We show that the stochastic Schrödinger equation (SSE) provides an ideal way to simulate the quantum mechanical spin dynamics of radical pairs. Electron spin relaxation effects arising from fluctuations in the spin Hamiltonian are straightforward to include in this approach, and their treatment can be combined with a highly efficient stochastic evaluation of the trace over nuclear spin states that is required to compute experimental observables. These features are illustrated in example applications to a flavin-tryptophan radical pair of interest in avian magnetoreception and to a problem involving spin-selective radical pair recombination along a molecular wire. In the first of these examples, the SSE is shown to be both more efficient and more widely applicable than a recent stochastic implementation of the Lindblad equation, which only provides a valid treatment of relaxation in the extreme-narrowing limit. In the second, the exact SSE results are used to assess the accuracy of a recently proposed combination of Nakajima-Zwanzig theory for the spin relaxation and Schulten-Wolynes theory for the spin dynamics, which is applicable to radical pairs with many more nuclear spins. We also analyze the efficiency of trace sampling in some detail, highlighting the particular advantages of sampling with SU(N) coherent states.
We show that the stochastic Schrödinger equation (SSE) provides an ideal way to simulate the quantum mechanical spin dynamics of radical pairs. Electron spin relaxation effects arising from fluctuations in the spin Hamiltonian are straightforward to include in this approach, and their treatment can be combined with a highly efficient stochastic evaluation of the trace over nuclear spin states that is required to compute experimental observables. These features are illustrated in example applications to a flavin-tryptophan radical pair of interest in avian magnetoreception and to a problem involving spin-selective radical pair recombination along a molecular wire. In the first of these examples, the SSE is shown to be both more efficient and more widely applicable than a recent stochastic implementation of the Lindblad equation, which only provides a valid treatment of relaxation in the extreme-narrowing limit. In the second, the exact SSE results are used to assess the accuracy of a recently proposed combination of Nakajima-Zwanzig theory for the spin relaxation and Schulten-Wolynes theory for the spin dynamics, which is applicable to radical pairs with many more nuclear spins. We also analyze the efficiency of trace sampling in some detail, highlighting the particular advantages of sampling with SU(N) coherent states.
Radical pairs are short-lived, spin-correlated intermediates that underpin processes in chemistry, biology, and emerging quantum technologies. Their behavior is governed by coupled electron-nuclear spin dynamics and is sensitive to weak magnetic fields, but full quantum treatments have been obstructed by the extreme computational cost of modeling many interacting spins. Here, this barrier is removed, demonstrating that open-system radical-pair dynamics can be resolved at nuclear-spin scales previously intractable, explicitly reaching regimes with tens of coupled nuclei and validated up to 60 spins. In biologically relevant flavin-tryptophan radical pairs, electron-transfer pathways and magnetic-field anisotropy are found to reshape spin evolution and, in turn, spin-selective reaction yields. The resulting directional responses expose a strong mechanistic link between the nuclear environment, magnetic geometry, and chemical outcome-a relationship central to hypotheses of avian magnetoreception and other magnetic-field effects in biology. This establishes a widely applicable simulation framework that removes a long-standing barrier in spin chemistry, quantum biology, and spin-based device science.
It is a remarkable fact that the interactions between electron and nuclear spins, and their interactions with a magnetic field, can have a profound effect on chemical reactivity, despite the fact that the characteristic interaction energies are orders of magnitude smaller than thermal energy. These observations are explained by the existence of long-lived quantum coherences between spins in certain molecular species (in particular radical pairs), and the study of these spin effects constitutes the field of spin chemistry, a field which spans a wide range of systems, from biochemical reactions to device physics. Because spin chemistry involves subtle quantum effects, many intuitive models used by Physical Chemists, in particular classical kinetic equations, cannot be universally applied. On the other hand, complete first principles modelling of reactions involving spin effects comes at an impossibly high computational cost in complex systems, and often offers little physical insight. In order to address the shortcomings of these approaches, quantum master equations (QMEs) are employed to describe spin chemical phenomena. These are equations that describe a reduced set of degrees of freedom quantum mechanically, accounting for the effects of remaining degrees freedom implicitly. In this thesis I explore the use of QME techniques to resolve a range of problems in spin chemistry. These techniques can be used to obtain the correct radical pair spin QME, resolving questions about the role of quantum measurement in these systems. As well as aiding the development of the theory of spin chemistry, QMEs provide a practical tool for modelling radical pair reactions including spin relaxation effects, as I also demonstrate. As a final study of QME techniques in spin chemistry, I use these methods to show when the classical kinetic description of radical pair reactions is and is not valid.
