Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.02714 · Physical Review Research

Effect of chaos on the simulation of quantum critical phenomena in analog quantum simulators

Karthik Chinni, Pablo M. Poggi, Ivan H. Deutsch

Published Aug 12, 2021• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study how chaos, introduced by a weak perturbation, affects the reliability of the output of analog quantum simulation. As a toy model, we consider the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. Inspired by the semiclassical behavior of the order parameter in the thermodynamic limit, we propose a protocol to measure the quantum phase transition in the ground state and the dynamical quantum phase transition associated with quench dynamics. We show that the presence of a small time-dependent perturbation can render the dynamics of the system chaotic. We then show that the estimates of the critical points of these quantum phase transitions, obtained from the quantum simulation of its dynamics, are robust to the presence of this chaotic perturbation, while other aspects of the system, such as the mean magnetization, are fragile and therefore cannot be reliably extracted from this simulator. This can be understood in terms of the simulated quantities that depend on the global structure of phase space vs those that depend on local trajectories.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.3.033145

Related papers

Sensitivity to Imperfections of Analog Quantum Simulation on Atomic Qudits

Nathan Lysne

As uncorrected quantum processors grow in sophistication, many are being used for analog quantum simulation (AQS) of novel physics beyond the capabilities of classical devices. However, without the guarantee of bounded errors achieved by digitizing the computation, we do not know when and how much to trust an AQS result in the presence of inevitable imperfections. Here, we present the results of using our exper- iment as a testbed for studying the impact of errors on AQS. We have developed a small but highly-accurate processor over a 16-dimensional Hilbert space comprising the combined electron-nuclear spin of a single 133Cs atom in the electronic ground state. Advances in Eigenvalue-Only (EVO) optimal control enable us to repeatedly (>100) perform arbitrary unitary transformations in this space while maintaining accuracy on the device. We use this capability to simulate model systems known to exhibit features of interest, such as chaos and hypersensitivity (quantum kicked top) and quantum phase transitions (the transverse Ising and Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick mod- els). Experimental simulations show high fidelity of the quantum state and dynamical features in the presence of native imperfections. We discuss these results in the con- text of a new framework for quantifying the average sensitivity of simulator outcomes to errors. These theoretical and experimental results support the idea that AQS of ‘macroscopic’ observables (e.g., total magnetization) can be robust in the presence of errors, while observables tied to a specific quantum state (e.g., the fidelity) are not.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Quenching a quantum critical state by the order parameter: Dynamical quantum phase transitions and quantum speed limits

Markus Heyl

The dynamics in the vicinity of quantum phase transitions entails a variety of important and universal phenomena, such as critical slowing down or the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, which are associated with the low-energy and long-time properties at criticality. Here, the author reveals that the opposite regime of transient nonequilibrium time evolution at criticality can similarly host universal temporal behavior. By strongly perturbing a quantum critical state through quenching the associated order parameter, the system experiences a dynamical quantum phase transition with physical quantities becoming nonanalytic at critical times. These dynamical quantum phase transitions are caused by superextensive energy fluctuations induced by the particular protocol, which turn out to have profound consequences for quantum speed limits and potential restricted thermalization despite the nonintegrability of the system.

arXiv:1608.06659•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 9, 2017•73 citations

Dynamical quantum phase transitions in the Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick model with longitudinal and transverse magnetic fields

D.S. Lohr-Robles, M. Grether, Enrique López‐Moreno +1 more

Abstract The dynamical properties of the Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick model with longitudinal and transverse fields are studied by considering quantum quenches. The model describes a many-body quantum system with long-range interactions. A semiclassical analysis is performed to obtain the critical points of quantum phase transitions. These critical points consist in the static separatrix, which is found by analyzing the stability structure of the semiclassical potential and is useful in the identification of ground state and excited states quantum phase transitions, and in the dynamical separatrix, which depends on initial conditions and is found by studying the classical equations of motion for the Hamiltonian. The static and dynamical separatrices divide the parameter space in regions of different dynamical behavior, and it is found that both separatrices play an important role in the determination of the occurrences of the dynamical quantum phase transitions. Graphical abstract

The European Physical Journal B•Dec 1, 2025•2 citations

Quantum state texture of dynamical criticality

Lucas C. Céleri, Krissia Zawadzki, Ivan Medina +1 more

We investigate the role of quantum state texture in dynamical quantum phase transitions by establishing a direct connection between critical nonequilibrium dynamics and the recently introduced notion of rugosity, a measure of quantum state texture. Considering a generic quench protocol, we analyze both standard formulations of dynamical quantum phase transitions. For type-I transitions, characterized through the long-time behavior of a dynamical order parameter, we show that the time-averaged rugosity, evaluated in the eigenbasis of the pre-quench Hamiltonian, exhibits an order-parameter-like behavior across the transition. In the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model, this behavior is traced back to the underlying semiclassical structure, where crossing the excited-state quantum phase transition separatrix controls the redistribution of the quantum state over the pre-quench energy basis. We further demonstrate that the response function associated with the time-averaged rugosity develops a pronounced critical peak whose maximum grows algebraically with the system size, providing quantitative finite-size evidence of its sensitivity to the dynamical critical point. For type-II transitions, characterized by nonanalyticities in the Loschmidt rate function, we establish an exact connection with rugosity. For a suitable choice of basis, the rate function is exactly given by the density of rugosity, establishing a model-independent equivalence. Moreover, we show that even in physically motivated bases, such as the pre-quench energy eigenbasis, rugosity provides clear signatures of dynamical criticality. Our results establish rugosity as a sensitive probe of dynamical quantum phase transitions while highlighting its role as a basis-dependent measure of quantum state texture, thereby providing an information-theoretic perspective on nonequilibrium quantum critical phenomena.

