Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2008.06633 · Quantum Science and Technology

How to define quantum mean-field solvable Hamiltonians using Lie algebras

Artur F. Izmaylov, Tzu-Ching Yen

Published Jun 30, 2021• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Necessary and sufficient conditions for quantum Hamiltonians to be exactly solvable within mean-field (MF) theories have not been formulated so far. To resolve this problem, first, we define what MF theory is, independently of a Hamiltonian realization in a particular set of operators. Second, using a Lie-algebraic framework we formulate a criterion for a Hamiltonian to be MF solvable. The criterion is applicable for both distinguishable and indistinguishable particle cases. For the electronic Hamiltonians, our approach reveals the existence of MF solvable Hamiltonians of higher fermionic operator powers than quadratic. Some of the MF solvable Hamiltonians require different sets of quasi-particle rotations for different eigenstates, which reflects a more complicated structure of such Hamiltonians.

DOI
10.1088/2058-9565/ac1040

Related papers

Extension of Exactly-Solvable Hamiltonians Using Symmetries of Lie Algebras

Smik Patel, Tzu-Ching Yen, Artur F. Izmaylov

Exactly solvable Hamiltonians that can be diagonalized by using relatively simple unitary transformations are of great use in quantum computing. They can be employed for the decomposition of interacting Hamiltonians either in Trotter-Suzuki approximations of the evolution operator for the quantum phase estimation algorithm or in the quantum measurement problem for the variational quantum eigensolver. One of the typical forms of exactly solvable Hamiltonians is a linear combination of operators forming a modestly sized Lie algebra. Very frequently, such linear combinations represent noninteracting Hamiltonians and thus are of limited interest for describing interacting cases. Here, we propose an extension in which the coefficients in these combinations are substituted by polynomials of the Lie algebra symmetries. This substitution results in a more general class of solvable Hamiltonians, and for qubit algebras, it is related to the recently proposed noncontextual Pauli Hamiltonians. In fermionic problems, this substitution leads to Hamiltonians with eigenstates that are single Slater determinants but with different sets of single-particle states for different eigenstates. The new class of solvable Hamiltonians can be measured efficiently using quantum circuits with gates that depend on the result of a midcircuit measurement of the symmetries.

arXiv:2305.18251•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•May 8, 2024•7 citations

Efficient Solvability of Hamiltonians and Limits on the Power of Some Quantum Computational Models

Rolando D. Somma, Howard Barnum, Gerardo Ortíz +1 more

One way to specify a model of quantum computing is to give a set of control Hamiltonians acting on a quantum state space whose initial state and final measurement are specified in terms of the Hamiltonians. We formalize such models and show that they can be simulated classically in a time polynomial in the dimension of the Lie algebra generated by the Hamiltonians and logarithmic in the dimension of the state space. This leads to a definition of Lie-algebraic "generalized mean-field Hamiltonians." We show that they are efficiently (exactly) solvable. Our results generalize the known weakness of fermionic linear optics computation and give conditions on control needed to exploit the full power of quantum computing.

arXiv:quant-ph/0601030•Physical Review Letters•Nov 9, 2006•40 citations

Three-dimensional Lie algebras and some of their realizations in quantum mechanics

Francisco Marcelo Fernández, Eduardo A. Castro

The number of exactly solvable eigenvalue problems has been rapidly increasing since the advent of quantum mechanics and there are many efficient ways to treat them. As a general rule, it is possible to write exactly solvable abstract eigenvalue equations in terms of the generators of finite-dimensional Lie algebras and solve them by means of purely algebraic methods. Matrix elements are commonly necessary for the application of perturbation theory and variational principles, among other approximate methods. The chapter discusses examples of three-dimensional Lie algebras with well-known quantum-mechanical realizations. Typically, exactly solvable quantum-mechanical problems are either onedimensional models or lead to separable equations in many dimensions. In the coordinate representation both cases reduce to ordinary differential equations of second order that determine the eigenvalues and separation constants compatible with the physical boundary conditions. In its purest form, a Lie algebraic method is representation-independent. Extensive application of algebraic methods to selected physical problems is already available elsewhere.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 16, 2020•0 citations

