Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.09748 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Entanglement transition in the projective transverse field Ising model

Nicolai Lang, Hans Peter Büchler

Published Sep 23, 2020• 149 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Random quantum circuits have emerged as useful toy models for entanglement transitions in quantum many-body systems. Here, the authors study a projective version of the transverse-field Ising model without unitary dynamics where the competition between two noncommuting measurements drives an entanglement transition. The authors identify a nonlocal classical process that captures the entanglement dynamics and relate the model to bond percolation in space-time. This leads to a conformal field theory description of the system at criticality which they verify numerically for large systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.102.094204

Related papers

Decoding the projective transverse field Ising model

Felix Roser, Hans Peter Büchler, Nicolai Lang

The competition between noncommuting projective measurements in discrete quantum circuits can give rise to entanglement transitions. It separates a regime where initially stored quantum information survives the time evolution from a regime where the measurements destroy the quantum information. Here we study one such system---the projective transverse field Ising model---with a focus on its capabilities as a quantum error correction code. The idea is to interpret one type of measurement as an error and the other type as a syndrome measurement. We demonstrate that there is a finite threshold below which quantum information encoded in an initially entangled state can be retrieved reliably. In particular, we implement the maximum likelihood decoder to demonstrate that the error correction threshold is distinct from the entanglement transition. This implies that there is a finite regime where quantum information is protected by the projective dynamics, but cannot be retrieved by using syndrome measurements.

arXiv:2303.03081•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 5, 2023•9 citations

Measurement-induced criticality in random quantum circuits

Chao‐Ming Jian, Yi‐Zhuang You, Romain Vasseur +1 more

A new class of quantum entanglement transitions separating phases with different entanglement entropy scaling has been observed in recent numerical studies. Despite the numerical efforts, an analytical understanding of such transitions has remained elusive. Here, the authors propose a theory for the area-law to volume-law entanglement transition in many-body systems that undergo both random unitary evolutions and projective measurements. Using the replica method, the authors map analytically this entanglement transition to an ordering transition in a classical statistical mechanics model. They derive the general entanglement scaling properties at the transition and show a solvable limit where this transition can be mapped onto two-dimensional percolation.

arXiv:1908.08051•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 3, 2020•490 citations

Robust detection of an entanglement transition in the projective transverse field Ising model

Felix Roser, Etienne M. Springer, Hans Peter Büchler +1 more

We propose a scalable and noise-resilient protocol for the detection of the entanglement transition in a projective version of the transverse field Ising model. Entanglement transitions are experimentally difficult to observe due to the inherent randomness of projective measurements and noise in large-scale experimental settings. Our approach combines error correction algorithms with classical shadow tomography to overcome both problems. This allows for experimentally accessible upper and lower bounds on the entanglement transition without postselection or full state tomography. These bounds remain robust under noise and their sharpness is a measure of the noise rate.

quant-pharXiv:2511.17370•Physical Review Letters•Nov 24, 2025•1 citation

Conformal invariance and quantum nonlocality in critical hybrid circuits

Yaodong Li, Xiao Chen, Andreas W. W. Ludwig +1 more

Local measurements in random quantum circuits lead to a new class of ``entanglement phase transitions''. Through extensive calculations at the critical point of ``stabilizer'' circuits --- organized by a mapping from the finite rectangular geometry to the semi-infinite plane --- the authors find here an emergent conformal field theory description of the entanglement dynamics, whose critical exponents are beyond any known theory. As we show, conformal symmetry implies a measurement-induced Bell-like nonlocality, where distant qubits become entangled with an infinite speed.

arXiv:2003.12721•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 14, 2021•194 citations

Unitary-projective entanglement dynamics

Amos Chan, Rahul Nandkishore, Michael Pretko +1 more

Starting from a state of low quantum entanglement, local unitary time evolution increases the entanglement of a quantum many-body system. In contrast, local projective measurements disentangle degrees of freedom and decrease entanglement. We study the interplay of these competing tendencies by considering time evolution combining both unitary and projective dynamics. We begin by constructing a toy model of Bell pair dynamics which demonstrates that measurements can keep a system in a state of low, i.e., area-law, entanglement, in contrast with the volume-law entanglement produced by generic pure unitary time evolution. While the simplest Bell pair model has area-law entanglement for any measurement rate, as seen in certain noninteracting systems, we show that more generic models of entanglement can feature an area-to-volume law transition at a critical value of the measurement rate, in agreement with recent numerical investigations. As a concrete example of these ideas, we analytically investigate Clifford evolution in qubit systems which can exhibit an entanglement transition. We are able to identify stabilizer size distributions characterizing the area law, volume law, and critical ``fixed points.'' We also discuss a Floquet random unitary circuit, where the answers depend on the order of limits---one order of limits yields area-law entanglement for any nonzero measurement rate, whereas a different order of limits allows for an arealaw--volumelaw transition. Finally, we provide a rigorous argument that a system subjected to projective measurements can only exhibit a volume-law entanglement entropy if it also features a subleading correction term, which provides a universal signature of projective dynamics in the high-entanglement phase.

arXiv:1808.05949•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 24, 2019•499 citations

