Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2009.09573 · Physical Review A

Quantum-classical dynamical brackets

M. Amin, Mark A. Walton

Published Sep 21, 2021• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the problem of constructing a general hybrid quantum-classical bracket from a partial classical limit of a full quantum bracket. Introducing a hybrid composition product, we show that such a bracket is the commutator of that product. From this we see that the hybrid bracket will obey the Jacobi identity and the Leibniz rule provided the composition product is associative. This suggests that the set of hybrid variables belonging to an associative subalgebra with the composition product will have consistent quantum-classical dynamics. This restricts the class of allowed quantum-classical interaction Hamiltonians. Furthermore, we show that pure quantum or classical variables can interact in a consistent framework, unaffected by no-go theorems in the literature or the restrictions for hybrid variables. In the proposed scheme, quantum backreaction appears as quantum-dependent terms in the classical equations of motion.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.104.032216

Related papers

A quantum-classical bracket that satisfies the Jacobi identity

Oleg V. Prezhdo

A quantum-classical bracket is proposed and is shown to satisfy the Jacobi identity, in contrast to previous definitions that obey this property only up to higher order terms in the Planck constant variant Planck's over 2pi. The Jacobi identity is required of a true Lie bracket and ensures that the Lie bracket of constants of motion is also a constant of motion. An explicit calculation of the Jacobi identity highlights the difference between the proposed and traditional definitions. A further example illustrates that the proposed bracket generates a more consistent quantum-classical dynamics than the traditional bracket. The traditional quantum-classical dynamics in the Henon-Heiles system diverges due to higher order variant Planck's over 2pi terms. The divergence is eliminated with the proposed bracket.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•May 22, 2006•33 citations

Hybrid classical-quantum systems in terms of moments

David Brizuela, Sara F. Uria

We present a consistent formalism to describe the dynamics of hybrid systems with mixed classical and quantum degrees of freedom. The probability function of the system, which, in general, will be a combination of the classical distribution function and the quantum density matrix, is described in terms of its corresponding moments. We then define a hybrid Poisson bracket, such that the dynamics of the moments is ruled by an effective Hamiltonian. In particular, a closed formula for the Poisson brackets between any two moments for an arbitrary number of degrees of freedom is presented, which corrects previous expressions derived in the literature for the purely quantum case. This formula is of special relevance for practical applications of the formalism. Finally, we study the dynamics of a particular hybrid system given by two coupled oscillators, one being quantum and the other classical. Due to the coupling, specific quantum and classical properties are transferred between different sectors. In particular, the quantum sector is allowed to violate the uncertainty relation, though we explicitly show that there exists a minimum positive bound of the total uncertainty of the hybrid system.

arXiv:2312.13946•Physical Review A•Mar 12, 2024•8 citations

Canonical bracket in quantum-classical hybrid systems

V. Gil, L. L. Salcedo

We study compound systems with a classical sector and a quantum sector. Among other consistency conditions we require a canonical structure, that is, a Lie bracket for the dynamical evolution of hybrid observables in the Heisenberg picture, interpolating between the Poisson bracket and the commutator. Weak and strong postulates are proposed. We explicitly construct one such hybrid bracket when the Hilbert space of the quantum sector is finite dimensional and show that it is unique if the strong postulates are enforced. The adjoint bracket for the Schr\"odinger picture version of the dynamics is also obtained. Unfortunately, preservation of the positivity of the density matrix under the evolution is not guaranteed. The case of a particle with classical position and momentum and quantum spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ is discussed and the spin-orbit dynamics is worked out.

arXiv:1612.05799•Physical Review A•Jan 27, 2017•16 citations

Nambu mechanics and its quantization

Debendranath Sahoo, M. C. Valsakumar

The algebra of observables inherent in the Nambu formalism [Phys. Rev. D 7, 2405 (1973)] for a generalization of classical Hamiltonian dynamics is investigated. A consistency requirement of time evolution of the Nambu bracket leads to a five-point identity. Two types of algebras are possible at the classical level. Their composition properties under a tensor product are considered and the physical implications are analyzed. A quantum generalization of these algebras is shown to be impossible.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1992•39 citations

Formulation of the Classical Mechanics in the Ring of Operators

Abdullah Verçin

By making use of the Weyl-Wigner-Groenewold-Moyal association rules, a commutative product and a new quantum bracket are constructed in the ring of operators \cal{F}(H). In this way, an isomorphism between Lie algebra of classical observables (with Poisson bracket) and the Lie algebra of quantum observables with this new bracket is established. By these observations, a formulation of the classical mechanics in \cal{F}(H} is obtained and is shown to be \hbar\to 0 limit of the Heisenberg picture formulation of the quantum mechanics.

arXiv:quant-ph/9902064•Feb 18, 1999•1 citation

Algebra of quantum mechanics via classical phonons. II: Klein-Gordon dynamics, the Heisenberg formalism, the Dirac canonical commutation rule and the Poincare algebra through the continuous Poisson bracket formalism

