Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.14378

No point-localized photon states

Scott E. Hoffmann

Published May 29, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to critically examine claims that it is possible to construct point-localized state vectors for the photon. We supply a brief proof of the impossibility of this. Then it is found that the authors making these claims use a non-standard scalar product, not equal to the quantum-mechanical one. This alternative scalar product is found to be proportional to a Dirac delta function in position for the state vectors they use, but the remaining elements of the proof, namely satisfying all three Newton-Wigner criteria, are lacking.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2005.14378

Related papers

Photon wave functions in a localized coordinate space basis

Margaret Hawton

A first quantized theory of the photon is developed that incorporates all of the usual rules of quantum mechanics. The state vector is argued to be proportional to the four-vector potential. Scalar products and the probability amplitude are invariant under gauge transformations that satisfy the Lorentz gauge condition. The eigenvectors of a recently constructed Hermitian position operator with commuting components provide a basis for the position representation.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1999•57 citations

Lorentz-Invariant Localization for Elementary Systems. II

Andrés J. Kálnay

The purpose of this paper is to find to what extent the notion of position in the relativistic quantum mechanics of free elementary systems of nonzero mass is defined (or precluded) by the requirement that the descriptions of a localized state as seen from two observers in different frames of reference should be physically consistent. Neither the existence of a time component of the position operator nor the compatibility of the space components of position is assumed. Hermiticity with respect to the quantum-relativistic scalar product in state-vector space is neither assumed nor rejected. There are three possibilities: (i) The position is represented as usual by a Hermitian operator; this is the point-type position. (ii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, and the $k$ component of position can represent segments of the $k$ axis with length of the order of $\frac{1}{m}$; when the operator is not only non-Hermitian, but also non-normal, this is the extended-type position. (iii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, but the segments are reduced to points; this is the limiting case of the extended-type position. Case (ii) is not studied in this paper. General conditions are found for any spin as regards cases (i) and (iii), and their consequences are obtained for spin 0 and spin \textonehalf{}. The results are the following: There is no position operator in case (i), but in case (iii) the position operator is unique for spin 0 and unique up to a parameter for spin \textonehalf{}. For both spins, in spite of the lack of relativistic Hermiticity, the eigenvalues of position are real, and the velocity is the expected one. The eigenstates of one component of the position are found. The components of the position are compatible with each other for spin 0, and incompatible for spin \textonehalf{}. In the former case, the simultaneous eigenstates of all components are Philip's class-I localized states. Related work is discussed.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1970•27 citations

The Observables and Localized States of a Dirac Particle

P. M. Mathews, A. Sankaranarayanan

It is shown that for a non-zero mass Dirac particle, only one of the four position operators recently discovered by the authors has eigenstates (describing the localized states of the particle) which obey the regularity condition imposed by Newton and Wigner. However, this condition is not applicable to the states of a particle with zero rest mass, and in such a case the multiplicity of possible position (and other) operators persists.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•May 1, 1962•12 citations

