Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.02333 · Physical Review A

Entanglement cost for steering assemblages

Thomas Cope

Published Oct 25, 2021• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper we answer the question of how one can quantify the amount of entanglement necessary to create a given steering assemblage when the original state and measurements are unknown. To do this, we extend the concepts of entanglement cost and entanglement of formation to steering assemblages and provide easy-to-calculate upper and lower bounds. We prove that the entanglement of formation for assemblages is not generally continuous and not a flat roof extension (in contrast with the state-based quantity), and we use numerical analysis to illustrate these properties. Finally, we discuss the consequences of these results for assemblage-to-assemblage conversion and suggest potential applications.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.104.042220

Related papers

Cost of Simulating Entanglement in Steering Scenarios

Yujie Zhang, Jiaxuan Zhang, Eric Chitambar

Quantum entanglement is a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics, yet certain entangled states that are unsteerable can be classically simulated in steering scenarios, making them unable to exhibit quantum steering. Despite their significance, a systematic comparison of such entangled states has not been explored. In this work, we quantify the resource content of unsteerable quantum states in terms of the amount of shared randomness required to simulate the assemblages they generate in the steering scenario. We rigorously demonstrate that the simulation cost is unbounded even for certain unsteerable two-qubit states. Moreover, the simulation cost of entangled two-qubit states is always strictly larger than that for any separable state. A significant portion of our results rests on the relationship between the simulation cost of two-qubit Werner states and that of noisy spin measurements. Using noisy spin measurements as our central example, we also investigate the minimum number of outcomes a parent measurement requires to simulate a given set of compatible measurements. Although certain continuous measurement families admit a finite-outcome parent measurement, we identify scenarios where the simulation cost is unbounded. Our results establish previously unknown lower bounds and upper bounds on the shared randomness simulation cost, supported by connections between the simulation cost of noisy spin measurements and various geometric inequalities, including ones from the zonotope approximation problem in Banach space theory.

arXiv:2302.09060•Quantum•Oct 31, 2025•6 citations

Quantifying entanglement of formation for two-mode Gaussian states: Analytical expressions for upper and lower bounds and numerical estimation of its exact value

Spyros Tserkis, Sho Onoe, Timothy C. Ralph

Entanglement of formation quantifies the entanglement of a state in terms of the entropy of entanglement of the least entangled pure state needed to prepare it. An analytical expression for this measure exists only for special cases, and finding a closed formula for an arbitrary state remains an open problem. In this work we focus on two-mode Gaussian states, and we derive narrow upper and lower bounds for the measure that get tight for several special cases. Further, we show that the problem of calculating the actual value of the entanglement of formation for arbitrary two-mode Gaussian states reduces to a trivial single parameter optimization process, and we provide an efficient algorithm for the numerical calculation of the measure.

arXiv:1903.09961•Physical Review A•May 23, 2019•54 citations

Measurable bounds for entanglement of formation

Ming Li, Shao-Ming Fei

We study the entanglement of formation for arbitrary dimensional bipartite mixed unknown states. Experimentally measurable lower and upper bounds for entanglement of formation are derived.

arXiv:1010.4969•Physical Review A•Oct 21, 2010•23 citations

Geometric steering criterion for two-qubit states

Baichu Yu, Zhian Jia, Yu-Chun Wu +1 more

According to the geometric characterization of measurement assemblages and local hidden state (LHS) models, we propose a steering criterion which is both necessary and sufficient for two-qubit states under arbitrary measurement sets. A quantity is introduced to describe the required local resources to reconstruct a measurement assemblage for two-qubit states. We show that the quantity can be regarded as a quantification of steerability and be used to find out optimal LHS models. Finally we propose a method to generate unsteerable states, and construct some two-qubit states which are entangled but unsteerable under all projective measurements.

arXiv:1710.06691•Physical Review A•Jan 29, 2018•16 citations

Quantifying the high-dimensionality of quantum devices

Thomas Cope, Roope Uola

We introduce a measure of average dimensionality (or coherence) for high-dimensional quantum devices. This includes sets of quantum measurements, steering assemblages, and quantum channels. For measurements and channels, our measure corresponds to an average compression dimension, whereas for quantum steering we get a semi-device independent quantifier for the average entanglement dimensionality known as the Schmidt measure. We analyse the measure in all three scenarios. First, we show that it can be decided via semi-definite programming for channels and measurements in low-dimensional systems. Second, we argue that the resulting steering measure is a high-dimensional generalisation of the well-known steering weight. Finally, we analyse the behaviour of the measure in the asymptotic setting. More precisely, we show that the asymptotic Schmidt measure of bipartite quantum states is equal to the entanglement cost and show how the recently introduced entanglement of formation for steering assemblages can be related to our measure in the asymptotic case.

