Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.11329

Quantum and classical approaches in statistical physics: some basic inequalities

Lev Sakhnovich

Published Jun 19, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present some basic inequalities between the classical and quantum values of free energy, entropy and mean energy. We investigate the transition from the deterministic case (classical mechanics) to the probabilistic case (quantum mechanics). In the first part of the paper, we assume that the reduced Planck constant $\hbar$, the absolute temperature $T$, the frequency of an oscillator $ω$, and the degree of freedom of a system $N$ are fixed. This approach to the problem of comparing quantum and classical mechanics is new (see [35]--[37]). In the second part of the paper, we simultaneously derive the semiclassical limits for four cases, that is, for $\hbar{\to}0$, $T{\to}\infty$, $ω{\to}0$, and $N{\to}\infty$. We note that only the case $\hbar{\to}0$ is usually considered in quantum mechanics (see [21]). The cases $T{\to}\infty$ and $ω{\to}0$ in quantum mechanics were initially studied by M. Planck and by A. Einstein, respectively.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2006.11329

Related papers

Quantum and classical approaches in statistical physics: some basic inequalities and game theoretic interpretation

Lev Sakhnovich

We present some basic inequalities between the classical and quantum values of free energy, entropy and mean energy. The extremal principles (e.g., the Fermat's principle of least time and the least action principle), which remain central in modern physics, are formulated in terms of one physical value. Using our inequalities, we give a game theoretic interpretation of the interaction of three physical values, namely, free energy, entropy and mean energy. Such approach is inspired by Neumann--Morgenstern and Nash game theories. According to these game theories, the transition from the deterministic strategy (classical mechanics) to probabilistic strategy (quantum mechanics) increases the winning for all players. In the second part of the paper, we simultaneously derive the quasi-classical limits for four cases, that is, for $h{\to}0$, $T{\to}\infty$, $\omega{\to}0$, and $N{\to}\infty,$ where $h$ is the Planck constant, $T$ is the absolute temperature, $\omega$ is the frequency of an oscillator, and $N$ is the degree of freedom of a system. We note that only the first case is usually considered in quantum physics. The second case was studied initially by M. Planck and the third case by A.~Einstein.

•Jun 19, 2020•0 citations

Quantum and Classical Statistical Systems in Terms of Constraints

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical statistical mechanics/thermodynamics is sometimes portrayed as an approximate approach to describing the classical mechanical motion of very large numbers of particles. Equilibrium statistical mechanics/thermodynamics, however, is a special situation in which thermodynamic averages such as temperature, pressure etc do not change in time. We argue in this note that this is due to constraints imposed on such equilibrium scenarios namely time reversal reaction balance. It is this (approximate) constraint which yields the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution which in turn defines average values of classical values e.g. pressure resulting from an average of bvv (b=constant) and temperature being related to average kinetic energy. Interestingly, average values such as average energy and pressure may yield a classical mechanical relationship for adiabatic processes, otherwise the more complicated dE=TdS - PdV applies to these averages. (To be more accurate one may use the constraints of microcanonical theory.) Quantum mechanics is also a statistical theory because a single particle with a fixed momentum is characterized by a physical wavelength region and a probability distribution exp(ipx). If interactions occur with potential regions a superposition of these distributions (i.e. a momentum superposition) occurs i.e. W(x)= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). This represents one constraint in quantum mechanics), but there is a second, namely that averages for a bound system match classical values. Thus, like classical statistical mechanics one may imagine a system characterized by a parameter say L (box length) which changes such that the particle stays in the same quantum state (i.e. an adiabatic change). Given that bound quantum mechanics is constrained to behave on average as a classical system it is not surprising that a dE=PdV which is essentially a Newton’s second law statement dE=Fdx and is not necessarily linked to a usual statistical system. If a quantum state has its parameter changed nonadiabatically it should be able to have it change into a superposition of new quantum states (new L) which is very different from the classical statistical mechanical scenario. Furthermore the ideal gas relationship PV=NRT and E=3/2NRT (3 degrees of freedom) or PV=(⅔)E matches a classical mechanical result because a particle with p may bounce from a wall yielding an impulse. In this note we try to examine some of these underlying constraints and argue that even dE=PdV for average E and P values (i.e. no entropy change) one must be aware of the specific constraints involved. In other words because dE=PdV for both adiabatic classical statistical mechanical systems and a quantum eigenstate, these do not necessarily represent the same statistical type of physics. We further argue that quantum mechanical bound states are constrained to have some average and rms values such as KE(x) and p rms behave as classical values and so these should not be taken to represent “intrinsic” quantum behaviour while average spatial density on the other hand does. (It is linked to the constraint of wavelength.)

