Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2010.04572 · Physical Review Letters

Nevanlinna Analytical Continuation

Jiani Fei, Chia-Nan Yeh, Emanuel Gull

Published Feb 4, 2021• 125 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Simulations of finite temperature quantum systems provide imaginary frequency Green's functions that correspond one to one to experimentally measurable real-frequency spectral functions. However, due to the bad conditioning of the continuation transform from imaginary to real frequencies, established methods tend to either wash out spectral features at high frequencies or produce spectral functions with unphysical negative parts. Here, we show that explicitly respecting the analytic "Nevanlinna" structure of the Green's function leads to intrinsically positive and normalized spectral functions, and we present a continued fraction expansion that yields all possible functions consistent with the analytic structure. Application to synthetic trial data shows that sharp, smooth, and multipeak data is resolved accurately. Application to the band structure of silicon demonstrates that high energy features are resolved precisely. Continuations in a realistic correlated setup reveal additional features that were previously unresolved. By substantially increasing the resolution of real frequency calculations our work overcomes one of the main limitations of finite-temperature quantum simulations.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.126.056402

Related papers

Extracting spectral properties from Keldysh Green functions

Andreas Dirks, Martin Eckstein, Thomas Pruschke +1 more

We investigate the possibility to assist the numerically ill-posed calculation of spectral properties of interacting quantum systems in thermal equilibrium by extending the imaginary-time simulation to a finite Schwinger-Keldysh contour. The effect of this extension is tested within the standard maximum entropy approach to analytic continuation. We find that the inclusion of real-time data improves the resolution of structures at high energy, while the imaginary-time data are needed to correctly reproduce low-frequency features such as quasiparticle peaks. As a nonequilibrium application, we consider the calculation of time-dependent spectral functions from retarded Green function data on a finite time interval, and compare the maximum entropy approach to direct Fourier transformation and a method based on Padé approximants.

arXiv:1210.7867•Physical Review E•Feb 21, 2013•12 citations

Stochastic pole expansion method for analytic continuation of the Green's function

Li Huang, Shuang Liang

In this paper, we propose an analytic continuation method to extract real-frequency spectral functions from imaginary-frequency Green's functions of quantum many-body systems. This method is based on the pole representation of Matsubara Green's function and a stochastic sampling procedure is utilized to optimize the amplitudes and locations of poles. In order to capture narrow peaks and sharp band edges in the spectral functions, a constrained sampling algorithm and a self-adaptive sampling algorithm are developed. To demonstrate the usefulness and performance of this method, we at first apply it to study the spectral functions of representative fermionic and bosonic correlators. Then we employ this method to tackle the analytic continuation problems of matrix-valued Green's functions. The synthetic Green's functions, as well as realistic correlation functions from finite-temperature quantum many-body calculations, are used as input. The benchmark results demonstrate that this method is capable of reproducing most of the key characteristics in the spectral functions. The sharp, smooth, and multipeak features in both low- and high-frequency regions of spectral functions could be accurately resolved, which overcomes one of the main limitations of the traditional maximum entropy method. More importantly, it exhibits excellent robustness with respect to noisy and incomplete input data. The causality of spectral function is always satisfied even in the presence of sizable noises. As a by-product, this method could derive a fitting formula for the Matsubara data, which provides a compact approximation to the many-body Green's functions. Hence, we expect that this method could become a pivotal workhorse for numerically analytic continuation and be broadly useful in many applications.

arXiv:2307.11324•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 13, 2023•11 citations

Bosonic Nevanlinna Analytic Continuation

Kosuke Nogaki, Hiroshi Shinaoka

Analytical continuation (AC) connects theoretical calculations and experimentally measurable quantities. The recently proposed Nevanlinna AC method is capable of accurately reproducing the sharp features of spectral functions at high frequencies while maintaining the causality of the response function. However, their use is currently limited to fermions. Here, we present an extension of this method to bosons using the hyperbolic tangent trick, allowing us to transform bosons into auxiliary fermions to which the Nevanlinna analytic continuation can be applied.

arXiv:2305.03449•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Feb 17, 2023•22 citations

Padé approximant approach for obtaining finite-temperature spectral functions of quantum impurity models using the numerical renormalization group technique

