Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.03236 · National Science Review

Uniquely identifying topological order based on boundary-bulk duality and anyon condensation

Yong-Ju Hai, Ze Zhang, Hao Zheng, Liang Kong, Jiansheng Wu, Dapeng Yu

Published Nov 24, 2022• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

ABSTRACT Topological order is a new quantum phase that is beyond Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. Its defining features include robust degenerate ground states, long-range entanglement and anyons. It was known that R and F matrices, which characterize the fusion-braiding properties of anyons, can be used to uniquely identify topological order. In this article, we explore an essential question: how can the R and F matrices be experimentally measured? We show that the braidings, i.e. the R matrices, can be completely determined by the half braidings of boundary excitations due to the boundary-bulk duality and the anyon condensation. The F matrices can also be measured by comparing the quantum states involving the fusion of three anyons in two different orders. Thus we provide a model-independent experimental protocol to uniquely identify topological order. By using quantum simulations based on a toric code model with boundaries encoded in three- and four-qubit systems and state-of-the-art technology, we obtain the first experimental measurement of R and F matrices by means of an NMR quantum computer at room temperature.

DOI
10.1093/nsr/nwac264

Related papers

Experimental Identification of Non-Abelian Topological Orders on a Quantum Simulator

Keren Li, Yidun Wan, Ling-Yan Hung +5 more

Topological orders can be used as media for topological quantum computing-a promising quantum computation model due to its invulnerability against local errors. Conversely, a quantum simulator, often regarded as a quantum computing device for special purposes, also offers a way of characterizing topological orders. Here, we show how to identify distinct topological orders via measuring their modular S and T matrices. In particular, we employ a nuclear magnetic resonance quantum simulator to study the properties of three topologically ordered matter phases described by the string-net model with two string types, including the Z_{2} toric code, doubled semion, and doubled Fibonacci. The third one, non-Abelian Fibonacci order is notably expected to be the simplest candidate for universal topological quantum computing. Our experiment serves as the basic module, built on which one can simulate braiding of non-Abelian anyons and ultimately, topological quantum computation via the braiding, and thus provides a new approach of investigating topological orders using quantum computers.

arXiv:1608.06932•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 2017•41 citations

Topological phases of matter

Pak On Chan

Topological phases are gapped quantum phases of matter classified beyond the paradigm of Landau's symmetry breaking theory. In particular, topologically ordered phases are topological phases with topological order. Unlike the conventional symmetry-breaking order described by local order parameter, topological order is characterized by the excitations. For example, in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are particle-like excitations called anyons. In contrast, in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are both particle-like and loop-like excitations. These excitations exhibit braiding statistics, meaning that carrying one excitation adiabatically around another transform the ground state by a phase (or generally a unitary transformation). The braiding statistics of these excitations serves as a crucial ingredient in characterizing the topological order in these phases. One important aspect is to understand the braiding statistics in topologically ordered phases. While the anyonic braiding statistics in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases is well established, the braiding statistics in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases is far from clear. In (3+1)D, the most well-understood braiding statistics is the particle-loop braiding statistics, where a particle winds around a loop excitation acquires an Aharonov Bohm phase. In the thesis, we introduce a new braiding statistics, which we called the Borromean-Rings braiding statistics. It is a particle-loop-loop braiding statistics where a particle travels around two unlinked loops acquires a braiding phase. Unlike the particle-loop braiding, the particle trajectory in the Borromean-Rings braiding is not linked with any of the two loops. Another important aspect is to probe the topological order in topologically ordered phases. One usual way to probe the topological order is to examine the properties of the phases on various orientable surfaces. For example, for (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, the number of degenerate ground states on Torus counts the number of anyons. Also, ground state transformation under twisting the torus encodes the braiding data. In the thesis, we attempt to probe the topological order by putting the phases on non-orientable surfaces. We find that the ground state degeneracy and the ground state transformation reveals a special kind of anyons, called the parity symmetric anyons, which show a lost of orientation in their braiding statistics. They in turn distinguish different topological order. Even without topological order, there can be non-trivial topological phases in the presence of global symmetry. These topological phases are called the symmetry protected topological phases. For example, (3+1)D fermionic matter with time reversal symmetry and charge conservation symmetry has a non-trivial phase, namely the topological insulators. While the bulk of the topological insulators behaves like trivial insulators, the surface is anomalous with odd number of massless dirac fermions. While most of the understanding of topological insulators is developed upon the free fermion picture, such phase survives under interaction. In the thesis, we derive hydrodynamic field theory for the topological insulators by functional bosonization. Such formulation is robust against interaction. In addition, by suitably incorporating electron interactions, we predict new topological phases, called the fractional topological insulators. Besides, the surface theory of topological insulators also justify the famous duality between free massless dirac fermion and QED_3.

