Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.01323 · Leibniz international proceedings in informatics

Span Programs and Quantum Time Complexity

Arjan Cornelissen, Stacey Jeffery, Māris Ozols, Álvaro Piedrafita

Published Jan 1, 2020• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Span programs are an important model of quantum computation due to their tight correspondence with quantum query complexity. For any decision problem $f$, the minimum complexity of a span program for $f$ is equal, up to a constant factor, to the quantum query complexity of $f$. Moreover, this correspondence is constructive. A span program for $f$ with complexity $C$ can be compiled into a bounded error quantum algorithm for $f$ with query complexity $O(C)$, and vice versa. In this work, we prove an analogous connection for quantum time complexity. In particular, we show how to convert a quantum algorithm for $f$ with time complexity $T$ into a span program for $f$ such that it compiles back into a quantum algorithm for $f$ with time complexity $\widetilde{O}(T)$. While the query complexity of quantum algorithms obtained from span programs is well-understood, it is not generally clear how to implement certain query-independent operations in a time-efficient manner. We show that for span programs derived from algorithms with a time-efficient implementation, we can preserve the time efficiency when implementing the span program. This means in particular that span programs not only fully capture quantum query complexity, but also quantum time complexity. One practical advantage of being able to convert quantum algorithms to span programs in a way that preserves time complexity is that span programs compose very nicely. We demonstrate this by improving Ambainis's variable-time quantum search result using our construction through a span program composition for the OR function.

DOI
10.4230/lipics.mfcs.2020.26

Related papers

Span programs and quantum query algorithms.

Ben W. Reichardt

Quantum query complexity measures the number of input bits that must be read by a quantum algorithm in order to evaluate a function. Hoyer et al. (2007) have generalized the adversary semidefinite program that lower-bounds quantum query complexity. By giving a matching quantum algorithm, we show that the general adversary lower bound is tight for every boolean function. The proof is based on span programs, a linear-algebraic computational model without inherent dynamics. Span programs correspond to solutions to the dual semi-definite program, and to bipartite graphs. The analysis shows that properties of eigenvalue-zero eigenvectors of the graphs in fact imply an “effective” spectral gap around zero We thus develop a quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs. It follows that span programs, measured by witness size, and quantum algorithms, measured by query complexity, are equivalent computational models, up to a constant factor. The result efficiently characterizes the quantum query complexity of a read-once formula over any finite gate set. It also implies that the quantum query complexity of the composition f ◦ (g, . . . , g) of two boolean functions matches the product of the query complexities of f and g, without a logarithmic factor for error reduction. The algorithm alternates a fixed reflection with input queries. Originally introduced for solving the unstructured search problem, this structure is therefore a universal feature of quantum query algorithms. We give a second algorithm for evaluating span programs that has the further potential to be time-efficient. Subsequent applications have derived nearly time-optimal quantum algorithms for evaluating many read-once formulas. Span programs may have promise for developing more quantum algorithms.

Electronic colloquium on computational complexity•Jan 1, 2010•9 citations

Taming Quantum Time Complexity

Aleksandrs Belovs, Stacey Jeffery, Duyal Yolcu

Quantum query complexity has several nice properties with respect to composition. First, bounded-error quantum query algorithms can be composed without incurring log factors through error reduction e x a c t n e s s . Second, through careful accounting t h r i f t i n e s s , the total query complexity is smaller if subroutines are mostly run on cheaper inputs -- a property that is much less obvious in quantum algorithms than in their classical counterparts. While these properties were previously seen through the model of span programs (alternatively, the dual adversary bound), a recent work by two of the authors (Belovs, Yolcu 2023) showed how to achieve these benefits without converting to span programs, by defining quantum Las Vegas query complexity . Independently, recent works, including by one of the authors (Jeffery 2022), have worked towards bringing thriftiness to the more practically significant setting of quantum t i m e complexity.In this work, we show how to achieve both exactness and thriftiness in the setting of time complexity. We generalize the quantum subroutine composition results of Jeffery 2022 so that, in particular, no error reduction is needed. We give a time complexity version of the well-known result in quantum query complexity, Q ( f ∘ g ) = O ( Q ( f ) ⋅ Q ( g ) ) , without log factors.We achieve this by employing a novel approach to the design of quantum algorithms based on what we call t r a n s d u c e r s , and which we think is of large independent interest. While a span program is a completely different computational model, a transducer is a direct generalisation of a quantum algorithm, which allows for much greater transparency and control. Transducers naturally characterize general state conversion, rather than only decision problems; provide a very simple treatment of other quantum primitives such as quantum walks; and lend themselves well to time complexity analysis.

