Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.13500 · Entropy

Quantum Randomness is Chimeric

Karl Svozil

Published Apr 24, 2021• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

If quantum mechanics is taken for granted, the randomness derived from it may be vacuous or even delusional, yet sufficient for many practical purposes. "Random" quantum events are intimately related to the emergence of both space-time as well as the identification of physical properties through which so-called objects are aggregated. We also present a brief review of the metaphysics of indeterminism.

DOI
10.3390/e23050519

Related papers

The Quantum and the Random: Similarities, Differences, and “Contradictions”

Jan-Åke Larsson

This paper makes an attempt to present Quantum Mechanics in simple terms, but without oversimplification. It will be in essence, a comparison of the usual understanding of randomness to the more difficult notion of “quantumness.” The restricted format of this paper will unfortunately force the presentation to be very terse. But perhaps this paper can be seen as a synopsis of the approach I have in mind.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

The Chimerical Cat: Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics in Historical Perspective

Stephen G. Brush

The establishment of the Heisenberg-Schrodinger quantum mechanics in 1926 was undoubtedly the most important event m the history of twentieth-century science - for science itself, even if not for society. One might therefore suppose that the metaphysical conclusions associated with quantum mechanics are a major part of our present view of the world The purpose of this paper is to show that two of these conclusions - indeterminism, and the denial of independent reality to atomic properties - are not unique to quantum mechanics, but emerged as the culmination of historical trends begun m the nineteenth century It postulates cyclic oscillation between 'Romantic' and 'Realist' periods m science and culture, and ascribes a gradual breakdown of belief in determinism to debates about irreversibility. Albert Einstein's opposition to the 'Copenhagen Interpretation' of quantum mechanics was based on a preference for realism as much as a dislike for indeterminism, and the 'Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox' was a formidable challenge to subjectivist instrumentalism. Following the revival of realist interpretations m the 1950s, new experiments seem to have reconfirmed the subjectivist view But there is currently strong disagreement on what kind of subjectivism is scientifically legitimate; John Wheeler's version of the 'anthropic principle' and parapsychological explanations both conflict with the naive realism that has dominated the Western Intellectual tradition since the seventeenth century.

Social Studies of Science•Nov 1, 1980•35 citations

Quantum randomness and unpredictability

Gregg S. Jaeger

Quantum mechanics is a physical theory supplying probabilities corresponding to expectation values for measurement outcomes. Indeed, its formalism can be constructed with measurement as a fundamental process, as was done by Schwinger, provided that individual measurements outcomes occur in a random way. The randomness appearing in quantum mechanics, as with other forms of randomness, has often been considered equivalent to a form of indeterminism. Here, it is argued that quantum randomness should instead be understood as a form of unpredictability because, amongst other things, indeterminism is not a necessary condition for randomness. For concreteness, an explication of the randomness of quantum mechanics as the unpredictability of quantum measurement outcomes is provided. Finally, it is shown how this view can be combined with the recently introduced view that the very appearance of individual quantum measurement outcomes can be grounded in the Plenitude principle of Leibniz, a principle variants of which have been utilized in physics by Dirac and Gell‐Mann in relation to the fundamental processes. This move provides further support to Schwinger's “symbolic” derivation of quantum mechanics from measurement.

Fortschritte der Physik•Dec 5, 2016•9 citations

Quantum Randomness and Underdetermination

Jeffrey Alan Barrett, Simon M. Huttegger

We consider the nature of quantum randomness and how one might have empirical evidence for it. We will see why, depending on one’s computational resources, it may be impossible to determine whether a particular notion of randomness properly characterizes one’s empirical data. Indeed, we will see why even an ideal observer under ideal epistemic conditions may never have any empirical evidence whatsoever for believing that the results of one’s quantum-mechanical experiments are randomly determined. This illustrates a radical sort of empirical underdetermination faced by fundamentally stochastic theories like quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of Science•Feb 20, 2020•23 citations

Quantum-like Data Modeling in Applied Sciences: Review

Stan Lipovetsky

This work presents a brief review on the modern approaches to data modeling by the methods developed in the quantum physics during the last one hundred years. Quantum computers and computations have already been widely investigated theoretically and attempted in some practical implementations, but methods of quantum data modeling are not yet sufficiently established. A vast range of concepts and methods of quantum mechanics have been tried in many fields of information and behavior sciences, including communications and artificial intelligence, cognition and decision making, sociology and psychology, biology and economics, financial and political studies. The application of quantum methods in areas other than physics is called the quantum-like paradigm, meaning that such approaches may not be related to the physical processes but rather correspond to data modeling by the methods designed for operating in conditions of uncertainty. This review aims to attract attention to the possibilities of these methods of data modeling that can enrich theoretical consideration and be useful for practical purposes in various sciences and applications.