•Dec 3, 2018•0 citations

Entanglement phases as holographic duals of anyon condensates

Kasper Duivenvoorden, Mohsin Iqbal, Jutho Haegeman +2 more

Topological phases are exotic states of matters which do not order locally yet exhibit a global ordering in their entanglement, making their characterization a challenging task. In this work, the authors construct an explicit holographic duality between topological phases in the bulk and the structure of the entanglement spectrum at its boundary, thereby establishing a one-to-one correspondence between different bulk topological orders and symmetry-breaking and symmetry-protected orderings of the entanglement. This allows classification and detection of topological phases holographically through ``entanglement spectroscopy'' at the boundary, and construction of order parameters that measure the condensation and confinement of anyons, and thus permits characterization of the nature of topological phase transitions.

arXiv:1702.08469•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 12, 2017•60 citations

Topological Phases of Matter

Topological phases are gapped quantum phases of matter classified beyond the paradigm of Landau's symmetry breaking theory.In particular, topologically ordered phases are topological phases with topological order.Unlike the conventional symmetry-breaking order described by local order parameter, topological order is characterized by the excitations.For example, in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are particle-like excitations called anyons.In contrast, in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are both particle-like and loop-like excitations.These excitations exhibit braiding statistics, meaning that carrying one excitation adiabatically around another transform the ground state by a phase (or generally a unitary transformation).The braiding statistics of these excitations serves as a crucial ingredient in characterizing the topological order in these phases.One important aspect is to understand the braiding statistics in topologically ordered phases.While the anyonic braiding statistics in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases is well established, the braiding statistics in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases is far from clear.In (3+1)D, the most well-understood braiding statistics is the particle-loop braiding statistics, where a particle winds around a loop excitation acquires an Aharonov Bohm phase.In the thesis, we introduce a new braiding statistics, which we called the Borromean-Rings braiding statistics.It is a particleloop-loop braiding statistics where a particle travels around two unlinked loops acquires a braiding phase.Unlike the particle-loop braiding, the particle trajectory in the Borromean-Rings braiding is not linked with any of the two loops.Another important aspect is to probe the topological order in topologically ordered phases.One usual way to probe the topological order is to examine the properties of the phases on various orientable surfaces.For example, for (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, the number of degenerate ground states on Torus counts the number of anyons.Also, ground state transformation under twisting the torus encodes the braiding data.In the thesis, we attempt to probe the topological order by putting the phases on non-orientable surfaces.We find that the ground state degeneracy and the ground state transformation reveals a special kind of anyons, called the parity symmetric anyons, which show a lost of orientation in their braiding statistics.They in turn distinguish different topological order.Even without topological order, there can be non-trivial topological phases in the presence of global symmetry.These topological phases are called the symmetry protected topological phases.For example, (3+1)D fermionic matter with time reversal symmetry and charge conservation symmetry has a non-trivial phase, namely the topological I would like to give my sincere thanks to my advisor Shinsei Ryu.Throughout my PhD study, he taught me a lot about condensed matter physics, particularly on the forefront subjects in topological phases.Under his supervision, I worked on different abstract yet inspiring topics on topological phases.His guide is always clear with mathematical interpretation and physical insight.His advice not only guided me though the research, but also shaped my views and thinking.From my advisor, I learnt the way to convey difficult ideas

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 13, 2016•1 citation

General procedure for determining braiding and statistics of anyons using entanglement interferometry

Yi Zhang, Tarun Grover, Ashvin Vishwanath

Recently, it was argued that the braiding and statistics of anyons in a two-dimensional topological phase can be extracted by studying the quantum entanglement of the degenerate ground states on the torus. This construction either required a lattice symmetry (such as $\ensuremath{\pi}/2$ rotation) or tacitly assumed that the minimum entanglement states (MESs) for two different bipartitions can be uniquely assigned quasiparticle labels. Here we describe a procedure to obtain the modular $\mathcal{S}$ matrix, which encodes the braiding statistics of anyons, which does not require making any of these assumptions. Our strategy is to coherently compare MESs of three independent entanglement bipartitions of the torus, which leads to a unique modular $\mathcal{S}$. This procedure also puts strong constraints on the modular $\mathcal{T}$ and $\mathcal{U}$ matrices without requiring any symmetries, and in certain special cases, completely determines it. Our method applies equally to Abelian and non-Abelian topological phases.