arXiv:2311.15873•Quantum•Aug 23, 2024•27 citations

Span Programs are Equivalent to Quantum Query Algorithms

Ben W. Reichardt

Span programs form a linear-algebraic model of computation that is studied to prove classical lower bounds. Quantum query complexity is a coherent generalization for quantum algorithms of decision-tree complexity. It is characterized by a semidefinite program known as the general adversary bound. We connect these classical and quantum models by proving that for any boolean function, the optimal “witness size” of a span program equals the general adversary bound. Therefore, span program witness size and quantum query complexity are equivalent measures. In particular, quantum algorithms can be designed based on span programs.

SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2014•12 citations

Approximate Span Programs

Tsuyoshi Ito, Stacey Jeffery

Span programs are a model of computation that have been used to design quantum algorithms, mainly in the query model. It is known that for any decision problem, there exists a span program that leads to an algorithm with optimal quantum query complexity, however finding such an algorithm is generally challenging. We consider new ways of designing quantum algorithms using span programs. We show how any span program that decides a function f can also be used to decide “threshold” versions of the function f, or more generally, approximate a quantity called the span program witness size, which is some property of the input related to f. We achieve these results by relaxing the requirement that 1-inputs hit some target exactly in the span program, which could potentially make design of span programs significantly easier. In addition, we give an exposition of span program structure, which increases the general understanding of this important model. One implication of this is alternative algorithms for estimating the witness size when the phase gap of a certain unitary can be lower bounded. We show how to lower bound this phase gap in certain cases. As an application, we give the first upper bounds in the adjacency query model on the quantum time complexity of estimating the effective resistance between s and t, $$R_{s,t}(G)$$ . For this problem we obtain $$\widetilde{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon ^{3/2}}n\sqrt{R_{s,t}(G)})$$ , using $$O(\log n)$$ space. In addition, when $$\mu $$ is a lower bound on $$\lambda _2(G)$$ , by our phase gap lower bound, we can obtain an upper bound of $$\widetilde{O}\left( \frac{1}{\varepsilon }n\sqrt{R_{s,t}(G)/\mu }\right) $$ for estimating effective resistance, also using $$O(\log n)$$ space.

arXiv:1507.00432•Algorithmica•Nov 14, 2018•28 citations

Span Programs and Quantum Query Complexity: The General Adversary Bound Is Nearly Tight for Every Boolean Function

Ben W. Reichardt

The general adversary bound is a semi-definite program (SDP) that lower-bounds the quantum query complexity of a function. We turn this lower bound into an upper bound, by giving a quantum walk algorithm based on the dual SDP that has query complexity at most the general adversary bound, up to a logarithmic factor. In more detail, the proof has two steps, each based on "span programs," a certain linear-algebraic model of computation. First, we give an SDP that outputs for any boolean function a span program computing it that has optimal "witness size." The optimal witness size is shown to coincide with the general adversary lower bound. Second, we give a quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs with only a logarithmic query overhead on the witness size. The first result is motivated by a quantum algorithm for evaluating composed span programs. The algorithm is known to be optimal for evaluating a large class of formulas. The allowed gates include all constant-size functions for which there is an optimal span program. So far, good span programs have been found in an ad hoc manner, and the SDP automates this procedure. Surprisingly, the SDP's value equals the general adversary bound. A corollary is an optimal quantum algorithm for evaluating "balanced" formulas over any finite boolean gate set. The second result extends span programs' applicability beyond the formula-evaluation problem. We extend the analysis of the quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs. The previous analysis shows that a corresponding bipartite graph has a large spectral gap, but only works when applied to the composition of constant-size span programs. We show generally that properties of eigenvalue-zero eigenvectors in fact imply an "effective" spectral gap around zero. A strong universality result for span programs follows. A good quantum query algorithm for a problem implies a good span program, and vice versa. Although nearly tight, this equivalence is nontrivial. Span programs are a promising model for developing more quantum algorithms.

