Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.11365 · Symmetry

Symmetry, Transactions, and the Mechanism of Wave Function Collapse

J. G. Cramer, Carver Mead

Published Aug 18, 2020• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Transactional Interpretation of quantum mechanics exploits the intrinsic time-symmetry of wave mechanics to interpret the ψ and ψ* wave functions present in all wave mechanics calculations as representing retarded and advanced waves moving in opposite time directions that form a quantum “handshake” or transaction. This handshake is a 4D standing-wave that builds up across space-time to transfer the conserved quantities of energy, momentum, and angular momentum in an interaction. Here, we derive a two-atom quantum formalism describing a transaction. We show that the bi-directional electromagnetic coupling between atoms can be factored into a matched pair of vector potential Green’s functions: one retarded and one advanced, and that this combination uniquely enforces the conservation of energy in a transaction. Thus factored, the single-electron wave functions of electromagnetically-coupled atoms can be analyzed using Schrödinger’s original wave mechanics. The technique generalizes to any number of electromagnetically coupled single-electron states—no higher-dimensional space is needed. Using this technique, we show a worked example of the transfer of energy from a hydrogen atom in an excited state to a nearby hydrogen atom in its ground state. It is seen that the initial exchange creates a dynamically unstable situation that avalanches to the completed transaction, demonstrating that wave function collapse, considered mysterious in the literature, can be implemented with solutions of Schrödinger’s original wave mechanics, coupled by this unique combination of retarded/advanced vector potentials, without the introduction of any additional mechanism or formalism. We also analyze a simplified version of the photon-splitting and Freedman–Clauser three-electron experiments and show that their results can be predicted by this formalism.

DOI
10.3390/sym12081373

Related papers

The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics

J. G. Cramer

The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics [1] was originally published in 1986 and is now about 14 years old. It is an explicitly nonlocal and Lorentz invariant alternative to the Copenhagen interpretation. It interprets the formalism for a quantum interaction as describing a “handshake” between retarded waves (ψ) and advanced waves (ψ*) for each quantum event or “transaction” in which energy, momentum, angular momentum, and other conserved quantities are transferred. The transactional interpretation offers the advantages that (1) it is actually “visible” in the formalism of quantum mechanics, (2) it is economical, involving fewer independent assumptions than its rivals, (3) it is paradox-free, resolving all of the paradoxes of standard quantum theory including nonlocality and wave function collapse, (4) it does not give a privileged role to observers or measurements, and (5) it permits the visualization of quantum events. We will review the transactional interpretation and some of its applications to “quantum paradoxes.”

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2001•73 citations

The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics

J. G. Cramer

The interpretational problems of quantum mechanics are considered. The way in which the standard Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics deals with these problems is reviewed. A new interpretation of the formalism of quantum mechanics, the transactional interpretation, is presented. The basic element of this interpretation is the transaction describing a quantum event as an exchange of advanced and retarded waves, as implied by the work of Wheeler and Feynman, Dirac, and others. The transactional interpretation is explicitly nonlocal and thereby consistent with recent tests of the Bell inequality, yet is relativistically invariant and fully causal. A detailed comparison of the transactional and Copenhagen interpretations is made in the context of well-known quantum-mechanical Gedankenexperimente and "paradoxes." The transactional interpretation permits quantum-mechanical wave functions to be interpreted as real waves physically present in space rather than as "mathematical representations of knowledge" as in the Copenhagen interpretation. The transactional interpretation is shown to provide insight into the complex character of the quantum-mechanical state vector and the mechanism associated with its "collapse." It also leads in a natural way to justification of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and the Born probability law ($P=\ensuremath{\psi}{\ensuremath{\psi}}^{*}$), basic elements of the Copenhagen interpretation.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 1, 1986•873 citations

The Transactional Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Nonlocality

J. G. Cramer

Quantum nonlocality is discussed as an aspect of the quantum formalism that is seriously in need of interpretation. The Transactional Interpretation of quantum mechanics, which describes quantum processes as transactional "handshakes" between retarded $ψ$ waves and advanced $ψ*$ waves, is discussed. Examples of the use of the Transactional Interpretation in resolving quantum paradoxes and in understanding the counter-intuitive aspects of the formalism, particularly quantum nonlocality, are provided.

arXiv:1503.00039•Feb 28, 2015•19 citations

A Wave–Particle Model of Energy Transfer Between Two Atoms in a Transactional Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Lloyd Watts, Carver Mead