•Oct 22, 2021•0 citations

Relative Probabilities in Quantum and Classical Statistical Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical mechanics in the ideal gas scenario and quantum mechanics make use of a set of energy levels which a single particle may occupy. Thus the problem becomes to determine the probability associated with ei i.e. P(ei). In this note we take the approach that relative probabilities depend on the energy gap in question. For example, consider a quantum two level system where ei values are provided by the time-independent Schrodinger equation. From the point of view of statistics, these are simply a set of ei values. Their associated physics is contained in the Schrodinger equation. For the quantum two level system one must find the relative probabilities PR(e1) and PR(e2). Next, imagine a quantum system with many levels and assume for the sake of argument there are levels e1,e2 and ei,e(i+1) such that e2-e1=e(i+1)-ei. If the mechanism is the same for jumping from e1 to e2 and from ei to e(i+1) (i.e. absorbing a photon of the same energy), one might argue that the relative probabilities PR(e2)/PR(e1) = PR(e(i+1))/PR(ei). From this one may obtain the Maxwell-Boltzman result exp(-ei/T)). Note that levels do not need to be adjacent. For example in a large level system one might consider e1 and e3 and any ei and ej such that e3-e1 = ej - ei. In some situations this may need to be modified (e.g. fermions and bosons have enhancements and there may be level related issues), but as a first step we argue that insisting on relative probabilities being dependent on ei-ej has important consequences. Furthermore, in such a case the normalization constant for these relative probabilities i.e. C(T)= Sum over i exp(-ei/T) is important. Taking ln(C(T) and then taking the derivative d/dT yields an expression proportional to the average energy. An expression for dE/dT dT, however, would lead to a second order differential equation in ln(C(T)). If one introduces a new function S such that E-TS = -Tln(C), then one may show that dE/dT = T dS/dT i.e. entropy S emerges.

•Mar 3, 2022•0 citations

Single Equilibration in Classical Statistical versus Double in Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

We argue that classical statistical mechanics (say of an ideal gas) is based on a single equilibration scheme characterized by a temperature T (even in the presence of a potential V(x)). This single scheme is based on the maximization of entropy (subject to an average energy constraint) in order to determine probabilities for p,v and x. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, is based on two equilibration schemes, we argue. The first is due to a built-in probability of exp(ipx) for a free particle. In this case, a potential V(x) interacts with momentum (impulse hits) to create a potential energy. No velocity appears in the creation of potential energy, but does appear in the creation of average kinetic energy. Like with a classical mechanical bound state, energy becomes a system variable. This is the first equilibration. We argue that it should have its own entropy. The probability form exp(ipx) together with conservation of energy and boundary conditions fix allowable single particle energy values (which are discrete) unlike in the classical statistical mechanical case. The second equilibration occurs if there exists a mechanism for moving from one discrete E to another, e.g. photon emission/absorption. This equilibration is based on maximization of entropy (a second entropy), but the effects of the first equilibration remain because it is this first scheme which controls allowable E values. We also argue that exp(-i Et) from the first equilibration scheme may affect the usual entropy based on exp(-E/T) used in the second scheme.

•Jul 17, 2023•0 citations

Statistical Context of Semiclassical Quantum Variance and Entropy

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical mechanics is deterministic in that it links x and t i.e. x(t) from which one may take derivatives to obtain velocity and acceleration. We argued in (1) that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory which represents the decoupling of x and t. If this is the case, what does it mean to say that large n approaches classical mechanics (correspondence principle) or to use semiclassical approaches such as Integral p dx = n3.14 where the integral is between the classical turning points? We consider this question and also try to apply the semiclassical approaches of (2) to the calculation of the variance of p and x. In particular we consider a particle in a box with infinite potential walls and an oscillator. We also consider Sp = - Integral dp a(p)a(p) ln[a(p)a(p)] where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and try to argue that this quantity may not have a semiclassical analogue while Sx = - Integral dx W(x)W(x) ln[W(x)W(x)] does. In other words there may be a spatial correspondence principle, but not a momentum one with respect to Shannon’s entropy.

•May 18, 2022•0 citations

Statistical Similarities Between Quantum Mechanics and Statistical Mechanics in the Case of an Oscillator

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Both quantum mechanics and classical statistical mechanics predict the same momentum and spatial density forms forms for the solution of an oscillator. In the case of quantum mechanics, the ground state is considered. One may ask whether this is a coincidence, and if not, why two seemingly different theories should lead to the same result for the oscillator case. We argue in this note that it is the form of the conservation equation of the oscillator which leads to x and p having the same probability distribution.Furthermore, given that both quantum mechanics and classical statistical mechanics are of a statistical nature, one may inquire into the actual nature of the statistics being used, the meaning behind averages being used. For example, the classical deterministic solution of an oscillator can be written in statistical terms by removing time dependence and using density = dx/v. This does not mean, however, that the actual physical motion is no longer deterministic. In addition, we try to argue that quantum mechanics may be a more detailed statistical model including dynamics which satisfies the more static statistical result of spatial density for classical statistical mechanics.

