Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2011.12678 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Few-body nature of Kondo correlated ground states

Maxime Debertolis, Serge Florens, Izak Snyman

Published Jun 29, 2021• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quenching of degenerate impurity states in metals generally induces a long-range correlated quantum state known as the Kondo screening cloud. While a macroscopic number of particles clearly take part in forming this extended structure, assessing the number of truly entangled degrees of freedom requires a careful analysis of the relevant many-body wave function. For this purpose, we examine the natural single-particle orbitals that are eigenstates of the single-particle density (correlation) matrix for the ground state of two quantum impurity problems: the interacting resonant level model (IRLM) and the single impurity Anderson model (SIAM). As a simple and general probe for few-body versus many-body character we consider the rate of exponential decay of the correlation matrix eigenvalues towards inactive (fully empty or filled) orbitals. We find that this rate remains large in the physically most relevant region of parameter space, implying a few-body character. Genuine many-body correlations emerge only when the Kondo temperature becomes exponentially small, for instance near a quantum critical point. In addition, we demonstrate that a simple numerical diagonalization of the few-body problem restricted to the Fock space of the most correlated orbitals converges exponentially fast with respect to the number of orbitals, to the true ground state of the IRLM. We also show that finite-size effects drastically affect the correlation spectrum, shedding light on an apparent paradox arising from previous studies on short chains.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.103.235166

Related papers

Unveiling the Kondo cloud: Unitary renormalization-group study of the Kondo model

Anirban Mukherjee, Abhirup Mukherjee, N. S. Vidhyadhiraja +2 more

We analyze the single-channel Kondo model using the recently developed unitary renormalization-group (URG) method and obtain a comprehensive understanding of the Kondo screening cloud. The fixed-point low-energy Hamiltonian enables the computation of a plethora of thermodynamic quantities (specific heat, susceptibility, Wilson ratio, etc.) as well as spectral functions, all of which are found to be in good agreement with known results. By integrating out the impurity, we obtain an effective Hamiltonian for the excitations of the electrons comprising the Kondo cloud. This is found to contain both $k$-space number diagonal (Fermi liquid) and off-diagonal four-fermion scattering terms. Our conclusions are reinforced by a URG study of the two-particle entanglement and many-body correlations among members of the Kondo cloud and impurity. The entanglement between the impurity and a cloud electron, as well as between any two cloud electrons, is found to increase under flow towards the singlet ground state at the strong-coupling fixed point. Both the number diagonal and off-diagonal correlations within the conduction cloud are also found to increase as the impurity is screened under the flow, and the latter are found to be responsible for the macroscopic entanglement of the Kondo-singlet ground state. The URG flow enables an analytic computation of the phase shifts suffered by the conduction electrons at the strong-coupling fixed point. This reveals an orthogonality catastrophe between the local-moment and strong-coupling ground states and is related to a change in the Luttinger volume of the conduction bath under the crossover to strong coupling. Our results offer fresh insight into the nature of the emergent many-particle entanglement within the Kondo cloud and pave the way for further investigations in more exotic contexts such as the fixed point of the overscreened multichannel Kondo problem.

arXiv:2111.10580•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 14, 2022•9 citations

Simulating realistic screening clouds around quantum impurities: Role of spatial anisotropy and disorder