Abstract We adapt the Monte-Carlo wavefunction (MCWF) approach to treat the open-system spin dynamics of radical pairs subject to spin-selective recombination reactions. For these systems, non-Lindbladian master equations are widely employed, which account for recombination via the non trace-preserving Haberkorn superoperator in combination with reaction-dependent exchange and singlet–triplet dephasing terms. We show that this type of master equation can be accommodated in the MCWF approach, by introducing a second type of quantum jump that accounts for the reaction simply by suitably terminating the propagation. In this way, we are able to evaluate approximate solutions to the time-dependent radical pair survival probability for systems that have been considered untreatable with the master equation approach until now. We explicate the suggested approach with calculations for radical pair reactions that have been suggested to be relevant for the quantum compass of birds and related phenomena.
The development of the radical pair mechanism has allowed for theoretical explanation of the fact that magnetic fields are observed to have an effect on chemical reactions. The mechanism describes how an external magnetic field can alter chemical yields by interacting with the spin state of a pair of radicals. In the field of quantum biology, there has been some interest in the application of the mechanism to biological systems. This paper takes an open quantum systems approach to a model of the radical pair mechanism in order to derive a master equation in the Born-Markov approximation for the case of two electrons, each interacting with an environment of nuclear spins as well as the external magnetic field, then placed in a dissipative bosonic bath. This model is used to investigate two different cases relating to radical pair dynamics. The first uses a collective coupling approach to simplify calculations for larger numbers of nuclei interacting with the radical pair. The second looks at the effects of different hyperfine configurations of the radical pair model, for instance the case in which one of the electrons interact with two nuclei with different hyperfine coupling constants. The results of these investigations are analysed to see if they offer any insights into the biological application of the radical pair mechanism in avian magnetoreception.
The dynamics of many chemical systems can be influenced significantly by interactions with their environment (bath). An exact treatment of this is often infeasible due to the exponential scaling of Hilbert space with the number of degrees of freedom. In this thesis, dynamical methods, which overcome this difficulty, are considered for spin systems coupled to spin baths as well as systems coupled to harmonic oscillator baths. The thesis begins by considering recombination reactions of radical pairs, in which two electron spins interact with baths of nuclear spins. Motivated by inaccuracies observed in semiclassical treatments of the dynamics of a series of cryptochrome-based radical pairs, a new approach capable of treating the quantum dynamics of spin systems coupled to large baths of spins is presented. This method is validated for a series of central spin models, and is found to correctly describe the quantum dynamics of spin systems containing up to 1000 spins. Following this, the validity of the conventional treatment of radical pair recombination reactions is explored by considering the coupled electronic, nuclear and spin dynamics of a model radical ion pair. The dynamics of this model is treated using the hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) formalism, and the results obtained are used to validate a recently proposed series of master equations. The HEOM formalism exactly captures the quantum dynamics of systems that are coupled to harmonic baths. However, due to the scaling of its computational cost with the strength of the coupling, it often becomes impractical. To overcome this difficulty, an efficient tree tensor network-based approach is presented and valided by treating a series of simple models. Following this, it is applied to the calculation of electron transfer rates for a series of models spanning a wide range of physical regimes in order to validate a recently proposed interpolation formula for the calculation of electron transfer rates.
