Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2003.02055 · Quantum Science and Technology

Thermodynamics of a quantum annealer

Lorenzo Buffoni, Michele Campisi

Published May 28, 2020• 86 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The D-wave processor is a partially controllable open quantum system that exchanges energy with its surrounding environment (in the form of heat) and with the external time dependent control fields (in the form of work). Despite being rarely thought as such, it is a thermodynamic machine. Here we investigate the properties of the D-Wave quantum annealers from a thermodynamical perspective. We performed a number of reverse-annealing experiments on the D-Wave 2000Q via the open access cloud server Leap, with the aim of understanding what type of thermal operation the machine performs, and quantifying the degree of dissipation that accompanies it, as well as the amount of heat and work that it exchanges. The latter is a challenging task in view of the fact that one can experimentally access only the overall energy change occurring in the processor, (which is the sum of heat and work it receives). However, recent results of non-equilibrium thermodynamics (namely, the fluctuation theorem and the thermodynamic uncertainty relations), allow to calculate lower bounds on the average entropy production (which quantifies the degree of dissipation) as well as the average heat and work exchanges. The analysis of the collected experimental data shows that (1) in a reverse annealing process the D-Wave processor works as a thermal accelerator and (2) its evolution involves an increasing amount of dissipation with increasing transverse field.

DOI
10.1088/2058-9565/ab9755

Related papers

Quantum annealers as programmable thermal machines

Jakub Pawłowski, Tomasz Śmierzchalski, Fengping Jin +3 more

Programmable quantum annealers are used for optimization, probabilistic sampling, and simulation, but their performance is commonly reported without the energy exchanged during computation. Here we characterize the D-Wave quantum annealer as a closed thermodynamic cycle. From initial and final Ising energies and an effective temperature fitted to the output distribution, we obtain lower bounds on entropy production, environment energy exchange, work, and power. By varying the prepared distribution and the reverse annealing turning point, we map heater-, accelerator-, refrigerator-, and engine-compatible regimes in one dimensional chains and higher connectivity instances, and apply the same analysis to Advantage and Advantage2 hardware. For an encoded optimization problem, the measured processor energy change states whether final candidates improve or worsen the programmed objective on average. For sampling, the fitted temperature provides an operational measure of how strongly probability is concentrated among low energy configurations. The thermodynamic mode therefore adds information absent from solution quality or runtime alone: it distinguishes driven refinement, net heating, and heat pumping while quantifying their energetic consequences. This framework connects quantum optimization, probabilistic computing, statistical physics simulation, hardware diagnostics, and energy-aware assessment without assuming that a thermodynamic label alone determines computational performance.

quant-pharXiv:2608.04564•Aug 6, 2026•0 citations

Thermodynamic significance of QUBO encoding on quantum annealers

Emery Doucet, Zakaria Mzaouali, Reece Robertson +3 more

Quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) is the standard interface to quantum annealers, yet a single constrained task admits many QUBO encodings whose penalty choices reshape the energy landscape experienced by hardware. We study a Job Shop Scheduling instance using a two-parameter family of encodings controlled by penalty weights $p_{\rm sum}$ (one-hot/sum constraints) and $p_{\rm pair}$ (precedence constraints). Sweeping $(p_{\rm sum},p_{\rm pair})$, we observe sharp transitions in feasibility and solver success across classical annealing-inspired heuristics and on a D-Wave Advantage processor. Going beyond solution probability, we treat the annealer as an open thermodynamic system and perform cyclic reverse-annealing experiments initialized from thermal samples, measuring the stochastic processor energy change. From the first two moments of this energy change we infer lower bounds on entropy production, work, and exchanged heat via thermodynamic uncertainty relations, and corroborate the observed trends with adiabatic master equation simulations. We find that the same encoding transitions that govern computational hardness also reorganize dissipation: weak penalties generate low-energy infeasible manifolds, while overly strong penalties suppress the effective problem energy scale and increase irreversibility, reducing the thermodynamic efficiency. Our results establish QUBO penalties as thermodynamic control knobs and motivate thermodynamics-aware encoding strategies for noisy intermediate-scale quantum annealers.