Maxime Debertolis, Izak Snyman, Serge Florens

Dynamical quantum impurities in metals induce electronic correlations in real space that are difficult to simulate due to their multiscale nature, so that only $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ scattering in clean metallic hosts has been investigated so far. However, screening clouds should show anisotropy due to lack of full rotational invariance in two- and three-dimensional lattices, while inherent disorder will also induce spatial inhomogeneities. To tackle these challenges, we present an efficient and robust algorithm based on the recursive generation of natural orbitals defined as eigenvectors of the truncated single-particle density matrix. This method provides well-converged many-body wave functions on lattices with up to tens of thousands of sites, bypassing some limitations of other approaches. The algorithm is put to the test by investigating the charge screening cloud around an interacting resonant level, both on clean and disordered lattices, achieving accurate spatial resolution from short to long distances. We thus demonstrate strong anisotropy of spatial correlations around an adatom in the half-filled square lattice. Taking advantage of the efficiency of the algorithm, we further compute the disorder-induced distribution of Kondo temperatures over several thousands of random realizations, at the same time gaining access to the full spatial profile of the screening cloud in each sample. While the charge screening cloud is typically shortened due to the polarization of the impurity by the disorder potential, we surprisingly find that rare disorder configurations preserve the long-range nature of Kondo correlations in the electronic bath.

arXiv:2203.13041•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 12, 2022•8 citations

Unveiling the internal entanglement structure of the Kondo singlet

Chun Yang, Adrian E. Feiguin

We disentangle all the individual degrees of freedom in the quantum impurity problem to deconstruct the Kondo singlet, both in real and energy space, by studying the contribution of each individual free electron eigenstate. This is a problem of two spins coupled to a bath, where the bath is formed by the remaining conduction electrons. Being a mixed state, we resort to the ``concurrence'' to quantify entanglement. We identify ``projected natural orbitals'' that allow us to individualize a single-particle electronic wave function that is responsible of more than $90%$ of the impurity screening. In the weak coupling regime, the impurity is entangled to an electron at the Fermi level, while in the strong coupling regime, the impurity counterintuitively entangles mostly with the high energy electrons and disentangles completely from the low-energy states carving a ``hole'' around the Fermi level. This enables one to use concurrence as a pseudo order parameter to compute the characteristic ``size'' of the Kondo cloud, beyond which electrons are weakly correlated to the impurity and are dominated by the physics of the boundary.

arXiv:1703.02383•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 6, 2017•35 citations

Single impurity Anderson model and dynamical mean field theory : a functional renormalization group study

Michael Kinza, Carsten Honerkamp A

An essential role for the description of correlated quantum many-particle systems is played by impurity problems. These consist of a small number of localized orbitals, where the electrons are subject to a Coulomb-interaction, coupled to noninteracting bath degrees of freedom. Impurity models are used for the description of magnetic impurities in metals, of quantum points in nanostructures, and in the context of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT). For their solution a large number of numerical methods exists. We mention here quantum Monte Carlo methods, the numerical renormalization group, or the exact diagonalization method. In this thesis we introduce a new approach to impurity problems, which is based on the functional renormalization group (fRG). In contrast to the methods mentioned above this approach is approximative, but it can be applied with comparatively lower numerical effort. The aim of this thesis is to examine the advantages and limits of this method. An important role in this connection is played by the single impurity Anderson model (SIAM), which is already understood very well with other methods and is seen as a prototype for models with strong local correlations. The spin fluctuations of this model are governed by the so-called Kondo energy scale and a central question of this thesis is whether this scale can be reproduced with our approach. We begin with a short introduction to the Green's function formalism for correlated quantum many particle systems. Then the fRG flow equations for the one-particle irreducible vertex functions are deduced, and several approximation schemes are discussed. In chapter 4 we introduce the fRG scheme used in this thesis. At first the SIAM is mapped to a semi-infinite chain, in which the interacting orbital is given by the first site of this chain. The system is then subdivided into two parts. The first part, which is called 'core', consists of the interacting orbital and the first L bath sites. The remaining bath sites form the second part. At the beginning both parts are decoupled from each other such that the core can be solved exactly. Starting with this exact solution the coupling between the core and the remaining bath sites is switched on slowly in a renormalization group flow. This way it is possible to calculate the one-particle and two-particle correlation functions on the correlated site. We call this flow scheme 'hybridization flow'. The flow equations are formulated in an effective theory on the first bath site outside the core, which turns out to be advantageous compared to other implementations of the hybridization flow. In chapter 5 this hybridization flow method is applied to the SIAM with semi-elliptic bath density of states. We discuss the differences which arise for different core-sizes (L = 0,1,2,3) and for different truncations of the fRG flow equations. In the cases L=0 and L=2 the local Fermi liquid properties of the SIAM and the associated Kondo scale can not be reproduced in both approximation schemes. For the core sizes L=1 and L=3 the ground state of the core is already a spin singlet state in the beginning of the flow and the Fermi liquid properties are reproduced. The Kondo energy scale, which determines the width of the central quasi-particle peak and the size of the local spin-susceptibility, is however not accurately resolved. This is partly due to the finite temperature used in our implementation such that for larger interaction strength the temperature is above the Kondo energy scale. The application of the hybridization flow method to quantum impurity problems in the context of the DMFT is discussed in chapter 6. In this approach lattice models with a local interaction, like the Hubbard model, are mapped to an effective impurity problem for a single lattice site embedded in a dynamical mean field representing the influence of the other electrons. This scheme is exact in infinitely many dimensions and a nonperturbative approximation method for finite-dimensional systems. In particular the Mott metal-insulator transition in the Hubbard model is successfully described by this method. One class of quantities, which is easily accessible from the hybridization flow scheme, is given by the local two-particle correlation functions. These play an essential role in non-local extensions of the DMFT. Therefore we mainly focus on these quantities. At first we apply our flow scheme to the Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice in infinite dimensions and calculate the local one-particle irreducible vertex functions in the insulating and the metallic phase in good agreement with previous calculations, which use the exact diagonalization method as impurity solver. After this we extend our flow scheme to a cluster DMFT method, which includes short-range antiferromagnetic correlations and calculate again the local and non-local vertex functions for the two-dimensional Hubbard model. We compare these to the results of the single-site DMFT.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