•Dec 13, 2018•0 citations
We present some basic inequalities between the classical and quantum values of free energy, entropy and mean energy. We investigate the transition from the deterministic case (classical mechanics) to the probabilistic case (quantum mechanics). In the first part of the paper, we assume that the reduced Planck constant ℏ\hbarℏ, the absolute temperature TTT, the frequency of an oscillator ωωω, and the degree of freedom of a system NNN are fixed. This approach to the problem of comparing quantum and classical mechanics is new (see [35]--[37]). In the second part of the paper, we simultaneously derive the semiclassical limits for four cases, that is, for ℏ→0\hbar{\to}0ℏ→0, T→∞T{\to}\inftyT→∞, ω→0ω{\to}0ω→0, and N→∞N{\to}\inftyN→∞. We note that only the case ℏ→0\hbar{\to}0ℏ→0 is usually considered in quantum mechanics (see [21]). The cases T→∞T{\to}\inftyT→∞ and ω→0ω{\to}0ω→0 in quantum mechanics were initially studied by M. Planck and by A. Einstein, respectively.
We present some basic inequalities between the classical and quantum values of free energy, entropy and mean energy. The extremal principles (e.g., the Fermat's principle of least time and the least action principle), which remain central in modern physics, are formulated in terms of one physical value. Using our inequalities, we give a game theoretic interpretation of the interaction of three physical values, namely, free energy, entropy and mean energy. Such approach is inspired by Neumann--Morgenstern and Nash game theories. According to these game theories, the transition from the deterministic strategy (classical mechanics) to probabilistic strategy (quantum mechanics) increases the winning for all players. In the second part of the paper, we simultaneously derive the quasi-classical limits for four cases, that is, for h→0h{\to}0h→0, T→∞T{\to}\inftyT→∞, ω→0\omega{\to}0ω→0, and N→∞,N{\to}\infty,N→∞, where hhh is the Planck constant, TTT is the absolute temperature, ω\omegaω is the frequency of an oscillator, and NNN is the degree of freedom of a system. We note that only the first case is usually considered in quantum physics. The second case was studied initially by M. Planck and the third case by A.~Einstein.
Classical statistical mechanics/thermodynamics is sometimes portrayed as an approximate approach to describing the classical mechanical motion of very large numbers of particles. Equilibrium statistical mechanics/thermodynamics, however, is a special situation in which thermodynamic averages such as temperature, pressure etc do not change in time. We argue in this note that this is due to constraints imposed on such equilibrium scenarios namely time reversal reaction balance. It is this (approximate) constraint which yields the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution which in turn defines average values of classical values e.g. pressure resulting from an average of bvv (b=constant) and temperature being related to average kinetic energy. Interestingly, average values such as average energy and pressure may yield a classical mechanical relationship for adiabatic processes, otherwise the more complicated dE=TdS - PdV applies to these averages. (To be more accurate one may use the constraints of microcanonical theory.) Quantum mechanics is also a statistical theory because a single particle with a fixed momentum is characterized by a physical wavelength region and a probability distribution exp(ipx). If interactions occur with potential regions a superposition of these distributions (i.e. a momentum superposition) occurs i.e. W(x)= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). This represents one constraint in quantum mechanics), but there is a second, namely that averages for a bound system match classical values. Thus, like classical statistical mechanics one may imagine a system characterized by a parameter say L (box length) which changes such that the particle stays in the same quantum state (i.e. an adiabatic change). Given that bound quantum mechanics is constrained to behave on average as a classical system it is not surprising that a dE=PdV which is essentially a Newton’s second law statement dE=Fdx and is not necessarily linked to a usual statistical system. If a quantum state has its parameter changed nonadiabatically it should be able to have it change into a superposition of new quantum states (new L) which is very different from the classical statistical mechanical scenario. Furthermore the ideal gas relationship PV=NRT and E=3/2NRT (3 degrees of freedom) or PV=(⅔)E matches a classical mechanical result because a particle with p may bounce from a wall yielding an impulse. In this note we try to examine some of these underlying constraints and argue that even dE=PdV for average E and P values (i.e. no entropy change) one must be aware of the specific constraints involved. In other words because dE=PdV for both adiabatic classical statistical mechanical systems and a quantum eigenstate, these do not necessarily represent the same statistical type of physics. We further argue that quantum mechanical bound states are constrained to have some average and rms values such as KE(x) and p rms behave as classical values and so these should not be taken to represent “intrinsic” quantum behaviour while average spatial density on the other hand does. (It is linked to the constraint of wavelength.)
