Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2101.06766 · Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física

On the mean value of the force operator for 1D particles in the step potential

Salvatore De Vincenzo

Published Jan 1, 2021• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the one-dimensional Klein-Fock-Gordon theory, the probability density is a discontinuous function at the point where the step potential is discontinuous. Thus, the mean value of the external classical force operator cannot be calculated from the corresponding formula of the mean value. To resolve this issue, we obtain this quantity directly from the Klein-Fock-Gordon equation in Hamiltonian form, or the Feshbach-Villars wave equation. Not without surprise, the result obtained is not proportional to the average of the discontinuity of the probability density but to the size of the discontinuity. In contrast, in the one-dimensional Schrödinger and Dirac theories this quantity is proportional to the value that the respective probability density takes at the point where the step potential is discontinuous. We examine these issues in detail in this paper. The presentation is suitable for the advanced undergraduate level.

DOI
10.1590/1806-9126-rbef-2020-0422

Related papers

On average forces and the Ehrenfest theorem for a particle in a semi-infinite interval

Salvatore De Vincenzo

"We study the issues of average forces and the Ehrenfest theorem for a particle restricted to a semi-infinite interval by an impenetrable wall. We consider and discuss two specific cases: (i) a free particle in an infinite step potential, and (ii) a free particle on a half-line. In each situation, we show that the mean values of the position, momentum and force, as functions of time, verify the Ehrenfest theorem (the state of the particle being a general wave packet that is a continuous superposition of the energy eigenstates for the Hamiltonian). However, the involved force is not the same in each case. In fact, we have the usual external classical force in the first case and a type of nonlocal boundary quantum force in the second case. In spite of these different forces, the corresponding mean values of these quantities give the same results. Accordingly, the Ehrenfest equations in the two situations are equivalent. We believe that a careful and clear consideration of how the two cases differ but, in the end, agree, is pertinent, and has not been included in the literature."

Revista Mexicana de Física E•Jan 12, 2013•2 citations

Average Force on the Wavefunction Versus Force on Plane Wave Constituents

Francesco R. Ruggeri

The Schrodinger equation for a bound state includes the classical potential V(r) for which –d/dxj V represents Fj or force in the j direction. It has been argued in a previous note (1), that one may attribute physical meaning to the Fourier series of V(r). In such a case, V(r) and W(r) (the wavefunction) are quantities averaged over momentum (or vectors) as well as being averages over time. One may write the product of V(r)W(r) as one of two Fourier series and then reorganize into a series with basis exp(ikr). In such a case, one examines an interaction with V at each momentum wave level. Then the average is only over time as different k momentum states of in W combine with different p momentum states of the Fourier series of V(r). For a p momentum wave, one may write: p2/2m fp + Sum k Vk f(p-k) = E fp where W= Sum over p fp exp(ipx) in one dimension ((1)) The objective of this note is to observe differences in the interaction of a single plane wave with a potential ((1)) and the interaction of W with V in the Schrodinger equation. In particular, for a particle in a box with infinite walls, V(x)=0 inside the one dimensional box, yet the Fourier series of W includes all p values. From ((1)), even though V(x)=0 as an average, there seems to still be an interaction with various Vk values (Vk= the kth Fourier transform) in the interior of the box as ((1)) holds at all x points.

•Nov 25, 2019•0 citations

Klein–Gordon equation in hydrodynamical form

Cheuk-Yin Wong

We follow and modify the Feshbach–Villars formalism by separating the Klein–Gordon equation into two coupled time-dependent Schrödinger equations for particle and antiparticle wave function components with positive probability densities. We find that the equation of motion for the probability densities is in the form of relativistic hydrodynamics where various forces have their classical counterparts, with the additional element of the quantum stress tensor that depends on the derivatives of the amplitude of the wave function. We derive the equation of motion for the Wigner function and we find that its approximate classical weak-field limit coincides with the equation of motion for the distribution function in the collisionless kinetic theory.

arXiv:1011.5510•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2010•9 citations

Less than perfect quantum wavefunctions in momentum-space: How ϕ(p) senses disturbances in the force

M. Belloni, R. W. Robinett

We develop a systematic approach to determine the large |p| behavior of the momentum-space wave function, ϕ(p), of a one-dimensional quantum system for which the position-space wave function, ψ(x), has a discontinuous derivative at any order. We find that if the kth derivative of the potential energy function for the system has a discontinuity, there is a corresponding discontinuity in ψ(k+2)(x) at the same point. This discontinuity leads directly to a power-law tail in the momentum-space wave function proportional to 1/pk+3. A number of familiar pedagogical examples are examined in this context, leading to a general derivation of the result.

