Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.06989 · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences

Emergent entanglement structures and self-similarity in quantum spin chains

Boris Sokolov, Matteo A. C. Rossi, Guillermo García-Pérez, Sabrina Maniscalco

Published May 23, 2022• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce an experimentally accessible network representation for many-body quantum states based on entanglement between all pairs of its constituents. We illustrate the power of this representation by applying it to a paradigmatic spin chain model, the XX model, and showing that it brings to light new phenomena. The analysis of these entanglement networks reveals that the gradual establishment of quasi-long range order is accompanied by a symmetry regarding single-spin concurrence distributions, as well as by instabilities in the network topology. Moreover, we identify the existence of emergent entanglement structures, spatially localized communities enforced by the global symmetry of the system that can be revealed by model-agnostic community detection algorithms. The network representation further unveils the existence of structural classes and a cyclic self-similarity in the state, which we conjecture to be intimately linked to the community structure. Our results demonstrate that the use of tools and concepts from complex network theory enables the discovery, understanding and description of new physical phenomena even in models studied for decades. This article is part of the theme issue 'Emergent phenomena in complex physical and socio-technical systems: from cells to societies'.

DOI
10.1098/rsta.2020.0421

Related papers

Exploring entanglement phenomena with near-term quantum computers

Anton Nykänen

A methodology to explore quantum entanglement phenomena on near-term quantum computers is presented. The method combines two prominent Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) algorithms, the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and pairwise tomography, to extract pairwise quantum properties from quantum many-body systems. VQE prepares a parametrized quantum circuit and optimizes it to represent the ground state of the system under study. Pairwise tomography provides an exponential decrease in the required measurements to construct two-qubit reduced density matrices. Two pairwise quantities, mutual information and concurrence, are used to construct complex network representations of the system. Then, network properties can be used to analyze the entanglement structures. Three quantum spin chains are explored: the Ising model, the spin-1/2 XX model and the XXZ model. The methodology is benchmarked with known results and new results for the XXZ model are presented. Applications for the study of fundamental physics are explored. More specifically, emergent space from quantum entanglement is studied. Mutual information between parts of a redundancy-constrained system is used to define a metric that is then embedded into a smooth manifold embedded in Rᴰ. Effects of entanglement perturbations on the geometry of the embedding are studied.

•Jul 2, 2021•0 citations

Quantum physics in connected worlds

Joseph Tindall, Amy Kate Searle, Abdulla Alhajri +1 more

Theoretical research into many-body quantum systems has mostly focused on regular structures which have a small, simple unit cell and where a vanishingly small fraction of the pairs of the constituents directly interact. Motivated by advances in control over the pairwise interactions in many-body simulators, we determine the fate of spin systems on more general, arbitrary graphs. Placing the minimum possible constraints on the underlying graph, we prove how, with certainty in the thermodynamic limit, such systems behave like a single collective spin. We thus understand the emergence of complex many-body physics as dependent on 'exceptional', geometrically constrained structures such as the low-dimensional, regular ones found in nature. Within the space of dense graphs we identify hitherto unknown exceptions via their inhomogeneity and observe how complexity is heralded in these systems by entanglement and highly non-uniform correlation functions. Our work paves the way for the discovery and exploitation of a whole class of geometries which can host uniquely complex phases of matter.

arXiv:2205.07924•Nature Communications•Dec 2, 2022•11 citations

Tensor network methods for quantum phases

Jacob C. Bridgeman

The physics that emerges when large numbers of particles interact can be complex and exotic. The collective behaviour may not reflect the underlying constituents, for example fermionic quasiparticles can emerge from models of interacting bosons. Due to this emergent complexity, manybody phenomena can be very challenging to study, but also very useful. A theoretical understanding of such systems is important for robust quantum information storage and processing. The emergent, macroscopic physics can be classified using the idea of a quantum phase. All models within a given phase exhibit similar low-energy emergent physics, which is distinct from that displayed by models in different phases. In this thesis, we utilise tensor networks to study many-body systems in a range of quantum phases. These include topologically ordered phases, gapless symmetry-protected phases, and symmetry-enriched topological phases.