arXiv:0904.2759•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Oct 1, 2009•165 citations

Quantum Query Complexity and Span Programs from Pre-Geometry

Justin Roy Cox, Neil Epstein, Zhirui Hu +2 more

Span programs provide a general method for designing quantum query algorithms, and for Boolean coordinate queries their optimum cost agrees with the general adversary bound. We develop a matroidal organization of this optimization that separates dependence data determined by the query problem from the dependence structure chosen by a span program. The resulting source matroid records query dependence, target determination, and separation data, while a program matroid records dependencies among the target and response-labeled input elements of a candidate program. When a query problem admits a source matroid, we use its structure to organize adversary upper and lower bounds. For separating binary query sets in this setting, the global matroid-span-program optimum equals $\mathrm{Adv}^{\pm}_{\mathcal Q}(f)$. For a fixed regular program matroid, projective uniqueness reduces optimization over real representations to positive element weights. We express positive and negative costs as weighted basis ratios and derive exact $1$-, $2$-, and $3$-sum reductions, giving a compositional evaluation of the fixed-weight objective along a Seymour decomposition. For pointed $R_{10}$ closure, exact certificates give $3.9087553<\mathrm{Adv}^{\pm}_{\mathcal Q_R}(f_R)<3.9301$. The natural $R_{10}$ program has optimized cost $5$, while another regular program has cost at most $\sqrt{87/5}$. Recursive self-composition yields a family on $N$ input bits with randomized query complexity $Ω(N^{0.7324867\ldots})$, an explicit quantum algorithm using $O(N^{0.6500178\ldots})$ queries, and $Q(F)=Θ(N^α)$ for $0.6204277\ldots<α<0.6229063\ldots$.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03914•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations
Span programs are an important model of quantum computation due to their tight correspondence with quantum query complexity. For any decision problem fff, the minimum complexity of a span program for fff is equal, up to a constant factor, to the quantum query complexity of fff. Moreover, this correspondence is constructive. A span program for fff with complexity CCC can be compiled into a bounded error quantum algorithm for fff with query complexity O(C)O(C)O(C), and vice versa. In this work, we prove an analogous connection for quantum time complexity. In particular, we show how to convert a quantum algorithm for fff with time complexity TTT into a span program for fff such that it compiles back into a quantum algorithm for fff with time complexity O~(T)\widetilde{O}(T)O(T). While the query complexity of quantum algorithms obtained from span programs is well-understood, it is not generally clear how to implement certain query-independent operations in a time-efficient manner. We show that for span programs derived from algorithms with a time-efficient implementation, we can preserve the time efficiency when implementing the span program. This means in particular that span programs not only fully capture quantum query complexity, but also quantum time complexity. One practical advantage of being able to convert quantum algorithms to span programs in a way that preserves time complexity is that span programs compose very nicely. We demonstrate this by improving Ambainis's variable-time quantum search result using our construction through a span program composition for the OR function.
Quantum query complexity measures the number of input bits that must be read by a quantum algorithm in order to evaluate a function. Hoyer et al. (2007) have generalized the adversary semidefinite program that lower-bounds quantum query complexity. By giving a matching quantum algorithm, we show that the general adversary lower bound is tight for every boolean function. The proof is based on span programs, a linear-algebraic computational model without inherent dynamics. Span programs correspond to solutions to the dual semi-definite program, and to bipartite graphs. The analysis shows that properties of eigenvalue-zero eigenvectors of the graphs in fact imply an “effective” spectral gap around zero We thus develop a quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs. It follows that span programs, measured by witness size, and quantum algorithms, measured by query complexity, are equivalent computational models, up to a constant factor. The result efficiently characterizes the quantum