Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.02337 · Physical Review A

Impossibility of achieving Landauer's bound for almost every quantum state

Paul M. Riechers, Mile Gu

Published Jul 19, 2021• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The thermodynamic cost of resetting an arbitrary initial state to a particular desired state is lower bounded by Landauer's bound. However, here we demonstrate that this lower bound is necessarily unachievable for every initial state (except possibly the single minimally dissipative input) for any reliable reset mechanism. Since local heating threatens rapid decoherence, this issue is of substantial importance beyond mere energy efficiency. For the case of qubit reset, we find the minimally dissipative state analytically for any reliable reset protocol, in terms of the entropy-flow vector introduced here. This allows us to verify a recent theorem about initial-state dependence of entropy production for any finite-time transformation, as it pertains to quantum state preparation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.104.012214

Related papers

Optimally Fast Qubit Reset

Yue Liu, Chenlong Huang, Xingyu Zhang +1 more

In practice, qubit reset must be operated in an extremely short time, which incurs a thermodynamic cost within multiple orders of magnitude above the Landauer bound. We present a general framework to determine the minimal thermodynamic cost and the corresponding optimal protocol for memory erasure under arbitrary erasure speeds. Our study reveals the divergent behavior of minimal entropy production in the short-time limit depends on the convergence and divergence of the jump operator. There is an inherent trade-off between the minimal required time and the set error probability for the convergent class. Moreover, we find the optimal protocol exhibits general features in the fast-driving regime. To illustrate these findings, we employ fermionic and bosonic baths as examples. Our results suggest that the super-Ohmic bosonic heat bath is suitable for qubit reset.

arXiv:2412.04883•Physical Review Letters•Mar 11, 2025•3 citations

Guaranteed Energy-Efficient Bit Reset in Finite Time

Cormac Browne, Andrew J. P. Garner, Oscar Dahlsten +1 more

Landauer's principle states that it costs at least kBTln2 of work to reset one bit in the presence of a heat bath at temperature T. The bound of kBTln2 is achieved in the unphysical infinite-time limit. Here we ask what is possible if one is restricted to finite-time protocols. We prove analytically that it is possible to reset a bit with a work cost close to kBTln2 in a finite time. We construct an explicit protocol that achieves this, which involves thermalizing and changing the system's Hamiltonian so as to avoid quantum coherences. Using concepts and techniques pertaining to single-shot statistical mechanics, we furthermore prove that the heat dissipated is exponentially close to the minimal amount possible not just on average, but guaranteed with high confidence in every run. Moreover, we exploit the protocol to design a quantum heat engine that works near the Carnot efficiency in finite time.

arXiv:1311.7612•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2014•33 citations

Lower bounds for the mean dissipated heat in an open quantum system

Kazunari Hashimoto, Bassano Vacchini, Chikako Uchiyama

Landauer's principle provides a perspective on the physical meaning of information as well as on the minimum working cost of information processing. Whereas most studies have related the decrease in entropy during a computationally irreversible process to a lower bound of dissipated heat, recent efforts have also provided another lower bound associated with the thermodynamic fluctuation of heat. The coexistence of the two conceptually independent bounds has stimulated comparative studies of their close relationship or tightness; however, these studies were concerned with finite quantum systems that allowed the revival of erased information because of a finite recurrence time. We broaden these comparative studies further to open quantum systems with infinite recurrence times. By examining their dependence on the initial state, we find the independence of the thermodynamic bound from the initial coherence, whereas the entropic bound depends on both the initial coherence and the population. A crucial role is indicated by the purity of the initial state: The entropic bound is tighter when the initial condition is sufficiently mixed, whereas the thermodynamic bound is tighter when the initial state is close to a pure state. These trends are consistent with previous results obtained for finite systems.

arXiv:2006.09960•Physical Review A•May 20, 2020•4 citations

Entropy Production as an Operational Boundary for Quantum Reset in Superconducting Processors

Fernando Cesar Coelho Coutinho

Quantum information reset is an intrinsically irreversible process constrained by the second law of thermodynamics. In contemporary superconducting processors, dissipation during qubit reset is frequently dominated not only by quantum limits but by a classical energy floor on the order of 10^{-21} J. In contrast, the entropic bound T \Delta S at dilution refrigerator temperatures (\sim 15 mK) corresponds to a lower energy scale of approximately 10^{-23} J, establishing entropy production as the organizing physical principle that limits both the efficiency and the speed of reset operations. We introduce an entropy-limited efficiency estimator, \eta_S = 1 - (T \Delta S / W_{\rm diss}), which quantifies the thermodynamic distance from the entropic (Landauer) limit. By construction, \eta_S = 0 corresponds to the saturation of the entropy production limit, while \eta_S \to 1 indicates dissipation dominated by non-entropic (classical) contributions. Maximizing \eta_S is equivalent to a constrained variational problem in which dissipated work is minimized subject to the second law of thermodynamics. For typical superconducting qubits (\omega_q/2\pi \sim 5 GHz, T_1 \sim 50–100 \mus, T \sim 15 mK), the entropic bound T \Delta S \sim 10^{-23} J lies two orders of magnitude below the experimentally observed classical dissipation floor W_{\rm floor} \sim 10^{-21} J. Figures 1 and 2 were generated using the provided scripts_generate_figures.py script, using parameters: \omega_q/2\pi = 5 GHz, T_1 = 80 \mus, and T = 15 mK.

