Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2010.08699 · Fundamental Research

Bosonic quantum error correction codes in superconducting quantum circuits

Weizhou Cai, Yuwei Ma, Weiting Wang, Chang-Ling Zou, Luyan Sun

Published Jan 1, 2021• 251 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum information is vulnerable to environmental noise and experimental imperfections, hindering the reliability of practical quantum information processors. Therefore, quantum error correction (QEC) that can protect quantum information against noise is vital for universal and scalable quantum computation. Among many different experimental platforms, superconducting quantum circuits and bosonic encodings in superconducting microwave modes are appealing for their unprecedented potential in QEC. During the last few years, bosonic QEC is demonstrated to reach the break-even point, i.e. the lifetime of a logical qubit is enhanced to exceed that of any individual components composing the experimental system. Beyond that, universal gate sets and fault-tolerant operations on the bosonic codes are also realized, pushing quantum information processing towards the QEC era. In this article, we review the recent progress of the bosonic codes, including the Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill codes, cat codes, and binomial codes, and discuss the opportunities of bosonic codes in various quantum applications, ranging from fault-tolerant quantum computation to quantum metrology. We also summarize the challenges associated with the bosonic codes and provide an outlook for the potential research directions in the long terms.

DOI
10.1016/j.fmre.2020.12.006

Related papers

Advances in Quantum Error Correction: From Theory to Experimental Realization

Shilpi Verma, Markandey Singh

Quantum error correction (QEC) has emerged as a cornerstone in the quest for scalable and fault-tolerant quantum technologies. While quantum systems promise exponential advantages over classical computation, their extreme susceptibility to noise and decoherence presents a formidable challenge. This review critically examines the trajectory of QEC from its theoretical foundations to recent experimental realizations. Foundational codes, including Shor’s and Steane’s constructions, laid the groundwork for the stabilizer formalism and the development of topological and bosonic codes. Over the past decade, experimental demonstrations have validated these concepts, with logical qubits surpassing the lifetimes of physical qubits on platforms such as superconducting circuits, trapped ions, and photonics. Emerging approaches, including low-density parity-check codes, hybrid mitigation–correction strategies, and artificial intelligence–driven decoders, further illustrate the field’s dynamism. By synthesizing theoretical progress, empirical validation, and cross-platform innovations, this review highlights both achievements and persistent challenges particularly the overhead of physical qubits, the speed of real-time decoding, and integration into full-stack architectures. The analysis concludes that while scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing remains a work in progress, recent breakthroughs mark a decisive transition from abstraction to practicality, establishing QEC as a central pillar in the development of quantum computation, communication, and sensing.

•Sep 29, 2025•0 citations

Quantum error correction with bosonic encoding

Heng Fan

Recently, the achievement, entitled “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction”, has been selected as one of “The Ten Major Advances in Chinese Science 2023”. Here, we will introduce briefly the importance of this work. It is known that quantum states are fragile due to decoherence induced by environment. Error will happen on a qubit, resulting in continuously changes of the parameters for this qubit, such as amplitude and phase parameters. The aim of quantum error correction is to amend those errors by using various quantum error correction codes, in which a logic qubit can be represented by several physical qubits. It should be noted that the quantum error correction can be realized by correcting a discrete set of errors, such as bit-flip error, phase-flip error or both of them. On the other hand, types of errors occurred depend on specific platforms of quantum computation. For example, photon loss is more inclined to occur in photonic systems. In this case, the approach of bosonic encoding of quantum error correction is more efficient. The work “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction” is for such a scenario. The challenge of quantum error correction is that operation itself is not perfect which may incur new errors. So it is actually difficult to demonstrate that we can benefit from quantum error correction. The achievement of lifetime enhancement by bosonic encoding error correction succeeds in beating this break-even point. The experiments are performed by circuit quantum electrodynamics on a superconducting processor with a qubit and a coupled resonate cavity. The logic qubit is realized by the bosonic mode of the cavity, while the superconducting qubit plays the role of the ancillary qubit in error correction. The initial states are prepared by the superconducting qubit, and are transferred to the logic qubit in the cavity. Then the error correction can be performed based on detection of photon loss by the superconducting qubit. The results show that the lifetime of the logic qubit increases from 694 μs to 805 μs with 16% enhancement. Besides high quality devices, the success of this experiment depends on the feedback control to detect and correct the error of photon loss in a short time. The result of beating the break-even point of bosonic encoding error correction is for one logic qubit. In the near future, it is hopeful to implement logic gates, such as single-qubit rotation gate and two-qubit gate, on a couple of logic qubits by bosonic encoding. The importance of the results will depend on whether higher fidelity can be achieved compared with those of gates with physical qubits. In this way, the advantage of the logic qubits for quantum computation is presented. It will be significant that the approach of bosonic encoding with a superconducting processor is scalable to hundreds of logic qubits, which may take a few years to realize. Our aim is to realize a fault-tolerant universal quantum computer based on a large quantity of high-precision logic qubits. The work “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction” is an important step toward this aim.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Jul 22, 2024•0 citations