A local moment approach to the degenerate Anderson impurity model

Martin R. Galpin, Anne B Gilbert, David E. Logan

The local moment approach is extended to the orbitally degenerate (SU(2N)) Anderson impurity model (AIM). Single-particle dynamics are obtained over the full range of energy scales, focusing on particle-hole symmetry in the strongly-correlated regime where the onsite Coulomb interaction leads to many-body Kondo physics with entangled spin and orbital degrees of freedom. The approach captures many-body broadening of the Hubbard satellites and recovers the correct exponential vanishing of the Kondo scale for all N, and its universal scaling spectra are found to be in very good agreement with numerical renormalization group (NRG) results. In particular the high-frequency logarithmic decays of the scaling spectra, obtained here in closed form for arbitrary N, coincide essentially perfectly with available numerics from the NRG. A particular case of an anisotropic Coulomb interaction, in which the model represents a system of N 'capacitively coupled' SU(2) AIMs, is also discussed. Here the model is generally characterized by two low-energy scales, the crossover between which is seen directly in its dynamics.

arXiv:0908.2245•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Aug 13, 2009•13 citations

Many-body physics in small systems: Observing the onset and saturation of correlation in linear atomic chains

Emily Townsend, Tomáš Neuman, Alex Debrecht +2 more

The exact study of small systems can guide us toward relevant measures for extracting information about many-body physics as we move to larger and more complex systems capable of quantum information processing or quantum analog simulation. We use exact diagonalization to study many electrons in short 1-D atom chains represented by long-range extended Hubbard-like models. We introduce a novel measure, the Single-Particle Excitation Content (SPEC) of an eigenstate and show that the dependence of SPEC on eigenstate number reveals the nature of the ground state (ordered phases), and the onset and saturation of correlation between the electrons as Coulomb interaction strength increases. We use this SPEC behavior to identify five regimes as interaction is increased: a non-interacting single-particle regime, a regime of perturbative Coulomb interaction in which the SPEC is a nearly universal function of eigenstate number, the onset and saturation of correlation, a regime of fully correlated states in which hopping is a perturbation and SPEC is a different universal function of state number, and the regime of no hopping. In particular, the behavior of the SPEC shows that when electron-electron correlation plays a minor role, all of the lowest energy eigenstates are made up primarily of single-particle excitations of the ground state, and as the Coulomb interaction increases, the lowest energy eigenstates increasingly contain many-particle excitations. In addition, the SPEC highlights a fundamental, distinct difference between a non-interacting system and one with minute, very weak interactions. While SPEC is a quantity that can be calculated for small exactly diagonalizable systems, it guides our intuition for larger systems, suggesting the nature of excitations and their distribution in the spectrum. Thus, this function, like correlation functions or order parameters, provides us with a window of intuition about the behavior of a physical system.