A Dissolution of the Problem of Locality

Simon W. Saunders

Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•13 citations

Coherent states and scattering for exactly solvable quantum systems

Scott E. Hoffmann

This thesis concerns quantum states that are superpositions of discrete or of continuum energy levels. It develops mathematical methods to characterize the physical properties of these states and finds important consequences. Regarding rational extensions of the harmonic oscillator, no other authors had constructed the coherent states associated with the ladder operators of Marquette and Quesne. It was our aim to proceed with this construction, then to calculate physical properties of these coherent states, looking for classical or quantum behaviour. The method of partial wave analysis was known to be not applicable to the Coulomb potential for the scattering of plane waves. It was my aim to repeat the calculation for wavepacket scattering, to investigate whether the method became applicable. Other authors have constructed relativistic probability amplitudes and compared them to the scalar Klein-Gordon amplitude. In this context, it was my aim to question the conclusion of a minimum width for a massive particle. In the same context, I investigated the possibility of a four-vector probability current with the Newton-Wigner position probability density as the zero component. In Chapter 12, my aim was to construct a measure of localization for the photon, knowing from the work of other authors that a point-localized photon state is not possible.In Chapters 3, 4 and 5, our measures of classicality for the Barut-Girardello coherent states included plotting energy expectations as functions of the magnitude of the coherent state para- meter, z, position probability densities for the coherent states and the even and odd cat states, the Wigner functions for particular choices of z, the two-photon number probability distribu- tion and the linear entropy for a coherent state on a beamsplitter, position spreads to look for squeezing and the Mandel Q parameter. In Chapter 6, it was necessary to approximate an integral containing a particular Wigner rotation matrix. An approximation of general Wigner rotation matrices, at low angle, was derived and its precision evaluated numerically in Chapter 7. The exact values for the Coulomb phase shifts were used to construct the incoming wavefunction. Time reversal and a rotation were used to construct the outgoing wavefunction. The sums over l were evaluated numerically. In Chapter 10, four arguments were used against the minimum width. Comparison of the scalar amplitude and the relativistic probability amplitude for a Newton-Wigner localized state showed the root of the problem. A Lorentz transformation was applied to the scalar function to see if the “minimum” width became even smaller. A simple construction produced scalar functions with arbitrarily small widths. A relevant argument from Almeida and Jabs was included here. In Chapter 11, the algebra involving the four components of a four-vector current (at the origin) and the boost generators was derived. All of these commutators must be satisfied by a four-vector, providing a test for the claimed four-vector probability currents of other authors. In Chapter 12, field expectations were taken in a coherent state with a mean photon number of unity, built from identical single-photon states.In Chapters 3, 4 and 5, we found a mix of classical and quantum behaviour for the coherent states. In none of the systems studied did we see the high degree of classicality of the unmodified harmonic oscillator. The investigation of cat states was relevant to the fundamental problem of measurement in quantum mechanics. In Chapter 6, the use of wavepackets introduced a convergence factor into the sum over l, which diverges in the plane wave treatment. The elimination of a divergence is the most significant result of this thesis. Scattering probabilities remained finite at all angles, in disagreement with the diverging Rutherford formula, but only on small angular regions around forward scattering. Future work will investigate the measurability of the phenomena predicted here. In Chapter 10, all four arguments pointed to no minimum width for a massive particle. In Chapter 11, it was found that there can be no four-vector current density with the Newton-Wigner position probability density as the zero component, for any spin. Other authors were found to be in error when they claimed to have produced such a four-vector current density. This result strengthens the position of the Dirac current as the appropriate current for an electron. In Chapter 12, the coherent state field expectations were found to provide a meaningful measure of localization. In summary, wavepackets give a realism to the description of a scattering experiment that is absent with the use of plane waves. Phenomena not captured by the plane wave scattering amplitude, such as time delays, are calculable in the wavepacket context. Relativistic probability amplitudes provide a complete description of free particles, consistent with quantum mechanics and with special relativity. They predict agreement with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and relativistic effects such as Lorentz contraction. The absence of relativistic probability amplitudes from standard textbooks on relativistic quantum mechanics is a serious omission.

