2026•0 citations

Quantum entanglement goes large

Ian S. Osborne

Quantum Systems Quantum entanglement occurs when two separate entities become strongly linked in a way that cannot be explained by classical physics; it is a powerful resource in quantum communication protocols and advanced technologies that aim to exploit the enhanced capabilities of quantum systems. To date, entanglement has generally been limited to microscopic quantum units such as pairs or multiples of single ions, atoms, photons, and so on. Kotler et al. and Mercier de Lepinay et al. demonstrate the ability to extend quantum entanglement to massive macroscopic systems (see the Perspective by Lau and Clerk). Entanglement of two mechanical oscillators on such a large length and mass scale is expected to find widespread use in both applications and fundamental physics to probe the boundary between the classical and quantum worlds. Science , this issue p. [622][1], p. [625][2]; see also p. [570][3] [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abf2998 [2]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abf5389 [3]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abh3419

Science•May 6, 2021•0 citations

Exactly solvable models for qubits coupled to spin environments : decoherence and entanglement.

Yamen Hamdouni

During the last decade the field of quantum information has seen considerable progress both theoretically and experimentally. The building block of this theory is the so-called qubit, the quantum counterpart of the classical bit. It turns out that spin degrees of freedom of quantum particles are among the most promising candidates for quantum information processing and computation. Thus, a deep understanding of the different processes that govern the dynamics of these objects is of fundamental importance. For instance, the decoherence process, caused the coupling of the qubits to their surrounding environment, is the main obstacle to quantum information processing: it leads them to lose their quantum coherence and thus behave classically. In addition, quantum systems exhibit correlations that have no classical counterpart. This phenomenon is called entanglement and is the vital resource for quantum teleportation and quantum computing. Decoherence and entanglement dynamics were extensively studied within the framework of the Markovian approximation using the master equation approach. However, due to the non-commuting character of quantum observables, only few models are known to be exactly solvable. Moreover, many spin systems display a strongly non-Markovian behavior. This thesis is devoted to the development of new techniques for deriving the exact dynamics of spin qubits, coupled through Heisenberg and/or Ising interactions to spin environments that have internal dynamics. The basic idea behind these techniques is to use the underlying symmetries exhibited by the Hamitonian operators of the composite systems. This allows for the study of problems related to decoherence and entanglement.