•Sep 8, 2017•0 citations

Applications of Tensor Network Algorithms in Quantum Many-Body Physics

Colin G. West

The classical simulation of many-body quantum systems is an essential tool in understanding many fundamental aspects of condensed matter physics. But a major obstacle arises from the number of degrees of freedom involved in describing such systems, which is exponential in the system size. Recently, however, a class of numerical techniques based on structures called "tensor networks" has emerged, which allows many "typical" quantum states (such as the ground states of gapped, local Hamiltonians) to be represented much more efficiently. In this work we extend and apply these techniques to consider several central topics in quantum many-body physics. After reviewing the relevant background material from the field of tensor networks and tensor network states, we demonstrate a method for computing high order moments and cumulants of operators with respect to such states, including the so-called "Binder cumulant," a powerful tool for detecting phase transitions. Next, we employ tensor network algorithms to characterize the ground state phase diagram of a quantum spin model, including both symmetry-breaking phases and symmetry protected topological order, and find a signicant variety of phases and phase transitions. Finally, we consider the entanglement properties of quantum states exhibiting many-body localization, using a combination of exact diagonalization and tensor network techniques. | 231 pages

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Entanglement Entropy in Tunable-Range Quantum Networks

AZZALI, ANDREA

Motivated by recent advances in quantum technologies, we investigate entanglement spreading and excitation transport within quantum complex networks. For this purpose, we adopt a description in which network nodes represent sites of the physical system (e.g. qubits), and links represent pairs of sites coupled by the Hamiltonian [Bentsen et al., Phys Rev Lett (2019)]. We consider a random tunable-range model [Gori et al., Phys Rev E (2017)] which, in terms of only two parameters, encompasses a large variety of graphs and reduces, in limiting cases, to well-studied benchmarks. Then, it is equipped with a paradigmatic Hamiltonian consisting of hopping terms on the network links. Building on known results [Gori et al., Phys Rev E (2017)], we first study the classical case, providing new semi-analytical estimates. We then address quantum dynamics: For the single-particle case, we analyse the asymptotic entanglement entropy between two halves of the system, computed by Exact Diagonalization. Surprisingly, we observe a new localization region for intermediate ranges of the network links. To understand this phenomenon, we introduce an approximate one-dimensional model and try to relate dynamics to network measures. The analysis is extended to half-filling using fermionic Gaussian states, obtaining results close to the single-particle ones that raise new interesting questions for future work. It is concluded that this model exhibits non-trivial behaviour, especially in the region where unexpected localization occurs. We infer that this is determined by the interplay between network features and quantum effects, possibly induced by structural disorder.

•Sep 17, 2025•0 citations

Link representation of the entanglement entropies for all bipartitions

Sudipto Singha Roy, Silvia N. Santalla, Germán Sierra +1 more

Abstract We have recently shown that the entanglement entropy of any bipartition of a quantum state can be approximated as the sum of certain link strengths connecting internal and external sites. The representation is useful to unveil the geometry associated with the entanglement structure of a quantum many-body state which may occasionally differ from the one suggested by the Hamiltonian of the system. Yet, the obtention of these entanglement links is a complex mathematical problem. In this work, we address this issue and propose several approximation techniques for matrix product states, free fermionic states, or in cases in which contiguous blocks are specially relevant. Along with this, we discuss the accuracy of the approximation for different types of states and partitions. Finally, we employ the link representation to discuss two different physical systems: the spin-1/2 long-range XXZ chain and the spin-1 bilinear biquadratic chain.

