Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2011.10107 · Quantum

Multi-time correlations in the positive-P, Q, and doubled phase-space representations

Piotr Deuar

Published May 10, 2021• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A number of physically intuitive results for the calculation of multi-time correlations in phase-space representations of quantum mechanics are obtained. They relate time-dependent stochastic samples to multi-time observables, and rely on the presence of derivative-free operator identities. In particular, expressions for time-ordered normal-ordered observables in the positive-P distribution are derived which replace Heisenberg operators with the bare time-dependent stochastic variables, confirming extension of earlier such results for the Glauber-Sudarshan P. Analogous expressions are found for the anti-normal-ordered case of the doubled phase-space Q representation, along with conversion rules among doubled phase-space s-ordered representations. The latter are then shown to be readily exploited to further calculate anti-normal and mixed-ordered multi-time observables in the positive-P, Wigner, and doubled-Wigner representations. Which mixed-order observables are amenable and which are not is indicated, and explicit tallies are given up to 4th order. Overall, the theory of quantum multi-time observables in phase-space representations is extended, allowing non-perturbative treatment of many cases. The accuracy, usability, and scalability of the results to large systems is demonstrated using stochastic simulations of the unconventional photon blockade system and a related Bose-Hubbard chain. In addition, a robust but simple algorithm for integration of stochastic equations for phase-space samples is provided.

DOI
10.22331/q-2021-05-10-455

Related papers

Quantum-field-theoretical approach to phase-space techniques: Generalizing the positive-Prepresentation

Lev I. Plimak, Michael Fleischhauer, M. K. Olsen +1 more

We present an introduction to phase-space techniques (PST) based on a quantum-field-theoretical (QFT) approach. In addition to bridging the gap between PST and QFT, our approach results in a number of generalizations of the PST. First, for problems where the usual PST do not result in a genuine Fokker-Planck equation (even after phase-space doubling) and hence fail to produce a stochastic differential equation (SDE), we show how the system in question may be approximated via stochastic difference equations $(\mathrm{S}\ensuremath{\Delta}\mathrm{E}).$ Second, we show that introducing sources into the SDE's (or $\mathrm{S}\ensuremath{\Delta}\mathrm{E}\mathrm{'}\mathrm{s})$ generalizes them to a full quantum nonlinear stochastic response problem (thus generalizing Kubo's linear reaction theory to a quantum nonlinear stochastic response theory). Third, we establish general relations linking quantum response properties of the system in question to averages of operator products ordered in a way different from time normal. This extends PST to a much wider assemblage of operator products than are usually considered in phase-space approaches. In all cases, our approach yields a very simple and straightforward way of deriving stochastic equations in phase space.

Physical Review A•Jan 29, 2003•23 citations

Phase-space distributions

P. D. Drummond, Mark S. Hillery

In this chapter, we will develop methods for mapping operator equations to equivalent c-number equations. This results in a continuous phase-space representation of a many-body quantum system, using phase-space distributions instead of density matrices. In order to do this, we will first find c-number representations of operators. We have already seen one such representation, the Glauber–Sudarshan P -representation for the density matrix. We now introduce several more such representations. The main focus will be on the truncated Wigner representation, valid at large photon number, and the positive P -representation, which uses a double-dimensional phase space and exists as a positive probability for all quantum density matrices. Phase-space techniques have a great advantage over conventional matrix-type solutions to the Schrödinger equation, in that they do not have an exponential growth in complexity with mode and particle number. Instead, the equations that describe the dynamics of these c-number representations of the density matrix are Fokker–Planck equations. These have equivalent stochastic differential equations, which behave as c-number analogs of Heisenberg-picture equations of motion. This means that problems that would be essentially impossible to solve using conventional number-state representations can be transformed into readily soluble differential equations. In many cases, no additional approximations, such as perturbation theory or factorization assumptions, are needed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 27, 2014•1 citation

Stochastic wave-function approach to the calculation of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Bernd Kappler, Francesco Petruccione

Within the framework of probability distributions on projective Hilbert space, a scheme for the calculation of multitime correlation functions is developed. The starting point is the Markovian stochastic wave-function description of an open quantum system coupled to an environment consisting of an ensemble of harmonic oscillators in arbitrary pure or mixed states. It is shown that matrix elements of reduced Heisenberg picture operators and general time-ordered correlation functions can be expressed by time-symmetric expectation values of extended operators in a doubled Hilbert space. This representation allows the construction of a stochastic process in the doubled Hilbert space which enables a determination of arbitrary matrix elements and correlation functions. The numerical efficiency of the resulting stochastic simulation algorithm is investigated and compared with an alternative Monte Carlo wave function method proposed first by Dalibard, Castin, and M\o{}lmer [Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 580 (1992)]. By means of a standard example the suggested algorithm is shown to be more efficient numerically and to converge faster. Finally, some specific examples from quantum optics are presented in order to illustrate the proposed method, such as the coupling of a system to a vacuum, a squeezed vacuum within a finite solid angle, and a thermal mixture of coherent states.

arXiv:quant-ph/9807079•Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1997•33 citations

