Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.01307 · Physical Review X

Autonomous Temporal Probability Concentration: Clockworks and the Second Law of Thermodynamics

Emanuel Schwarzhans, Maximilian P. E. Lock, Paul Erker, Nicolai Friis, Marcus Huber

Published Mar 8, 2021• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

According to thermodynamics, the inevitable increase of entropy allows the past to be distinguished from the future.From this perspective, any clock must incorporate an irreversible process that allows this flow of entropy to be tracked.In addition, an integral part of a clock is a clockwork, that is, a system whose purpose is to temporally concentrate the irreversible events that drive this entropic flow, thereby increasing the accuracy of the resulting clock ticks compared to counting purely random equilibration events.In this article, we formalize the task of autonomous temporal probability concentration as the inherent goal of any clockwork based on thermal gradients.Within this framework, we show that a perfect clockwork can be approximated arbitrarily well by increasing its complexity.Furthermore, we combine such an idealized clockwork model, comprised of many qubits, with an irreversible decay mechanism to showcase the ultimate thermodynamic limits to the measurement of time.

DOI
10.1103/physrevx.11.011046

Related papers

Fundamental Accuracy-Resolution Trade-Off for Timekeeping Devices

Florian Meier, Emanuel Schwarzhans, Paul Erker +1 more

From a thermodynamic point of view, all clocks are driven by irreversible processes. Additionally, one can use oscillatory systems to temporally modulate the thermodynamic flux towards equilibrium. Focusing on the most elementary thermalization events, this modulation can be thought of as a temporal probability concentration for these events. There are two fundamental factors limiting the performance of clocks: On the one level, the inevitable drifts of the oscillatory system, which are addressed by finding stable atomic or nuclear transitions that lead to astounding precision of today's clocks. On the other level, there is the intrinsically stochastic nature of the irreversible events upon which the clock's operation is based. This becomes relevant when seeking to maximize a clock's resolution at high accuracy, which is ultimately limited by the number of such stochastic events per reference time unit. We address this essential trade-off between clock accuracy and resolution, proving a universal bound for all clocks whose elementary thermalization events are memoryless.

arXiv:2301.05173•Physical Review Letters•Nov 28, 2023•32 citations

Autonomous Quantum Clocks: Does Thermodynamics Limit Our Ability to Measure Time?

Paul Erker, Mark T. Mitchison, Ralph Silva +3 more

Time remains one of the least well-understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics.A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time.One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly.Here, we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous.Specifically, our autonomous quantum clock consists of a system out of thermal equilibrium-a prerequisite for any system to function as a clock-powered by minimal resources, namely, two thermal baths at different temperatures.Through a detailed analysis of this specific clock model, we find that the laws of thermodynamics dictate a trade-off between the amount of dissipated heat and the clock's performance in terms of its accuracy and resolution.Our results furthermore imply that a fundamental entropy production is associated with the operation of any autonomous quantum clock, assuming that quantum machines cannot achieve perfect efficiency at finite power.More generally, autonomous clocks provide a natural framework for the exploration of fundamental questions about time in quantum theory and beyond.

arXiv:1609.06704•Physical Review X•Aug 2, 2017•165 citations

Feedback-Induced Advantage in Quantum Clockworks

Jakob Miller, Paul Erker

Atomic frequency standards have achieved steadily increasing precision over the past seventy years, enabled in part by feedback mechanisms that stabilise their output. In parallel, the timekeeping capabilities of quantum systems have been explored within the recently developed ticking-clock framework, which models clocks as dynamical systems producing a stochastic sequence of ticks. However, a theoretical description that unifies these perspectives and incorporates feedback into autonomous quantum clocks has been lacking. We introduce a framework for feedback-controlled clockworks in which classical information extracted from the tick sequence is used to influence the subsequent dynamics of the clock. We show that such feedback preserves the core structural features of self-timing and clockwork independence that characterise autonomous ticking clocks. We further identify the signal-to-noise ratio $\mathfrak{S}$ as the fundamental figure of merit for assessing the performance of feedback-controlled clocks. Applying our framework to two representative architectures, we prove that classical clockworks cannot surpass the optimal signal-to-noise ratio achievable without feedback. In contrast, for quantum clockworks we present numerical evidence that feedback can provide a genuine and robust performance enhancement, improving the maximal attainable signal-to-noise ratio. We provide additional numerical evidence, suggesting that the magnitude of the improvement strongly depends on the amount and type of the stored, classical information. These results establish feedback as a potentially essential ingredient in pushing the fundamental limits of timekeeping in the quantum regime.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04556•Mar 6, 2026•1 citation