arXiv:1010.4244•American Journal of Physics•Dec 13, 2010•5 citations

Quantum and classical limits in a potential step

CLAUDIO O. DIB, Oscar F. Orellana

Abstract We have often found among many of our students and colleagues the common idea that the mathematical expression for a physical quantity that is essentially of quantum nature must contain a dependence on ℏ. Conversely, a phenomenon described by classical physics should contain no explicit reference to ℏ. However, the problem of a particle encountering a discontinuous potential step, which is one of the simplest examples in quantum mechanics, contradicts this common thought: even when the particle carries enough kinetic energy to go across the step, the resulting expression for the reflection probability is non-zero—a purely quantum phenomenon—and yet it contains no reference to ℏ. We show that the absence of ℏ in this purely quantum expression is due to the idealised limit in which the potential rises sharply at a single position, thus losing any reference to a length dimension in the problem. To address the correct classical limit of the phenomenon we first regularise the discontinuity in the potential by taking a continuous linearly rising function over a distance a . We show that the correct classical limit, which is when no reflection occurs, is obtained for large values of a , not for vanishing a . The latter actually corresponds to a purely quantum case, albeit in a limiting case of a discontinuously abrupt change in the potential at a single point in space.

European Journal of Physics•Apr 20, 2017•2 citations

Quantifying some properties of the stochastic quantum force

Roumen Tsekov, Eyal Heifetz

We consider for clarity the simple case of the one dimensional non-relativistic Schrödinger equation and regard it as an ensemble mean representation of the stochastic motion of a single particle in a vacuum, subject to an undefined stochastic quantum force. By analyzing the Bohm potential it is found that the imaginary part of the quantum momentum is the root mean square fluctuation of the particle around its mean velocity, where the latter is the real part of the quantum momentum. The local mean of the quantum force is found to be proportional to the third spatial derivative of the probability density function, and its associated pressure to the second spatial derivative. The latter is decomposed from the single particle diluted gas pressure, and this pressure partition allows the interpretation of the quantum Bohm potential as the energy required to put a particle in a bath of fluctuating vacuum at constant entropy and volume. The stochastic force expectation value is zero and is uncorrelated with the particle location, thus does not perform work on average. Nonetheless it is anti-correlated with volume and this anti-correlation leads to a new type of an Heisenberg like relation. We imply the dynamic Gaussian solution to the Schrödinger equation as a simple example for exploring the mean properties of this quantum force. Still an interesting remained open task is the identification of the stochastic law that leads to these obtained mean properties.