In 2000, Carver Mead introduced a time-symmetrical theory of energy exchange between two atoms, building on the Transactional Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics by John Cramer in 1986. In 2020, Cramer and Mead developed the theory further, proposing a conceptual path integral formulation by which energy could be completely transferred over long distances, and showing that this theory can explain the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox, the Hanbury-Brown–Twiss effect, and the Freedman–Clauser entanglement experiment. In this paper, we develop the theory further, proposing a specific formulation of the interaction between Emitter and Absorber Atoms, in which the energy density is proportional to the root-mean-square of the product of retarded and advanced four-vector potential waves, and show how this interaction efficiently and completely transfers energy from the Emitter Atom to the Absorber Atom over arbitrary distances. We use Mach’s Principle and conservation of energy to find the proportionality constant by matching the mean transition time constant for all possible Absorbers in the universe to the mean transition lifetime computed from Fermi’s Golden Rule, leading to a complete solution with no adjustable parameters. The solution represents the exchange of energy between two atoms, valid over 26 orders of magnitude in Emitter–Absorber distance, from about 0.52 m to the radius of the Hubble Sphere 1.27×1026 m. We define this Wave–Particle Model as the product of a retarded Emitter vector potential wave and an advanced Absorber vector potential wave, which exhibits the particle-like properties of losslessly carrying energy at the speed of light in a straight line from Emitter Atom to Absorber Atom in a vacuum in the absence of gravity.

Entropy•Jul 17, 2026•0 citations

Wave Mechanics

P. J. E. Peebles

This chapter develops the wave mechanics formalism. The emphasis here is on symmetries and conservation laws: parity, linear and angular momentum, and the electromagnetic interaction. The only specific physical application is the completion of the study of an isolated hydrogen atom, with some discussion of the motion of a particle in a magnetic field. The chapter also outlines the general assumptions of quantum wave mechanics, which may be summarized as follows: the state of a physical system is represented by a wave function and each measurable attribute of the system is represented by a linear self-adjoint operator in the space of functions. To apply these general assumptions to a given physical system, one must give a specific prescription for the observables and their algebra, and one must adopt a definite form for the Hamiltonians as a function of the observables.

Princeton University Press eBooks•May 14, 2019•0 citations

Entanglement swapping in the transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics

Louis Marchildon

The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics, which uses retarded and advanced solutions of the Schrodinger equation and its complex conjugate, offers an original way to visualize and understand quantum processes. After a brief review, we show how it can be applied to different quantum situations, emphasizing the importance of specifying a complete configuration of absorbers. We consider in more detail the phenomenon of entanglement swapping, and see how the apparent retroactive enforcement of entanglement can be understood in the transactional interpretation.