Phase Space Distributions

Bryan J. Dalton, John Jeffers, Stephen Mark Barnett

Abstract This chapter formally presents the representation of the quantum density operator by phase space distribution functions of phase space variables, leading to expressions for quantum correlation functions in terms of phase space integrals in which phase space variables for each mode—c-numbers for bosons, Grassmann numbers for fermions—replace mode annihilation and creation operators. The emphasis is on double-phase-space normally ordered (positive P type) normalised distribution functions, with distinct phase space variables for annihilation and creation operators; however, symmetrically ordered (Wigner type) distribution functions are also considered, along with unnormalised B distribution functions, which lead to phase space integrals for Fock state populations and coherences. Characteristic functions are first defined and then shown to be related to distribution functions via phase space integrals. The existence and symmetry properties of distribution functions—which are non-unique and non-analytic for bosons—is demonstrated using Bargmann coherent-state projectors.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 13, 2014•1 citation

Commuting Heisenberg operators as the quantum response problem: Time-normal averages in the truncated Wigner representation

B. Berg, Lev I. Plimak, Anatoli Polkovnikov +3 more

The applicability of the so-called truncated Wigner approximation $(\ensuremath{-}W)$ is extended to multitime averages of Heisenberg field operators. This task splits naturally in two. First, what class of multitime averages the $\ensuremath{-}W$ approximates and, second, how to proceed if the average in question does not belong to this class. To answer the first question, we develop a (in principle, exact) path-integral approach in phase space based on the symmetric (Weyl) ordering of creation and annihilation operators. These techniques calculate a new class of averages which we call time-symmetric. The $\ensuremath{-}W$ equations emerge as an approximation within these path-integral techniques. We then show that the answer to the second question is associated with response properties of the system. In fact, for two-time averages, Kubo's renowned formula relating the linear-response function to two-time commutators suffices. The $\ensuremath{-}W$ is directly generalized to the response properties of the system allowing one to calculate approximate time normally ordered two-time correlation functions with surprising ease. The techniques we develop are demonstrated for the Bose-Hubbard model.