•Dec 27, 2025•0 citations

Minimising the heat dissipation of quantum information erasure

Majid Mohammady, Masoud Mohseni, Yasser Omar

Quantum state engineering and quantum computation rely on information erasure procedures that, up to some fidelity, prepare a quantum object in a pure state. Such processes occur within Landauer's framework if they rely on an interaction between the object and a thermal reservoir. Landauer's principle dictates that this must dissipate a minimum quantity of heat, proportional to the entropy reduction that is incurred by the object, to the thermal reservoir. However, this lower bound is only reachable for some specific physical situations, and it is not necessarily achievable for any given reservoir. The main task of our work can be stated as the minimisation of heat dissipation given probabilistic information erasure, i.e., minimising the amount of energy transferred to the thermal reservoir as heat if we require that the probability of preparing the object in a specific pure state | φ 1 ⟩ be no smaller than p φ 1 max − δ . Here p φ 1 max is the maximum probability of information erasure that is permissible by the physical context, and δ ⩾ 0 the error. To determine the achievable minimal heat dissipation of quantum information erasure within a given physical context, we explicitly optimise over all possible unitary operators that act on the composite system of object and reservoir. Specifically, we characterise the equivalence class of such optimal unitary operators, using tools from majorisation theory, when we are restricted to finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, we discuss how pure state preparation processes could be achieved with a smaller heat cost than Landauer's limit, by operating outside of Landauer's framework.

arXiv:1510.02062•New Journal of Physics•Jan 15, 2016•16 citations

Finite-Time Quantum Landauer Principle and Quantum Coherence

Tan Van Vu, Keiji Saito

The Landauer principle states that any logically irreversible information processing must be accompanied by dissipation into the environment. In this Letter, we investigate the heat dissipation associated with finite-time information erasure and the effect of quantum coherence in such processes. By considering a scenario wherein information is encoded in an open quantum system whose dynamics are described by the Markovian Lindblad equation, we show that the dissipated heat is lower bounded by the conventional Landauer cost, as well as a correction term inversely proportional to the operational time. To clarify the relation between quantum coherence and dissipation, we derive a lower bound for heat dissipation in terms of quantum coherence. This bound quantitatively implies that the creation of quantum coherence in the energy eigenbasis during the erasure process inevitably leads to additional heat costs. The obtained bounds hold for arbitrary operational time and control protocol. By following an optimal control theory, we numerically present an optimal protocol and illustrate our findings by using a single-qubit system.

