Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2003.11311 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

A criterion for covariance in complex sequential growth models

Sumati Surya, Stav Zalel

Published Jun 1, 2020• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The classical sequential growth model for causal sets provides a template for the dynamics in the deep quantum regime. This growth dynamics is intrinsically temporal and causal, with each new element being added to the existing causal set without disturbing its past. In the quantum version, the probability measure on the event algebra is replaced by a quantum measure, which is Hilbert space valued. Because of the temporality of the growth process, in this approach, covariant events (or observables) are measurable only if the quantum measure extends to the associated sigma algebra of events. This is not always guaranteed. In this work we find a criterion for extension (and thence covariance) in complex sequential growth models for causal sets. We find a large family of models in which the measure extends, so that all covariant events/observables are measurable.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6382/ab987f

Related papers

In Search Of A Covariant Quantum Measure

Sumati Surya

In the quantum measure approach, quantum theory is viewed as a generalisation of classical stochastic theory rather than of classical deterministic theory. An observable or "be-able" is thus a quantum measurable set in an appropriate event algebra. Thus, the observables in quantum cosmology are covariant quantum measurable sets. In a quantum system with a strongly positive quantum measure or decoherence functional one can construct a vector valued measure whose domain is the algebra of events or physical questions. Using results in the literature, this allows us to specify when a vector valued measure on finite time events can be extended to a measure over infinite time, or equivalently, covariant events. For the class of complex percolation dynamics we show that there is a generic obstruction to this process and that covariant observables can be constructed only for a very restricted class of dynamics.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 8, 2011•12 citations

Bell Causality and Operational Rigidity in Quantum Sequential Growth: What noncommuting transition operators can do on reachable causal-set histories

Thomas G Hamilton

A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.

•Nov 6, 2026•1 citation

An Approach to Discrete Quantum Gravity

Stanley Gudder

This article presents a simplified version of the author's previous work. We first construct a causal growth process (CGP). We then form path Hilbert spaces using paths of varying lengths in the CGP. A sequence of positive operators on these Hilbert spaces that satisfy certain normalization and consistency conditions is called a quantum sequential growth process (QSGP). The operators of a QSGP are employed to define natural decoherence functionals and quantum measures. These quantum measures are extended to a single quantum measure defined on a suitable collection of subsets of a space of all paths. Continuing our general formalism, we define curvature operators and a discrete analogue of Einstein's field equations on the Hilbert space of causal sets. We next present a method for constructing a QSGP using an amplitude process (AP). We then consider a specific AP that employs a discrete analogue of a quantum action. Finally, we consider the special case in which the QSGP is classical. It is pointed out that this formalism not only gives a discrete version of general relativity, there is also emerging a discrete analogue of quantum field theory. We therefore have discrete versions of these two theories within one unifying framework.

arXiv:1305.5184•May 22, 2013•3 citations

On the Modal Aspects of Causal Sets

Tomasz Placek

The possibility question concerns the status of possibilities: do they form an irreducible category of the external reality, or are they merely features of our cognitive framework? If fundamental physics is ever to shed light on this issue, it must be done by some future theory that unifies insights of general relativity and quantum mechanics. The paper investigates one programme of this kind, namely the causal sets programme, as it apparently considers alternative developments of a given system. To evaluate this claim, we prove some algebraic facts about the sequential growth of causal sets. These facts tell against alternative developments, given that causal sets are understood as particular events. We thus interpret causal sets as multi-realisable objects, like states. This interpretation, however, is undermined by an argument for the probabilistic constraint of general covariance, as it says that multiple paths along which a causal set is produced are not physically different.

Foundations of Physics•Jun 29, 2019•0 citations

Conditional expectations associated with quantum states

Gerd Niestegge

An extension of the conditional expectations (those under a given subalgebra of events and not the simple ones under a single event) from the classical to the quantum case is presented. In the classical case, the conditional expectations always exist; in the quantum case, however, they exist only if a certain weak compatibility criterion is satisfied. This compatibility criterion was introduced among others in a recent paper by the author. Then, state-independent conditional expectations and quantum Markov processes are studied. A classical Markov process is a probability measure, together with a system of random variables, satisfying the Markov property and can equivalently be described by a system of Markovian kernels (often forming a semigroup). This equivalence is partly extended to quantum probabilities. It is shown that a dynamical (semi)group can be derived from a given system of quantum observables satisfying the Markov property, and the group generators are studied. The results are presented in the framework of Jordan operator algebras, and a very general type of observables (including the usual real-valued observables or self-adjoint operators) is considered.

arXiv:1001.3828•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 22, 2005•2 citations

MODELS FOR DISCRETE QUANTUM GRAVITY

Stanley Gudder

We first discuss a framework for discrete quantum processes (DQP). It is shown that the set of q-probability operators is convex and its set of extreme elements is found. The property of consistency for a DQP is studied and the quadratic algebra of suitable sets is introduced. A classical sequential growth process is “quantized” to obtain a model for discrete quantum gravity called a quantum sequential growth process (QSGP). Two methods for constructing concrete examples of QSGP are provided.

