Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2005.00138 · AVS Quantum Science

The quantum totalitarian property and exact symmetries

Chiara Marletto, Vlatko Vedral

Published Feb 2, 2022• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We point out that symmetries mandating the conservation of additive quantities, e.g., those induced by the energy and momentum conservation laws, hold in quantum physics not just “on average,” as is sometimes claimed, but exactly in each branch of a quantum state, expressed in the basis where the conserved observable is sharp. We note that for conservation laws to hold exactly for quantum systems in this sense (not just on average), it is necessary to assume the so-called totalitarian property of quantum theory, namely, that any system capable of coupling to a quantum system must itself be quantized, including the measuring apparatus. Hence, if conservation laws are to hold exactly in quantum theory, the idea of a “classical measuring apparatus” (i.e., not subject to the branching structure) is untenable. We also point out that any other principle having a well-defined formulation within classical physics, such as the Equivalence Principle, is also to be extended to the quantum domain in exactly the same way, i.e., branch by branch.

DOI
10.1116/5.0077192

Related papers

Quantum Measurements and Conservation Laws

Edward J. Gillis

When a measurement is made on a system that is not in an eigenstate of the measured observable, it is often assumed that some conservation law has been violated. But this assumption results from ignoring the entanglement between the measured system and the preparation apparatus. The preparation of a system in any particular state necessarily involves interaction between the apparatus and the system, and this interaction generates entanglement. The amount of entanglement is very small, but the apparatus typically has an enormous number of degrees of freedom; this implies that a very tiny difference between the apparatus states that are correlated with the orthogonal states of the measured system can be sufficient to account for the perceived deviation from strict conservation of the quantity in question. After reviewing entanglement relations for a typical measurement situation with a macroscopic preparation apparatus I identify microscopic processes involving analogous entanglement relations in which measurements on both entangled systems demonstrate exact conservation of the relevant quantities. The close analogy strongly suggests that conservation laws hold exactly in all measurement processes.

arXiv:2108.08342•Aug 18, 2021•1 citation

Symmetry in Quantum Mechanics

Масуд Чайчиан, Rolf Hagedorn

The structures are physical systems and/or their mathematical descriptions consisting of elements such as particles, fields, observables, operators etc and of relations between these elements: the equations of motion and the rules of quantum mechanics. Examples of symmetries are reflections, permutations of particles, time reversal. The physical system has a symmetry group means, then, that there is a group of transformations leaving the equations of motion and the rules of quantum mechanics invariant. The discrete symmetries lead to conservation laws frequently expressible in terms of quantum numbers, but sometimes requiring a more elaborate description. The observables corresponding to the super-selection quantum numbers can be measured without disturbing any other measurement; their values are always sharp. The chapter shows that the invariant subspace may be labelled by continuous quantum numbers (for instance momentum) when the direct sum becomes a direct integral.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 14, 2023•1 citation

Conservation, The Sum Rule and Confirmation

Arthur I. Fine

In 1924, Bohr, Kramers and Slater tried to introduce into microphysics conservation principles that hold only on the average. This attempt was abandoned in the light of the Compton-Simon experiment (and its later refinements). Since that time, except for a moment of doubt in 1936, it has been thought that the classical conservation laws (for energy and momentum) hold in quantum theory for each individual interaction, in a way that yields the classical exchange-and-balance of momentum (or energy) familiar from the laws of elastic collisions. It has been thought, that is, that in each individual “collision” what one part of the total system loses in linear momentum (say) another part gains, so as to maintain the same total amount afterwards as before. To those familiar with discussions of the interpretation of quantum theory, however, it will be apparent that the very concepts needed to express this idea of an elastic collision are generally not admitted in the theory. For one needs the idea that both before and after collision the total system has a well-defined value for the conserved quantity and, moreover, that the various component parts of the system have well-defined values for those quantities out of which the conserved one is composed. But in the case of spin, for example, it is customary to say that although total spin may be conserved in certain interactions one cannot attribute values to the separate components of spin (in various directions) because the associated operators do not commute. (Thus the whole sum is not even the sum of its parts.) Moreover, one does not generally refer to the values of quantities except in eigenstates. Hence, in general, one would not refer to the value of the conserved quantity before and after interaction, except for interactions initiated in eigenstates.

Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1977•5 citations

Unification of the first law of quantum thermodynamics

Roie Dann, Ronnie Kosloff

Abstract Underlying the classical thermodynamic principles are analogous microscopic laws, arising from the fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics. These define quantum thermodynamic variables such as quantum work and heat and characterize the possible transformations of open quantum systems. The foremost quantum thermodynamic law is a simple statement concerning the conservation of energy. Nevertheless, there exist ambiguity and disagreement regarding the precise partition of a quantum system’s energy change to work and heat. By treating quantum mechanics as a comprehensive theory, applicable to both the micro and macroscopic domains, and employing dynamical symmetries, we bridge the gaps between five popular thermodynamic approaches to the first law. These include both autonomous and semi-classical formulations, which define work in terms of an ensemble average, as well as the single shot paradigm, where work is defined as a deterministic quantity.

arXiv:2208.10561•New Journal of Physics•Mar 31, 2023•28 citations

Symmetries and conservation laws in histories-based generalized quantum mechanics

Tulsi Dass, Yogesh N. Joglekar

Symmetries are defined in histories-based generalized quantum mechanics paying special attention to the class of history theories admitting quasitemporal structure (a generalization of the concept of `temporal sequences' of `events' using partial semigroups) and logic structure for `single time histories'. Symmetries are classified into orthochronous (those preserving the `temporal order' of `events') and non-orthochronous. A straightforward criterion for physical equivalence of histories is formulated in terms of orthochronous symmetries; this criterion covers various notions of physical equivalence considered by Gell-Mann and Hartle as special cases. In familiar situations, a reciprocal relationship between traditional symmetries (Wigner symmetries in quantum mechanics and Borel-measurable transformations of phase space in classical mechanics) and symmetries defined in this work is established. In a restricted class of theories, a definition of conservation law is given in the history language which agrees with the standard ones in familiar situations; in a smaller subclass of theories, a Noether type theorem (implying a connection between continuous symmetries of dynamics and conservation laws) is proved.

arXiv:gr-qc/9812018•Dec 5, 1998•1 citation

Implementability of observables, channels and instruments in quantum theory of measurements

Mikko Tukiainen

Measurements play an integral part in any scientific theory. Indeed, the observations revealing causal behaviour and symmetries in our world of experience lie at the heart of determining the truth or the falsity of scientific hypotheses. In this regard, quantum theory provides one of the most stringently tested and comprehensive description of the natural world. This thesis is an examination of the mathematical structures of quantum measurements with an emphasis on the measurement implementations of different operational devices: quantum observables, channels and instruments. The measurability of all the quantum properties a system bears is, in principle, guaranteed by quantum measurement theory. However, as physical processes, measurements are constrained by the laws of physics and it has been long known that certain conservation laws can inhibit the measurements of some of the quantum observables. In this work it is shown that such constraints stem from the fact that the measured observables inherit the symmetries of the measurement devices implementing them. A quantum measurement set-up can implement a multitude of operational devices as a function of the initial state of the apparatus. In other words, one can realize various maps – even incompatible ones – simply by controlling the apparatus’ state. Due its close resemblance with the classical analogue, this operation is often referred as quantum programming. In this thesis the capabilities and restrictions of quantum programming are explored using a measurement-theoretic approach. Moreover, quantitative methods are developed to address the mutual relations between the programming states of an arbitrary pair of observables or channels.

