Abstract Is it possible to encompass the full extent of the universe within a theory based on a finite set of first principles and inference rules? The r^ole of observers and observations in physics theories is considered here in the light of G¨odel’s incompleteness theorem. Physics theories are the sum-total that we – humans, scientists, physicists – can make in interpreting our observations of the universe. We are integral part of the universe, together with our observations, therefore acts of observation are also observables and should become part of the phenomena considered by the theory, especially in view of the fact that arbitrarily chosen modes of observations may essentially determine empirical results. Incompleteness arises in G¨odel’s theorem with self-referential propositions. Observations and interpretations are acts of referencing, and self-referencing occurs in physics whenever the observer is recognized as being part of the observed system. If self-reference appears in physics in simile to G¨odel’s theorem, then incompleteness seems unavoidable in physics. The article discusses observers and observations as referencing in physics, culminating with the understanding that they are hierarchically inter-related so that a universal physics theory cannot be complete.
Abstract Is it possible to encompass the full extent of the universe within a theory based on a finite set of first principles and inference rules? The r^ole of observers and observations in physics theories is considered here in the light of G¨odel’s incompleteness theorem. Physics theories are the sum-total that we – humans, scientists, physicists – can make in interpreting our observations of the universe. We are integral part of the universe, together with our observations, therefore acts of observation are also observables and should become part of the phenomena considered by the theory, especially in view of the fact that arbitrarily chosen modes of observations may essentially determine empirical results. Incompleteness arises in G¨odel’s theorem with self-referential propositions. Observations and interpretations are acts of referencing, and self-referencing occurs in physics whenever the observer is recognized as being part of the observed system. If self-reference appears in physics in simile to G¨odel’s theorem, then incompleteness seems unavoidable in physics. The article discusses observers and observations as referencing in physics, culminating with the understanding that they are hierarchically inter-related so that a universal physics theory cannot be complete.
The r\^{o}le of observers and observations in physics theories is considered in the light of G\{o}del's incompleteness theorem. Incompleteness arises in G\{o}del's theorem with self-referential propositions, when the system asks to define itself in its own terms. Self-referencing occurs in physics whenever the observer is recognized as being part of the observed system, so the acts of observation are also observables and should become part of the phenomena considered by the theory. This is emphasized by the fact that in many instances the same physical phenomenon may be viewed in more than one way, hence its interpretation depends on the mode of observation. Observations of observations imply a potentially endless hierarchy of levels of observations. Each higher level suggests a larger overview with more profound insight into the universe, empirically implying essentially new discoveries and realizations. New discoveries imply new first principles in the foundation of the theory, so the theory remains open and cannot be complete.
Abstract This article1 presents a two-part proposal aimed at exploring “reality” through unifying perspectives and universally consistent foundations. Both parts are inspired by Erwin Schrödinger’s principle of objectivation, particularly the function of the ‘Subject of Cognizance’ embedded within it, and the (seemingly unresolvable, yet inescapable!) issue of the ‘location’ of the boundary between the ‘observed’ and the ‘observer’ that arises in the interpretation of quantum theory. In the first part, it is argued that different interpretations of quantum theory could be viewed as complementary rather than as alternatives, for each interpretation provides insight into different aspects of reality, and thus, integrating perspectives from multiple quantum interpretations can offer a more holistic understanding of reality than relying on a single interpretation. The plausibility of this argument is explained with a brief reference to the phenomenon of electron double-slit interference. The second part of the proposal asserts that, it is essential to eliminate any discrepancy between the way in which the terms ‘physics’ and ‘reality’ are regarded in scientific inquiry, for developing a universal, all-encompassing and consistent world view of the latter — emphasising that not only the ‘observed’ but also the ‘observer’ (considered here as the measuring instrument or apparatus) and the ‘Subject of Cognizance’ (viewed here as the conscious observer) are integral parts of the whole reality. This assertion is supported by some specific remarks of Richard Feynman and David Bohm.
However, the observations encompassed by classical physics excludes the observer from the physical reality, yet the deep-down understandung of nature --{\it the quantum theory}-- can not avoid the intrusion of observer into the measurement process. Indeed, the quantum physics experiments have knocked the door of a new paradigm: in which science of consciousness is an important axiom. In the present work, it is argued --by taking into account of the views of learned scientists and philosophers-- that modern science is incomplete and lacking something in the basic understanding of nature \cite{r}. Classical physics has failed to explain the dynamics of the microscopic particles, eventhough modern scientific researches are based upon the prejudice posed by classical physics: keeping the outer physical universe as a separate entity, that is something quite independent of the observer --human mind. One should not forget that human-being is a part of nature and human mind is an essential component of our observations. Basically, it is the observer --the consciousness-- which makes perception possible. The working of human mind must be included in our scientific theories. In fact, human free will is an illusion and nothing in the entire universe (with life) lies outside the domain of science and determinism.
