Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.13563 · Physical Review A

Forbidden subspaces for level-1 quantum approximate optimization algorithm and instantaneous quantum polynomial circuits

Michael Streif, Martin Leib

Published Oct 28, 2020• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a thorough investigation of problems that can be solved exactly with the level-1 quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). To this end, we implicitly define a class of problem Hamiltonians that are employed as phase separators in a level-1 QAOA circuit and provide unit overlap with a target subspace spanned by a set of computational basis states. For one-dimensional target subspaces, we identify instances within the implicitly defined class of Hamiltonians for which quantum annealing (QA) and simulated annealing (SA) have an exponentially small probability of finding the solution. Consequently, our results define a demarcation line between QAOA on one hand and QA and SA on the other, and highlight the fundamental differences between an interference-based search heuristic such as QAOA and heuristics that are based on thermal and quantum fluctuations like SA and QA respectively. Moreover, for two-dimensional solution subspaces, we are able to show that the depth of the QAOA circuit grows linearly with the Hamming distance between the two target states. We further show that there are no genuine solutions for target subspaces of dimension higher than 2 and smaller than ${2}^{n}$. We also transfer these results to instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.042416

Related papers

Comparison of QAOA with Quantum and Simulated Annealing

Michael Streif, Martin Leib

We present a comparison between the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and two widely studied competing methods, Quantum Annealing (QA) and Simulated Annealing (SA). To achieve this, we define a class of optimization problems with respect to their spectral properties which are exactly solvable with QAOA. In this class, we identify instances for which QA and SA have an exponentially small probability to find the solution. Consequently, our results define a first demarcation line between QAOA, Simulated Annealing and Quantum Annealing, and highlight the fundamental differences between an interference-based search heuristic such as QAOA and heuristics that are based on thermal and quantum fluctuations like SA and QA respectively.

arXiv:1901.01903•Jan 7, 2019•78 citations

Exploring the neighborhood of 1-layer QAOA with instantaneous quantum polynomial circuits

Sebastian Leontica, David Amaro

We embed 1-layer QAOA circuits into the larger class of parametrized instantaneous quantum polynomial circuits to produce an improved variational quantum algorithm for solving combinatorial optimization problems. The use of analytic expressions to find optimal parameters classically makes our protocol robust against barren plateaus and hardware noise. The average overlap with the ground state scales as 2−0.31(2)N with the number of qubits N for random Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) Hamiltonians of up to 29 qubits, a polynomial improvement over 1-layer QAOA. Additionally, we observe that performing variational imaginary time evolution on the manifold approximates low-temperature pseudo-Boltzmann states. Our protocol outperforms 1-layer QAOA on the recently released Quantinuum H2 trapped-ion quantum hardware and emulator, where we obtain an average approximation ratio of 0.985 across 312 random SK instances of 7 to 32 qubits, from which almost 44% are solved optimally using only 4 to 1208 shots per instance. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2210.05526•Physical Review Research•Jan 19, 2024•13 citations

Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm in Finite Size and Large Depth and Equivalence to Quantum Annealing

Sami Boulebnane, James Sud, Ruslan Shaydulin +1 more

The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and quantum annealing are two of the most popular quantum optimization heuristics. While QAOA is known to be able to approximate quantum annealing, the approximation requires QAOA angles to vanish with the problem size $n$, whereas optimized QAOA angles are observed to be size-independent for small $n$ and constant in the infinite-size limit. This fact led to a folklore belief that QAOA has a mechanism that is fundamentally different from quantum annealing. In this work, we provide evidence against this by analytically showing that QAOA energy approximates that of quantum annealing under two conditions, namely that angles vary smoothly from one layer to the next and that the sum is bounded by a constant. These conditions are known to hold for near-optimal QAOA angles empirically. Our proof relies on a series expansion of QAOA energy in sum of angles, which we show converges to quantum annealing limit as QAOA depth grows for constant sum of angles even if angles do not vanish with problem size $n$. A corollary of our results is a quadratic improvement for the bound on depth required to compile Trotterized quantum annealing of the SK model in the average case.

arXiv:2503.09563•Mar 12, 2025•11 citations

Universal resources for quantum approximate optimization algorithm and quantum annealing

Pablo Díez-Valle, Fernando J. Gómez-Ruiz, Diego Porras +1 more

The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a variational ansatz that resembles the Trotterized dynamics of a Quantum Annealing (QA) protocol. This work formalizes this connection formally and empirically, showing the angles of a multilayer QAOA circuit converge to universal QA trajectories. Furthermore, the errors in both QAOA circuits and QA paths act as thermal excitations in pseudo-Boltzmann probability distributions whose temperature decreases with the invested resource -- i.e. integrated angles or total time -- and which in QAOA also contain a higher temperature arising from the Trotterization. This also means QAOA and QA are cooling protocols and simulators of partition functions whose target temperature can be tuned by rescaling the universal trajectory. The average cooling power of both methods exhibits favorable algebraic scalings with respect to the target temperature and problem size, whereby in QAOA the coldest temperature is inversely proportional to the number of layers, $T\sim 1/p$, and to the integrated angles -- or integrated interactions in QA.