arXiv:2011.07113•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 20, 2021•5 citations
The quenching of degenerate impurity states in metals generally induces a long-range correlated quantum state known as the Kondo screening cloud. While a macroscopic number of particles clearly take part in forming this extended structure, assessing the number of truly entangled degrees of freedom requires a careful analysis of the relevant many-body wave function. For this purpose, we examine the natural single-particle orbitals that are eigenstates of the single-particle density (correlation) matrix for the ground state of two quantum impurity problems: the interacting resonant level model (IRLM) and the single impurity Anderson model (SIAM). As a simple and general probe for few-body versus many-body character we consider the rate of exponential decay of the correlation matrix eigenvalues towards inactive (fully empty or filled) orbitals. We find that this rate remains large in the physically most relevant region of parameter space, implying a few-body character. Genuine many-body correlations emerge only when the Kondo temperature becomes exponentially small, for instance near a quantum critical point. In addition, we demonstrate that a simple numerical diagonalization of the few-body problem restricted to the Fock space of the most correlated orbitals converges exponentially fast with respect to the number of orbitals, to the true ground state of the IRLM. We also show that finite-size effects drastically affect the correlation spectrum, shedding light on an apparent paradox arising from previous studies on short chains.
We analyze the single-channel Kondo model using the recently developed unitary renormalization-group (URG) method and obtain a comprehensive understanding of the Kondo screening cloud. The fixed-point low-energy Hamiltonian enables the computation of a plethora of thermodynamic quantities (specific heat, susceptibility, Wilson ratio, etc.) as well as spectral functions, all of which are found to be in good agreement with known results. By integrating out the impurity, we obtain an effective Hamiltonian for the excitations of the electrons comprising the Kondo cloud. This is found to contain both kkk-space number diagonal (Fermi liquid) and off-diagonal four-fermion scattering terms. Our conclusions are reinforced by a URG study of the two-particle entanglement and many-body correlations among members of the Kondo cloud and impurity. The entanglement between the impurity and a cloud electron, as well as between any two cloud electrons, is found to increase under flow towards the singlet ground state at the strong-coupling fixed point. Both the number diagonal and off-diagonal correlations within the conduction cloud are also found to increase as the impurity is screened under the flow, and the latter are found to be responsible for the macroscopic entanglement of the Kondo-singlet ground state. The URG flow enables an analytic computation of the phase shifts suffered by the conduction electrons at the strong-coupling fixed point. This reveals an orthogonality catastrophe between the local-moment and strong-coupling ground states and is related to a change in the Luttinger volume of the conduction bath under the crossover to strong coupling. Our results offer fresh insight into the nature of the emergent many-particle entanglement within the Kondo cloud and pave the way for further investigations in more exotic contexts such as the fixed point of the overscreened multichannel Kondo problem.
Dynamical quantum impurities in metals induce electronic correlations in real space that are difficult to simulate due to their multiscale nature, so that only $s\text{\ensuremath{-}}\mathrm{wave}$ scattering in clean metallic hosts has been investigated so far. However, screening clouds should show anisotropy due to lack of full rotational invariance in two- and three-dimensional lattices, while inherent disorder will also induce spatial inhomogeneities. To tackle these challenges, we present an efficient and robust algorithm based on the recursive generation of natural orbitals defined as eigenvectors of the truncated single-particle density matrix. This method provides well-converged many-body wave functions on lattices with up to tens of thousands of sites, bypassing some limitations of other approaches. The algorithm is put to the test by investigating the charge screening cloud around an interacting resonant level, both on clean and disordered lattices, achieving accurate spatial resolution from short to long distances. We thus demonstrate strong anisotropy of spatial correlations around an adatom in the half-filled square lattice. Taking advantage of the efficiency of the algorithm, we further compute the disorder-induced distribution of Kondo temperatures over several thousands of random realizations, at the same time gaining access to the full spatial profile of the screening cloud in each sample. While the charge screening cloud is typically shortened due to the polarization of the impurity by the disorder potential, we surprisingly find that rare disorder configurations preserve the long-range nature of Kondo correlations in the electronic bath.