arXiv:2106.05743•Physical Review Letters•Jan 4, 2022•84 citations
The thermodynamic cost of resetting an arbitrary initial state to a particular desired state is lower bounded by Landauer's bound. However, here we demonstrate that this lower bound is necessarily unachievable for every initial state (except possibly the single minimally dissipative input) for any reliable reset mechanism. Since local heating threatens rapid decoherence, this issue is of substantial importance beyond mere energy efficiency. For the case of qubit reset, we find the minimally dissipative state analytically for any reliable reset protocol, in terms of the entropy-flow vector introduced here. This allows us to verify a recent theorem about initial-state dependence of entropy production for any finite-time transformation, as it pertains to quantum state preparation.
In practice, qubit reset must be operated in an extremely short time, which incurs a thermodynamic cost within multiple orders of magnitude above the Landauer bound. We present a general framework to determine the minimal thermodynamic cost and the corresponding optimal protocol for memory erasure under arbitrary erasure speeds. Our study reveals the divergent behavior of minimal entropy production in the short-time limit depends on the convergence and divergence of the jump operator. There is an inherent trade-off between the minimal required time and the set error probability for the convergent class. Moreover, we find the optimal protocol exhibits general features in the fast-driving regime. To illustrate these findings, we employ fermionic and bosonic baths as examples. Our results suggest that the super-Ohmic bosonic heat bath is suitable for qubit reset.
Landauer's principle states that it costs at least kBTln2 of work to reset one bit in the presence of a heat bath at temperature T. The bound of kBTln2 is achieved in the unphysical infinite-time limit. Here we ask what is possible if one is restricted to finite-time protocols. We prove analytically that it is possible to reset a bit with a work cost close to kBTln2 in a finite time. We construct an explicit protocol that achieves this, which involves thermalizing and changing the system's Hamiltonian so as to avoid quantum coherences. Using concepts and techniques pertaining to single-shot statistical mechanics, we furthermore prove that the heat dissipated is exponentially close to the minimal amount possible not just on average, but guaranteed with high confidence in every run. Moreover, we exploit the protocol to design a quantum heat engine that works near the Carnot efficiency in finite time.
Landauer's principle provides a perspective on the physical meaning of information as well as on the minimum working cost of information processing. Whereas most studies have related the decrease in entropy during a computationally irreversible process to a lower bound of dissipated heat, recent efforts have also provided another lower bound associated with the thermodynamic fluctuation of heat. The coexistence of the two conceptually independent bounds has stimulated comparative studies of their close relationship or tightness; however, these studies were concerned with finite quantum systems that allowed the revival of erased information because of a finite recurrence time. We broaden these comparative studies further to open quantum systems with infinite recurrence times. By examining their dependence on the initial state, we find the independence of the thermodynamic bound from the initial coherence, whereas the entropic bound depends on both the initial coherence and the population. A crucial role is indicated by the purity of the initial state: The entropic bound is tighter when the initial condition is sufficiently mixed, whereas the thermodynamic bound is tighter when the initial state is close to a pure state. These trends are consistent with previous results obtained for finite systems.
Quantum information reset is an intrinsically irreversible process constrained by the second law of thermodynamics. In contemporary superconducting processors, dissipation during qubit reset is frequently dominated not only by quantum limits but by a classical energy floor on the order of 10^{-21} J. In contrast, the entropic bound T \Delta S at dilution refrigerator temperatures (\sim 15 mK) corresponds to a lower energy scale of approximately 10^{-23} J, establishing entropy production as the organizing physical principle that limits both the efficiency and the speed of reset operations. We introduce an entropy-limited efficiency estimator, \eta_S = 1 - (T \Delta S / W_{\rm diss}), which quantifies the thermodynamic distance from the entropic (Landauer) limit. By construction, \eta_S = 0 corresponds to the saturation of the entropy production limit, while \eta_S \to 1 indicates dissipation dominated by non-entropic (classical) contributions. Maximizing \eta_S is equivalent to a constrained variational problem in which dissipated work is minimized subject to the second law of thermodynamics. For typical superconducting qubits (\omega_q/2\pi \sim 5 GHz, T_1 \sim 50–100 \mus, T \sim 15 mK), the entropic bound T \Delta S \sim 10^{-23} J lies two orders of magnitude below the experimentally observed classical dissipation floor W_{\rm floor} \sim 10^{-21} J. Figures 1 and 2 were generated using the provided scripts_generate_figures.py script, using parameters: \omega_q/2\pi = 5 GHz, T_1 = 80 \mus, and T = 15 mK.
Quantum state engineering and quantum computation rely on information erasure procedures that, up to some fidelity, prepare a quantum object in a pure state. Such processes occur within Landauer's framework if they rely on an interaction between the object and a thermal reservoir. Landauer's principle dictates that this must dissipate a minimum quantity of heat, proportional to the entropy reduction that is incurred by the object, to the thermal reservoir. However, this lower bound is only reachable for some specific physical situations, and it is not necessarily achievable for any given reservoir. The main task of our work can be stated as the minimisation of heat dissipation given probabilistic information erasure, i.e., minimising the amount of energy transferred to the thermal reservoir as heat if we require that the probability of preparing the object in a specific pure state | φ 1 ⟩ be no smaller than p φ 1 max − δ . Here p φ 1 max is the maximum probability of information erasure that is permissible by the physical context, and δ ⩾ 0 the error. To determine the achievable minimal heat dissipation of quantum information erasure within a given physical context, we explicitly optimise over all possible unitary operators that act on the composite system of object and reservoir. Specifically, we characterise the equivalence class of such optimal unitary operators, using tools from majorisation theory, when we are restricted to finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Furthermore, we discuss how pure state preparation processes could be achieved with a smaller heat cost than Landauer's limit, by operating outside of Landauer's framework.
The Landauer principle states that any logically irreversible information processing must be accompanied by dissipation into the environment. In this Letter, we investigate the heat dissipation associated with finite-time information erasure and the effect of quantum coherence in such processes. By considering a scenario wherein information is encoded in an open quantum system whose dynamics are described by the Markovian Lindblad equation, we show that the dissipated heat is lower bounded by the conventional Landauer cost, as well as a correction term inversely proportional to the operational time. To clarify the relation between quantum coherence and dissipation, we derive a lower bound for heat dissipation in terms of quantum coherence. This bound quantitatively implies that the creation of quantum coherence in the energy eigenbasis during the erasure process inevitably leads to additional heat costs. The obtained bounds hold for arbitrary operational time and control protocol. By following an optimal control theory, we numerically present an optimal protocol and illustrate our findings by using a single-qubit system.