Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2008.11550

The non-individuals interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Décio Krause, Jonas R. Becker Arenhart, Otávio Bueno

Published Aug 26, 2020• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The non-individuals interpretation of quantum mechanics is presented with the aim of clarifying it and highflying some of its salient features. Alternative formulations of it are proposed and examined.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2008.11550

Related papers

The Non-Reflexive Formulation of Quantum Mechanics: the Whys and the Hows

Décio Krause

In the non-reflexive formulation of quantum physics, attention is given to a metaphysical view of quantum objects (q-objects) as non-individuals, characterised as entities to which the standard notion of identity lacks sense. The reference to the nature of q-objects is usually omitted in other interpretations and the most we can find is some vague reference to “to each [quantum] system we associate a Hilbert space”, and nothing more is said about them; we need to infer from the theory their characteristics, and it gives us several alternatives. One of them, to be justified here in broad aspects, is the non-individual view. It is important to enlighten that we are not trying to just find a way to deal with quantum entities but to defend a possible ontology of non-individuals, which can be applied also to ‘particles’ arising from quantum fields. Our account is based on two assumptions: (i) the ‘classical theory of identity’ does not apply to q-objects, and (ii) their non-individuality must be attributed from the start, that is, as a primitive notion and not ‘made a posteriori’ say by assuming symmetry principles. The underlying logic is called non-reflexive because the reflexive law of identity \(\forall{x{({x = x})}}\) is supposed not to hold for q-objects. Since all the details demand a lot of space, here we only sketch and justify our view. The references provide a more detailed account.

Qeios•Mar 19, 2025•0 citations

Non-seperability, Non-supervenience, and Quantum Ontology

Darrin W.S. Belousek

An argument to the effect that quantum mechanics commits us to the existence of non-supervenient relations, and therefore that we should admit such relations into our quantum ontology as fundamental entities, has been given by Teller and reformulated by French. This paper aims, first, to explicate and evaluate that argument; second, to extend its premises in order to assess its relevance for other interpretations of quantum mechanics; and, third, to clarify its implications for holism and individuation in quantum ontology.

Philosophy of Science•Oct 1, 2003•20 citations

An unorthodox view on quantum mechanics

Gerard ’t Hooft

The author's opinion on the interpretation of quantum mechanics is further elucidated. Not only may quantum mechanics be a description of the sub-microscopic world that is profoundly different from what is often asserted, particularly concerning 'what is really going on', but questions such as these may well be essential for finding new ways of constructing models beyond what is now called the Standard Model of the sub-atomic particles.

arXiv:2104.03179•Apr 7, 2021•1 citation

Interlude: Some Alternative Interpretations

Richard Healey

An understanding of quantum theory is manifested by the ability successfully and unproblematically to use it to further the scientific goals of prediction, explanation, and control of natural phenomena. An Interpretation seeks further to formulate or reformulate it as a fundamental theory that provides a self-contained description of the world. I critically review three prominent but radically different Interpretations of quantum theory (Bohmian mechanics, non-linear theories, Everettian quantum mechanics) and give my reasons for rejecting each as a way of understanding quantum theory. These include problems associated with non-locality, failure of relativistic invariance, empirical inaccessibility, and decision-making. We can achieve a satisfactory understanding of quantum theory and how it successfully advances the goals of science without providing an Interpretation of the theory.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 20, 2017•0 citations

On the problem of the interpretation of quantum physics

A A Grib

Current thinking on the interpretation of quantum physics is reviewed, with special detail given to the Copenhagen and Everett many-worlds interpretations.

