Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.11886

On the conditions for the classicality of a quantum particle

Kuzmichev, V. E., V. V. Kuzmichev

Published Jul 23, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Conditions under which a quantum particle is described using classical quantities are studied. The one-dimensional (1D) and three-dimensional (3D) problems are considered. It is shown that the sum of the contributions from all quantum corrections (in the WKB sense) strictly vanishes, when a quantum particle interacts with some specific medium. The indices of refraction of such media are found. In this case, the smallness of the Planck constant is not assumed. The momenta of quantum particles in these media and the wave functions of stationary states are determined. It is found that, for the 1D case, the wave function is similar to that of the test particle with zero binding energy in a singular attractive potential, which admits "fall" to the center. For the 3D case with central symmetry, a stationary state, describing a quantum particle with a classical momentum, is defined by the wave function, which has the resonance of width about two de Broglie wavelengths.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2007.11886

Related papers

Classical behavior of a quantum particle in a refringent medium

V. E. Kuzmichev, V. V. Kuzmichev

Conditions under which a quantum particle can be described using classical quantities are studied. We investigate the wavefunction of a quantum particle submitted to a potential field for which all quantum effects vanish, even if Planck's constant is non-negligible. This problem is equivalent to the problem of the motion of a particle in a refringent medium. The indices of refraction of such media are found. In these media, quantum particles have classical momenta, while their wave properties are described by the wave-optics equation with a characteristic length equal to the de Broglie wavelength ƛ. In the 1D case, the particle cannot be found in the region near the origin, since the index of refraction tends to infinity there. For the 3D case with central symmetry, the wave properties are determined by a function that has a resonance of width about 2ƛ. Experimental verification of theoretical predictions is discussed.

American Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2021•0 citations

Quantum potential and free classical particles

Hristu Culetu

A quantum potential V (x, t) of δ-function type is introduced, to describe the motion of a particle. Quantum-mechanically, it is in a bound state (potential trap of Hojman and Asenjo [6]), though classically one seems to be free. The motion of the object takes place according to the Huygens-Fresnel principle. The new position of the object (wave front) plays the role of the secondary sources that maintain the propagation. We found that the de Broglie-Bohm quantum potential is the difference between the constant bound energy E = −mc 2 /2 from the stationary case and our potential V (x, t).

•Jan 28, 2021•0 citations

Exact solutions to fall of particle to singular potential: classical versus quantum cases

Michael I. Tribelsky

Exact solutions describing a fall of a particle to the centre of a non-regularized singular potential in classical and quantum cases are obtained and compared. We inspect the quantum problem with the help of the conventional Schrödinger’s equation. During the fall, the wave function spatial localization area contracts into a single zero-dimensional point. For the fall-admitting potentials, the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian. Because of that, the wave function norm occurs time-dependent. It demands an extension to this case of the continuity equation and rules for mean value calculations. Surprisingly, the quantum and classical solutions exhibit striking similarities. In particular, both are self-similar as the particle energy equals zero. The characteristic spatial scales of the quantum and classical self-similar solutions obey the same temporal dependence. We present arguments indicating that these self-similar solutions are attractors to a broader class of solutions, describing the fall at finite energy of the particle.

arXiv:2202.12615•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Sep 1, 2023•5 citations

Fall of Quantum Particle to the Center: Exact results

Michael I. Tribelsky

The fall of a particle to the center of a singular potential U(r) is one of a few fundamental problems of quantum mechanics. Nonetheless, its solution is not complete yet. The known results just indicate that if U(r) decays fast enough at r tends to zero, the spectrum of the Schrodinger equation is not bounded from below. However, the wave functions of the problem are singular at r = 0 and do not admit the limiting transition to the wave function of the ground state. Therefore, the unboundedness of the spectrum is only the necessary condition. To prove that a quantum particle indeed can fall to the center, a wave function describing the fall should be obtained explicitly. This is done in the present paper. Specifically, an exact solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation describing the fall to the center is obtained and analyzed. The law describing the collapse to a single point of the region of the wave function localization is obtained explicitly, as well as the temporal dependences of the average kinetic and potential energy of the falling particle and its momentum. It is shown that the known necessary conditions for the particle to fall simultaneously are sufficient.