This thesis is concerned with the design of numerical methods for quantum simulation and the development of improved models for quantum relaxation. Analysis is presented for the treatment of quantum systems using the density matrix formalism. This approach has been developed from the early days of quantum mechanics as a tool to describe from a statistical point of view a large number of identical quantum ensembles. Traditional methods are well established and reliable, but they perform poorly for practical simulation as the system size is scaled up. Ad hoc schemes for nuclear spin dynamics appearing in the literature can be shown to fail in certain situations. The challenge is therefore to identify efficient reduction methods for the quantum system which are also based on a rigorous foundation. The method presented in the thesis, for the time–independent Hamiltonian case, combines a quantum density matrix formalism with a procedure based on Chebyshev polynomials; application of the method to Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is considered, and it is shown that the new technique outperforms existing alternatives in term of computational costs. The case of a time–dependent Hamiltonian in NMR simulation is studied as well and some splitting methods are presented. To the author’s knowledge this is the first time such methods have been applied within the NMR framework, and the numerical results show a better error–to–cost rate than traditional methods. In a separate strand of research, formulations for open quantum systems are studied and new dynamical systems approaches are considered for this problem. Motivations This thesis work is mainly focused on nuclear spin dynamics. Nuclear spin dynamics constitutes the basis for NMR, which is a very powerful spectroscopy technique that exploits the interaction between nuclear spins and magnetic fields. The same technique is used to reveal the presence of hydrogen atoms in the blood for Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI). Within this framework the role of simulations is extremely important, as it provides a benchmark for studies of new materials, and the development of new magnetic fields. The main computational issue is that with current software for NMR simulation it is extremely expensive to deal with systems made of more than few (7–10) spins. There is therefore a strong need to develop new algorithms capable of simulating larger systems. In recent years NMR simulations have been found to be one of the most favorable candidates for quantum computing. There are two reasons for this: nuclear quantum states maintain extremely long coherences, and it is possible to attain a very strong control on the quantum state via the application of sequences of pulses. In order to develop a proper quantum computer it is fundamental to understand how the entangled states lose coherence and relax back to equilibrium by means of external interactions. This process is described as relaxation in an open quantum system. The theory for such systems has been available for 50 years but there are still substantial limitations in the two main approaches. There are also relatively few numerical approaches for the simulation of such systems, for this reason it is important to develop numerical alternatives for the description of open quantum systems. Thesis Outline The thesis is organized as follow: the first two chapters provide background material to familiarize the reader with fundamental concepts of both quantum mechanics and nuclear spin dynamics; in this part of the thesis no new results are presented. The first chapter introduces the concept of quantum systems and the mathematical environment with which we describe those systems. We also present the main equations we need to solve to determine the dynamics of a quantum system in a statistical framework. In the second chapter we introduce the nuclear spin system, that is the physical system that has been the main reference frame in this work, for both tests and practical applications of the new algorithms. We describe how nuclear spin systems are at the basis of very important applications like NMR spectroscopy and MRI. We present in some detail the physical features of the NMR technique and the equations we need to solve to describe the dynamics of a spin system; we also focus on the relevance of numerical simulations for these systems, and consequently which must be the interest in developing new algorithms, and the major obstacles which must be overcome. In the third chapter we investigate the numerical challenges that arise in simulation of quantum systems, we describe some of the methods that have been developed in the literature, focusing on the performances and the computational costs of them, setting the new developments of this thesis in the proper research frame. We discuss one of the major issues: the evaluation of the matrix exponential. We also present the analysis we have done of a recent method called Zero Track Elimination (ZTE) that has been developed specifically for NMR simulations. This analysis shows the limitations of this method but also gives a mathematical explanation of why–and in which cases–it works. In the fourth chapter we present the main result of the thesis, the development of a new method that directly evaluates the expectation values for a quantum simulation via a different application of the well known Chebyshev expansion. We have proved that this new method can provide an excellent boost in terms of performance, with computational costs that can be reduced by a factor ten in common cases. (The results of this chapter and the new method have been presented in international conferences and recently they have been submitted for publication). We also present some attempts we have made in the application of splitting methods for the evolution of the system in a time dependent environment. To our knowledge this is the first time splitting methods have been used for NMR simulations. The results of this approach are as follows: for a particular splitting technique combined with a Lanczos iteration method it is possible to speed up the calculation by a third if compared with a Lanczos type method whilst keeping the error below a critical threshold. This last approach is still a work in progress especially in terms of developing clever ways to split the Hamiltonian. The last chapter of this thesis deals with simulation of quantum systems interacting with an external environment. After presenting the main theoretical approaches for the description of such systems we then survey several the techniques that are currently used for the numerical implementation of such theories. As a work in progress we present a considerably different new approach we have been developing aiming to overcome some of the issues that arise when treating this kind of system within usual frameworks. This is somewhat speculative work that gives rise to some new directions in the development of a numerical description for open quantum systems. We also present some numerical results. (The main core of this chapter has been presented in international conferences).