Žiga Osolin, Rok Žitko

We introduce an alternative approach for obtaining smooth finite-temperature spectral functions of quantum impurity models using the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique. It is based on calculating first the Green's function on the imaginary-frequency axis, followed by an analytic continuation to the real-frequency axis using Pad\'e approximants. The arbitrariness in choosing a suitable kernel in the conventional broadening approach is thereby removed and, furthermore, we find that the Pad\'e method is able to resolve fine details in spectral functions with less artifacts on the scale of $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}T$. We discuss the convergence properties with respect to the NRG calculation parameters (discretization $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$, $z$-averaging, truncation cutoff) and the number of Matsubara points taken into account in the analytic continuation. We test the technique on the single-impurity Anderson model and the Hubbard model (within the dynamical mean-field theory). For the Anderson impurity model, we discuss the shape of the Kondo resonance and its temperature dependence. For the Hubbard model, we discuss the inner structure of the Hubbard bands in metallic and insulating solutions at half-filling, as well as in the doped Mott insulator. Based on these test cases, we conclude that the Pad\'e approximant approach provides improved results for spectral functions at low-frequency scales of $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\lesssim}T$ and that it is capable of resolving sharp spectral features also at high frequencies.

arXiv:1302.3334•Physical Review B•Jun 28, 2013•38 citations

Analytic continuation

James E. Gubernatis, Naoki Kawashima, Philipp Werner

The presence of dynamical information is a feature distinguishing a finite-temperature quantum Monte Carlo simulation from a classical one. We now discuss numerical methods for extracting this information that use techniques and concepts borrowed from an area of probability theory called Bayesian statistical inference. The use of these techniques and concepts provided a solution to the very difficult problem of analytically continuing imaginary-time Green's functions, estimated by a quantum Monte Carlo simulation, to the real-time axis. Baym and Mermin (1961) proved that a unique mapping between these functions exists. However, executing this mapping numerically, with a simulation's incomplete and noisy data, transforms the problem into one without a unique solution and thus into a problem of finding a “best” solution according to some reasonable criterion. Instead of executing the analytic continuation between imaginary- and real-time Green's functions, thereby obtaining real-time dynamics, we instead estimate the experimentally relevant spectral density function these Green's functions share. We present three “best” solutions and emphasize that making the simulation data consistent with the assumptions of the numerical approach is a key step toward finding any of these best solutions.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 31, 2016•0 citations

Robust analytic continuation of Green's functions via projection, pole estimation, and semidefinite relaxation

Zhen Huang, Emanuel Gull, Lin Lin

Green's functions of fermions are described by matrix-valued Herglotz-Nevanlinna functions. Since analytic continuation is fundamentally an ill-posed problem, the causal space described by the matrix-valued Herglotz-Nevanlinna structure can be instrumental in improving the accuracy and in enhancing the robustness with respect to noise. We demonstrate a three-pronged procedure for robust analytic continuation called PES: (1) projection of data to the causal space; (2) estimation of pole locations; and (3) semidefinite relaxation within the causal space. We compare the performance of PES with the recently developed Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory continuation methods and find that PES is more robust in the presence of noise and does not require the usage of extended precision arithmetics. We also demonstrate that a causal projection improves the performance of the Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory methods. The PES method is generalized to bosonic response functions, for which the Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory continuation methods have not yet been developed. It is particularly useful for studying spectra with sharp features, as they occur in the study of molecules and band structures in solids.