Measurement-driven transitions between area law phases

Hui Yu, Jiangping Hu

Abstract In recent years, quantum circuits consisting of unitary gates and projective measurements have become valuable tools for stimulating or preparing quantum many-body states with non-trivial properties. Here, we introduce and examine a measurement-only circuit (the projective quantum Ising model with three-spin interactions) that involves three non-commuting projective measurements. This model features three distinct phases, separated by two critical lines. We utilize two entanglement measures (topological entanglement entropy and mutual information) to identify the phase boundaries and derive various critical exponents through scaling analysis. We establish a relationship between our model and a two-dimensional statistical model (bond percolation) within certain limits. We hope that our results will shed light on further studies using other measurement-only models.

arXiv:2509.15634•Physica Scripta•May 8, 2025•4 citations
Random quantum circuits have emerged as useful toy models for entanglement transitions in quantum many-body systems. Here, the authors study a projective version of the transverse-field Ising model without unitary dynamics where the competition between two noncommuting measurements drives an entanglement transition. The authors identify a nonlocal classical process that captures the entanglement dynamics and relate the model to bond percolation in space-time. This leads to a conformal field theory description of the system at criticality which they verify numerically for large systems.
The competition between noncommuting projective measurements in discrete quantum circuits can give rise to entanglement transitions. It separates a regime where initially stored quantum information survives the time evolution from a regime where the measurements destroy the quantum information. Here we study one such system---the projective transverse field Ising model---with a focus on its capabilities as a quantum error correction code. The idea is to interpret one type of measurement as an error and the other type as a syndrome measurement. We demonstrate that there is a finite threshold below which quantum information encoded in an initially entangled state can be retrieved reliably. In particular, we implement the maximum likelihood decoder to demonstrate that the error correction threshold is distinct from the entanglement transition. This implies that there is a finite regime where quantum information is protected by the projective dynamics, but cannot be retrieved by using syndrome measurements.
A new class of quantum entanglement transitions separating phases with different entanglement entropy scaling has been observed in recent numerical studies. Despite the numerical efforts, an analytical understanding of such transitions has remained elusive. Here, the authors propose a theory for the area-law to volume-law entanglement transition in many-body systems that undergo both random unitary evolutions and projective measurements. Using the replica method, the authors map analytically this entanglement transition to an ordering transition in a classical statistical mechanics model. They derive the general entanglement scaling properties at the transition and show a solvable limit where this transition can be mapped onto two-dimensional percolation.
We propose a scalable and noise-resilient protocol for the detection of the entanglement transition in a projective version of the transverse field Ising model. Entanglement transitions are experimentally difficult to observe due to the inherent randomness of projective measurements and noise in large-scale experimental settings. Our approach combines error correction algorithms with classical shadow tomography to overcome both problems. This allows for experimentally accessible upper and lower bounds on the entanglement transition without postselection or full state tomography. These bounds remain robust under noise and their sharpness is a measure of the noise rate.
Local measurements in random quantum circuits lead to a new class of ``entanglement phase transitions''. Through extensive calculations at the critical point of ``stabilizer'' circuits --- organized by a mapping from the finite rectangular geometry to the semi-infinite plane --- the authors find here an emergent conformal field theory description of the entanglement dynamics, whose critical exponents are beyond any known theory. As we show, conformal symmetry implies a measurement-induced Bell-like nonlocality, where distant qubits become entangled with an infinite speed.
Starting from a state of low quantum entanglement, local unitary time evolution increases the entanglement of a quantum many-body system. In contrast, local projective measurements disentangle degrees of freedom and decrease entanglement. We study the interplay of these competing tendencies by considering time evolution combining both unitary and projective dynamics. We begin by constructing a toy model of Bell pair dynamics which demonstrates that measurements can keep a system in a state of low, i.e., area-law, entanglement, in contrast with the volume-law entanglement produced by generic pure unitary time evolution. While the simplest Bell pair model has area-law entanglement for any measurement rate, as seen in certain noninteracting systems, we show that more generic models of entanglement can feature an area-to-volume law transition at a critical value of the measurement rate, in agreement with recent numerical investigations. As a concrete example of these ideas, we analytically investigate Clifford evolution in qubit systems which can exhibit an entanglement transition. We are able to identify stabilizer size distributions characterizing the area law, volume law, and critical ``fixed points.'' We also discuss a Floquet random unitary circuit, where the answers depend on the order of limits---one order of limits yields area-law entanglement for any nonzero measurement rate, whereas a different order of limits allows for an arealaw--volumelaw transition. Finally, we provide a rigorous argument that a system subjected to projective measurements can only exhibit a volume-law entanglement entropy if it also features a subleading correction term, which provides a universal signature of projective dynamics in the high-entanglement phase.
Abstract In recent years, quantum circuits consisting of unitary gates and projective measurements have become valuable tools for stimulating or preparing quantum many-body states with non-trivial properties. Here, we introduce and examine a measurement-only circuit (the projective quantum Ising model with three-spin interactions) that involves three non-commuting projective measurements. This model features three distinct phases, separated by two critical lines. We utilize two entanglement measures (topological entanglement entropy and mutual information) to identify the phase boundaries and derive various critical exponents through scaling analysis. We establish a relationship between our model and a two-dimensional statistical model (bond percolation) within certain limits. We hope that our results will shed light on further studies using other measurement-only models.