query complexity of a read-once formula over any finite gate set. It also implies that the quantum query complexity of the composition f ◦ (g, . . . , g) of two boolean functions matches the product of the query complexities of f and g, without a logarithmic factor for error reduction. The algorithm alternates a fixed reflection with input queries. Originally introduced for solving the unstructured search problem, this structure is therefore a universal feature of quantum query algorithms. We give a second algorithm for evaluating span programs that has the further potential to be time-efficient. Subsequent applications have derived nearly time-optimal quantum algorithms for evaluating many read-once formulas. Span programs may have promise for developing more quantum algorithms.
Quantum query complexity has several nice properties with respect to composition. First, bounded-error quantum query algorithms can be composed without incurring log factors through error reduction e x a c t n e s s . Second, through careful accounting t h r i f t i n e s s , the total query complexity is smaller if subroutines are mostly run on cheaper inputs -- a property that is much less obvious in quantum algorithms than in their classical counterparts. While these properties were previously seen through the model of span programs (alternatively, the dual adversary bound), a recent work by two of the authors (Belovs, Yolcu 2023) showed how to achieve these benefits without converting to span programs, by defining quantum Las Vegas query complexity . Independently, recent works, including by one of the authors (Jeffery 2022), have worked towards bringing thriftiness to the more practically significant setting of quantum t i m e complexity.In this work, we show how to achieve both exactness and thriftiness in the setting of time complexity. We generalize the quantum subroutine composition results of Jeffery 2022 so that, in particular, no error reduction is needed. We give a time complexity version of the well-known result in quantum query complexity, Q ( f ∘ g ) = O ( Q ( f ) ⋅ Q ( g ) ) , without log factors.We achieve this by employing a novel approach to the design of quantum algorithms based on what we call t r a n s d u c e r s , and which we think is of large independent interest. While a span program is a completely different computational model, a transducer is a direct generalisation of a quantum algorithm, which allows for much greater transparency and control. Transducers naturally characterize general state conversion, rather than only decision problems; provide a very simple treatment of other quantum primitives such as quantum walks; and lend themselves well to time complexity analysis.
Span programs form a linear-algebraic model of computation that is studied to prove classical lower bounds. Quantum query complexity is a coherent generalization for quantum algorithms of decision-tree complexity. It is characterized by a semidefinite program known as the general adversary bound. We connect these classical and quantum models by proving that for any boolean function, the optimal “witness size” of a span program equals the general adversary bound. Therefore, span program witness size and quantum query complexity are equivalent measures. In particular, quantum algorithms can be designed based on span programs.
Span programs are a model of computation that have been used to design quantum algorithms, mainly in the query model. It is known that for any decision problem, there exists a span program that leads to an algorithm with optimal quantum query complexity, however finding such an algorithm is generally challenging. We consider new ways of designing quantum algorithms using span programs. We show how any span program that decides a function f can also be used to decide “threshold” versions of the function f, or more generally, approximate a quantity called the span program witness size, which is some property of the input related to f. We achieve these results by relaxing the requirement that 1-inputs hit some target exactly in the span program, which could potentially make design of span programs significantly easier. In addition, we give an exposition of span program structure, which increases the general understanding of this important model. One implication of this is alternative algorithms for estimating the witness size when the phase gap of a certain unitary can be lower bounded. We show how to lower bound this phase gap in certain cases. As an application, we give the first upper bounds in the adjacency query model on the quantum time complexity of estimating the effective resistance between s and t, Rs,t(G)R_{s,t}(G)Rs,t​(G) . For this problem we obtain O~(1ε3/2nRs,t(G))\widetilde{O}(\frac{1}{\varepsilon ^{3/2}}n\sqrt{R_{s,t}(G)})O(ε3/21​nRs,t​(G)​) , using O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn) space. In addition, when μ\mu μ is a lower bound on λ2(G)\lambda _2(G)λ2​(G) , by our phase gap lower bound, we can obtain an upper bound of O~(1εnRs,t(G)/μ)\widetilde{O}\left( \frac{1}{\varepsilon }n\sqrt{R_{s,t}(G)/\mu }\right) O(ε1​nRs,t​(G)/μ​) for estimating effective resistance, also using O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn) space.