In 1929 Szilard pointed out that the physics of the observer may play a role in the analysis of experiments. The same year, Bohr pointed out that complementarity appears to arise naturally in psychology where both the objects of perception and the perceiving subject belong to 'our mental content'. Here we argue that the formalism of quantum theory can be derived from two related intuitive principles: (i) inference is a physical process performed by physical systems, observers, which are part of the experimental setup---this implies non-commutativity and imaginary-time quantum mechanics; (ii) experiments must be described from a first-person perspective---this leads to self-reference, complementarity, and real-time quantum dynamics. This approach sheds new light on the foundations of quantum theory and suggests fundamental equations in physics are typically of second order due to the physical nature of the observer. It also suggests some experimental conjectures: (i) the quantum of action could be understood as the result of the additional energy required to transition from unconscious to conscious perception; (ii) humans can observe a single photon of visible light; (iii) self-aware systems and the neural correlates of the self should be composed of two complementary sub-systems, much like the DNA molecule is composed of two strands---this may help explain the double-hemisphere architecture of the brain. Moreover, this approach may help bridge the gap between science and human experience. We discuss the potential implications of these ideas for the modern research programs on consciousness and contemplative science. As side results: (i) we show that message-passing algorithms and stochastic processes can be written in a quantum-like manner; (ii) we provide evidence that non-stoquasticity, a quantum computational resource, may be related to non-equilibrium phenomena.
In 1929 Szilard pointed out that the physics of the observer may play a role in the analysis of experiments. The same year, Bohr pointed out that complementarity appears to arise naturally in psychology where both the objects of perception and the perceiving subject belong to 'our mental content'. Here we argue that the formalism of quantum theory can be derived from two related intuitive principles: (i) inference is a physical process performed by physical systems, observers, which are part of the experimental setup---this implies non-commutativity and imaginary-time quantum mechanics; (ii) experiments must be described from a first-person perspective---this leads to self-reference, complementarity, and real-time quantum dynamics. This approach sheds new light on the foundations of quantum theory and suggests fundamental equations in physics are typically of second order due to the physical nature of the observer. It also suggests some experimental conjectures: (i) the quantum of action could be understood as the result of the additional energy required to transition from unconscious to conscious perception; (ii) humans can observe a single photon of visible light; (iii) self-aware systems and the neural correlates of the self should be composed of two complementary sub-systems, much like the DNA molecule is composed of two strands---this may help explain the double-hemisphere architecture of the brain. Moreover, this approach may help bridge the gap between science and human experience. We discuss the potential implications of these ideas for the modern research programs on consciousness and contemplative science. As side results: (i) we show that message-passing algorithms and stochastic processes can be written in a quantum-like manner; (ii) we provide evidence that non-stoquasticity, a quantum computational resource, may be related to non-equilibrium phenomena.
Why do physicists discover different equations to describe the same universe? This paper proposes a new answer by introducing the Observer Hierarchy of Physics, a general framework in which physical theories are understood as exact observer equations, each preserving the information accessible within a particular observational regime rather than replacing one another. Instead of treating Newtonian mechanics, Maxwell's equations, the Schrödinger equation, the Dirac equation, thermodynamics, and other successful theories as competing descriptions, the framework argues that each is the minimal mathematical description required to preserve the measurements available to a specific observer algebra. The central idea is that the observer algebra is not chosen arbitrarily. It is generated by the observer's physical coupling to the underlying substrate together with finite spatial resolution, temporal resolution, energy access, detector sensitivity, and measurement precision. Once that coupling-generated observer algebra is specified, the minimal sufficient field representation, observer state, and observer equation follow naturally. In this view, the universe continuously evolves its full microscopic state, while observer equations describe only the information that survives physical coupling and projection into observable records. The paper introduces five new theoretical results: • Observer Hierarchy Theorem — demonstrating that a single physical system may admit multiple exact observer equations corresponding to different observational regimes. • Observer Sufficiency Theorem — establishing that an equation may be non-fundamental while remaining mathematically exact within the regime whose observables it preserves. • Representation Sufficiency Theorem — showing that reduced field representations are selected by observer algebras rather than by different physical laws or runtime modes. • Information Preservation Theorem — proving that observer equations are characterized by the information they preserve, not by the information they discard. • Observer Reduction Theorem, together with the Coupling-Determined Algebra Principle, showing that observer algebras arise from physical coupling to the substrate and that transitions between observer equations correspond to information-preserving projections rather than changes in physical reality. The framework is then illustrated using the Lattice Field Medium (LFM), where a continuously evolving second-order computational substrate gives rise to observer-selected field registers, a stable electron solution, the relativistic Dirac observer equation, and finally the low-energy Schrödinger observer equation. Importantly, the substrate itself never changes representation; only the observer's retained description changes as additional observables become experimentally accessible. Seven numerical information-projection diagnostics accompany the theoretical development, validating observer compression, register sufficiency, information preservation, bandwidth-dependent validity, and representation selection through controlled computational experiments. Rather than proposing that future theories replace existing ones, this work argues that scientific progress should explain why existing equations remain exact within their domains of applicability. If correct, the Observer Hierarchy provides a unified organizing principle for theoretical physics in which the evolution of physical theory is understood as the progressive discovery of observer equations emerging from an underlying computational reality.