The Universal Algebraic Structure of Exactly Solvable Quantum Systems

Revista, Zen, PHYSICS, 10

Exactly solvable quantum systems represent a fascinating and critically important class of models in theoretical physics, offering exact solutions to non-trivial problems that often shed light on the behavior of more complex, intractable systems. The remarkable feature of these systems lies not only in their solvability but also in the underlying mathematical structures that facilitate such solutions. This paper explores the concept of a universal algebraic structure that underpins exactly solvable quantum systems. We delve into how diverse models, ranging from one-dimensional spin chains to many-body systems and field theories, exhibit common algebraic symmetries, such as Lie algebras, affine Lie algebras, and quantum groups. These algebraic frameworks provide a unified language for understanding integrability, the existence of an infinite number of conserved quantities, and the ability to construct exact eigenstates. We review the historical development of these ideas, from the Bethe ansatz to the development of the inverse scattering method and quantum groups. Our discussion highlights how these mathematical structures are not merely tools for calculation but fundamental descriptors of the physical reality of these systems, offering profound insights into non-perturbative quantum phenomena. The identification of a universal algebraic architecture suggests a deeper coherence in the landscape of quantum mechanics, paving the way for new discoveries and classifications of quantum models.

•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations

Quantum many-body problems and perturbation theory

A. V. Turbiner

We show that the existence of algebraic forms of exactly solvable A-B-C-D , G 2 , and F 4 Olshanetsky-Perelomov Hamiltonians allows one to develop algebraic perturbation theory, where corrections are computed by purely algebraic means. A classification of perturbations leading to such a perturbation theory based on the theory of representations of Lie algebras is given. In particular, this scheme admits an explicit study of anharmonic many-body problems. Some examples are presented.

arXiv:hep-th/0108160•Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Jun 1, 2002•6 citations

Algebraic mean field theory

Ts. Dankova, George Rosensteel

Mean field theory has an unexpected group theoretic mathematical foundation. Instead of representation theory which applies to most group theoretic quantum models, Hartree-Fock and Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov have been formulated in terms of coadjoint orbits for the groups U(n) and O(2n). The general theory of mean fields is formulated for any arbitrary Lie algebra {\textbf g} of fermion operators. The moment map provides the correspondence between the Hilbert space of microscopic wave functions and the dual space {\textbf g}$^\ast$ of densities. The coadjoint orbits of the group in the dual space are phase spaces on which time-dependent mean field theory is equivalent to a classical Hamiltonian dynamical system. Indeed it forms a finite-dimensional Lax system. The SU(3) mean field theory is constructed explicitly in the coadjoint orbit framework.