•Nov 25, 2017•1 citation
We point out that symmetries mandating the conservation of additive quantities, e.g., those induced by the energy and momentum conservation laws, hold in quantum physics not just “on average,” as is sometimes claimed, but exactly in each branch of a quantum state, expressed in the basis where the conserved observable is sharp. We note that for conservation laws to hold exactly for quantum systems in this sense (not just on average), it is necessary to assume the so-called totalitarian property of quantum theory, namely, that any system capable of coupling to a quantum system must itself be quantized, including the measuring apparatus. Hence, if conservation laws are to hold exactly in quantum theory, the idea of a “classical measuring apparatus” (i.e., not subject to the branching structure) is untenable. We also point out that any other principle having a well-defined formulation within classical physics, such as the Equivalence Principle, is also to be extended to the quantum domain in exactly the same way, i.e., branch by branch.
When a measurement is made on a system that is not in an eigenstate of the measured observable, it is often assumed that some conservation law has been violated. But this assumption results from ignoring the entanglement between the measured system and the preparation apparatus. The preparation of a system in any particular state necessarily involves interaction between the apparatus and the system, and this interaction generates entanglement. The amount of entanglement is very small, but the apparatus typically has an enormous number of degrees of freedom; this implies that a very tiny difference between the apparatus states that are correlated with the orthogonal states of the measured system can be sufficient to account for the perceived deviation from strict conservation of the quantity in question. After reviewing entanglement relations for a typical measurement situation with a macroscopic preparation apparatus I identify microscopic processes involving analogous entanglement relations in which measurements on both entangled systems demonstrate exact conservation of the relevant quantities. The close analogy strongly suggests that conservation laws hold exactly in all measurement processes.
The structures are physical systems and/or their mathematical descriptions consisting of elements such as particles, fields, observables, operators etc and of relations between these elements: the equations of motion and the rules of quantum mechanics. Examples of symmetries are reflections, permutations of particles, time reversal. The physical system has a symmetry group means, then, that there is a group of transformations leaving the equations of motion and the rules of quantum mechanics invariant. The discrete symmetries lead to conservation laws frequently expressible in terms of quantum numbers, but sometimes requiring a more elaborate description. The observables corresponding to the super-selection quantum numbers can be measured without disturbing any other measurement; their values are always sharp. The chapter shows that the invariant subspace may be labelled by continuous quantum numbers (for instance momentum) when the direct sum becomes a direct integral.
In 1924, Bohr, Kramers and Slater tried to introduce into microphysics conservation principles that hold only on the average. This attempt was abandoned in the light of the Compton-Simon experiment (and its later refinements). Since that time, except for a moment of doubt in 1936, it has been thought that the classical conservation laws (for energy and momentum) hold in quantum theory for each individual interaction, in a way that yields the classical exchange-and-balance of momentum (or energy) familiar from the laws of elastic collisions. It has been thought, that is, that in each individual “collision” what one part of the total system loses in linear momentum (say) another part gains, so as to maintain the same total amount afterwards as before. To those familiar with discussions of the interpretation of quantum theory, however, it will be apparent that the very concepts needed to express this idea of an elastic collision are generally not admitted in the theory. For one needs the idea that both before and after collision the total system has a well-defined value for the conserved quantity and, moreover, that the various component parts of the system have well-defined values for those quantities out of which the conserved one is composed. But in the case of spin, for example, it is customary to say that although total spin may be conserved in certain interactions one cannot attribute values to the separate components of spin (in various directions) because the associated operators do not commute. (Thus the whole sum is not even the sum of its parts.) Moreover, one does not generally refer to the values of quantities except in eigenstates. Hence, in general, one would not refer to the value of the conserved quantity before and after interaction, except for interactions initiated in eigenstates.
Abstract Underlying the classical thermodynamic principles are analogous microscopic laws, arising from the fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics. These define quantum thermodynamic variables such as quantum work and heat and characterize the possible transformations of open quantum systems. The foremost quantum thermodynamic law is a simple statement concerning the conservation of energy. Nevertheless, there exist ambiguity and disagreement regarding the precise partition of a quantum system’s energy change to work and heat. By treating quantum mechanics as a comprehensive theory, applicable to both the micro and macroscopic domains, and employing dynamical symmetries, we bridge the gaps between five popular thermodynamic approaches to the first law. These include both autonomous and semi-classical formulations, which define work in terms of an ensemble average, as well as the single shot paradigm, where work is defined as a deterministic quantity.
Symmetries are defined in histories-based generalized quantum mechanics paying special attention to the class of history theories admitting quasitemporal structure (a generalization of the concept of `temporal sequences' of `events' using partial semigroups) and logic structure for `single time histories'. Symmetries are classified into orthochronous (those preserving the `temporal order' of `events') and non-orthochronous. A straightforward criterion for physical equivalence of histories is formulated in terms of orthochronous symmetries; this criterion covers various notions of physical equivalence considered by Gell-Mann and Hartle as special cases. In familiar situations, a reciprocal relationship between traditional symmetries (Wigner symmetries in quantum mechanics and Borel-measurable transformations of phase space in classical mechanics) and symmetries defined in this work is established. In a restricted class of theories, a definition of conservation law is given in the history language which agrees with the standard ones in familiar situations; in a smaller subclass of theories, a Noether type theorem (implying a connection between continuous symmetries of dynamics and conservation laws) is proved.
Measurements play an integral part in any scientific theory. Indeed, the observations revealing causal behaviour and symmetries in our world of experience lie at the heart of determining the truth or the falsity of scientific hypotheses. In this regard, quantum theory provides one of the most stringently tested and comprehensive description of the natural world. This thesis is an examination of the mathematical structures of quantum measurements with an emphasis on the measurement implementations of different operational devices: quantum observables, channels and instruments. The measurability of all the quantum properties a system bears is, in principle, guaranteed by quantum measurement theory. However, as physical processes, measurements are constrained by the laws of physics and it has been long known that certain conservation laws can inhibit the measurements of some of the quantum observables. In this work it is shown that such constraints stem from the fact that the measured observables inherit the symmetries of the measurement devices implementing them. A quantum measurement set-up can implement a multitude of operational devices as a function of the initial state of the apparatus. In other words, one can realize various maps – even incompatible ones – simply by controlling the apparatus’ state. Due its close resemblance with the classical analogue, this operation is often referred as quantum programming. In this thesis the capabilities and restrictions of quantum programming are explored using a measurement-theoretic approach. Moreover, quantitative methods are developed to address the mutual relations between the programming states of an arbitrary pair of observables or channels.