arXiv:2108.01981•Aug 4, 2021•0 citations

On a Parallelism between Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics

Yoshio Nishiyama

Striking parallelism between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics is evidenced for several bound system in a rather general form by introducing reasonably “quantum-mechanical momentum” from the Schrödinger equation. The following are proved: The “quantum-mechanical momentum” which is nearly equal to the corresponding classical momentum in “classical region” can be defined in the whole range of validity of the coordinate for the bound systems. In the same way as in classical mechanics, in quantum mechanics one can construct an associated wave accompanying a motion of a quantum particle and obeying the Schrödinger equation. The uniqueness condition on the associated wave throughout an orbit leads to the boundary condition on the wave function which is composed of the associated wave and to “quantum-mechanical quantization condition”, equivalently. In addition, all these quantum-mechanical quantities are approximately equal to the corresponding classical ones in the “classical region” of the coordinate. In particular it is demonstrated that even for a bound system of a singular (central) potential exists the ground state with the lowest energy eigenvalue. It is proved in one dimension that to any physical system obeying the Schrödinger equation always exists the corresponding classical system.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 1965•0 citations

Conservation and the Distribution of a Defining Property(energy/momentum) Versus The Distribution of Probability

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical statistical mechanics, e.g. a Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) gas, one tries to find the probability distribution of a particular quantity such as particle energy pp/2m. Thus there is a distribution in a quantity, making it the stochastic variable. This quantity, however, is subject to a conservation law i.e. elastic two particle scattering. In a previous note (1), we considered the case of reflection/refraction and called momentum the stochastic variable and noted that it too was linked with conservation. In fact, we argued that both the MB gas and reflection/refraction followed the same stochastic law: P(variable1) P(variable 2) = P(variable 1 + variable 2) whether variable 1 is a scalar or vector. In (2), however, we noted that exp(ipx), a free particle wavefunction, treats p as a parameter with x being the “probability” variable. This seems a little unusual because p, which is normally a variable in an MB gas and even in a quantum bound state i.e. a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx) takes on the role of a parameter i.e. p=hbar/wavelength. Why this duality? Why is p a parameter for “x” of the probability distribution and yet at the same time a variable associated with conservation of momentum? In this note, we argue that unlike the distribution of a defining property of a particle such as momentum or energy, one may have a distribution associated with probability itself. This we argue is the case for a reflection/refraction problem which applies to both light and a particle. In the case of light, there is an interface of two media with different indices of refraction and in the case of a particle an interface with two constant potentials. In both cases, total energy of the photon/particle is constant, but there are two choices or probabilities, reflection or refraction, but they are linked with different times. A single photon or particle can only undergo one at a time. One knows exactly the two values of momentum, but the probability of each is unknown. Thus unlike an MB gas where energy/momentum is being redistributed because the two particles of the outcome exist at the same time, here a probability of 1 must somehow be distributed to the two events.. Given that the incident momentum is p, the reflected -p and the refracted p2, only considering a specific time event i.e. reflection or refraction, does not conserve momentum. In the MB case, a single time event i.e. scattering conserves both momentum and energy. Thus it seems that one does not deal with events in time. There is a distribution of probability in such a way as to ensure conservation of momentum, but does this probability already exist or get created at the interface point? We argued in (3) that if the scenario were deterministic one would have to follow it in time and treat each event separately. Rather we suggest that a distribution of probabilities allows for conservation of momentum, but this means that all three momenta exist at the interface x point as one is not considering an event at a precise point in time. This then allows for each momentum to have its own x distribution based on momentum p so that one may impose conservation of momentum and not have a deterministic time associated with the interface point.. This last idea of conservation of momentum appearing is not discussed in (3) and allows for p to behave like a parameter for x while at the same time being a variable which is conserved. In short, in an MB gas one distributes energy between two colliding particles in order to conserve total energy while for a quantum particle or photon which reflects/refracts one distributes probability to the two scenarios (reflection or refraction) such that momentum is conserved. Thus the nature of what is “distributed” is very different.