arXiv:1412.0677•Physical Review B•Jan 26, 2015•25 citations

Characterizing topological order by the information convex

Bowen Shi, Yuan-Ming Lu

Motivated by previous efforts in detecting topological orders from the ground state(s) wave function, we introduce a new quantum information tool, coined the information convex, to capture the bulk and boundary topological excitations of a 2D topological order. Defined as a set of reduced density matrices that minimizes the energy in a subsystem, the information convex encodes not only the bulk anyons but also the gapped boundaries of 2D topological orders. Using untwisted gapped boundaries of non-Abelian quantum doubles as an example, we show how the information convex reveals and characterizes deconfined bulk and boundary topological excitations, and the condensation rule relating them. Interference experiments in cold atoms provide potential measurements for the invariant structure of information convex.

arXiv:1801.01519•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 7, 2019•26 citations
ABSTRACT Topological order is a new quantum phase that is beyond Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. Its defining features include robust degenerate ground states, long-range entanglement and anyons. It was known that R and F matrices, which characterize the fusion-braiding properties of anyons, can be used to uniquely identify topological order. In this article, we explore an essential question: how can the R and F matrices be experimentally measured? We show that the braidings, i.e. the R matrices, can be completely determined by the half braidings of boundary excitations due to the boundary-bulk duality and the anyon condensation. The F matrices can also be measured by comparing the quantum states involving the fusion of three anyons in two different orders. Thus we provide a model-independent experimental protocol to uniquely identify topological order. By using quantum simulations based on a toric code model with boundaries encoded in three- and four-qubit systems and state-of-the-art technology, we obtain the first experimental measurement of R and F matrices by means of an NMR quantum computer at room temperature.
Topological orders can be used as media for topological quantum computing-a promising quantum computation model due to its invulnerability against local errors. Conversely, a quantum simulator, often regarded as a quantum computing device for special purposes, also offers a way of characterizing topological orders. Here, we show how to identify distinct topological orders via measuring their modular S and T matrices. In particular, we employ a nuclear magnetic resonance quantum simulator to study the properties of three topologically ordered matter phases described by the string-net model with two string types, including the Z_{2} toric code, doubled semion, and doubled Fibonacci. The third one, non-Abelian Fibonacci order is notably expected to be the simplest candidate for universal topological quantum computing. Our experiment serves as the basic module, built on which one can simulate braiding of non-Abelian anyons and ultimately, topological quantum computation via the braiding, and thus provides a new approach of investigating topological orders using quantum computers.
Topological phases are gapped quantum phases of matter classified beyond the paradigm of Landau's symmetry breaking theory. In particular, topologically ordered phases are topological phases with topological order. Unlike the conventional symmetry-breaking order described by local order parameter, topological order is characterized by the excitations. For example, in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are particle-like excitations called anyons. In contrast, in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are both particle-like and loop-like excitations. These excitations exhibit braiding statistics, meaning that carrying one excitation adiabatically around another transform the ground state by a phase (or generally a unitary transformation). The braiding statistics of these excitations serves as a crucial ingredient in characterizing the topological order in these phases. One important aspect is to understand the braiding statistics in topologically ordered phases. While the anyonic braiding statistics in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases is well established, the braiding statistics in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases is far from clear. In (3+1)D, the most well-understood braiding statistics is the particle-loop braiding statistics, where a particle winds around a loop excitation acquires an Aharonov Bohm phase. In the thesis, we introduce a new braiding statistics, which we called the Borromean-Rings braiding statistics. It is a particle-loop-loop braiding statistics where a particle travels around two unlinked loops acquires a braiding phase. Unlike the particle-loop braiding, the particle trajectory in the Borromean-Rings braiding is not linked with any of the two loops. Another important aspect is to probe the topological order in topologically ordered phases. One usual way to probe the topological order is to examine the properties of the phases on various orientable surfaces. For example, for (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, the number of degenerate ground states on Torus counts the number of anyons. Also, ground state transformation under twisting the torus encodes the braiding data. In the thesis, we attempt to probe the topological order by putting the phases on non-orientable surfaces. We find that the ground state degeneracy and the ground state transformation reveals a special kind of anyons, called the parity symmetric anyons, which show a lost of orientation in their braiding statistics. They in turn distinguish different topological order. Even without topological order, there can be non-trivial topological phases in the presence of global symmetry. These topological phases are called the symmetry protected topological phases. For example, (3+1)D fermionic matter with time reversal symmetry and charge conservation symmetry has a non-trivial phase, namely the topological insulators. While the bulk of the topological insulators behaves like trivial insulators, the surface is anomalous with odd number of massless dirac fermions. While most of the understanding of topological insulators is developed upon the free fermion picture, such phase survives under interaction. In the thesis, we derive hydrodynamic field theory for the topological insulators by functional bosonization. Such formulation is robust against interaction. In addition, by suitably incorporating electron interactions, we predict new topological phases, called the fractional topological insulators. Besides, the surface theory of topological insulators also justify the famous duality between free massless dirac fermion and QED_3.