quant-pharXiv:2605.04161•Physical Review A•May 7, 2026•8 citations

Classical versus quantum errors in quantum computation of dynamical systems

Davide Rossini, Giuliano Benenti, Giulio Casati

We analyze the stability of a quantum algorithm simulating the quantum dynamics of a system with different regimes, ranging from global chaos to integrability. We compare, in these different regimes, the behavior of the fidelity of quantum motion when the system's parameters are perturbed or when there are unitary errors in the quantum gates implementing the quantum algorithm. While the first kind of errors has a classical limit, the second one has no classical analog. It is shown that, whereas in the first case ("classical errors") the decay of fidelity is very sensitive to the dynamical regime, in the second case ("quantum errors") it is almost independent of the dynamical behavior of the simulated system. Therefore, the rich variety of behaviors found in the study of the stability of quantum motion under "classical" perturbations has no correspondence in the fidelity of quantum computation under its natural perturbations. In particular, in this latter case it is not possible to recover the semiclassical regime in which the fidelity decays with a rate given by the classical Lyapunov exponent.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405189•Physical Review E•Nov 22, 2004•10 citations

Analog quantum simulation of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model in a transmon qudit

Elizabeth Champion, Annie Schwartz, Muhammad A. Ijaz +4 more

The simulation of large-scale quantum systems is one of the most sought-after applications of quantum computers. Of particular interest for near-term demonstrations of quantum computational advantage are analog quantum simulations, which employ analog controls instead of digitized gates. Most analog quantum simulations to date, however, have been performed using qubit-based processors, despite the fact that many physical systems are more naturally represented in terms of qudits (i.e., $d$-level systems). Motivated by this, we present an experimental realization of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick (LMG) model using an analog simulator based on a single superconducting transmon qudit with up to $d = 9$ levels. This is accomplished by moving to a rotated frame in which evolution under any time-dependent local field and one-axis twisting can be realized by the application of multiple simultaneous drives. Combining this analog drive scheme with universal control and single-shot readout of the qudit state, we provide a detailed study of five finite-size precursors of quantum criticality in the LMG model: dynamical phase transitions, closing of the energy gap, Kibble-Zurek-like dynamics, statistics of the order parameter, and excited-state phase transitions. For each experiment we devise a protocol for extracting the relevant properties which does not require any prior knowledge of the system eigenstates, and can therefore be readily extended to higher dimensions or more complicated models. Our results cement high-dimensional transmon qudits as an exciting path towards simulating many-body physics.