quant-pharXiv:2506.03241•Physical Review Research•Jun 5, 2025•11 citations

The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm Can Require Exponential Time to Optimize Linear Functions

Francisco Chicano, Zakaria Abdelmoiz Dahi, Gabriel Luque

QAOA is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm to solve optimization problems in gate-based quantum computers. It is based on a variational quantum circuit that can be interpreted as a discretization of the annealing process that quantum annealers follow to find a minimum energy state of a given Hamiltonian. This ensures that QAOA must find an optimal solution for any given optimization problem when the number of layers, p, used in the variational quantum circuit tends to infinity. In practice, the number of layers is usually bounded by a small number. This is a must in current quantum computers of the NISQ era, due to the depth limit of the circuits they can run to avoid problems with decoherence and noise. In this paper, we show mathematical evidence that QAOA requires exponential time to solve linear functions when the number of layers is less than the number of different coefficients of the linear function n. We conjecture that QAOA needs exponential time to find the global optimum of linear functions for any constant value of p, and that the runtime is linear only if p ≥ n. We conclude that we need new quantum algorithms to reach quantum supremacy in quantum optimization.

arXiv:2505.06404•Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion (GECCO Companion)•Jul 14, 2025•2 citations

Quantum Optimal Control and Variational Algorithms for Optimization

RUIYI WANG

Recent advances in quantum technologies have intensified the search for algo rithms that can use quantum resources effectively. Quantum annealing and hybrid quantum–classical variational algorithms are two prominent approaches in this set ting. Conventional quantum annealing follows a prescribed Hamiltonian interpo lation and may therefore be limited by small spectral gaps along that path. This Thesis investigates how algorithmic performance changes when three elements are varied: the annealing schedule (Chapter 2), the independent parameters of a digi tized evolution (Chapter 3), and the encoding of the problem (Chapter 4). For weighted MaxCut instances with anomalously small annealing gaps, opti mized smooth schedules outperform linear digitized annealing at equal circuit depth. Rather than restoring adiabaticity or enlarging the gap, the dynamics deliberately leaves the instantaneous ground state and later returns the population to the target state. Smoothness allows these digital solutions to retain their quality as continuous time controls and when transferred between related instances. The schedule restriction is then removed for a frustrated Ising ring whose anneal ing gap closes exponentially with system size. Optimizing all circuit angles inde pendently yields numerically exact ground-state preparation at the critical depth Pcr 1 =(N2−1)/4. This quadratic threshold is explained by the dimension and sym metries of the reachable free-fermion manifold, demonstrating that controllability, rather than the gap of a particular interpolation, determines the required number of digital controls. Finally, the same ring family is reformulated through the parity mapping. For the original frustrated ring, Parity-QAOA reaches the exact ground state using only single-qubit rotations, without applying the constraint unitary. The number of layers equals the number of distinct coupling values and does not grow with system size. To clarify the role of constraints, an equal-magnitude signed ring is also studied, for which the constraint unitary is essential for preparing the target ground state. Together, these results identify the shape, controllability, and encoding of a quan tum protocol as resources for overcoming limitations imposed by more restricted routes to ground-state preparation.