Topological phases are exotic states of matters which do not order locally yet exhibit a global ordering in their entanglement, making their characterization a challenging task. In this work, the authors construct an explicit holographic duality between topological phases in the bulk and the structure of the entanglement spectrum at its boundary, thereby establishing a one-to-one correspondence between different bulk topological orders and symmetry-breaking and symmetry-protected orderings of the entanglement. This allows classification and detection of topological phases holographically through ``entanglement spectroscopy'' at the boundary, and construction of order parameters that measure the condensation and confinement of anyons, and thus permits characterization of the nature of topological phase transitions.
Topological phases are gapped quantum phases of matter classified beyond the paradigm of Landau's symmetry breaking theory.In particular, topologically ordered phases are topological phases with topological order.Unlike the conventional symmetry-breaking order described by local order parameter, topological order is characterized by the excitations.For example, in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are particle-like excitations called anyons.In contrast, in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases, there are both particle-like and loop-like excitations.These excitations exhibit braiding statistics, meaning that carrying one excitation adiabatically around another transform the ground state by a phase (or generally a unitary transformation).The braiding statistics of these excitations serves as a crucial ingredient in characterizing the topological order in these phases.One important aspect is to understand the braiding statistics in topologically ordered phases.While the anyonic braiding statistics in (2+1)D topologically ordered phases is well established, the braiding statistics in (3+1)D topologically ordered phases is far from clear.In (3+1)D, the most well-understood braiding statistics is the particle-loop braiding statistics, where a particle winds around a loop excitation acquires an Aharonov Bohm phase.In the thesis, we introduce a new braiding statistics, which we called the Borromean-Rings braiding statistics.It is a particleloop-loop braiding statistics where a particle travels around two unlinked loops acquires a braiding phase.Unlike the particle-loop braiding, the particle trajectory in the Borromean-Rings braiding is not linked with any of the two loops.Another important aspect is to probe the topological order in topologically ordered phases.One usual way to probe the topological order is to examine the properties of the phases on various orientable surfaces.For example, for (2+1)D topologically ordered phases, the number of degenerate ground states on Torus counts the number of anyons.Also, ground state transformation under twisting the torus encodes the braiding data.In the thesis, we attempt to probe the topological order by putting the phases on non-orientable surfaces.We find that the ground state degeneracy and the ground state transformation reveals a special kind of anyons, called the parity symmetric anyons, which show a lost of orientation in their braiding statistics.They in turn distinguish different topological order.Even without topological order, there can be non-trivial topological phases in the presence of global symmetry.These topological phases are called the symmetry protected topological phases.For example, (3+1)D fermionic matter with time reversal symmetry and charge conservation symmetry has a non-trivial phase, namely the topological I would like to give my sincere thanks to my advisor Shinsei Ryu.Throughout my PhD study, he taught me a lot about condensed matter physics, particularly on the forefront subjects in topological phases.Under his supervision, I worked on different abstract yet inspiring topics on topological phases.His guide is always clear with mathematical interpretation and physical insight.His advice not only guided me though the research, but also shaped my views and thinking.From my advisor, I learnt the way to convey difficult ideas
Recently, it was argued that the braiding and statistics of anyons in a two-dimensional topological phase can be extracted by studying the quantum entanglement of the degenerate ground states on the torus. This construction either required a lattice symmetry (such as $\ensuremath{\pi}/2$ rotation) or tacitly assumed that the minimum entanglement states (MESs) for two different bipartitions can be uniquely assigned quasiparticle labels. Here we describe a procedure to obtain the modular S\mathcal{S}S matrix, which encodes the braiding statistics of anyons, which does not require making any of these assumptions. Our strategy is to coherently compare MESs of three independent entanglement bipartitions of the torus, which leads to a unique modular S\mathcal{S}S. This procedure also puts strong constraints on the modular T\mathcal{T}T and U\mathcal{U}U matrices without requiring any symmetries, and in certain special cases, completely determines it. Our method applies equally to Abelian and non-Abelian topological phases.
Motivated by previous efforts in detecting topological orders from the ground state(s) wave function, we introduce a new quantum information tool, coined the information convex, to capture the bulk and boundary topological excitations of a 2D topological order. Defined as a set of reduced density matrices that minimizes the energy in a subsystem, the information convex encodes not only the bulk anyons but also the gapped boundaries of 2D topological orders. Using untwisted gapped boundaries of non-Abelian quantum doubles as an example, we show how the information convex reveals and characterizes deconfined bulk and boundary topological excitations, and the condensation rule relating them. Interference experiments in cold atoms provide potential measurements for the invariant structure of information convex.