arXiv:1312.6398•Physica Scripta•Dec 1, 2014•0 citations
The Transactional Interpretation of quantum mechanics exploits the intrinsic time-symmetry of wave mechanics to interpret the ψ and ψ* wave functions present in all wave mechanics calculations as representing retarded and advanced waves moving in opposite time directions that form a quantum “handshake” or transaction. This handshake is a 4D standing-wave that builds up across space-time to transfer the conserved quantities of energy, momentum, and angular momentum in an interaction. Here, we derive a two-atom quantum formalism describing a transaction. We show that the bi-directional electromagnetic coupling between atoms can be factored into a matched pair of vector potential Green’s functions: one retarded and one advanced, and that this combination uniquely enforces the conservation of energy in a transaction. Thus factored, the single-electron wave functions of electromagnetically-coupled atoms can be analyzed using Schrödinger’s original wave mechanics. The technique generalizes to any number of electromagnetically coupled single-electron states—no higher-dimensional space is needed. Using this technique, we show a worked example of the transfer of energy from a hydrogen atom in an excited state to a nearby hydrogen atom in its ground state. It is seen that the initial exchange creates a dynamically unstable situation that avalanches to the completed transaction, demonstrating that wave function collapse, considered mysterious in the literature, can be implemented with solutions of Schrödinger’s original wave mechanics, coupled by this unique combination of retarded/advanced vector potentials, without the introduction of any additional mechanism or formalism. We also analyze a simplified version of the photon-splitting and Freedman–Clauser three-electron experiments and show that their results can be predicted by this formalism.
The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics [1] was originally published in 1986 and is now about 14 years old. It is an explicitly nonlocal and Lorentz invariant alternative to the Copenhagen interpretation. It interprets the formalism for a quantum interaction as describing a “handshake” between retarded waves (ψ) and advanced waves (ψ*) for each quantum event or “transaction” in which energy, momentum, angular momentum, and other conserved quantities are transferred. The transactional interpretation offers the advantages that (1) it is actually “visible” in the formalism of quantum mechanics, (2) it is economical, involving fewer independent assumptions than its rivals, (3) it is paradox-free, resolving all of the paradoxes of standard quantum theory including nonlocality and wave function collapse, (4) it does not give a privileged role to observers or measurements, and (5) it permits the visualization of quantum events. We will review the transactional interpretation and some of its applications to “quantum paradoxes.”
The interpretational problems of quantum mechanics are considered. The way in which the standard Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics deals with these problems is reviewed. A new interpretation of the formalism of quantum mechanics, the transactional interpretation, is presented. The basic element of this interpretation is the transaction describing a quantum event as an exchange of advanced and retarded waves, as implied by the work of Wheeler and Feynman, Dirac, and others. The transactional interpretation is explicitly nonlocal and thereby consistent with recent tests of the Bell inequality, yet is relativistically invariant and fully causal. A detailed comparison of the transactional and Copenhagen interpretations is made in the context of well-known quantum-mechanical Gedankenexperimente and "paradoxes." The transactional interpretation permits quantum-mechanical wave functions to be interpreted as real waves physically present in space rather than as "mathematical representations of knowledge" as in the Copenhagen interpretation. The transactional interpretation is shown to provide insight into the complex character of the quantum-mechanical state vector and the mechanism associated with its "collapse." It also leads in a natural way to justification of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and the Born probability law ($P=\ensuremath{\psi}{\ensuremath{\psi}}^{*}$), basic elements of the Copenhagen interpretation.
Quantum nonlocality is discussed as an aspect of the quantum formalism that is seriously in need of interpretation. The Transactional Interpretation of quantum mechanics, which describes quantum processes as transactional "handshakes" between retarded ψψψ waves and advanced ψ∗ψ*ψ∗ waves, is discussed. Examples of the use of the Transactional Interpretation in resolving quantum paradoxes and in understanding the counter-intuitive aspects of the formalism, particularly quantum nonlocality, are provided.
In 2000, Carver Mead introduced a time-symmetrical theory of energy exchange between two atoms, building on the Transactional Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics by John Cramer in 1986. In 2020, Cramer and Mead developed the theory further, proposing a conceptual path integral formulation by which energy could be completely transferred over long distances, and showing that this theory can explain the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox, the Hanbury-Brown–Twiss effect, and the Freedman–Clauser entanglement experiment. In this paper, we develop the theory further, proposing a specific formulation of the interaction between Emitter and Absorber Atoms, in which the energy density is proportional to the root-mean-square of the product of retarded and advanced four-vector potential waves, and show how this interaction efficiently and completely transfers energy from the Emitter Atom to the Absorber Atom over arbitrary distances. We use Mach’s Principle and conservation of energy to find the proportionality constant by matching the mean transition time constant for all possible Absorbers in the universe to the mean transition lifetime computed from Fermi’s Golden Rule, leading to a complete solution with no adjustable parameters. The solution represents the exchange of energy between two atoms, valid over 26 orders of magnitude in Emitter–Absorber distance, from about 0.52 m to the radius of the Hubble Sphere 1.27×1026 m. We define this Wave–Particle Model as the product of a retarded Emitter vector potential wave and an advanced Absorber vector potential wave, which exhibits the particle-like properties of losslessly carrying energy at the speed of light in a straight line from Emitter Atom to Absorber Atom in a vacuum in the absence of gravity.
This chapter develops the wave mechanics formalism. The emphasis here is on symmetries and conservation laws: parity, linear and angular momentum, and the electromagnetic interaction. The only specific physical application is the completion of the study of an isolated hydrogen atom, with some discussion of the motion of a particle in a magnetic field. The chapter also outlines the general assumptions of quantum wave mechanics, which may be summarized as follows: the state of a physical system is represented by a wave function and each measurable attribute of the system is represented by a linear self-adjoint operator in the space of functions. To apply these general assumptions to a given physical system, one must give a specific prescription for the observables and their algebra, and one must adopt a definite form for the Hamiltonians as a function of the observables.
The transactional interpretation of quantum mechanics, which uses retarded and advanced solutions of the Schrodinger equation and its complex conjugate, offers an original way to visualize and understand quantum processes. After a brief review, we show how it can be applied to different quantum situations, emphasizing the importance of specifying a complete configuration of absorbers. We consider in more detail the phenomenon of entanglement swapping, and see how the apparent retroactive enforcement of entanglement can be understood in the transactional interpretation.