The Thermodynamic Cost of Measuring Time

Anthony Short

Time remains one of the least well-understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics.A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time.One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly.Here, we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous.Specifically, our autonomous quantum clock consists of a system out of thermal equilibrium-a prerequisite for any system to function as a clock-powered by minimal resources, namely, two thermal baths at different temperatures.Through a detailed analysis of this specific clock model, we find that the laws of thermodynamics dictate a trade-off between the amount of dissipated heat and the clock's performance in terms of its accuracy and resolution.Our results furthermore imply that a fundamental entropy production is associated with the operation of any autonomous quantum clock, assuming that quantum machines cannot achieve perfect efficiency at finite power.More generally, autonomous clocks provide a natural framework for the exploration of fundamental questions about time in quantum theory and beyond.

Physics•Aug 2, 2017•0 citations

Autonomous machines and clocks in quantum thermodynamics

Max F. Frenzel

Thermodynamics is one of the core disciplines of physics, and despite its long history it is still a very active area of research. Particularly in the regime of non-equilibrium processes and at small scales many open questions remain. In this thesis we critically study the role that autonomous machines play in the emerging field of quantum thermodynamics. We show that autonomous machines generally comprise several interacting subsystems that can take on various roles. In Part I we look at the issue of external control. Any non-autonomous machine by definition requires some external agent to interact with the machine. This agent is generally assumed to be classical and to not suffer any back-actions from the machine. If all the involved systems are of microscopic size this approximation is no longer valid and we have to include all the control mechanisms within a unified quantum framework. We show that in order to avoid external control and operate autonomously, a machine that is to extract work from another system requires an inbuilt quantum clock. Being itself a finite-size quantum system, such a clock will inevitably experience back-actions and develop correlations with the other systems, which lead to its degradation as a time keeping device. We show that this degradation can be counteracted by a judicious choice of quantum measurements. These measurements not only allow us to stabilise the clock, but also magnify thermodynamic properties such as work from the quantum scale, where their definition can be ambiguous, to the well understood classical scale. In Part II we consider the scenario of an autonomous quantum machine interacting with a thermal environment, for which we are experimentally restricted to only observe a subset of all the possible environment interactions, while the remaining ones are hidden from direct observation. Using a modification of the notion of quantum jump trajectories we show that the visible interactions in many cases still allow us to make some inferences about the hidden interactions. We introduce a new quantity, the coarse-grained hidden entropy, which quantifies the entropy production in the hidden subsystem conditioned on our observations of the visible part. The total entropy production consisting of the sum of visible and coarse-grained hidden entropy is shown to satisfy an integral fluctuations theorem. Depending on the information flow between the subsystems, the hidden entropy can assume negative values in which case the hidden systems acts as a Maxwell's demon. This behaviour is also captured by a modified second law like inequality which gives a refinement of the conventional second law for autonomous quantum machines with continuous information flows between the machine's subsystems.