•Feb 7, 2023•0 citations
Conditions under which a quantum particle is described using classical quantities are studied. The one-dimensional (1D) and three-dimensional (3D) problems are considered. It is shown that the sum of the contributions from all quantum corrections (in the WKB sense) strictly vanishes, when a quantum particle interacts with some specific medium. The indices of refraction of such media are found. In this case, the smallness of the Planck constant is not assumed. The momenta of quantum particles in these media and the wave functions of stationary states are determined. It is found that, for the 1D case, the wave function is similar to that of the test particle with zero binding energy in a singular attractive potential, which admits "fall" to the center. For the 3D case with central symmetry, a stationary state, describing a quantum particle with a classical momentum, is defined by the wave function, which has the resonance of width about two de Broglie wavelengths.
Conditions under which a quantum particle can be described using classical quantities are studied. We investigate the wavefunction of a quantum particle submitted to a potential field for which all quantum effects vanish, even if Planck's constant is non-negligible. This problem is equivalent to the problem of the motion of a particle in a refringent medium. The indices of refraction of such media are found. In these media, quantum particles have classical momenta, while their wave properties are described by the wave-optics equation with a characteristic length equal to the de Broglie wavelength ƛ. In the 1D case, the particle cannot be found in the region near the origin, since the index of refraction tends to infinity there. For the 3D case with central symmetry, the wave properties are determined by a function that has a resonance of width about 2ƛ. Experimental verification of theoretical predictions is discussed.
A quantum potential V (x, t) of δ-function type is introduced, to describe the motion of a particle. Quantum-mechanically, it is in a bound state (potential trap of Hojman and Asenjo [6]), though classically one seems to be free. The motion of the object takes place according to the Huygens-Fresnel principle. The new position of the object (wave front) plays the role of the secondary sources that maintain the propagation. We found that the de Broglie-Bohm quantum potential is the difference between the constant bound energy E = −mc 2 /2 from the stationary case and our potential V (x, t).
Exact solutions describing a fall of a particle to the centre of a non-regularized singular potential in classical and quantum cases are obtained and compared. We inspect the quantum problem with the help of the conventional Schrödinger’s equation. During the fall, the wave function spatial localization area contracts into a single zero-dimensional point. For the fall-admitting potentials, the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian. Because of that, the wave function norm occurs time-dependent. It demands an extension to this case of the continuity equation and rules for mean value calculations. Surprisingly, the quantum and classical solutions exhibit striking similarities. In particular, both are self-similar as the particle energy equals zero. The characteristic spatial scales of the quantum and classical self-similar solutions obey the same temporal dependence. We present arguments indicating that these self-similar solutions are attractors to a broader class of solutions, describing the fall at finite energy of the particle.
The fall of a particle to the center of a singular potential U(r) is one of a few fundamental problems of quantum mechanics. Nonetheless, its solution is not complete yet. The known results just indicate that if U(r) decays fast enough at r tends to zero, the spectrum of the Schrodinger equation is not bounded from below. However, the wave functions of the problem are singular at r = 0 and do not admit the limiting transition to the wave function of the ground state. Therefore, the unboundedness of the spectrum is only the necessary condition. To prove that a quantum particle indeed can fall to the center, a wave function describing the fall should be obtained explicitly. This is done in the present paper. Specifically, an exact solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation describing the fall to the center is obtained and analyzed. The law describing the collapse to a single point of the region of the wave function localization is obtained explicitly, as well as the temporal dependences of the average kinetic and potential energy of the falling particle and its momentum. It is shown that the known necessary conditions for the particle to fall simultaneously are sufficient.