arXiv:2210.04187•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 23, 2023•47 citations
Simulations of finite temperature quantum systems provide imaginary frequency Green's functions that correspond one to one to experimentally measurable real-frequency spectral functions. However, due to the bad conditioning of the continuation transform from imaginary to real frequencies, established methods tend to either wash out spectral features at high frequencies or produce spectral functions with unphysical negative parts. Here, we show that explicitly respecting the analytic "Nevanlinna" structure of the Green's function leads to intrinsically positive and normalized spectral functions, and we present a continued fraction expansion that yields all possible functions consistent with the analytic structure. Application to synthetic trial data shows that sharp, smooth, and multipeak data is resolved accurately. Application to the band structure of silicon demonstrates that high energy features are resolved precisely. Continuations in a realistic correlated setup reveal additional features that were previously unresolved. By substantially increasing the resolution of real frequency calculations our work overcomes one of the main limitations of finite-temperature quantum simulations.
We investigate the possibility to assist the numerically ill-posed calculation of spectral properties of interacting quantum systems in thermal equilibrium by extending the imaginary-time simulation to a finite Schwinger-Keldysh contour. The effect of this extension is tested within the standard maximum entropy approach to analytic continuation. We find that the inclusion of real-time data improves the resolution of structures at high energy, while the imaginary-time data are needed to correctly reproduce low-frequency features such as quasiparticle peaks. As a nonequilibrium application, we consider the calculation of time-dependent spectral functions from retarded Green function data on a finite time interval, and compare the maximum entropy approach to direct Fourier transformation and a method based on Padé approximants.
In this paper, we propose an analytic continuation method to extract real-frequency spectral functions from imaginary-frequency Green's functions of quantum many-body systems. This method is based on the pole representation of Matsubara Green's function and a stochastic sampling procedure is utilized to optimize the amplitudes and locations of poles. In order to capture narrow peaks and sharp band edges in the spectral functions, a constrained sampling algorithm and a self-adaptive sampling algorithm are developed. To demonstrate the usefulness and performance of this method, we at first apply it to study the spectral functions of representative fermionic and bosonic correlators. Then we employ this method to tackle the analytic continuation problems of matrix-valued Green's functions. The synthetic Green's functions, as well as realistic correlation functions from finite-temperature quantum many-body calculations, are used as input. The benchmark results demonstrate that this method is capable of reproducing most of the key characteristics in the spectral functions. The sharp, smooth, and multipeak features in both low- and high-frequency regions of spectral functions could be accurately resolved, which overcomes one of the main limitations of the traditional maximum entropy method. More importantly, it exhibits excellent robustness with respect to noisy and incomplete input data. The causality of spectral function is always satisfied even in the presence of sizable noises. As a by-product, this method could derive a fitting formula for the Matsubara data, which provides a compact approximation to the many-body Green's functions. Hence, we expect that this method could become a pivotal workhorse for numerically analytic continuation and be broadly useful in many applications.
Analytical continuation (AC) connects theoretical calculations and experimentally measurable quantities. The recently proposed Nevanlinna AC method is capable of accurately reproducing the sharp features of spectral functions at high frequencies while maintaining the causality of the response function. However, their use is currently limited to fermions. Here, we present an extension of this method to bosons using the hyperbolic tangent trick, allowing us to transform bosons into auxiliary fermions to which the Nevanlinna analytic continuation can be applied.
We introduce an alternative approach for obtaining smooth finite-temperature spectral functions of quantum impurity models using the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique. It is based on calculating first the Green's function on the imaginary-frequency axis, followed by an analytic continuation to the real-frequency axis using Pad\'e approximants. The arbitrariness in choosing a suitable kernel in the conventional broadening approach is thereby removed and, furthermore, we find that the Pad\'e method is able to resolve fine details in spectral functions with less artifacts on the scale of $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\sim}T$. We discuss the convergence properties with respect to the NRG calculation parameters (discretization $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$, zzz-averaging, truncation cutoff) and the number of Matsubara points taken into account in the analytic continuation. We test the technique on the single-impurity Anderson model and the Hubbard model (within the dynamical mean-field theory). For the Anderson impurity model, we discuss the shape of the Kondo resonance and its temperature dependence. For the Hubbard model, we discuss the inner structure of the Hubbard bands in metallic and insulating solutions at half-filling, as well as in the doped Mott insulator. Based on these test cases, we conclude that the Pad\'e approximant approach provides improved results for spectral functions at low-frequency scales of $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\lesssim}T$ and that it is capable of resolving sharp spectral features also at high frequencies.
The presence of dynamical information is a feature distinguishing a finite-temperature quantum Monte Carlo simulation from a classical one. We now discuss numerical methods for extracting this information that use techniques and concepts borrowed from an area of probability theory called Bayesian statistical inference. The use of these techniques and concepts provided a solution to the very difficult problem of analytically continuing imaginary-time Green's functions, estimated by a quantum Monte Carlo simulation, to the real-time axis. Baym and Mermin (1961) proved that a unique mapping between these functions exists. However, executing this mapping numerically, with a simulation's incomplete and noisy data, transforms the problem into one without a unique solution and thus into a problem of finding a “best” solution according to some reasonable criterion. Instead of executing the analytic continuation between imaginary- and real-time Green's functions, thereby obtaining real-time dynamics, we instead estimate the experimentally relevant spectral density function these Green's functions share. We present three “best” solutions and emphasize that making the simulation data consistent with the assumptions of the numerical approach is a key step toward finding any of these best solutions.
Green's functions of fermions are described by matrix-valued Herglotz-Nevanlinna functions. Since analytic continuation is fundamentally an ill-posed problem, the causal space described by the matrix-valued Herglotz-Nevanlinna structure can be instrumental in improving the accuracy and in enhancing the robustness with respect to noise. We demonstrate a three-pronged procedure for robust analytic continuation called PES: (1) projection of data to the causal space; (2) estimation of pole locations; and (3) semidefinite relaxation within the causal space. We compare the performance of PES with the recently developed Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory continuation methods and find that PES is more robust in the presence of noise and does not require the usage of extended precision arithmetics. We also demonstrate that a causal projection improves the performance of the Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory methods. The PES method is generalized to bosonic response functions, for which the Nevanlinna and Carath\'eodory continuation methods have not yet been developed. It is particularly useful for studying spectra with sharp features, as they occur in the study of molecules and band structures in solids.