arXiv:0905.3127•Physical Review A•Sep 29, 2009•44 citations

Quantum mechanics as a generalized stochastic theory in phase space

M. D. Srinivas

In this paper we formulate a new stochastic description of quantum mechanics in phase space. The theory of phase-space representations of quantum mechanics, initiated by Wigner, Groenewold, and Moyal and systematized recently by Agarwal and Wolf is essentially a single-time theory, in that it deals only with the quantum-mechanical joint distribution functions for position and momentum at a single instant of time. We develop a natural multitime extension of such a single-time theory. We consider a class of multitime phase-space distribution functions such that an arbitrary quantum multitime correlation function can be expressed as a phase-space average of the form encountered in classical stochastic theories. We study the nonclassical features of these multitime distribution functions and show that they may be considered as characterizing a generalized stochastic process in phase space. We demonstrate that the multitime distribution functions that correspond to Hamiltonian evolution of isolated quantum systems satisfy a certain condition that may be regarded as characterizing a generalized Markov process. We also investigate certain special features of the generalized stochastic processes that characterize the evolution of open systems.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1977•6 citations
A number of physically intuitive results for the calculation of multi-time correlations in phase-space representations of quantum mechanics are obtained. They relate time-dependent stochastic samples to multi-time observables, and rely on the presence of derivative-free operator identities. In particular, expressions for time-ordered normal-ordered observables in the positive-P distribution are derived which replace Heisenberg operators with the bare time-dependent stochastic variables, confirming extension of earlier such results for the Glauber-Sudarshan P. Analogous expressions are found for the anti-normal-ordered case of the doubled phase-space Q representation, along with conversion rules among doubled phase-space s-ordered representations. The latter are then shown to be readily exploited to further calculate anti-normal and mixed-ordered multi-time observables in the positive-P, Wigner, and doubled-Wigner representations. Which mixed-order observables are amenable and which are not is indicated, and explicit tallies are given up to 4th order. Overall, the theory of quantum multi-time observables in phase-space representations is extended, allowing non-perturbative treatment of many cases. The accuracy, usability, and scalability of the results to large systems is demonstrated using stochastic simulations of the unconventional photon blockade system and a related Bose-Hubbard chain. In addition, a robust but simple algorithm for integration of stochastic equations for phase-space samples is provided.
We present an introduction to phase-space techniques (PST) based on a quantum-field-theoretical (QFT) approach. In addition to bridging the gap between PST and QFT, our approach results in a number of generalizations of the PST. First, for problems where the usual PST do not result in a genuine Fokker-Planck equation (even after phase-space doubling) and hence fail to produce a stochastic differential equation (SDE), we show how the system in question may be approximated via stochastic difference equations $(\mathrm{S}\ensuremath{\Delta}\mathrm{E}).$ Second, we show that introducing sources into the SDE's (or $\mathrm{S}\ensuremath{\Delta}\mathrm{E}\mathrm{'}\mathrm{s})$ generalizes them to a full quantum nonlinear stochastic response problem (thus generalizing Kubo's linear reaction theory to a quantum nonlinear stochastic response theory). Third, we establish general relations linking quantum response properties of the system in question to averages of operator products ordered in a way different from time normal. This extends PST to a much wider assemblage of operator products than are usually considered in phase-space approaches. In all cases, our approach yields a very simple and straightforward way of deriving stochastic equations in phase space.
In this chapter, we will develop methods for mapping operator equations to equivalent c-number equations. This results in a continuous phase-space representation of a many-body quantum system, using phase-space distributions instead of density matrices. In order to do this, we will first find c-number representations of operators. We have already seen one such representation, the Glauber–Sudarshan P -representation for the density matrix. We now introduce several more such representations. The main focus will be on the truncated Wigner representation, valid at large photon number, and the positive P -representation, which uses a double-dimensional phase space and exists as a positive probability for all quantum density matrices. Phase-space techniques have a great advantage over conventional matrix-type solutions to the Schrödinger equation, in that they do not have an exponential growth in complexity with mode and particle number. Instead, the equations that describe the dynamics of these c-number representations of the density matrix are Fokker–Planck equations. These have equivalent stochastic differential equations, which behave as c-number analogs of Heisenberg-picture equations of motion. This means that problems that would be essentially impossible to solve using conventional number-state representations can be transformed into readily soluble differential equations. In many cases, no additional approximations, such as perturbation theory or factorization assumptions, are needed.
Within the framework of probability distributions on projective Hilbert space, a scheme for the calculation of multitime correlation functions is developed. The starting point is the Markovian stochastic wave-function description of an open quantum system coupled to an environment consisting of an ensemble of harmonic oscillators in arbitrary pure or mixed states. It is shown that matrix elements of reduced Heisenberg picture operators and general time-ordered correlation functions can be expressed by time-symmetric expectation values of extended operators in a doubled Hilbert space. This representation allows the construction of a stochastic process in the doubled Hilbert space which enables a determination of arbitrary matrix elements and correlation functions. The numerical efficiency of the resulting stochastic simulation algorithm is investigated and compared with an alternative Monte Carlo wave function method proposed first by Dalibard, Castin, and M\o{}lmer [Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 580 (1992)]. By means of a standard example the suggested algorithm is shown to be more efficient numerically and to converge faster. Finally, some specific examples from quantum optics are presented in order to illustrate the proposed method, such as the coupling of a system to a vacuum, a squeezed vacuum within a finite solid angle, and a thermal mixture of coherent states.
Abstract This chapter formally presents the representation of the quantum density operator by phase space distribution functions of phase space variables, leading to expressions for quantum correlation functions in terms of phase space integrals in which phase space variables for each mode—c-numbers for bosons, Grassmann numbers for fermions—replace mode annihilation and creation operators. The emphasis is on double-phase-space normally ordered (positive P type) normalised distribution functions, with distinct phase space variables for annihilation and creation operators; however, symmetrically ordered (Wigner type) distribution functions are also considered, along with unnormalised B distribution functions, which lead to phase space integrals for Fock state populations and coherences. Characteristic functions are first defined and then shown to be related to distribution functions via phase space integrals. The existence and symmetry properties of distribution functions—which are non-unique and non-analytic for bosons—is demonstrated using Bargmann coherent-state projectors.
The applicability of the so-called truncated Wigner approximation $(\ensuremath{-}W)$ is extended to multitime averages of Heisenberg field operators. This task splits naturally in two. First, what class of multitime averages the $\ensuremath{-}W$ approximates and, second, how to proceed if the average in question does not belong to this class. To answer the first question, we develop a (in principle, exact) path-integral approach in phase space based on the symmetric (Weyl) ordering of creation and annihilation operators. These techniques calculate a new class of averages which we call time-symmetric. The $\ensuremath{-}W$ equations emerge as an approximation within these path-integral techniques. We then show that the answer to the second question is associated with response properties of the system. In fact, for two-time averages, Kubo's renowned formula relating the linear-response function to two-time commutators suffices. The $\ensuremath{-}W$ is directly generalized to the response properties of the system allowing one to calculate approximate time normally ordered two-time correlation functions with surprising ease. The techniques we develop are demonstrated for the Bose-Hubbard model.
In this paper we formulate a new stochastic description of quantum mechanics in phase space. The theory of phase-space representations of quantum mechanics, initiated by Wigner, Groenewold, and Moyal and systematized recently by Agarwal and Wolf is essentially a single-time theory, in that it deals only with the quantum-mechanical joint distribution functions for position and momentum at a single instant of time. We develop a natural multitime extension of such a single-time theory. We consider a class of multitime phase-space distribution functions such that an arbitrary quantum multitime correlation function can be expressed as a phase-space average of the form encountered in classical stochastic theories. We study the nonclassical features of these multitime distribution functions and show that they may be considered as characterizing a generalized stochastic process in phase space. We demonstrate that the multitime distribution functions that correspond to Hamiltonian evolution of isolated quantum systems satisfy a certain condition that may be regarded as characterizing a generalized Markov process. We also investigate certain special features of the generalized stochastic processes that characterize the evolution of open systems.