Hardware-Efficient Fault Tolerant Quantum Computing with Bosonic Grid States in Superconducting Circuits

Marc-Antoine Lemonde, Dany Lachance-Quirion, Guillaume Duclos-Cianci +5 more

Quantum computing holds the promise of solving classically intractable problems. Enabling this requires scalable and hardware-efficient quantum processors with vanishing error rates. This perspective manuscript describes how bosonic codes, particularly grid state encodings, offer a pathway to scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing in superconducting circuits. By leveraging the large Hilbert space of bosonic modes, quantum error correction can operate at the single physical unit level, therefore reducing drastically the hardware requirements to bring fault-tolerant quantum computing to scale. Going beyond the well-known Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill (GKP) code, we discuss how using multiple bosonic modes to encode a single qubit offers increased protection against control errors and enhances its overall error-correcting capabilities. Given recent successful demonstrations of critical components of this architecture, we argue that it offers the shortest path to achieving fault tolerance in gate-based quantum computing processors with a MHz logical clock rate.

arXiv:2409.05813•Sep 9, 2024•13 citations

Recent Advances in Quantum Error Correction Codes for Superconducting Quantum Computing

Zi Wang, Guohua Gao, 武光明

Superconducting quantum computing has become one of the leading technological routes toward practical quantum computing due to its relatively long coherence times and compatibility with scalable integration. However, the high error rates of physical qubits create a scaling paradox that limits further system expansion, making quantum error correction (QEC) a core enabler of fault-tolerant quantum computing. This paper briefly introduces superconducting quantum noise models, stabilizer-code principles, and representative research achievements from 2022 to 2023 as necessary theoretical background and benchmarking references, while mainly focusing on the latest research advances in quantum error correction codes in the field of superconducting quantum computing from 2024 to 2026. It elaborates on the foundational principles of superconducting quantum noise models and stabilizer codes, with a focus on analyzing the architectures and mechanisms of surface codes, color codes, high-rate qLDPC codes, and bosonic codes. This work also summarizes recent milestone achievements, including the first exponential suppression of logical errors achieved by surface codes, the significant reduction of hardware redundancy enabled by high-rate codes, and the break-even point crossed by bosonic codes. Through multidimensional comparisons, it is shown that achieving fault tolerance at the million-qubit scale will require deep synergistic optimization of hardware, codes, and decoders. On this basis, pathways and guidance are provided for building low-overhead, high-efficiency universal quantum computers.

International Symposium on Computer Technology and Information Science (ISCTIS)•May 15, 2026•0 citations

Error-detectable Universal Control for High-Gain Bosonic Quantum Error Correction

Weizhou Cai, Zi-Jie Chen, Ming Li +5 more

Protecting quantum information through quantum error correction (QEC) is a cornerstone of future fault-tolerant quantum computation. However, current QEC-protected logical qubits have only achieved coherence times about twice those of their best physical constituents. Here, we show that the primary barrier to higher QEC gains is ancilla-induced operational errors rather than intrinsic cavity coherence. To overcome this bottleneck, we introduce error-detectable universal control of bosonic modes, wherein ancilla relaxation events are detected and the corresponding trajectories discarded, thereby suppressing operational errors on logical qubits. For binomial codes, we demonstrate universal gates with fidelities exceeding $99.6\%$ and QEC gains of $8.33\times$ beyond break-even. Our results establish that gains beyond $10\times$ are achievable with state-of-the-art devices, establishing a path toward fault-tolerant bosonic quantum computing.

quant-pharXiv:2601.21838•Jan 30, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Error Correction and Fault-Tolerant Computing: Recent Progress in Codes, Decoders, and Architectures

Volkan Erol

Quantum error correction (QEC) represents the cornerstone technology for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing, addressing the fundamental challenge of quantum state decoherence in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. This comprehensive review examines recent advances in QEC implementations from 2020-2024, spanning theoretical foundations to practical hardware demonstrations. We analyze the evolution from pioneering stabilizer codes to modern topological approaches, with particular emphasis on surface codes and low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes that have demonstrated below-threshold error correction in superconducting and trapped-ion systems. The paper provides a comparative analysis of classical and machine learning-based decoder algorithms, evaluating their performance through complexity analysis and threshold comparisons in real-time error correction scenarios. Through examination of breakthrough experiments by Google, IBM, Quantinuum, and emerging platforms, we assess the current state of fault-tolerant quantum computing and identify critical engineering challenges including correlated noise models, cryogenic control systems, and scalable logical gate implementations. Our quantitative analysis reveals that while significant progress has been made toward practical fault-tolerance thresholds, achieving the resource efficiency and reliability required for large-scale quantum computation remains challenging. We provide detailed resource estimates for key applications including Shor's algorithm and optimization problems, along with analysis of industry roadmaps toward thousand-logical-qubit systems. This review serves as a comprehensive guide for researchers and engineers working toward the next generation of fault-tolerant quantum computers, with particular focus on information-theoretic perspectives relevant to quantum information entropy and syndrome processing.