arXiv:1404.2784•Physics-Uspekhi•Dec 4, 2013•17 citations

Adaptive Constraint Cascades in Quantum Measurement

Thanh Minh Nguyen

This work proposes a structural framework for quantum measurement based on adaptive constraint operators.Instead of treating wavefunction collapse as an instantaneous and fundamental discontinuity, measurement is interpreted as the effective result of a sequence of constraint operations acting on the quantum state. The approach introduces a clear separation between dynamical evolution, governed by the Schrödinger equation, and constraint-based selection, which captures admissibility and measurement structure.Within this framework, measurement is modeled as a constraint cascade, where each constraint operator progressively restricts the state space. A key feature of the formulation is the incorporation of adaptive constraint operators, which depend on time and measurement history.This naturally leads to non-commutativity and provides a structural interpretation of contextuality in quantum measurement. A concrete example based on polarization measurement is presented, demonstrating consistency with standard quantum mechanics while offering an alternative interpretation of state reduction. This work does not aim to replace existing quantum theory, but rather to complement it by introducing an additional structural layer that may help clarify the role of measurement and admissibility in physical systems. Keywords: quantum measurement, constraint operators, contextuality, non-commutativity, quantum foundations Notes:This paper is part of an ongoing series exploring constraint-based formulations of physical theory.

•May 4, 2026•0 citations
In the non-reflexive formulation of quantum physics, attention is given to a metaphysical view of quantum objects (q-objects) as non-individuals, characterised as entities to which the standard notion of identity lacks sense. The reference to the nature of q-objects is usually omitted in other interpretations and the most we can find is some vague reference to “to each [quantum] system we associate a Hilbert space”, and nothing more is said about them; we need to infer from the theory their characteristics, and it gives us several alternatives. One of them, to be justified here in broad aspects, is the non-individual view. It is important to enlighten that we are not trying to just find a way to deal with quantum entities but to defend a possible ontology of non-individuals, which can be applied also to ‘particles’ arising from quantum fields. Our account is based on two assumptions: (i) the ‘classical theory of identity’ does not apply to q-objects, and (ii) their non-individuality must be attributed from the start, that is, as a primitive notion and not ‘made a posteriori’ say by assuming symmetry principles. The underlying logic is called non-reflexive because the reflexive law of identity ∀x(x=x)\forall{x{({x = x})}}∀x(x=x) is supposed not to hold for q-objects. Since all the details demand a lot of space, here we only sketch and justify our view. The references provide a more detailed account.
An argument to the effect that quantum mechanics commits us to the existence of non-supervenient relations, and therefore that we should admit such relations into our quantum ontology as fundamental entities, has been given by Teller and reformulated by French. This paper aims, first, to explicate and evaluate that argument; second, to extend its premises in order to assess its relevance for other interpretations of quantum mechanics; and, third, to clarify its implications for holism and individuation in quantum ontology.
An understanding of quantum theory is manifested by the ability successfully and unproblematically to use it to further the scientific goals of prediction, explanation, and control of natural phenomena. An Interpretation seeks further to formulate or reformulate it as a fundamental theory that provides a self-contained description of the world. I critically review three prominent but radically different Interpretations of quantum theory (Bohmian mechanics, non-linear theories, Everettian quantum mechanics) and give my reasons for rejecting each as a way of understanding quantum theory. These include problems associated with non-locality, failure of relativistic invariance, empirical inaccessibility, and decision-making. We can achieve a satisfactory understanding of quantum theory and how it successfully advances the goals of science without providing an Interpretation of the theory.
This work proposes a structural framework for quantum measurement based on adaptive constraint operators.Instead of treating wavefunction collapse as an instantaneous and fundamental discontinuity, measurement is interpreted as the effective result of a sequence of constraint operations acting on the quantum state. The approach introduces a clear separation between dynamical evolution, governed by the Schrödinger equation, and constraint-based selection, which captures admissibility and measurement structure.Within this framework, measurement is modeled as a constraint cascade, where each constraint operator progressively restricts the state space. A key feature of the formulation is the incorporation of adaptive constraint operators, which depend on time and measurement history.This naturally leads to non-commutativity and provides a structural interpretation of contextuality in quantum measurement. A concrete example based on polarization measurement is presented, demonstrating consistency with standard quantum mechanics while offering an alternative interpretation of state reduction. This work does not aim to replace existing quantum theory, but rather to complement it by introducing an additional structural layer that may help clarify the role of measurement and admissibility in physical systems. Keywords: quantum measurement, constraint operators, contextuality, non-commutativity, quantum foundations Notes:This paper is part of an ongoing series exploring constraint-based formulations of physical theory.