Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2010.04067 · The European Physical Journal C

A response to criticisms on “CMB constraints cast a shadow on CSL model”

Jérôme Martin, Vincent Vennin

Published Jan 1, 2021• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Our recent letter “Cosmic Microwave Background Constraints Cast a Shadow On Continuous Spontaneous Localization Models” (Martin and Vennin Phys Rev Lett 124:080402, 2020, arXiv:1906.04405 ) has recently been criticised in Ref. (Bengochea et al. Eur Phys J C 80:1021, 2020a) (see also Ref. Bengochea et al. 2020b, arXiv:2006.05313 ). In this reply, we explain why the arguments presented in those articles are either incorrect or a confirmation of the robustness of our results.

DOI
10.1140/epjc/s10052-020-08811-0

Related papers

Comment on "Cosmic Microwave Background Constraints Cast a Shadow On Continuous Spontaneous Localization Models"

Gabriel R. Bengochea, Gabriel León, Philip Pearle +1 more

In a recent paper [J. Martin and V. Vennin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080402 (2020)] it was argued that, for most natural choices, the direct application of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) theory to the inflationary case, as it is known to work in non-relativistic laboratory situations, is ruled out by cosmological observational data, thus casting a shadow on models based on CSL theory. We point out that such results are based on the consideration of a rather narrow set of choices for the application of the theory to the cosmological context and that the landscape of open and different possibilities is extremely vast.

arXiv:2006.05313•Jun 7, 2020•10 citations

Discussions about the landscape of possibilities for treatments of cosmic inflation involving continuous spontaneous localization models

Gabriel R. Bengochea, Gabriel León, Philip Pearle +1 more

Abstract In this work we consider a wide variety of alternatives opened when applying the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) dynamical collapse theory to the inflationary era. The definitive resolution of many of the issues discussed here will have to await, not only for a general relativistic CSL theory, but for a fully workable theory of quantum gravity. Our concern here is to explore these issues, and to warn against premature conclusions. This exploration includes: two different approaches to deal with quantum field theory and gravitation, the identification of the collapse-generating operator and the general nature and values of the parameters of the CSL theory. All the choices connected with these issues have the potential to dramatically alter the conclusions one can draw. We also argue that the incompatibilities found in a recent paper, between the CSL parameter values and the cosmic microwave background observational data, are associated with specific choices made for the extrapolation to the cosmological context of the CSL theory (as it is known to work in non-relativistic laboratory situations) which do not represent the most natural ones.

arXiv:2008.05285•The European Physical Journal C•Nov 1, 2020•18 citations

Comment on "Phase-space consideration on barrier transmission in a time-dependent variational approach with superposed wave packets (arXiv:2201.02966)"

Hasegawa, N., K. Hagino, Yusuke Tanimura

We reply to the criticisms of our publication (N. Hasegawa, K. Hagino, and Y. Tanimura, Phys. Lett. B808, 135693 (2020)) made by A. Ono in his recent article, arXiv:2201.02966.

arXiv:2202.00513•Jan 31, 2022•1 citation

Reply to Comment on "Space-Time Crystals of Trapped Ions"

Tongcang Li, Zhexuan Gong, Zhang‐qi Yin +5 more

This is a reply to the comment from Patrick Bruno (arXiv:1211.4792) on our paper (Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 163001 (2012)).

arXiv:1212.6959•Dec 31, 2012•13 citations

Revisiting astrophysical bounds on continuous spontaneous localization models

Martin Miguel Ocampo, M. M. Miller Bertolami, Gabriel León

Abstract Among the open problems in fundamental physics, few are as conceptually significant as the “measurement problem” in Quantum Mechanics. One of the proposed solutions to this problem is the Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model, which introduces a non-linear and stochastic modification of the Schrödinger equation. This model incorporates two parameters that can be subjected to experimental constraints. One of the most notable consequences of this theory is the spontaneous heating of massive objects; this anomalous heating is dependent on the CSL parameters. In this work, we will revisit some astrophysical bounds previously found, and introduce new methods for testing the spontaneous heating in a variety of compact objects. Finally, we will compare our different bounds and discuss the benefits and shortcomings of each one.

arXiv:2406.04463•Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics•Oct 1, 2024•3 citations

Reply to Comment on "Superradiant Phase Transitions and the Standard Description of Circuit QED"

Oliver Viehmann, Jan von Delft, Florian Marquardt

A Reply to the Comment by C. Ciuti and P. Nataf [arXiv:1112.0986v1] on our Letter "Superradiant Phase Transitions and the Standard Description of Circuit QED" [Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 113602 (2011)].

arXiv:1202.2916•Feb 14, 2012•7 citations
Abstract Our recent letter “Cosmic Microwave Background Constraints Cast a Shadow On Continuous Spontaneous Localization Models” (Martin and Vennin Phys Rev Lett 124:080402, 2020, arXiv:1906.04405 ) has recently been criticised in Ref. (Bengochea et al. Eur Phys J C 80:1021, 2020a) (see also Ref. Bengochea et al. 2020b, arXiv:2006.05313 ). In this reply, we explain why the arguments presented in those articles are either incorrect or a confirmation of the robustness of our results.
In a recent paper [J. Martin and V. Vennin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080402 (2020)] it was argued that, for most natural choices, the direct application of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) theory to the inflationary case, as it is known to work in non-relativistic laboratory situations, is ruled out by cosmological observational data, thus casting a shadow on models based on CSL theory. We point out that such results are based on the consideration of a rather narrow set of choices for the application of the theory to the cosmological context and that the landscape of open and different possibilities is extremely vast.
Abstract In this work we consider a wide variety of alternatives opened when applying the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) dynamical collapse theory to the inflationary era. The definitive resolution of many of the issues discussed here will have to await, not only for a general relativistic CSL theory, but for a fully workable theory of quantum gravity. Our concern here is to explore these issues, and to warn against premature conclusions. This exploration includes: two different approaches to deal with quantum field theory and gravitation, the identification of the collapse-generating operator and the general nature and values of the parameters of the CSL theory. All the choices connected with these issues have the potential to dramatically alter the conclusions one can draw. We also argue that the incompatibilities found in a recent paper, between the CSL parameter values and the cosmic microwave background observational data, are associated with specific choices made for the extrapolation to the cosmological context of the CSL theory (as it is known to work in non-relativistic laboratory situations) which do not represent the most natural ones.
Abstract Among the open problems in fundamental physics, few are as conceptually significant as the “measurement problem” in Quantum Mechanics. One of the proposed solutions to this problem is the Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model, which introduces a non-linear and stochastic modification of the Schrödinger equation. This model incorporates two parameters that can be subjected to experimental constraints. One of the most notable consequences of this theory is the spontaneous heating of massive objects; this anomalous heating is dependent on the CSL parameters. In this work, we will revisit some astrophysical bounds previously found, and introduce new methods for testing the spontaneous heating in a variety of compact objects. Finally, we will compare our different bounds and discuss the benefits and shortcomings of each one.