•Sep 24, 2026•0 citations
We present a thorough investigation of problems that can be solved exactly with the level-1 quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). To this end, we implicitly define a class of problem Hamiltonians that are employed as phase separators in a level-1 QAOA circuit and provide unit overlap with a target subspace spanned by a set of computational basis states. For one-dimensional target subspaces, we identify instances within the implicitly defined class of Hamiltonians for which quantum annealing (QA) and simulated annealing (SA) have an exponentially small probability of finding the solution. Consequently, our results define a demarcation line between QAOA on one hand and QA and SA on the other, and highlight the fundamental differences between an interference-based search heuristic such as QAOA and heuristics that are based on thermal and quantum fluctuations like SA and QA respectively. Moreover, for two-dimensional solution subspaces, we are able to show that the depth of the QAOA circuit grows linearly with the Hamming distance between the two target states. We further show that there are no genuine solutions for target subspaces of dimension higher than 2 and smaller than 2n{2}^{n}2n. We also transfer these results to instantaneous quantum polynomial (IQP) circuits.
We present a comparison between the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and two widely studied competing methods, Quantum Annealing (QA) and Simulated Annealing (SA). To achieve this, we define a class of optimization problems with respect to their spectral properties which are exactly solvable with QAOA. In this class, we identify instances for which QA and SA have an exponentially small probability to find the solution. Consequently, our results define a first demarcation line between QAOA, Simulated Annealing and Quantum Annealing, and highlight the fundamental differences between an interference-based search heuristic such as QAOA and heuristics that are based on thermal and quantum fluctuations like SA and QA respectively.
We embed 1-layer QAOA circuits into the larger class of parametrized instantaneous quantum polynomial circuits to produce an improved variational quantum algorithm for solving combinatorial optimization problems. The use of analytic expressions to find optimal parameters classically makes our protocol robust against barren plateaus and hardware noise. The average overlap with the ground state scales as 2−0.31(2)N with the number of qubits N for random Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) Hamiltonians of up to 29 qubits, a polynomial improvement over 1-layer QAOA. Additionally, we observe that performing variational imaginary time evolution on the manifold approximates low-temperature pseudo-Boltzmann states. Our protocol outperforms 1-layer QAOA on the recently released Quantinuum H2 trapped-ion quantum hardware and emulator, where we obtain an average approximation ratio of 0.985 across 312 random SK instances of 7 to 32 qubits, from which almost 44% are solved optimally using only 4 to 1208 shots per instance. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) and quantum annealing are two of the most popular quantum optimization heuristics. While QAOA is known to be able to approximate quantum annealing, the approximation requires QAOA angles to vanish with the problem size nnn, whereas optimized QAOA angles are observed to be size-independent for small nnn and constant in the infinite-size limit. This fact led to a folklore belief that QAOA has a mechanism that is fundamentally different from quantum annealing. In this work, we provide evidence against this by analytically showing that QAOA energy approximates that of quantum annealing under two conditions, namely that angles vary smoothly from one layer to the next and that the sum is bounded by a constant. These conditions are known to hold for near-optimal QAOA angles empirically. Our proof relies on a series expansion of QAOA energy in sum of angles, which we show converges to quantum annealing limit as QAOA depth grows for constant sum of angles even if angles do not vanish with problem size nnn. A corollary of our results is a quadratic improvement for the bound on depth required to compile Trotterized quantum annealing of the SK model in the average case.
The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a variational ansatz that resembles the Trotterized dynamics of a Quantum Annealing (QA) protocol. This work formalizes this connection formally and empirically, showing the angles of a multilayer QAOA circuit converge to universal QA trajectories. Furthermore, the errors in both QAOA circuits and QA paths act as thermal excitations in pseudo-Boltzmann probability distributions whose temperature decreases with the invested resource -- i.e. integrated angles or total time -- and which in QAOA also contain a higher temperature arising from the Trotterization. This also means QAOA and QA are cooling protocols and simulators of partition functions whose target temperature can be tuned by rescaling the universal trajectory. The average cooling power of both methods exhibits favorable algebraic scalings with respect to the target temperature and problem size, whereby in QAOA the coldest temperature is inversely proportional to the number of layers, T∼1/pT\sim 1/pT∼1/p, and to the integrated angles -- or integrated interactions in QA.
QAOA is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm to solve optimization problems in gate-based quantum computers. It is based on a variational quantum circuit that can be interpreted as a discretization of the annealing process that quantum annealers follow to find a minimum energy state of a given Hamiltonian. This ensures that QAOA must find an optimal solution for any given optimization problem when the number of layers, p, used in the variational quantum circuit tends to infinity. In practice, the number of layers is usually bounded by a small number. This is a must in current quantum computers of the NISQ era, due to the depth limit of the circuits they can run to avoid problems with decoherence and noise. In this paper, we show mathematical evidence that QAOA requires exponential time to solve linear functions when the number of layers is less than the number of different coefficients of the linear function n. We conjecture that QAOA needs exponential time to find the global optimum of linear functions for any constant value of p, and that the runtime is linear only if p ≥ n. We conclude that we need new quantum algorithms to reach quantum supremacy in quantum optimization.
Recent advances in quantum technologies have intensified the search for algo rithms that can use quantum resources effectively. Quantum annealing and hybrid quantum–classical variational algorithms are two prominent approaches in this set ting. Conventional quantum annealing follows a prescribed Hamiltonian interpo lation and may therefore be limited by small spectral gaps along that path. This Thesis investigates how algorithmic performance changes when three elements are varied: the annealing schedule (Chapter 2), the independent parameters of a digi tized evolution (Chapter 3), and the encoding of the problem (Chapter 4). For weighted MaxCut instances with anomalously small annealing gaps, opti mized smooth schedules outperform linear digitized annealing at equal circuit depth. Rather than restoring adiabaticity or enlarging the gap, the dynamics deliberately leaves the instantaneous ground state and later returns the population to the target state. Smoothness allows these digital solutions to retain their quality as continuous time controls and when transferred between related instances. The schedule restriction is then removed for a frustrated Ising ring whose anneal ing gap closes exponentially with system size. Optimizing all circuit angles inde pendently yields numerically exact ground-state preparation at the critical depth Pcr 1 =(N2−1)/4. This quadratic threshold is explained by the dimension and sym metries of the reachable free-fermion manifold, demonstrating that controllability, rather than the gap of a particular interpolation, determines the required number of digital controls. Finally, the same ring family is reformulated through the parity mapping. For the original frustrated ring, Parity-QAOA reaches the exact ground state using only single-qubit rotations, without applying the constraint unitary. The number of layers equals the number of distinct coupling values and does not grow with system size. To clarify the role of constraints, an equal-magnitude signed ring is also studied, for which the constraint unitary is essential for preparing the target ground state. Together, these results identify the shape, controllability, and encoding of a quan tum protocol as resources for overcoming limitations imposed by more restricted routes to ground-state preparation.