arXiv:nucl-th/9909072•APS Division of Nuclear Physics Meeting Abstracts•Sep 29, 1999•1 citation
Abstract Necessary and sufficient conditions for quantum Hamiltonians to be exactly solvable within mean-field (MF) theories have not been formulated so far. To resolve this problem, first, we define what MF theory is, independently of a Hamiltonian realization in a particular set of operators. Second, using a Lie-algebraic framework we formulate a criterion for a Hamiltonian to be MF solvable. The criterion is applicable for both distinguishable and indistinguishable particle cases. For the electronic Hamiltonians, our approach reveals the existence of MF solvable Hamiltonians of higher fermionic operator powers than quadratic. Some of the MF solvable Hamiltonians require different sets of quasi-particle rotations for different eigenstates, which reflects a more complicated structure of such Hamiltonians.
Exactly solvable Hamiltonians that can be diagonalized by using relatively simple unitary transformations are of great use in quantum computing. They can be employed for the decomposition of interacting Hamiltonians either in Trotter-Suzuki approximations of the evolution operator for the quantum phase estimation algorithm or in the quantum measurement problem for the variational quantum eigensolver. One of the typical forms of exactly solvable Hamiltonians is a linear combination of operators forming a modestly sized Lie algebra. Very frequently, such linear combinations represent noninteracting Hamiltonians and thus are of limited interest for describing interacting cases. Here, we propose an extension in which the coefficients in these combinations are substituted by polynomials of the Lie algebra symmetries. This substitution results in a more general class of solvable Hamiltonians, and for qubit algebras, it is related to the recently proposed noncontextual Pauli Hamiltonians. In fermionic problems, this substitution leads to Hamiltonians with eigenstates that are single Slater determinants but with different sets of single-particle states for different eigenstates. The new class of solvable Hamiltonians can be measured efficiently using quantum circuits with gates that depend on the result of a midcircuit measurement of the symmetries.
One way to specify a model of quantum computing is to give a set of control Hamiltonians acting on a quantum state space whose initial state and final measurement are specified in terms of the Hamiltonians. We formalize such models and show that they can be simulated classically in a time polynomial in the dimension of the Lie algebra generated by the Hamiltonians and logarithmic in the dimension of the state space. This leads to a definition of Lie-algebraic "generalized mean-field Hamiltonians." We show that they are efficiently (exactly) solvable. Our results generalize the known weakness of fermionic linear optics computation and give conditions on control needed to exploit the full power of quantum computing.
The number of exactly solvable eigenvalue problems has been rapidly increasing since the advent of quantum mechanics and there are many efficient ways to treat them. As a general rule, it is possible to write exactly solvable abstract eigenvalue equations in terms of the generators of finite-dimensional Lie algebras and solve them by means of purely algebraic methods. Matrix elements are commonly necessary for the application of perturbation theory and variational principles, among other approximate methods. The chapter discusses examples of three-dimensional Lie algebras with well-known quantum-mechanical realizations. Typically, exactly solvable quantum-mechanical problems are either onedimensional models or lead to separable equations in many dimensions. In the coordinate representation both cases reduce to ordinary differential equations of second order that determine the eigenvalues and separation constants compatible with the physical boundary conditions. In its purest form, a Lie algebraic method is representation-independent. Extensive application of algebraic methods to selected physical problems is already available elsewhere.
Exactly solvable quantum systems represent a fascinating and critically important class of models in theoretical physics, offering exact solutions to non-trivial problems that often shed light on the behavior of more complex, intractable systems. The remarkable feature of these systems lies not only in their solvability but also in the underlying mathematical structures that facilitate such solutions. This paper explores the concept of a universal algebraic structure that underpins exactly solvable quantum systems. We delve into how diverse models, ranging from one-dimensional spin chains to many-body systems and field theories, exhibit common algebraic symmetries, such as Lie algebras, affine Lie algebras, and quantum groups. These algebraic frameworks provide a unified language for understanding integrability, the existence of an infinite number of conserved quantities, and the ability to construct exact eigenstates. We review the historical development of these ideas, from the Bethe ansatz to the development of the inverse scattering method and quantum groups. Our discussion highlights how these mathematical structures are not merely tools for calculation but fundamental descriptors of the physical reality of these systems, offering profound insights into non-perturbative quantum phenomena. The identification of a universal algebraic architecture suggests a deeper coherence in the landscape of quantum mechanics, paving the way for new discoveries and classifications of quantum models.
Mean field theory has an unexpected group theoretic mathematical foundation. Instead of representation theory which applies to most group theoretic quantum models, Hartree-Fock and Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov have been formulated in terms of coadjoint orbits for the groups U(n) and O(2n). The general theory of mean fields is formulated for any arbitrary Lie algebra {\textbf g} of fermion operators. The moment map provides the correspondence between the Hilbert space of microscopic wave functions and the dual space {\textbf g}∗^\ast∗ of densities. The coadjoint orbits of the group in the dual space are phase spaces on which time-dependent mean field theory is equivalent to a classical Hamiltonian dynamical system. Indeed it forms a finite-dimensional Lax system. The SU(3) mean field theory is constructed explicitly in the coadjoint orbit framework.