Stats•Feb 17, 2023•5 citations

Reality as Fields, Events, and Cascades of Convergence A conversation-derived framework for understanding quantum fields, particles, consciousness, and everything in between

Reddy Govind

Author's Note: This paper proposes a speculative ontological framework, not an empirical theory. Its claims are offered as a new direction of inquiry. Where they conflict with established physics they should be taken as questions, not corrections. Where they illuminate what established physics leaves obscure, they may be worth pursuing. The future will determine which is which. This paper distils a sustained conceptual dialogue into a coherent framework for understanding the deep structure of physical reality — written for anyone who thinks carefully, not only for specialists. The central argument is this: reality is not made of objects. It is made of fields and events. Quantum fields are immortal, pre-propertied substrates — the only permanent things in existence. Particles are not objects sitting inside fields; they are brief events that occur when conditions inside the field converge sufficiently. What we call objects — rocks, mountains, you, stars — are events of longer duration, not a different category of thing. And what drives the cascade from quantum fields all the way to minds is not a programme being run by anyone: it is the continuous convergence of events with other events, each convergence producing new stable patterns with genuinely new properties that could not have been predicted from the level below. The framework draws a precise analogy with software — fields are like classes, particles like instantiated objects — and then identifies exactlywhere the analogy breaks down and why that break matters profoundly: software needs a programmer; nature does not. Nature is bootstrapped.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
If quantum mechanics is taken for granted, the randomness derived from it may be vacuous or even delusional, yet sufficient for many practical purposes. "Random" quantum events are intimately related to the emergence of both space-time as well as the identification of physical properties through which so-called objects are aggregated. We also present a brief review of the metaphysics of indeterminism.
The establishment of the Heisenberg-Schrodinger quantum mechanics in 1926 was undoubtedly the most important event m the history of twentieth-century science - for science itself, even if not for society. One might therefore suppose that the metaphysical conclusions associated with quantum mechanics are a major part of our present view of the world The purpose of this paper is to show that two of these conclusions - indeterminism, and the denial of independent reality to atomic properties - are not unique to quantum mechanics, but emerged as the culmination of historical trends begun m the nineteenth century It postulates cyclic oscillation between 'Romantic' and 'Realist' periods m science and culture, and ascribes a gradual breakdown of belief in determinism to debates about irreversibility. Albert Einstein's opposition to the 'Copenhagen Interpretation' of quantum mechanics was based on a preference for realism as much as a dislike for indeterminism, and the 'Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox' was a formidable challenge to subjectivist instrumentalism. Following the revival of realist interpretations m the 1950s, new experiments seem to have reconfirmed the subjectivist view But there is currently strong disagreement on what kind of subjectivism is scientifically legitimate; John Wheeler's version of the 'anthropic principle' and parapsychological explanations both conflict with the naive realism that has dominated the Western Intellectual tradition since the seventeenth century.
Quantum mechanics is a physical theory supplying probabilities corresponding to expectation values for measurement outcomes. Indeed, its formalism can be constructed with measurement as a fundamental process, as was done by Schwinger, provided that individual measurements outcomes occur in a random way. The randomness appearing in quantum mechanics, as with other forms of randomness, has often been considered equivalent to a form of indeterminism. Here, it is argued that quantum randomness should instead be understood as a form of unpredictability because, amongst other things, indeterminism is not a necessary condition for randomness. For concreteness, an explication of the randomness of quantum mechanics as the unpredictability of quantum measurement outcomes is provided. Finally, it is shown how this view can be combined with the recently introduced view that the very appearance of individual quantum measurement outcomes can be grounded in the Plenitude principle of Leibniz, a principle variants of which have been utilized in physics by Dirac and Gell‐Mann in relation to the fundamental processes. This move provides further support to Schwinger's “symbolic” derivation of quantum mechanics from measurement.
We consider the nature of quantum randomness and how one might have empirical evidence for it. We will see why, depending on one’s computational resources, it may be impossible to determine whether a particular notion of randomness properly characterizes one’s empirical data. Indeed, we will see why even an ideal observer under ideal epistemic conditions may never have any empirical evidence whatsoever for believing that the results of one’s quantum-mechanical experiments are randomly determined. This illustrates a radical sort of empirical underdetermination faced by fundamentally stochastic theories like quantum mechanics.
This work presents a brief review on the modern approaches to data modeling by the methods developed in the quantum physics during the last one hundred years. Quantum computers and computations have already been widely investigated theoretically and attempted in some practical implementations, but methods of quantum data modeling are not yet sufficiently established. A vast range of concepts and methods of quantum mechanics have been tried in many fields of information and behavior sciences, including communications and artificial intelligence, cognition and decision making, sociology and psychology, biology and economics, financial and political studies. The application of quantum methods in areas other than physics is called the quantum-like paradigm, meaning that such approaches may not be related to the physical processes but rather correspond to data modeling by the methods designed for operating in conditions of uncertainty. This review aims to attract attention to the possibilities of these methods of data modeling that can enrich theoretical consideration and be useful for practical purposes in various sciences and applications.
Author's Note: This paper proposes a speculative ontological framework, not an empirical theory. Its claims are offered as a new direction of inquiry. Where they conflict with established physics they should be taken as questions, not corrections. Where they illuminate what established physics leaves obscure, they may be worth pursuing. The future will determine which is which. This paper distils a sustained conceptual dialogue into a coherent framework for understanding the deep structure of physical reality — written for anyone who thinks carefully, not only for specialists. The central argument is this: reality is not made of objects. It is made of fields and events. Quantum fields are immortal, pre-propertied substrates — the only permanent things in existence. Particles are not objects sitting inside fields; they are brief events that occur when conditions inside the field converge sufficiently. What we call objects — rocks, mountains, you, stars — are events of longer duration, not a different category of thing. And what drives the cascade from quantum fields all the way to minds is not a programme being run by anyone: it is the continuous convergence of events with other events, each convergence producing new stable patterns with genuinely new properties that could not have been predicted from the level below. The framework draws a precise analogy with software — fields are like classes, particles like instantiated objects — and then identifies exactlywhere the analogy breaks down and why that break matters profoundly: software needs a programmer; nature does not. Nature is bootstrapped.