We disentangle all the individual degrees of freedom in the quantum impurity problem to deconstruct the Kondo singlet, both in real and energy space, by studying the contribution of each individual free electron eigenstate. This is a problem of two spins coupled to a bath, where the bath is formed by the remaining conduction electrons. Being a mixed state, we resort to the ``concurrence'' to quantify entanglement. We identify ``projected natural orbitals'' that allow us to individualize a single-particle electronic wave function that is responsible of more than 9090%90 of the impurity screening. In the weak coupling regime, the impurity is entangled to an electron at the Fermi level, while in the strong coupling regime, the impurity counterintuitively entangles mostly with the high energy electrons and disentangles completely from the low-energy states carving a ``hole'' around the Fermi level. This enables one to use concurrence as a pseudo order parameter to compute the characteristic ``size'' of the Kondo cloud, beyond which electrons are weakly correlated to the impurity and are dominated by the physics of the boundary.
An essential role for the description of correlated quantum many-particle systems is played by impurity problems. These consist of a small number of localized orbitals, where the electrons are subject to a Coulomb-interaction, coupled to noninteracting bath degrees of freedom. Impurity models are used for the description of magnetic impurities in metals, of quantum points in nanostructures, and in the context of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT). For their solution a large number of numerical methods exists. We mention here quantum Monte Carlo methods, the numerical renormalization group, or the exact diagonalization method. In this thesis we introduce a new approach to impurity problems, which is based on the functional renormalization group (fRG). In contrast to the methods mentioned above this approach is approximative, but it can be applied with comparatively lower numerical effort. The aim of this thesis is to examine the advantages and limits of this method. An important role in this connection is played by the single impurity Anderson model (SIAM), which is already understood very well with other methods and is seen as a prototype for models with strong local correlations. The spin fluctuations of this model are governed by the so-called Kondo energy scale and a central question of this thesis is whether this scale can be reproduced with our approach. We begin with a short introduction to the Green's function formalism for correlated quantum many particle systems. Then the fRG flow equations for the one-particle irreducible vertex functions are deduced, and several approximation schemes are discussed. In chapter 4 we introduce the fRG scheme used in this thesis. At first the SIAM is mapped to a semi-infinite chain, in which the interacting orbital is given by the first site of this chain. The system is then subdivided into two parts. The first part, which is called 'core', consists of the interacting orbital and the first L bath sites. The remaining bath sites form the second part. At the beginning both parts are decoupled from each other such that the core can be solved exactly. Starting with this exact solution the coupling between the core and the remaining bath sites is switched on slowly in a renormalization group flow. This way it is possible to calculate the one-particle and two-particle correlation functions on the correlated site. We call this flow scheme 'hybridization flow'. The flow equations are formulated in an effective theory on the first bath site outside the core, which turns out to be advantageous compared to other implementations of the hybridization flow. In chapter 5 this hybridization flow method is applied to the SIAM with semi-elliptic bath density of states. We discuss the differences which arise for different core-sizes (L = 0,1,2,3) and for different truncations of the fRG flow equations. In the cases L=0 and L=2 the local Fermi liquid properties of the SIAM and the associated Kondo scale can not be reproduced in both approximation schemes. For the core sizes L=1 and L=3 the ground state of the core is already a spin singlet state in the beginning of the flow and the Fermi liquid properties are reproduced. The Kondo energy scale, which determines the width of the central