•Sep 30, 2025•3 citations
Quantum information is vulnerable to environmental noise and experimental imperfections, hindering the reliability of practical quantum information processors. Therefore, quantum error correction (QEC) that can protect quantum information against noise is vital for universal and scalable quantum computation. Among many different experimental platforms, superconducting quantum circuits and bosonic encodings in superconducting microwave modes are appealing for their unprecedented potential in QEC. During the last few years, bosonic QEC is demonstrated to reach the break-even point, i.e. the lifetime of a logical qubit is enhanced to exceed that of any individual components composing the experimental system. Beyond that, universal gate sets and fault-tolerant operations on the bosonic codes are also realized, pushing quantum information processing towards the QEC era. In this article, we review the recent progress of the bosonic codes, including the Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill codes, cat codes, and binomial codes, and discuss the opportunities of bosonic codes in various quantum applications, ranging from fault-tolerant quantum computation to quantum metrology. We also summarize the challenges associated with the bosonic codes and provide an outlook for the potential research directions in the long terms.
Quantum error correction (QEC) has emerged as a cornerstone in the quest for scalable and fault-tolerant quantum technologies. While quantum systems promise exponential advantages over classical computation, their extreme susceptibility to noise and decoherence presents a formidable challenge. This review critically examines the trajectory of QEC from its theoretical foundations to recent experimental realizations. Foundational codes, including Shor’s and Steane’s constructions, laid the groundwork for the stabilizer formalism and the development of topological and bosonic codes. Over the past decade, experimental demonstrations have validated these concepts, with logical qubits surpassing the lifetimes of physical qubits on platforms such as superconducting circuits, trapped ions, and photonics. Emerging approaches, including low-density parity-check codes, hybrid mitigation–correction strategies, and artificial intelligence–driven decoders, further illustrate the field’s dynamism. By synthesizing theoretical progress, empirical validation, and cross-platform innovations, this review highlights both achievements and persistent challenges particularly the overhead of physical qubits, the speed of real-time decoding, and integration into full-stack architectures. The analysis concludes that while scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing remains a work in progress, recent breakthroughs mark a decisive transition from abstraction to practicality, establishing QEC as a central pillar in the development of quantum computation, communication, and sensing.
Recently, the achievement, entitled “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction”, has been selected as one of “The Ten Major Advances in Chinese Science 2023”. Here, we will introduce briefly the importance of this work. It is known that quantum states are fragile due to decoherence induced by environment. Error will happen on a qubit, resulting in continuously changes of the parameters for this qubit, such as amplitude and phase parameters. The aim of quantum error correction is to amend those errors by using various quantum error correction codes, in which a logic qubit can be represented by several physical qubits. It should be noted that the quantum error correction can be realized by correcting a discrete set of errors, such as bit-flip error, phase-flip error or both of them. On the other hand, types of errors occurred depend on specific platforms of quantum computation. For example, photon loss is more inclined to occur in photonic systems. In this case, the approach of bosonic encoding of quantum error correction is more efficient. The work “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction” is for such a scenario. The challenge of quantum error correction is that operation itself is not perfect which may incur new errors. So it is actually difficult to demonstrate that we can benefit from quantum error correction. The achievement of lifetime enhancement by bosonic encoding error correction succeeds in beating this break-even point. The experiments are performed by circuit quantum electrodynamics on a superconducting processor with a qubit and a coupled resonate cavity. The logic qubit is realized by the bosonic mode of the cavity, while the superconducting qubit plays the role of the ancillary qubit in error correction. The initial states are prepared by the superconducting qubit, and are transferred to the logic qubit in the cavity. Then the error correction can be performed based on detection of photon loss by the superconducting qubit. The results show that the lifetime of the logic qubit increases from 694 μs to 805 μs with 16% enhancement. Besides high quality devices, the success of this experiment depends on the feedback control to detect and correct the error of photon loss in a short time. The result of beating the break-even point of bosonic encoding error correction is for one logic qubit. In the near future, it is hopeful to implement logic gates, such as single-qubit rotation gate and two-qubit gate, on a couple of logic qubits by bosonic encoding. The importance of the results will depend on whether higher fidelity can be achieved compared with those of gates with physical qubits. In this way, the advantage of the logic qubits for quantum computation is presented. It will be significant that the approach of bosonic encoding with a superconducting processor is scalable to hundreds of logic qubits, which may take a few years to realize. Our aim is to realize a fault-tolerant universal quantum computer based on a large quantity of high-precision logic qubits. The work “lifetime enhancement for a logic qubit by bosonic encoding error correction” is an important step toward this aim.