arXiv:2207.05722•Jul 12, 2022•5 citations

Entanglement Cost for Infinite-Dimensional Physical Systems

Hayata Yamasaki, Kohdai Kuroiwa, Patrick M. Hayden +1 more

Abstract We prove that the entanglement cost equals the regularized entanglement of formation for any infinite-dimensional quantum state $$\rho _{AB}$$ ρ AB with finite quantum entropy on at least one of the subsystems A or B . This generalizes a foundational result in quantum information theory that was previously formulated only for operations and states on finite-dimensional systems. The extension to infinite-dimensional systems is nontrivial because the conventional tools for establishing both the direct and converse bounds, i.e., strong typicality, monotonicity, and asymptotic continuity, are no longer directly applicable. To address this problem, we construct a new entanglement dilution protocol for infinite-dimensional states implementable by local operations and a finite amount of one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC), using weak and strong typicality multiple times. We also prove the optimality of this protocol among all protocols, even under infinite-dimensional separable operations, by developing an argument based on alternative forms of monotonicity and asymptotic continuity of the entanglement of formation for infinite-dimensional states. Along the way, we derive a new integral representation for the quantum entropy of infinite-dimensional states, which we believe to be of independent interest. Our results allow us to fully characterize an important operational entanglement measure—the entanglement cost—for all infinite-dimensional physical systems.

arXiv:2401.09554•Communications in Mathematical Physics•Oct 3, 2025•20 citations
In this paper we answer the question of how one can quantify the amount of entanglement necessary to create a given steering assemblage when the original state and measurements are unknown. To do this, we extend the concepts of entanglement cost and entanglement of formation to steering assemblages and provide easy-to-calculate upper and lower bounds. We prove that the entanglement of formation for assemblages is not generally continuous and not a flat roof extension (in contrast with the state-based quantity), and we use numerical analysis to illustrate these properties. Finally, we discuss the consequences of these results for assemblage-to-assemblage conversion and suggest potential applications.
Quantum entanglement is a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics, yet certain entangled states that are unsteerable can be classically simulated in steering scenarios, making them unable to exhibit quantum steering. Despite their significance, a systematic comparison of such entangled states has not been explored. In this work, we quantify the resource content of unsteerable quantum states in terms of the amount of shared randomness required to simulate the assemblages they generate in the steering scenario. We rigorously demonstrate that the simulation cost is unbounded even for certain unsteerable two-qubit states. Moreover, the simulation cost of entangled two-qubit states is always strictly larger than that for any separable state. A significant portion of our results rests on the relationship between the simulation cost of two-qubit Werner states and that of noisy spin measurements. Using noisy spin measurements as our central example, we also investigate the minimum number of outcomes a parent measurement requires to simulate a given set of compatible measurements. Although certain continuous measurement families admit a finite-outcome parent measurement, we identify scenarios where the simulation cost is unbounded. Our results establish previously unknown lower bounds and upper bounds on the shared randomness simulation cost, supported by connections between the simulation cost of noisy spin measurements and various geometric inequalities, including ones from the zonotope approximation problem in Banach space theory.
Entanglement of formation quantifies the entanglement of a state in terms of the entropy of entanglement of the least entangled pure state needed to prepare it. An analytical expression for this measure exists only for special cases, and finding a closed formula for an arbitrary state remains an open problem. In this work we focus on two-mode Gaussian states, and we derive narrow upper and lower bounds for the measure that get tight for several special cases. Further, we show that the problem of calculating the actual value of the entanglement of formation for arbitrary two-mode Gaussian states reduces to a trivial single parameter optimization process, and we provide an efficient algorithm for the numerical calculation of the measure.
According to the geometric characterization of measurement assemblages and local hidden state (LHS) models, we propose a steering criterion which is both necessary and sufficient for two-qubit states under arbitrary measurement sets. A quantity is introduced to describe the required local resources to reconstruct a measurement assemblage for two-qubit states. We show that the quantity can be regarded as a quantification of steerability and be used to find out optimal LHS models. Finally we propose a method to generate unsteerable states, and construct some two-qubit states which are entangled but unsteerable under all projective measurements.
We introduce a measure of average dimensionality (or coherence) for high-dimensional quantum devices. This includes sets of quantum measurements, steering assemblages, and quantum channels. For measurements and channels, our measure corresponds to an average compression dimension, whereas for quantum steering we get a semi-device independent quantifier for the average entanglement dimensionality known as the Schmidt measure. We analyse the measure in all three scenarios. First, we show that it can be decided via semi-definite programming for channels and measurements in low-dimensional systems. Second, we argue that the resulting steering measure is a high-dimensional generalisation of the well-known steering weight. Finally, we analyse the behaviour of the measure in the asymptotic setting. More precisely, we show that the asymptotic Schmidt measure of bipartite quantum states is equal to the entanglement cost and show how the recently introduced entanglement of formation for steering assemblages can be related to our measure in the asymptotic case.
Abstract We prove that the entanglement cost equals the regularized entanglement of formation for any infinite-dimensional quantum state ρAB\rho _{AB}ρAB​ ρ AB with finite quantum entropy on at least one of the subsystems A or B . This generalizes a foundational result in quantum information theory that was previously formulated only for operations and states on finite-dimensional systems. The extension to infinite-dimensional systems is nontrivial because the conventional tools for establishing both the direct and converse bounds, i.e., strong typicality, monotonicity, and asymptotic continuity, are no longer directly applicable. To address this problem, we construct a new entanglement dilution protocol for infinite-dimensional states implementable by local operations and a finite amount of one-way classical communication (one-way LOCC), using weak and strong typicality multiple times. We also prove the optimality of this protocol among all protocols, even under infinite-dimensional separable operations, by developing an argument based on alternative forms of monotonicity and asymptotic continuity of the entanglement of formation for infinite-dimensional states. Along the way, we derive a new integral representation for the quantum entropy of infinite-dimensional states, which we believe to be of independent interest. Our results allow us to fully characterize an important operational entanglement measure—the entanglement cost—for all infinite-dimensional physical systems.