Emmanuel Giner

In the first part of this series we have shown how the Schrodinger equation for a single particle and the corresponding non relativistic quantum observables can be obtained from a purely classical phonon model through the Newtonian equations of motion. In this work we focus instead on how the classical Hamiltonian formalism applied to the same phonon system allows to recover the feature of relativistic quantum mechanics for a single spinless particle. Using the classical nature of the phonon model, we naturally define continuous Poisson brackets between classical observables, which allows to recover the dynamics of such observables, i.e. the Ehrenfest relations associated to real-valued Klein-Gordon fields. The Poisson brackets also permits to obtain the generic form of constants of motions, thus generalizing the concept of inner products and momentum on Klein-Gordon fields. We then connect the formalism of real-valued classical functionals with that of hermitian operators and complex-valued wave functions. This is done through the introduction of a non-local complex-valued change of variables which allows to rewrite the real-valued Klein-Gordon equation in a form akin to the Schrodinger equation, and the classical observables as quantum expectation values. Then, we show how this change of variables allows to rewrite the classical Poisson brackets as commutators of hermitian operators. This points out the strict equivalence between the Heisenberg formalism and the formalism of classical Poisson bracket. Eventually, we illustrate how the Poisson brackets allows to recover the transformations of Poincare group in 1+1 dimension together with its algebra. The latter makes the link between the Lorentz invariant inner product of Mostafazadeh and the Casimir invariant associated to the mass of particle.

quant-pharXiv:2607.03909•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations
We study the problem of constructing a general hybrid quantum-classical bracket from a partial classical limit of a full quantum bracket. Introducing a hybrid composition product, we show that such a bracket is the commutator of that product. From this we see that the hybrid bracket will obey the Jacobi identity and the Leibniz rule provided the composition product is associative. This suggests that the set of hybrid variables belonging to an associative subalgebra with the composition product will have consistent quantum-classical dynamics. This restricts the class of allowed quantum-classical interaction Hamiltonians. Furthermore, we show that pure quantum or classical variables can interact in a consistent framework, unaffected by no-go theorems in the literature or the restrictions for hybrid variables. In the proposed scheme, quantum backreaction appears as quantum-dependent terms in the classical equations of motion.
A quantum-classical bracket is proposed and is shown to satisfy the Jacobi identity, in contrast to previous definitions that obey this property only up to higher order terms in the Planck constant variant Planck's over 2pi. The Jacobi identity is required of a true Lie bracket and ensures that the Lie bracket of constants of motion is also a constant of motion. An explicit calculation of the Jacobi identity highlights the difference between the proposed and traditional definitions. A further example illustrates that the proposed bracket generates a more consistent quantum-classical dynamics than the traditional bracket. The traditional quantum-classical dynamics in the Henon-Heiles system diverges due to higher order variant Planck's over 2pi terms. The divergence is eliminated with the proposed bracket.
We present a consistent formalism to describe the dynamics of hybrid systems with mixed classical and quantum degrees of freedom. The probability function of the system, which, in general, will be a combination of the classical distribution function and the quantum density matrix, is described in terms of its corresponding moments. We then define a hybrid Poisson bracket, such that the dynamics of the moments is ruled by an effective Hamiltonian. In particular, a closed formula for the Poisson brackets between any two moments for an arbitrary number of degrees of freedom is presented, which corrects previous expressions derived in the literature for the purely quantum case. This formula is of special relevance for practical applications of the formalism. Finally, we study the dynamics of a particular hybrid system given by two coupled oscillators, one being quantum and the other classical. Due to the coupling, specific quantum and classical properties are transferred between different sectors. In particular, the quantum sector is allowed to violate the uncertainty relation, though we explicitly show that there exists a minimum positive bound of the total uncertainty of the hybrid system.
We study compound systems with a classical sector and a quantum sector. Among other consistency conditions we require a canonical structure, that is, a Lie bracket for the dynamical evolution of hybrid observables in the Heisenberg picture, interpolating between the Poisson bracket and the commutator. Weak and strong postulates are proposed. We explicitly construct one such hybrid bracket when the Hilbert space of the quantum sector is finite dimensional and show that it is unique if the strong postulates are enforced. The adjoint bracket for the Schr\"odinger picture version of the dynamics is also obtained. Unfortunately, preservation of the positivity of the density matrix under the evolution is not guaranteed. The case of a particle with classical position and momentum and quantum spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ is discussed and the spin-orbit dynamics is worked out.
By making use of the Weyl-Wigner-Groenewold-Moyal association rules, a commutative product and a new quantum bracket are constructed in the ring of operators \cal{F}(H). In this way, an isomorphism between Lie algebra of classical observables (with Poisson bracket) and the Lie algebra of quantum observables with this new bracket is established. By these observations, a formulation of the classical mechanics in \cal{F}(H} is obtained and is shown to be \hbar\to 0 limit of the Heisenberg picture formulation of the quantum mechanics.
In the first part of this series we have shown how the Schrodinger equation for a single particle and the corresponding non relativistic quantum observables can be obtained from a purely classical phonon model through the Newtonian equations of motion. In this work we focus instead on how the classical Hamiltonian formalism applied to the same phonon system allows to recover the feature of relativistic quantum mechanics for a single spinless particle. Using the classical nature of the phonon model, we naturally define continuous Poisson brackets between classical observables, which allows to recover the dynamics of such observables, i.e. the Ehrenfest relations associated to real-valued Klein-Gordon fields. The Poisson brackets also permits to obtain the generic form of constants of motions, thus generalizing the concept of inner products and momentum on Klein-Gordon fields. We then connect the formalism of real-valued classical functionals with that of hermitian operators and complex-valued wave functions. This is done through the introduction of a non-local complex-valued change of variables which allows to rewrite the real-valued Klein-Gordon equation in a form akin to the Schrodinger equation, and the classical observables as quantum expectation values. Then, we show how this change of variables allows to rewrite the classical Poisson brackets as commutators of hermitian operators. This points out the strict equivalence between the Heisenberg formalism and the formalism of classical Poisson bracket. Eventually, we illustrate how the Poisson brackets allows to recover the transformations of Poincare group in 1+1 dimension together with its algebra. The latter makes the link between the Lorentz invariant inner product of Mostafazadeh and the Casimir invariant associated to the mass of particle.