Striking parallelism between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics is evidenced for several bound system in a rather general form by introducing reasonably “quantum-mechanical momentum” from the Schrödinger equation. The following are proved: The “quantum-mechanical momentum” which is nearly equal to the corresponding classical momentum in “classical region” can be defined in the whole range of validity of the coordinate for the bound systems. In the same way as in classical mechanics, in quantum mechanics one can construct an associated wave accompanying a motion of a quantum particle and obeying the Schrödinger equation. The uniqueness condition on the associated wave throughout an orbit leads to the boundary condition on the wave function which is composed of the associated wave and to “quantum-mechanical quantization condition”, equivalently. In addition, all these quantum-mechanical quantities are approximately equal to the corresponding classical ones in the “classical region” of the coordinate. In particular it is demonstrated that even for a bound system of a singular (central) potential exists the ground state with the lowest energy eigenvalue. It is proved in one dimension that to any physical system obeying the Schrödinger equation always exists the corresponding classical system.
In classical statistical mechanics, e.g. a Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) gas, one tries to find the probability distribution of a particular quantity such as particle energy pp/2m. Thus there is a distribution in a quantity, making it the stochastic variable. This quantity, however, is subject to a conservation law i.e. elastic two particle scattering. In a previous note (1), we considered the case of reflection/refraction and called momentum the stochastic variable and noted that it too was linked with conservation. In fact, we argued that both the MB gas and reflection/refraction followed the same stochastic law: P(variable1) P(variable 2) = P(variable 1 + variable 2) whether variable 1 is a scalar or vector. In (2), however, we noted that exp(ipx), a free particle wavefunction, treats p as a parameter with x being the “probability” variable. This seems a little unusual because p, which is normally a variable in an MB gas and even in a quantum bound state i.e. a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx) takes on the role of a parameter i.e. p=hbar/wavelength. Why this duality? Why is p a parameter for “x” of the probability distribution and yet at the same time a variable associated with conservation of momentum? In this note, we argue that unlike the distribution of a defining property of a particle such as momentum or energy, one may have a distribution associated with probability itself. This we argue is the case for a reflection/refraction problem which applies to both light and a particle. In the case of light, there is an interface of two media with different indices of refraction and in the case of a particle an interface with two constant potentials. In both cases, total energy of the photon/particle is constant, but there are two choices or probabilities, reflection or refraction, but they are linked with different times. A single photon or particle can only undergo one at a time. One knows exactly the two values of momentum, but the probability of each is unknown. Thus unlike an MB gas where energy/momentum is being redistributed because the two particles of the outcome exist at the same time, here a probability of 1 must somehow be distributed to the two events.. Given that the incident momentum is p, the reflected -p and the refracted p2, only considering a specific time event i.e. reflection or refraction, does not conserve momentum. In the MB case, a single time event i.e. scattering conserves both momentum and energy. Thus it seems that one does not deal with events in time. There is a distribution of probability in such a way as to ensure conservation of momentum, but does this probability already exist or get created at the interface point? We argued in (3) that if the scenario were deterministic one would have to follow it in time and treat each event separately. Rather we suggest that a distribution of probabilities allows for conservation of momentum, but this means that all three momenta exist at the interface x point as one is not considering an event at a precise point in time. This then allows for each momentum to have its own x distribution based on momentum p so that one may impose conservation of momentum and not have a deterministic time associated with the interface point.. This last idea of conservation of momentum appearing is not discussed in (3) and allows for p to behave like a parameter for x while at the same time being a variable which is conserved. In short, in an MB gas one distributes energy between two colliding particles in order to conserve total energy while for a quantum particle or photon which reflects/refracts one distributes probability to the two scenarios (reflection or refraction) such that momentum is conserved. Thus the nature of what is “distributed” is very different.