quasi-particle peak and the size of the local spin-susceptibility, is however not accurately resolved. This is partly due to the finite temperature used in our implementation such that for larger interaction strength the temperature is above the Kondo energy scale. The application of the hybridization flow method to quantum impurity problems in the context of the DMFT is discussed in chapter 6. In this approach lattice models with a local interaction, like the Hubbard model, are mapped to an effective impurity problem for a single lattice site embedded in a dynamical mean field representing the influence of the other electrons. This scheme is exact in infinitely many dimensions and a nonperturbative approximation method for finite-dimensional systems. In particular the Mott metal-insulator transition in the Hubbard model is successfully described by this method. One class of quantities, which is easily accessible from the hybridization flow scheme, is given by the local two-particle correlation functions. These play an essential role in non-local extensions of the DMFT. Therefore we mainly focus on these quantities. At first we apply our flow scheme to the Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice in infinite dimensions and calculate the local one-particle irreducible vertex functions in the insulating and the metallic phase in good agreement with previous calculations, which use the exact diagonalization method as impurity solver. After this we extend our flow scheme to a cluster DMFT method, which includes short-range antiferromagnetic correlations and calculate again the local and non-local vertex functions for the two-dimensional Hubbard model. We compare these to the results of the single-site DMFT.
The local moment approach is extended to the orbitally degenerate (SU(2N)) Anderson impurity model (AIM). Single-particle dynamics are obtained over the full range of energy scales, focusing on particle-hole symmetry in the strongly-correlated regime where the onsite Coulomb interaction leads to many-body Kondo physics with entangled spin and orbital degrees of freedom. The approach captures many-body broadening of the Hubbard satellites and recovers the correct exponential vanishing of the Kondo scale for all N, and its universal scaling spectra are found to be in very good agreement with numerical renormalization group (NRG) results. In particular the high-frequency logarithmic decays of the scaling spectra, obtained here in closed form for arbitrary N, coincide essentially perfectly with available numerics from the NRG. A particular case of an anisotropic Coulomb interaction, in which the model represents a system of N 'capacitively coupled' SU(2) AIMs, is also discussed. Here the model is generally characterized by two low-energy scales, the crossover between which is seen directly in its dynamics.
The exact study of small systems can guide us toward relevant measures for extracting information about many-body physics as we move to larger and more complex systems capable of quantum information processing or quantum analog simulation. We use exact diagonalization to study many electrons in short 1-D atom chains represented by long-range extended Hubbard-like models. We introduce a novel measure, the Single-Particle Excitation Content (SPEC) of an eigenstate and show that the dependence of SPEC on eigenstate number reveals the nature of the ground state (ordered phases), and the onset and saturation of correlation between the electrons as Coulomb interaction strength increases. We use this SPEC behavior to identify five regimes as interaction is increased: a non-interacting single-particle regime, a regime of perturbative Coulomb interaction in which the SPEC is a nearly universal function of eigenstate number, the onset and saturation of correlation, a regime of fully correlated states in which hopping is a perturbation and SPEC is a different universal function of state number, and the regime of no hopping. In particular, the behavior of the SPEC shows that when electron-electron correlation plays a minor role, all of the lowest energy eigenstates are made up primarily of single-particle excitations of the ground state, and as the Coulomb interaction increases, the lowest energy eigenstates increasingly contain many-particle excitations. In addition, the SPEC highlights a fundamental, distinct difference between a non-interacting system and one with minute, very weak interactions. While SPEC is a quantity that can be calculated for small exactly diagonalizable systems, it guides our intuition for larger systems, suggesting the nature of excitations and their distribution in the spectrum. Thus, this function, like correlation functions or order parameters, provides us with a window of intuition about the behavior of a physical system.