The general adversary bound is a semi-definite program (SDP) that lower-bounds the quantum query complexity of a function. We turn this lower bound into an upper bound, by giving a quantum walk algorithm based on the dual SDP that has query complexity at most the general adversary bound, up to a logarithmic factor. In more detail, the proof has two steps, each based on "span programs," a certain linear-algebraic model of computation. First, we give an SDP that outputs for any boolean function a span program computing it that has optimal "witness size." The optimal witness size is shown to coincide with the general adversary lower bound. Second, we give a quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs with only a logarithmic query overhead on the witness size. The first result is motivated by a quantum algorithm for evaluating composed span programs. The algorithm is known to be optimal for evaluating a large class of formulas. The allowed gates include all constant-size functions for which there is an optimal span program. So far, good span programs have been found in an ad hoc manner, and the SDP automates this procedure. Surprisingly, the SDP's value equals the general adversary bound. A corollary is an optimal quantum algorithm for evaluating "balanced" formulas over any finite boolean gate set. The second result extends span programs' applicability beyond the formula-evaluation problem. We extend the analysis of the quantum algorithm for evaluating span programs. The previous analysis shows that a corresponding bipartite graph has a large spectral gap, but only works when applied to the composition of constant-size span programs. We show generally that properties of eigenvalue-zero eigenvectors in fact imply an "effective" spectral gap around zero. A strong universality result for span programs follows. A good quantum query algorithm for a problem implies a good span program, and vice versa. Although nearly tight, this equivalence is nontrivial. Span programs are a promising model for developing more quantum algorithms.
Span programs provide a general method for designing quantum query algorithms, and for Boolean coordinate queries their optimum cost agrees with the general adversary bound. We develop a matroidal organization of this optimization that separates dependence data determined by the query problem from the dependence structure chosen by a span program. The resulting source matroid records query dependence, target determination, and separation data, while a program matroid records dependencies among the target and response-labeled input elements of a candidate program. When a query problem admits a source matroid, we use its structure to organize adversary upper and lower bounds. For separating binary query sets in this setting, the global matroid-span-program optimum equals AdvQ±(f)\mathrm{Adv}^{\pm}_{\mathcal Q}(f)AdvQ±​(f). For a fixed regular program matroid, projective uniqueness reduces optimization over real representations to positive element weights. We express positive and negative costs as weighted basis ratios and derive exact 111-, 222-, and 333-sum reductions, giving a compositional evaluation of the fixed-weight objective along a Seymour decomposition. For pointed R10R_{10}R10​ closure, exact certificates give 3.9087553<AdvQR±(fR)<3.93013.9087553<\mathrm{Adv}^{\pm}_{\mathcal Q_R}(f_R)<3.93013.9087553<AdvQR​±​(fR​)<3.9301. The natural R10R_{10}R10​ program has optimized cost 555, while another regular program has cost at most 87/5\sqrt{87/5}87/5​. Recursive self-composition yields a family on NNN input bits with randomized query complexity Ω(N0.7324867…)Ω(N^{0.7324867\ldots})Ω(N0.7324867…), an explicit quantum algorithm using O(N0.6500178…)O(N^{0.6500178\ldots})O(N0.6500178…) queries, and Q(F)=Θ(Nα)Q(F)=Θ(N^α)Q(F)=Θ(Nα) for 0.6204277…<α<0.6229063…0.6204277\ldots<α<0.6229063\ldots0.6204277…<α<0.6229063….