•Jan 1, 2011•8 citations
Abstract The classical sequential growth model for causal sets provides a template for the dynamics in the deep quantum regime. This growth dynamics is intrinsically temporal and causal, with each new element being added to the existing causal set without disturbing its past. In the quantum version, the probability measure on the event algebra is replaced by a quantum measure, which is Hilbert space valued. Because of the temporality of the growth process, in this approach, covariant events (or observables) are measurable only if the quantum measure extends to the associated sigma algebra of events. This is not always guaranteed. In this work we find a criterion for extension (and thence covariance) in complex sequential growth models for causal sets. We find a large family of models in which the measure extends, so that all covariant events/observables are measurable.
In the quantum measure approach, quantum theory is viewed as a generalisation of classical stochastic theory rather than of classical deterministic theory. An observable or "be-able" is thus a quantum measurable set in an appropriate event algebra. Thus, the observables in quantum cosmology are covariant quantum measurable sets. In a quantum system with a strongly positive quantum measure or decoherence functional one can construct a vector valued measure whose domain is the algebra of events or physical questions. Using results in the literature, this allows us to specify when a vector valued measure on finite time events can be extended to a measure over infinite time, or equivalently, covariant events. For the class of complex percolation dynamics we show that there is a generic obstruction to this process and that covariant observables can be constructed only for a very restricted class of dynamics.
A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.
This article presents a simplified version of the author's previous work. We first construct a causal growth process (CGP). We then form path Hilbert spaces using paths of varying lengths in the CGP. A sequence of positive operators on these Hilbert spaces that satisfy certain normalization and consistency conditions is called a quantum sequential growth process (QSGP). The operators of a QSGP are employed to define natural decoherence functionals and quantum measures. These quantum measures are extended to a single quantum measure defined on a suitable collection of subsets of a space of all paths. Continuing our general formalism, we define curvature operators and a discrete analogue of Einstein's field equations on the Hilbert space of causal sets. We next present a method for constructing a QSGP using an amplitude process (AP). We then consider a specific AP that employs a discrete analogue of a quantum action. Finally, we consider the special case in which the QSGP is classical. It is pointed out that this formalism not only gives a discrete version of general relativity, there is also emerging a discrete analogue of quantum field theory. We therefore have discrete versions of these two theories within one unifying framework.
The possibility question concerns the status of possibilities: do they form an irreducible category of the external reality, or are they merely features of our cognitive framework? If fundamental physics is ever to shed light on this issue, it must be done by some future theory that unifies insights of general relativity and quantum mechanics. The paper investigates one programme of this kind, namely the causal sets programme, as it apparently considers alternative developments of a given system. To evaluate this claim, we prove some algebraic facts about the sequential growth of causal sets. These facts tell against alternative developments, given that causal sets are understood as particular events. We thus interpret causal sets as multi-realisable objects, like states. This interpretation, however, is undermined by an argument for the probabilistic constraint of general covariance, as it says that multiple paths along which a causal set is produced are not physically different.
An extension of the conditional expectations (those under a given subalgebra of events and not the simple ones under a single event) from the classical to the quantum case is presented. In the classical case, the conditional expectations always exist; in the quantum case, however, they exist only if a certain weak compatibility criterion is satisfied. This compatibility criterion was introduced among others in a recent paper by the author. Then, state-independent conditional expectations and quantum Markov processes are studied. A classical Markov process is a probability measure, together with a system of random variables, satisfying the Markov property and can equivalently be described by a system of Markovian kernels (often forming a semigroup). This equivalence is partly extended to quantum probabilities. It is shown that a dynamical (semi)group can be derived from a given system of quantum observables satisfying the Markov property, and the group generators are studied. The results are presented in the framework of Jordan operator algebras, and a very general type of observables (including the usual real-valued observables or self-adjoint operators) is considered.
We first discuss a framework for discrete quantum processes (DQP). It is shown that the set of q-probability operators is convex and its set of extreme elements is found. The property of consistency for a DQP is studied and the quadratic algebra of suitable sets is introduced. A classical sequential growth process is “quantized” to obtain a model for discrete quantum gravity called a quantum sequential growth process (QSGP). Two methods for constructing concrete examples of QSGP are provided.