quant-pharXiv:2512.05237•Dec 8, 2025•5 citations
We study how chaos, introduced by a weak perturbation, affects the reliability of the output of analog quantum simulation. As a toy model, we consider the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. Inspired by the semiclassical behavior of the order parameter in the thermodynamic limit, we propose a protocol to measure the quantum phase transition in the ground state and the dynamical quantum phase transition associated with quench dynamics. We show that the presence of a small time-dependent perturbation can render the dynamics of the system chaotic. We then show that the estimates of the critical points of these quantum phase transitions, obtained from the quantum simulation of its dynamics, are robust to the presence of this chaotic perturbation, while other aspects of the system, such as the mean magnetization, are fragile and therefore cannot be reliably extracted from this simulator. This can be understood in terms of the simulated quantities that depend on the global structure of phase space vs those that depend on local trajectories.
As uncorrected quantum processors grow in sophistication, many are being used for analog quantum simulation (AQS) of novel physics beyond the capabilities of classical devices. However, without the guarantee of bounded errors achieved by digitizing the computation, we do not know when and how much to trust an AQS result in the presence of inevitable imperfections. Here, we present the results of using our exper- iment as a testbed for studying the impact of errors on AQS. We have developed a small but highly-accurate processor over a 16-dimensional Hilbert space comprising the combined electron-nuclear spin of a single 133Cs atom in the electronic ground state. Advances in Eigenvalue-Only (EVO) optimal control enable us to repeatedly (>100) perform arbitrary unitary transformations in this space while maintaining accuracy on the device. We use this capability to simulate model systems known to exhibit features of interest, such as chaos and hypersensitivity (quantum kicked top) and quantum phase transitions (the transverse Ising and Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick mod- els). Experimental simulations show high fidelity of the quantum state and dynamical features in the presence of native imperfections. We discuss these results in the con- text of a new framework for quantifying the average sensitivity of simulator outcomes to errors. These theoretical and experimental results support the idea that AQS of ‘macroscopic’ observables (e.g., total magnetization) can be robust in the presence of errors, while observables tied to a specific quantum state (e.g., the fidelity) are not.
The dynamics in the vicinity of quantum phase transitions entails a variety of important and universal phenomena, such as critical slowing down or the Kibble-Zurek mechanism, which are associated with the low-energy and long-time properties at criticality. Here, the author reveals that the opposite regime of transient nonequilibrium time evolution at criticality can similarly host universal temporal behavior. By strongly perturbing a quantum critical state through quenching the associated order parameter, the system experiences a dynamical quantum phase transition with physical quantities becoming nonanalytic at critical times. These dynamical quantum phase transitions are caused by superextensive energy fluctuations induced by the particular protocol, which turn out to have profound consequences for quantum speed limits and potential restricted thermalization despite the nonintegrability of the system.
Abstract The dynamical properties of the Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick model with longitudinal and transverse fields are studied by considering quantum quenches. The model describes a many-body quantum system with long-range interactions. A semiclassical analysis is performed to obtain the critical points of quantum phase transitions. These critical points consist in the static separatrix, which is found by analyzing the stability structure of the semiclassical potential and is useful in the identification of ground state and excited states quantum phase transitions, and in the dynamical separatrix, which depends on initial conditions and is found by studying the classical equations of motion for the Hamiltonian. The static and dynamical separatrices divide the parameter space in regions of different dynamical behavior, and it is found that both separatrices play an important role in the determination of the occurrences of the dynamical quantum phase transitions. Graphical abstract
We investigate the role of quantum state texture in dynamical quantum phase transitions by establishing a direct connection between critical nonequilibrium dynamics and the recently introduced notion of rugosity, a measure of quantum state texture. Considering a generic quench protocol, we analyze both standard formulations of dynamical quantum phase transitions. For type-I transitions, characterized through the long-time behavior of a dynamical order parameter, we show that the time-averaged rugosity, evaluated in the eigenbasis of the pre-quench Hamiltonian, exhibits an order-parameter-like behavior across the transition. In the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model, this behavior is traced back to the underlying semiclassical structure, where crossing the excited-state quantum phase transition separatrix controls the redistribution of the quantum state over the pre-quench energy basis. We further demonstrate that the response function associated with the time-averaged rugosity develops a pronounced critical peak whose maximum grows algebraically with the system size, providing quantitative finite-size evidence of its sensitivity to the dynamical critical point. For type-II transitions, characterized by nonanalyticities in the Loschmidt rate function, we establish an exact connection with rugosity. For a suitable choice of basis, the rate function is exactly given by the density of rugosity, establishing a model-independent equivalence. Moreover, we show that even in physically motivated bases, such as the pre-quench energy eigenbasis, rugosity provides clear signatures of dynamical criticality. Our results establish rugosity as a sensitive probe of dynamical quantum phase transitions while highlighting its role as a basis-dependent measure of quantum state texture, thereby providing an information-theoretic perspective on nonequilibrium quantum critical phenomena.
We analyze the stability of a quantum algorithm simulating the quantum dynamics of a system with different regimes, ranging from global chaos to integrability. We compare, in these different regimes, the behavior of the fidelity of quantum motion when the system's parameters are perturbed or when there are unitary errors in the quantum gates implementing the quantum algorithm. While the first kind of errors has a classical limit, the second one has no classical analog. It is shown that, whereas in the first case ("classical errors") the decay of fidelity is very sensitive to the dynamical regime, in the second case ("quantum errors") it is almost independent of the dynamical behavior of the simulated system. Therefore, the rich variety of behaviors found in the study of the stability of quantum motion under "classical" perturbations has no correspondence in the fidelity of quantum computation under its natural perturbations. In particular, in this latter case it is not possible to recover the semiclassical regime in which the fidelity decays with a rate given by the classical Lyapunov exponent.
The simulation of large-scale quantum systems is one of the most sought-after applications of quantum computers. Of particular interest for near-term demonstrations of quantum computational advantage are analog quantum simulations, which employ analog controls instead of digitized gates. Most analog quantum simulations to date, however, have been performed using qubit-based processors, despite the fact that many physical systems are more naturally represented in terms of qudits (i.e., ddd-level systems). Motivated by this, we present an experimental realization of the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick (LMG) model using an analog simulator based on a single superconducting transmon qudit with up to d=9d = 9d=9 levels. This is accomplished by moving to a rotated frame in which evolution under any time-dependent local field and one-axis twisting can be realized by the application of multiple simultaneous drives. Combining this analog drive scheme with universal control and single-shot readout of the qudit state, we provide a detailed study of five finite-size precursors of quantum criticality in the LMG model: dynamical phase transitions, closing of the energy gap, Kibble-Zurek-like dynamics, statistics of the order parameter, and excited-state phase transitions. For each experiment we devise a protocol for extracting the relevant properties which does not require any prior knowledge of the system eigenstates, and can therefore be readily extended to higher dimensions or more complicated models. Our results cement high-dimensional transmon qudits as an exciting path towards simulating many-body physics.