•Oct 1, 2016•0 citations

Thermalization and irreversibility of an isolated quantum system II

Guo, Xue-Yi

The irreversible entropy increase described by the second law of thermodynamics is fundamentally tied to thermalization and the emergence of equilibrium. In the first part of our work (Ref: arXiv.2503.04152), we constructed an isolated gas system model and numerically demonstrated irreversible growth of entanglement entropy caused by erasure of spread non-equilibrium state information. Here, we mathematically prove that for a typical macroscopic system in a non-equilibrium state $|ϕ_0\rangle$, the quantum state $|ϕ'_0\rangle = \hat{O}(t)|ϕ_0\rangle$ will inevitably evolve toward equilibrium. Our work demonstrates that the second law of thermodynamics, and consequently the ergodic hypothesis in statistical physics, can be understood and proven from a quantum information perspective. From this perspective, the second law can be stated as: In typical macroscopic physical systems, the spreading and erasure of non-equilibrium information is inevitable.

arXiv:2506.01351•Jun 2, 2025•1 citation
According to thermodynamics, the inevitable increase of entropy allows the past to be distinguished from the future.From this perspective, any clock must incorporate an irreversible process that allows this flow of entropy to be tracked.In addition, an integral part of a clock is a clockwork, that is, a system whose purpose is to temporally concentrate the irreversible events that drive this entropic flow, thereby increasing the accuracy of the resulting clock ticks compared to counting purely random equilibration events.In this article, we formalize the task of autonomous temporal probability concentration as the inherent goal of any clockwork based on thermal gradients.Within this framework, we show that a perfect clockwork can be approximated arbitrarily well by increasing its complexity.Furthermore, we combine such an idealized clockwork model, comprised of many qubits, with an irreversible decay mechanism to showcase the ultimate thermodynamic limits to the measurement of time.
From a thermodynamic point of view, all clocks are driven by irreversible processes. Additionally, one can use oscillatory systems to temporally modulate the thermodynamic flux towards equilibrium. Focusing on the most elementary thermalization events, this modulation can be thought of as a temporal probability concentration for these events. There are two fundamental factors limiting the performance of clocks: On the one level, the inevitable drifts of the oscillatory system, which are addressed by finding stable atomic or nuclear transitions that lead to astounding precision of today's clocks. On the other level, there is the intrinsically stochastic nature of the irreversible events upon which the clock's operation is based. This becomes relevant when seeking to maximize a clock's resolution at high accuracy, which is ultimately limited by the number of such stochastic events per reference time unit. We address this essential trade-off between clock accuracy and resolution, proving a universal bound for all clocks whose elementary thermalization events are memoryless.
Time remains one of the least well-understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics.A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time.One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly.Here, we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous.Specifically, our autonomous quantum clock consists of a system out of thermal equilibrium-a prerequisite for any system to function as a clock-powered by minimal resources, namely, two thermal baths at different temperatures.Through a detailed analysis of this specific clock model, we find that the laws of thermodynamics dictate a trade-off between the amount of dissipated heat and the clock's performance in terms of its accuracy and resolution.Our results furthermore imply that a fundamental entropy production is associated with the operation of any autonomous quantum clock, assuming that quantum machines cannot achieve perfect efficiency at finite power.More generally, autonomous clocks provide a natural framework for the exploration of fundamental questions about time in quantum theory and beyond.
Atomic frequency standards have achieved steadily increasing precision over the past seventy years, enabled in part by feedback mechanisms that stabilise their output. In parallel, the timekeeping capabilities of quantum systems have been explored within the recently developed ticking-clock framework, which models clocks as dynamical systems producing a stochastic sequence of ticks. However, a theoretical description that unifies these perspectives and incorporates feedback into autonomous quantum clocks has been lacking. We introduce a framework for feedback-controlled clockworks in which classical information extracted from the tick sequence is used to influence the subsequent dynamics of the clock. We show that such feedback preserves the core structural features of self-timing and clockwork independence that characterise autonomous ticking clocks. We further identify the signal-to-noise ratio S\mathfrak{S}S as the fundamental figure of merit for assessing the performance of feedback-controlled clocks. Applying our framework to two representative architectures, we prove that classical clockworks cannot surpass the optimal signal-to-noise ratio achievable without feedback. In contrast, for quantum clockworks we present numerical evidence that feedback can provide a genuine and robust performance enhancement, improving the maximal attainable signal-to-noise ratio. We provide additional numerical evidence, suggesting that the magnitude of the improvement strongly depends on the amount and type of the stored, classical information. These results establish feedback as a potentially essential ingredient in pushing the fundamental limits of timekeeping in the quantum regime.