arXiv:1607.02845•Jul 11, 2016•0 citations
In the one-dimensional Klein-Fock-Gordon theory, the probability density is a discontinuous function at the point where the step potential is discontinuous. Thus, the mean value of the external classical force operator cannot be calculated from the corresponding formula of the mean value. To resolve this issue, we obtain this quantity directly from the Klein-Fock-Gordon equation in Hamiltonian form, or the Feshbach-Villars wave equation. Not without surprise, the result obtained is not proportional to the average of the discontinuity of the probability density but to the size of the discontinuity. In contrast, in the one-dimensional Schrödinger and Dirac theories this quantity is proportional to the value that the respective probability density takes at the point where the step potential is discontinuous. We examine these issues in detail in this paper. The presentation is suitable for the advanced undergraduate level.
"We study the issues of average forces and the Ehrenfest theorem for a particle restricted to a semi-infinite interval by an impenetrable wall. We consider and discuss two specific cases: (i) a free particle in an infinite step potential, and (ii) a free particle on a half-line. In each situation, we show that the mean values of the position, momentum and force, as functions of time, verify the Ehrenfest theorem (the state of the particle being a general wave packet that is a continuous superposition of the energy eigenstates for the Hamiltonian). However, the involved force is not the same in each case. In fact, we have the usual external classical force in the first case and a type of nonlocal boundary quantum force in the second case. In spite of these different forces, the corresponding mean values of these quantities give the same results. Accordingly, the Ehrenfest equations in the two situations are equivalent. We believe that a careful and clear consideration of how the two cases differ but, in the end, agree, is pertinent, and has not been included in the literature."
The Schrodinger equation for a bound state includes the classical potential V(r) for which –d/dxj V represents Fj or force in the j direction. It has been argued in a previous note (1), that one may attribute physical meaning to the Fourier series of V(r). In such a case, V(r) and W(r) (the wavefunction) are quantities averaged over momentum (or vectors) as well as being averages over time. One may write the product of V(r)W(r) as one of two Fourier series and then reorganize into a series with basis exp(ikr). In such a case, one examines an interaction with V at each momentum wave level. Then the average is only over time as different k momentum states of in W combine with different p momentum states of the Fourier series of V(r). For a p momentum wave, one may write: p2/2m fp + Sum k Vk f(p-k) = E fp where W= Sum over p fp exp(ipx) in one dimension ((1)) The objective of this note is to observe differences in the interaction of a single plane wave with a potential ((1)) and the interaction of W with V in the Schrodinger equation. In particular, for a particle in a box with infinite walls, V(x)=0 inside the one dimensional box, yet the Fourier series of W includes all p values. From ((1)), even though V(x)=0 as an average, there seems to still be an interaction with various Vk values (Vk= the kth Fourier transform) in the interior of the box as ((1)) holds at all x points.
We follow and modify the Feshbach–Villars formalism by separating the Klein–Gordon equation into two coupled time-dependent Schrödinger equations for particle and antiparticle wave function components with positive probability densities. We find that the equation of motion for the probability densities is in the form of relativistic hydrodynamics where various forces have their classical counterparts, with the additional element of the quantum stress tensor that depends on the derivatives of the amplitude of the wave function. We derive the equation of motion for the Wigner function and we find that its approximate classical weak-field limit coincides with the equation of motion for the distribution function in the collisionless kinetic theory.
We develop a systematic approach to determine the large |p| behavior of the momentum-space wave function, ϕ(p), of a one-dimensional quantum system for which the position-space wave function, ψ(x), has a discontinuous derivative at any order. We find that if the kth derivative of the potential energy function for the system has a discontinuity, there is a corresponding discontinuity in ψ(k+2)(x) at the same point. This discontinuity leads directly to a power-law tail in the momentum-space wave function proportional to 1/pk+3. A number of familiar pedagogical examples are examined in this context, leading to a general derivation of the result.
Abstract We have often found among many of our students and colleagues the common idea that the mathematical expression for a physical quantity that is essentially of quantum nature must contain a dependence on ℏ. Conversely, a phenomenon described by classical physics should contain no explicit reference to ℏ. However, the problem of a particle encountering a discontinuous potential step, which is one of the simplest examples in quantum mechanics, contradicts this common thought: even when the particle carries enough kinetic energy to go across the step, the resulting expression for the reflection probability is non-zero—a purely quantum phenomenon—and yet it contains no reference to ℏ. We show that the absence of ℏ in this purely quantum expression is due to the idealised limit in which the potential rises sharply at a single position, thus losing any reference to a length dimension in the problem. To address the correct classical limit of the phenomenon we first regularise the discontinuity in the potential by taking a continuous linearly rising function over a distance a . We show that the correct classical limit, which is when no reflection occurs, is obtained for large values of a , not for vanishing a . The latter actually corresponds to a purely quantum case, albeit in a limiting case of a discontinuously abrupt change in the potential at a single point in space.
We consider for clarity the simple case of the one dimensional non-relativistic Schrödinger equation and regard it as an ensemble mean representation of the stochastic motion of a single particle in a vacuum, subject to an undefined stochastic quantum force. By analyzing the Bohm potential it is found that the imaginary part of the quantum momentum is the root mean square fluctuation of the particle around its mean velocity, where the latter is the real part of the quantum momentum. The local mean of the quantum force is found to be proportional to the third spatial derivative of the probability density function, and its associated pressure to the second spatial derivative. The latter is decomposed from the single particle diluted gas pressure, and this pressure partition allows the interpretation of the quantum Bohm potential as the energy required to put a particle in a bath of fluctuating vacuum at constant entropy and volume. The stochastic force expectation value is zero and is uncorrelated with the particle location, thus does not perform work on average. Nonetheless it is anti-correlated with volume and this anti-correlation leads to a new type of an Heisenberg like relation. We imply the dynamic Gaussian solution to the Schrödinger equation as a simple example for exploring the mean properties of this quantum force. Still an interesting remained open task is the identification of the stochastic law that leads to these obtained mean properties.