•Nov 25, 2014•0 citations
The relationship between classical and quantum mechanics is usually understood via the limit ħ→0. This is the underlying idea behind the quantization of classical objects. The apparent incompatibility of general relativity with quantum mechanics and quantum field theory has challenged for many decades this basic idea. We recently showed (Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 0000; Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 2021 [46,47]) the emergence of classical dynamics for very general quantum lattice systems with mean-field interactions, without (complete) suppression of its quantum features, in the infinite volume limit. This leads to a theoretical framework in which the classical and quantum worlds are entangled. Such an entanglement is noteworthy and is a consequence of the highly non-local character of mean-field interactions. Therefore, this phenomenon should not be restricted to systems with mean-field interactions only, but should also appear in presence of interactions that are sufficiently long-range, yielding effective, classical background fields, in the spirit of the Higgs mechanism of quantum field theory. In order to present the result in a less abstract way than in its original version, here we apply it to a concrete, physically relevant, example and discuss, by this means, various important aspects of our general approach. The model we consider is not exactly solvable and the particular results obtained are new.
Experimental progress in atomic, molecular, and optical platforms in the last decade has stimulated strong and broad interest in the quantum coherent dynamics of many long-range interacting particles. The prominent collective character of these systems enables novel non-equilibrium phenomena with no counterpart in conventional quantum systems with local interactions. Much of the theory work in this area either focussed on the impact of variable-range interaction tails on the physics of local interactions or relied on mean-field-like descriptions based on the opposite limit of all-to-all infinite-range interactions. In this Report, we present a systematic and organic review of recent advances in the field. Working with prototypical interacting quantum spin lattices without disorder, our presentation hinges upon a versatile theoretical formalism that interpolates between the few-body mean-field physics and the many-body physics of quasi-local interactions. Such a formalism allows us to connect these two regimes, providing both a formal quantitative tool and basic physical intuition. We leverage this unifying framework to review several findings of the last decade, including the peculiar non-ballistic spreading of quantum correlations, counter-intuitive slowdown of entanglement dynamics, suppression of thermalization and equilibration, anomalous scaling of defects upon traversing criticality, dynamical phase transitions, and genuinely non-equilibrium phases stabilized by periodic driving. The style of this Report is on the pedagogical side, which makes it accessible to readers without previous experience in the subject matter.
Understanding quantum many-body systems with long-range or infinite-range interactions is of relevance across a broad set of physical disciplines, including quantum optics, nuclear magnetic resonance, and nuclear physics. From a theoretical viewpoint, these systems are appealing since they can be efficiently studied with numerics, and in the thermodynamic limit are expected to be governed by mean-field equations of motion. Over the past years the capabilities to experimentally create long-range interacting systems have dramatically improved permitting their control in space and time. This allows us to induce and explore a plethora of nonequilibrium dynamical phases, including time crystals and even chaotic regimes. However, establishing the emergence of these phases from numerical simulations turns out to be surprisingly challenging. This difficulty led to the assertion that mean-field theory may not be applicable to time-dependent infinite-range interacting systems. Here, we rigorously prove that mean-field theory in fact exactly captures their dynamics, in the thermodynamic limit. We further provide bounds for finite-size effects and their dependence on the evolution time.
The problem of extending ideas and results on the dynamics of infinite classical lattice systems to the quantum domain naturally arises in different branches of physics (nonequilibrium statistical mechanics, quantum optics, solid state, ...) and new momentum from the development of quantum computer and quantum neural networks (which are in fact interacting arrays of binary systems) has been found. The stochastic limit of quantum theory allowed to deduce, as limits of the usual Hamiltonian systems, a new class of quantum stochastic flows which, when restricted to an appropriate Abelian subalgebra, produces precisely those interacting particle systems studied in classical statistical mechanics. Moreover, in many interesting cases, the underlying classical process "drives" the quantum one, at least as far as ergodicity or convergence to equilibrium are concerned. Thus many deep results concerning classical systems can be directly applied to carry information on the corresponding quantum system. The thermodynamic limit itself is obtained thanks to a technique (the four-semigroup method, new even in the classical case) which reduces the infinitesimal structure of a stochastic flow to that of four semigroups canonically associated to it (Chap. 1). Simple and effective methods to analyze qualitatively the ergodic behavior of quantum Markov semigroups are discussed in Chap. 2. Powerful estimates used to control the infinite volume limit, ergodic behavior and the spectral gap (Gaussian, exponential and hypercontractive bounds, classical and quantum logarithmic Sobolev inequalities, ...) are discussed in Chap. 3
This expository review reformulates the BCS analyses of Haag, Emch--Guenin, and Thirring--Wehrl, together with subsequent operator-algebraic mean-field results of Bóna, Raggio--Werner, and Bru--de Siqueira Pedra, in the language of quasi-local C∗C^{\ast}C∗-algebras and state decompositions. The quasi-spin model is realized on the UHF algebra of type 2∞2^{\infty}2∞, with product sectors described by von Neumann's incomplete infinite tensor products. This framework distinguishes strong limits of intensive observables, domain-restricted limits of extensive observables, and sectorwise Bogoliubov--Haag limits, including their operator criterion, gap equation, and limiting dynamics. In the degenerate model, the ground-state and thermal gauge averages admit central direct-integral decompositions over the gauge circle, and the thermal decomposition converges to the ground-state decomposition at zero temperature. Adjoining the gauge phase as a central classical variable combines the phase-dependent Bogoliubov dynamics into one automorphism group on C(S1,A)C(\mathbb{S}^{1},\mathcal{A})C(S1,A).
Quantum Systems Quantum entanglement occurs when two separate entities become strongly linked in a way that cannot be explained by classical physics; it is a powerful resource in quantum communication protocols and advanced technologies that aim to exploit the enhanced capabilities of quantum systems. To date, entanglement has generally been limited to microscopic quantum units such as pairs or multiples of single ions, atoms, photons, and so on. Kotler et al. and Mercier de Lepinay et al. demonstrate the ability to extend quantum entanglement to massive macroscopic systems (see the Perspective by Lau and Clerk). Entanglement of two mechanical oscillators on such a large length and mass scale is expected to find widespread use in both applications and fundamental physics to probe the boundary between the classical and quantum worlds. Science , this issue p. [622][1], p. [625][2]; see also p. [570][3] [1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abf2998 [2]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abf5389 [3]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.abh3419
During the last decade the field of quantum information has seen considerable progress both theoretically and experimentally. The building block of this theory is the so-called qubit, the quantum counterpart of the classical bit. It turns out that spin degrees of freedom of quantum particles are among the most promising candidates for quantum information processing and computation. Thus, a deep understanding of the different processes that govern the dynamics of these objects is of fundamental importance. For instance, the decoherence process, caused the coupling of the qubits to their surrounding environment, is the main obstacle to quantum information processing: it leads them to lose their quantum coherence and thus behave classically. In addition, quantum systems exhibit correlations that have no classical counterpart. This phenomenon is called entanglement and is the vital resource for quantum teleportation and quantum computing. Decoherence and entanglement dynamics were extensively studied within the framework of the Markovian approximation using the master equation approach. However, due to the non-commuting character of quantum observables, only few models are known to be exactly solvable. Moreover, many spin systems display a strongly non-Markovian behavior. This thesis is devoted to the development of new techniques for deriving the exact dynamics of spin qubits, coupled through Heisenberg and/or Ising interactions to spin environments that have internal dynamics. The basic idea behind these techniques is to use the underlying symmetries exhibited by the Hamitonian operators of the composite systems. This allows for the study of problems related to decoherence and entanglement.