Time remains one of the least well-understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics.A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time.One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly.Here, we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous.Specifically, our autonomous quantum clock consists of a system out of thermal equilibrium-a prerequisite for any system to function as a clock-powered by minimal resources, namely, two thermal baths at different temperatures.Through a detailed analysis of this specific clock model, we find that the laws of thermodynamics dictate a trade-off between the amount of dissipated heat and the clock's performance in terms of its accuracy and resolution.Our results furthermore imply that a fundamental entropy production is associated with the operation of any autonomous quantum clock, assuming that quantum machines cannot achieve perfect efficiency at finite power.More generally, autonomous clocks provide a natural framework for the exploration of fundamental questions about time in quantum theory and beyond.
Thermodynamics is one of the core disciplines of physics, and despite its long history it is still a very active area of research. Particularly in the regime of non-equilibrium processes and at small scales many open questions remain. In this thesis we critically study the role that autonomous machines play in the emerging field of quantum thermodynamics. We show that autonomous machines generally comprise several interacting subsystems that can take on various roles. In Part I we look at the issue of external control. Any non-autonomous machine by definition requires some external agent to interact with the machine. This agent is generally assumed to be classical and to not suffer any back-actions from the machine. If all the involved systems are of microscopic size this approximation is no longer valid and we have to include all the control mechanisms within a unified quantum framework. We show that in order to avoid external control and operate autonomously, a machine that is to extract work from another system requires an inbuilt quantum clock. Being itself a finite-size quantum system, such a clock will inevitably experience back-actions and develop correlations with the other systems, which lead to its degradation as a time keeping device. We show that this degradation can be counteracted by a judicious choice of quantum measurements. These measurements not only allow us to stabilise the clock, but also magnify thermodynamic properties such as work from the quantum scale, where their definition can be ambiguous, to the well understood classical scale. In Part II we consider the scenario of an autonomous quantum machine interacting with a thermal environment, for which we are experimentally restricted to only observe a subset of all the possible environment interactions, while the remaining ones are hidden from direct observation. Using a modification of the notion of quantum jump trajectories we show that the visible interactions in many cases still allow us to make some inferences about the hidden interactions. We introduce a new quantity, the coarse-grained hidden entropy, which quantifies the entropy production in the hidden subsystem conditioned on our observations of the visible part. The total entropy production consisting of the sum of visible and coarse-grained hidden entropy is shown to satisfy an integral fluctuations theorem. Depending on the information flow between the subsystems, the hidden entropy can assume negative values in which case the hidden systems acts as a Maxwell's demon. This behaviour is also captured by a modified second law like inequality which gives a refinement of the conventional second law for autonomous quantum machines with continuous information flows between the machine's subsystems.
The irreversible entropy increase described by the second law of thermodynamics is fundamentally tied to thermalization and the emergence of equilibrium. In the first part of our work (Ref: arXiv.2503.04152), we constructed an isolated gas system model and numerically demonstrated irreversible growth of entanglement entropy caused by erasure of spread non-equilibrium state information. Here, we mathematically prove that for a typical macroscopic system in a non-equilibrium state ∣ϕ0⟩|ϕ_0\rangle∣ϕ0​⟩, the quantum state ∣ϕ0′⟩=O^(t)∣ϕ0⟩|ϕ'_0\rangle = \hat{O}(t)|ϕ_0\rangle∣ϕ0′​⟩=O^(t)∣ϕ0​⟩ will inevitably evolve toward equilibrium. Our work demonstrates that the second law of thermodynamics, and consequently the ergodic hypothesis in statistical physics, can be understood and proven from a quantum information perspective. From this perspective, the second law can be stated as: In typical macroscopic physical systems, the spreading and erasure of non-equilibrium information is inevitable.