Classical mechanics in the ideal gas scenario and quantum mechanics make use of a set of energy levels which a single particle may occupy. Thus the problem becomes to determine the probability associated with ei i.e. P(ei). In this note we take the approach that relative probabilities depend on the energy gap in question. For example, consider a quantum two level system where ei values are provided by the time-independent Schrodinger equation. From the point of view of statistics, these are simply a set of ei values. Their associated physics is contained in the Schrodinger equation. For the quantum two level system one must find the relative probabilities PR(e1) and PR(e2). Next, imagine a quantum system with many levels and assume for the sake of argument there are levels e1,e2 and ei,e(i+1) such that e2-e1=e(i+1)-ei. If the mechanism is the same for jumping from e1 to e2 and from ei to e(i+1) (i.e. absorbing a photon of the same energy), one might argue that the relative probabilities PR(e2)/PR(e1) = PR(e(i+1))/PR(ei). From this one may obtain the Maxwell-Boltzman result exp(-ei/T)). Note that levels do not need to be adjacent. For example in a large level system one might consider e1 and e3 and any ei and ej such that e3-e1 = ej - ei. In some situations this may need to be modified (e.g. fermions and bosons have enhancements and there may be level related issues), but as a first step we argue that insisting on relative probabilities being dependent on ei-ej has important consequences. Furthermore, in such a case the normalization constant for these relative probabilities i.e. C(T)= Sum over i exp(-ei/T) is important. Taking ln(C(T) and then taking the derivative d/dT yields an expression proportional to the average energy. An expression for dE/dT dT, however, would lead to a second order differential equation in ln(C(T)). If one introduces a new function S such that E-TS = -Tln(C), then one may show that dE/dT = T dS/dT i.e. entropy S emerges.
We argue that classical statistical mechanics (say of an ideal gas) is based on a single equilibration scheme characterized by a temperature T (even in the presence of a potential V(x)). This single scheme is based on the maximization of entropy (subject to an average energy constraint) in order to determine probabilities for p,v and x. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, is based on two equilibration schemes, we argue. The first is due to a built-in probability of exp(ipx) for a free particle. In this case, a potential V(x) interacts with momentum (impulse hits) to create a potential energy. No velocity appears in the creation of potential energy, but does appear in the creation of average kinetic energy. Like with a classical mechanical bound state, energy becomes a system variable. This is the first equilibration. We argue that it should have its own entropy. The probability form exp(ipx) together with conservation of energy and boundary conditions fix allowable single particle energy values (which are discrete) unlike in the classical statistical mechanical case. The second equilibration occurs if there exists a mechanism for moving from one discrete E to another, e.g. photon emission/absorption. This equilibration is based on maximization of entropy (a second entropy), but the effects of the first equilibration remain because it is this first scheme which controls allowable E values. We also argue that exp(-i Et) from the first equilibration scheme may affect the usual entropy based on exp(-E/T) used in the second scheme.
Classical mechanics is deterministic in that it links x and t i.e. x(t) from which one may take derivatives to obtain velocity and acceleration. We argued in (1) that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory which represents the decoupling of x and t. If this is the case, what does it mean to say that large n approaches classical mechanics (correspondence principle) or to use semiclassical approaches such as Integral p dx = n3.14 where the integral is between the classical turning points? We consider this question and also try to apply the semiclassical approaches of (2) to the calculation of the variance of p and x. In particular we consider a particle in a box with infinite potential walls and an oscillator. We also consider Sp = - Integral dp a(p)a(p) ln[a(p)a(p)] where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) and try to argue that this quantity may not have a semiclassical analogue while Sx = - Integral dx W(x)W(x) ln[W(x)W(x)] does. In other words there may be a spatial correspondence principle, but not a momentum one with respect to Shannon’s entropy.
Both quantum mechanics and classical statistical mechanics predict the same momentum and spatial density forms forms for the solution of an oscillator. In the case of quantum mechanics, the ground state is considered. One may ask whether this is a coincidence, and if not, why two seemingly different theories should lead to the same result for the oscillator case. We argue in this note that it is the form of the conservation equation of the oscillator which leads to x and p having the same probability distribution.Furthermore, given that both quantum mechanics and classical statistical mechanics are of a statistical nature, one may inquire into the actual nature of the statistics being used, the meaning behind averages being used. For example, the classical deterministic solution of an oscillator can be written in statistical terms by removing time dependence and using density = dx/v. This does not mean, however, that the actual physical motion is no longer deterministic. In addition, we try to argue that quantum mechanics may be a more detailed statistical model including dynamics which satisfies the more static statistical result of spatial density for classical statistical mechanics.