Quantum computing holds the promise of solving classically intractable problems. Enabling this requires scalable and hardware-efficient quantum processors with vanishing error rates. This perspective manuscript describes how bosonic codes, particularly grid state encodings, offer a pathway to scalable fault-tolerant quantum computing in superconducting circuits. By leveraging the large Hilbert space of bosonic modes, quantum error correction can operate at the single physical unit level, therefore reducing drastically the hardware requirements to bring fault-tolerant quantum computing to scale. Going beyond the well-known Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill (GKP) code, we discuss how using multiple bosonic modes to encode a single qubit offers increased protection against control errors and enhances its overall error-correcting capabilities. Given recent successful demonstrations of critical components of this architecture, we argue that it offers the shortest path to achieving fault tolerance in gate-based quantum computing processors with a MHz logical clock rate.
Superconducting quantum computing has become one of the leading technological routes toward practical quantum computing due to its relatively long coherence times and compatibility with scalable integration. However, the high error rates of physical qubits create a scaling paradox that limits further system expansion, making quantum error correction (QEC) a core enabler of fault-tolerant quantum computing. This paper briefly introduces superconducting quantum noise models, stabilizer-code principles, and representative research achievements from 2022 to 2023 as necessary theoretical background and benchmarking references, while mainly focusing on the latest research advances in quantum error correction codes in the field of superconducting quantum computing from 2024 to 2026. It elaborates on the foundational principles of superconducting quantum noise models and stabilizer codes, with a focus on analyzing the architectures and mechanisms of surface codes, color codes, high-rate qLDPC codes, and bosonic codes. This work also summarizes recent milestone achievements, including the first exponential suppression of logical errors achieved by surface codes, the significant reduction of hardware redundancy enabled by high-rate codes, and the break-even point crossed by bosonic codes. Through multidimensional comparisons, it is shown that achieving fault tolerance at the million-qubit scale will require deep synergistic optimization of hardware, codes, and decoders. On this basis, pathways and guidance are provided for building low-overhead, high-efficiency universal quantum computers.
Protecting quantum information through quantum error correction (QEC) is a cornerstone of future fault-tolerant quantum computation. However, current QEC-protected logical qubits have only achieved coherence times about twice those of their best physical constituents. Here, we show that the primary barrier to higher QEC gains is ancilla-induced operational errors rather than intrinsic cavity coherence. To overcome this bottleneck, we introduce error-detectable universal control of bosonic modes, wherein ancilla relaxation events are detected and the corresponding trajectories discarded, thereby suppressing operational errors on logical qubits. For binomial codes, we demonstrate universal gates with fidelities exceeding 99.6%99.6\%99.6% and QEC gains of 8.33×8.33\times8.33× beyond break-even. Our results establish that gains beyond 10×10\times10× are achievable with state-of-the-art devices, establishing a path toward fault-tolerant bosonic quantum computing.
Quantum error correction (QEC) represents the cornerstone technology for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing, addressing the fundamental challenge of quantum state decoherence in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. This comprehensive review examines recent advances in QEC implementations from 2020-2024, spanning theoretical foundations to practical hardware demonstrations. We analyze the evolution from pioneering stabilizer codes to modern topological approaches, with particular emphasis on surface codes and low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes that have demonstrated below-threshold error correction in superconducting and trapped-ion systems. The paper provides a comparative analysis of classical and machine learning-based decoder algorithms, evaluating their performance through complexity analysis and threshold comparisons in real-time error correction scenarios. Through examination of breakthrough experiments by Google, IBM, Quantinuum, and emerging platforms, we assess the current state of fault-tolerant quantum computing and identify critical engineering challenges including correlated noise models, cryogenic control systems, and scalable logical gate implementations. Our quantitative analysis reveals that while significant progress has been made toward practical fault-tolerance thresholds, achieving the resource efficiency and reliability required for large-scale quantum computation remains challenging. We provide detailed resource estimates for key applications including Shor's algorithm and optimization problems, along with analysis of industry roadmaps toward thousand-logical-qubit systems. This review serves as a comprehensive guide for researchers and engineers working toward the next generation of fault-tolerant quantum computers, with particular focus on information-theoretic perspectives relevant to quantum information entropy and syndrome processing.