•Jun 8, 2020•0 citations

Localisation Of Photon States In Quantum Optics

Edward R. Pike, Sarben Sarkar

Non-classical light sources are now being developed in more and more laboratories. Their noise reduction properties are potentially important for technology. Examples are squeezed and antibunched light sources. It is tempting to picture in some of these processes single photons flying through space. In non-relativistic quantum mechanics it is easy to discuss the properties of particle localisation in a general context without recourse to a particular experimental configuration. A position operator exists and the localised states are just the eigenstates of this operator. The situation in relativistic quantum mechanics (or field theory) is not as straightforward. The photon is relativistic and it has the addi-tional property of being massless. It has no position operator associated with it. Yet, nevertheless, it is possible to pose the question of finding a generic construction for a wave packet for the photon which is localised as far as possible in some (imaginary) box in space. The difficulty of the construction follows from the fact that in an electromagnetic wave the polarisation is perpendicular to the direction of propagation. Thus we need to construct a vector field which is localised and has this transverse property related to the masslessness of the photon.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations
The aim of this paper is to critically examine claims that it is possible to construct point-localized state vectors for the photon. We supply a brief proof of the impossibility of this. Then it is found that the authors making these claims use a non-standard scalar product, not equal to the quantum-mechanical one. This alternative scalar product is found to be proportional to a Dirac delta function in position for the state vectors they use, but the remaining elements of the proof, namely satisfying all three Newton-Wigner criteria, are lacking.
The purpose of this paper is to find to what extent the notion of position in the relativistic quantum mechanics of free elementary systems of nonzero mass is defined (or precluded) by the requirement that the descriptions of a localized state as seen from two observers in different frames of reference should be physically consistent. Neither the existence of a time component of the position operator nor the compatibility of the space components of position is assumed. Hermiticity with respect to the quantum-relativistic scalar product in state-vector space is neither assumed nor rejected. There are three possibilities: (i) The position is represented as usual by a Hermitian operator; this is the point-type position. (ii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, and the kkk component of position can represent segments of the kkk axis with length of the order of 1m\frac{1}{m}m1​; when the operator is not only non-Hermitian, but also non-normal, this is the extended-type position. (iii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, but the segments are reduced to points; this is the limiting case of the extended-type position. Case (ii) is not studied in this paper. General conditions are found for any spin as regards cases (i) and (iii), and their consequences are obtained for spin 0 and spin \textonehalf{}. The results are the following: There is no position operator in case (i), but in case (iii) the position operator is unique for spin 0 and unique up to a parameter for spin \textonehalf{}. For both spins, in spite of the lack of relativistic Hermiticity, the eigenvalues of position are real, and the velocity is the expected one. The eigenstates of one component of the position are found. The components of the position are compatible with each other for spin 0, and incompatible for spin \textonehalf{}. In the former case, the simultaneous eigenstates of all components are Philip's class-I localized states. Related work is discussed.
Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.
This thesis concerns quantum states that are superpositions of discrete or of continuum energy levels. It develops mathematical methods to characterize the physical properties of these states and finds important consequences. Regarding rational extensions of the harmonic oscillator, no other authors had constructed the coherent states associated with the ladder operators of Marquette and Quesne. It was our aim to proceed with this construction, then to calculate physical properties of these coherent states, looking for classical or quantum behaviour. The method of partial wave analysis was known to be not applicable to the Coulomb potential for the scattering of plane waves. It was my aim to repeat the calculation for wavepacket scattering, to investigate whether the method became applicable. Other authors have constructed relativistic probability amplitudes and compared them to the scalar Klein-Gordon amplitude. In this context, it was my aim to question the conclusion of a minimum width for a massive particle. In the same context, I investigated the possibility of a four-vector probability current with the Newton-Wigner position probability density as the zero component. In Chapter 12, my aim was to construct a measure of localization for the photon, knowing from the work of other authors that a point-localized photon state is not possible.In Chapters 3, 4 and 5, our measures of classicality for the Barut-Girardello coherent states included plotting energy expectations as functions of the magnitude of the coherent state para- meter, z, position probability densities for the coherent states and the even and odd cat states, the Wigner functions for particular choices of z, the two-photon number probability distribu- tion and the linear entropy for a coherent state on a beamsplitter, position spreads to look for squeezing and the Mandel Q parameter. In Chapter 6, it was necessary to approximate an integral containing a particular Wigner rotation matrix. An approximation of general Wigner rotation matrices, at low angle, was derived and its precision evaluated numerically in Chapter 7. The exact values for the Coulomb phase shifts were used to construct the incoming wavefunction. Time reversal and a rotation were used to construct the outgoing wavefunction. The sums over l were evaluated numerically. In Chapter 10, four arguments were used against the minimum width. Comparison of the scalar amplitude and the relativistic probability amplitude for a Newton-Wigner localized state showed the root of the problem. A Lorentz transformation was applied to the scalar function to see if the “minimum” width became even smaller. A simple construction produced scalar functions with arbitrarily small widths. A relevant argument from Almeida and Jabs was included here. In Chapter 11, the algebra involving the four components of a four-vector current (at the origin) and the boost generators was derived. All of these commutators must be satisfied by a four-vector, providing a test for the claimed four-vector probability currents of other authors. In Chapter 12, field expectations were taken in a coherent state with a mean photon number of unity, built from identical single-photon states.In Chapters 3, 4 and 5, we found a mix of classical and quantum behaviour for the coherent states. In none of the systems studied did we see the high degree of classicality of the unmodified harmonic oscillator. The investigation of cat states was relevant to the fundamental problem of measurement in quantum mechanics. In Chapter 6, the use of wavepackets introduced a convergence factor into the sum over l, which diverges in the plane wave treatment. The elimination of a divergence is the most significant result of this thesis. Scattering probabilities remained finite at all angles, in disagreement with the diverging Rutherford formula, but only on small angular regions around forward scattering. Future work will investigate the measurability of the phenomena predicted here. In Chapter 10, all four arguments pointed to no minimum width for a massive particle. In Chapter 11, it was found that there can be no four-vector current density with the Newton-Wigner position probability density as the zero component, for any spin. Other authors were found to be in error when they claimed to have produced such a four-vector current density. This result strengthens the position of the Dirac current as the appropriate current for an electron. In Chapter 12, the coherent state field expectations were found to provide a meaningful measure of localization. In summary, wavepackets give a realism to the description of a scattering experiment that is absent with the use of plane waves. Phenomena not captured by the plane wave scattering amplitude, such as time delays, are calculable in the wavepacket context. Relativistic probability amplitudes provide a complete description of free particles, consistent with quantum mechanics and with special relativity. They predict agreement with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and relativistic effects such as Lorentz contraction. The absence of relativistic probability amplitudes from standard textbooks on relativistic quantum mechanics is a serious omission.
Non-classical light sources are now being developed in more and more laboratories. Their noise reduction properties are potentially important for technology. Examples are squeezed and antibunched light sources. It is tempting to picture in some of these processes single photons flying through space. In non-relativistic quantum mechanics it is easy to discuss the properties of particle localisation in a general context without recourse to a particular experimental configuration. A position operator exists and the localised states are just the eigenstates of this operator. The situation in relativistic quantum mechanics (or field theory) is not as straightforward. The photon is relativistic and it has the addi-tional property of being massless. It has no position operator associated with it. Yet, nevertheless, it is possible to pose the question of finding a generic construction for a wave packet for the photon which is localised as far as possible in some (imaginary) box in space. The difficulty of the construction follows from the fact that in an electromagnetic wave the polarisation is perpendicular to the direction of propagation. Thus we need to construct a vector field which is localised and has this transverse property related to the masslessness of the photon.