arXiv:2103.08929•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 10, 2021•14 citations
We introduce an experimentally accessible network representation for many-body quantum states based on entanglement between all pairs of its constituents. We illustrate the power of this representation by applying it to a paradigmatic spin chain model, the XX model, and showing that it brings to light new phenomena. The analysis of these entanglement networks reveals that the gradual establishment of quasi-long range order is accompanied by a symmetry regarding single-spin concurrence distributions, as well as by instabilities in the network topology. Moreover, we identify the existence of emergent entanglement structures, spatially localized communities enforced by the global symmetry of the system that can be revealed by model-agnostic community detection algorithms. The network representation further unveils the existence of structural classes and a cyclic self-similarity in the state, which we conjecture to be intimately linked to the community structure. Our results demonstrate that the use of tools and concepts from complex network theory enables the discovery, understanding and description of new physical phenomena even in models studied for decades. This article is part of the theme issue 'Emergent phenomena in complex physical and socio-technical systems: from cells to societies'.
A methodology to explore quantum entanglement phenomena on near-term quantum computers is presented. The method combines two prominent Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) algorithms, the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and pairwise tomography, to extract pairwise quantum properties from quantum many-body systems. VQE prepares a parametrized quantum circuit and optimizes it to represent the ground state of the system under study. Pairwise tomography provides an exponential decrease in the required measurements to construct two-qubit reduced density matrices. Two pairwise quantities, mutual information and concurrence, are used to construct complex network representations of the system. Then, network properties can be used to analyze the entanglement structures. Three quantum spin chains are explored: the Ising model, the spin-1/2 XX model and the XXZ model. The methodology is benchmarked with known results and new results for the XXZ model are presented. Applications for the study of fundamental physics are explored. More specifically, emergent space from quantum entanglement is studied. Mutual information between parts of a redundancy-constrained system is used to define a metric that is then embedded into a smooth manifold embedded in Rᴰ. Effects of entanglement perturbations on the geometry of the embedding are studied.
Theoretical research into many-body quantum systems has mostly focused on regular structures which have a small, simple unit cell and where a vanishingly small fraction of the pairs of the constituents directly interact. Motivated by advances in control over the pairwise interactions in many-body simulators, we determine the fate of spin systems on more general, arbitrary graphs. Placing the minimum possible constraints on the underlying graph, we prove how, with certainty in the thermodynamic limit, such systems behave like a single collective spin. We thus understand the emergence of complex many-body physics as dependent on 'exceptional', geometrically constrained structures such as the low-dimensional, regular ones found in nature. Within the space of dense graphs we identify hitherto unknown exceptions via their inhomogeneity and observe how complexity is heralded in these systems by entanglement and highly non-uniform correlation functions. Our work paves the way for the discovery and exploitation of a whole class of geometries which can host uniquely complex phases of matter.
The physics that emerges when large numbers of particles interact can be complex and exotic. The collective behaviour may not reflect the underlying constituents, for example fermionic quasiparticles can emerge from models of interacting bosons. Due to this emergent complexity, manybody phenomena can be very challenging to study, but also very useful. A theoretical understanding of such systems is important for robust quantum information storage and processing. The emergent, macroscopic physics can be classified using the idea of a quantum phase. All models within a given phase exhibit similar low-energy emergent physics, which is distinct from that displayed by models in different phases. In this thesis, we utilise tensor networks to study many-body systems in a range of quantum phases. These include topologically ordered phases, gapless symmetry-protected phases, and symmetry-enriched topological phases.
The classical simulation of many-body quantum systems is an essential tool in understanding many fundamental aspects of condensed matter physics. But a major obstacle arises from the number of degrees of freedom involved in describing such systems, which is exponential in the system size. Recently, however, a class of numerical techniques based on structures called "tensor networks" has emerged, which allows many "typical" quantum states (such as the ground states of gapped, local Hamiltonians) to be represented much more efficiently. In this work we extend and apply these techniques to consider several central topics in quantum many-body physics. After reviewing the relevant background material from the field of tensor networks and tensor network states, we demonstrate a method for computing high order moments and cumulants of operators with respect to such states, including the so-called "Binder cumulant," a powerful tool for detecting phase transitions. Next, we employ tensor network algorithms to characterize the ground state phase diagram of a quantum spin model, including both symmetry-breaking phases and symmetry protected topological order, and find a signicant variety of phases and phase transitions. Finally, we consider the entanglement properties of quantum states exhibiting many-body localization, using a combination of exact diagonalization and tensor network techniques. | 231 pages
Motivated by recent advances in quantum technologies, we investigate entanglement spreading and excitation transport within quantum complex networks. For this purpose, we adopt a description in which network nodes represent sites of the physical system (e.g. qubits), and links represent pairs of sites coupled by the Hamiltonian [Bentsen et al., Phys Rev Lett (2019)]. We consider a random tunable-range model [Gori et al., Phys Rev E (2017)] which, in terms of only two parameters, encompasses a large variety of graphs and reduces, in limiting cases, to well-studied benchmarks. Then, it is equipped with a paradigmatic Hamiltonian consisting of hopping terms on the network links. Building on known results [Gori et al., Phys Rev E (2017)], we first study the classical case, providing new semi-analytical estimates. We then address quantum dynamics: For the single-particle case, we analyse the asymptotic entanglement entropy between two halves of the system, computed by Exact Diagonalization. Surprisingly, we observe a new localization region for intermediate ranges of the network links. To understand this phenomenon, we introduce an approximate one-dimensional model and try to relate dynamics to network measures. The analysis is extended to half-filling using fermionic Gaussian states, obtaining results close to the single-particle ones that raise new interesting questions for future work. It is concluded that this model exhibits non-trivial behaviour, especially in the region where unexpected localization occurs. We infer that this is determined by the interplay between network features and quantum effects, possibly induced by structural disorder.
Abstract We have recently shown that the entanglement entropy of any bipartition of a quantum state can be approximated as the sum of certain link strengths connecting internal and external sites. The representation is useful to unveil the geometry associated with the entanglement structure of a quantum many-body state which may occasionally differ from the one suggested by the Hamiltonian of the system. Yet, the obtention of these entanglement links is a complex mathematical problem. In this work, we address this issue and propose several approximation techniques for matrix product states, free fermionic states, or in cases in which contiguous blocks are specially relevant. Along with this, we discuss the accuracy of the approximation for different types of states and partitions. Finally, we employ the link representation to discuss two different physical systems: the spin-1/2 long-range XXZ chain and the spin-1 bilinear biquadratic chain.