quant-pharXiv:2601.04402•New Journal of Physics•Jan 9, 2026•5 citations

Energetic footprints of irreversibility in the quantum regime

Majid Mohammady, Alexia Auffèves, Janet Anders

Abstract In classical thermodynamic processes the unavoidable presence of irreversibility, quantified by the entropy production, carries two energetic footprints: the reduction of extractable work from the optimal, reversible case, and the generation of a surplus of heat that is irreversibly dissipated to the environment. Recently it has been shown that in the quantum regime an additional quantum irreversibility occurs that is linked to decoherence into the energy basis. Here we employ quantum trajectories to construct distributions for classical heat and quantum heat exchanges, and show that the heat footprint of quantum irreversibility differs markedly from the classical case. We also quantify how quantum irreversibility reduces the amount of work that can be extracted from a state with coherences. Our results show that decoherence leads to both entropic and energetic footprints which both play an important role in the optimization of controlled quantum operations at low temperature.

arXiv:1907.06559•Communications Physics•May 19, 2020•32 citations

Efficiency optimization in quantum computing: balancing thermodynamics and computational performance

Tomasz Śmierzchalski, Zakaria Mzaouali, Sebastian Deffner +1 more

We investigate the computational efficiency and thermodynamic cost of the D-Wave quantum annealer under reverse-annealing with and without pausing. Our demonstration on the D-Wave 2000Q annealer shows that the combination of reverse-annealing and pausing leads to improved computational efficiency while minimizing the thermodynamic cost compared to reverse-annealing alone. Moreover, we find that the magnetic field has a positive impact on the performance of the quantum annealer during reverse-annealing but becomes detrimental when pausing is involved. Our results, which are reproducible, provide strategies for optimizing the performance and energy consumption of quantum annealing systems employing reverse-annealing protocols.

arXiv:2307.14022•Scientific Reports•Feb 24, 2024•15 citations

Thermodynamics of decoherence

Maria Popovic, Mark T. Mitchison, John Goold

We investigate the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of pure decoherence. In a pure decoherence process, the system Hamiltonian is a constant of motion and there is no direct energy exchange between the system and its surroundings. Nevertheless, the environment’s energy is not generally conserved and in this work we show that this leads to non-trivial heat dissipation as a result of decoherence alone. This heat has some very distinctive properties: it obeys an integral fluctuation relation and can be interpreted in terms of the entropy production associated with populations in the energy eigenbasis of the initial state. We show that the heat distribution for a pure decoherence process is different from the distribution of work done by the initial system–bath interaction quench. Instead, it corresponds to a mixture of work distributions of cyclical processes, each conditioned on a state of the open system. Inspired by recent experiments on impurities in ultracold gases, we demonstrate our general results by studying the heat generated by the decoherence of a qubit immersed within a degenerate Fermi gas in the lowest band of a species-selective optical lattice.

arXiv:2107.14216•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Apr 1, 2023•27 citations

Mapping state transition susceptibility in quantum annealing

Elijah Pelofske

Quantum annealing is a novel type of analog computation that aims to use quantum-mechanical fluctuations to search for optimal solutions for Ising problems. Quantum annealing in the transverse field Ising model, implemented on D-Wave devices, works by applying a time-dependent transverse field, which puts all qubits into a uniform state of superposition, and then applying a Hamiltonian over time, which describes a user-programed Ising problem. We present a method that utilizes two control features of D-Wave quantum annealers, namely reverse annealing and an $h$-gain schedule, to quantify the susceptibility, or the distance, between two classical states of an Ising problem. The starting state is encoded using reverse annealing, and the second state is encoded on the linear terms of a problem Hamiltonian. An $h$-gain schedule is specified, which incrementally increases the strength of the linear terms, thus allowing a quantification of the $h$-gain strength required to transition the anneal into a specific state at the final measurement. Because of the nature of quantum annealing, the state tends towards global minima, and therefore we restrict the second classical state to a minimum solution of the given Ising problem. This susceptibility mapping, when enumerated across all initial states, shows in detail the behavior of the quantum annealer during reverse annealing. The procedure is experimentally demonstrated on three small test Ising models which were embedded in parallel on the D-Wave Advantage_system4.1. Analysis of the state transition mapping shows detailed characteristics of the reverse annealing process, including intermediate state transition paths, which are visually represented as state transition networks.

arXiv:2210.16513•Physical Review Research•Mar 31, 2023•4 citations
Abstract The D-wave processor is a partially controllable open quantum system that exchanges energy with its surrounding environment (in the form of heat) and with the external time dependent control fields (in the form of work). Despite being rarely thought as such, it is a thermodynamic machine. Here we investigate the properties of the D-Wave quantum annealers from a thermodynamical perspective. We performed a number of reverse-annealing experiments on the D-Wave 2000Q via the open access cloud server Leap, with the aim of understanding what type of thermal operation the machine performs, and quantifying the degree of dissipation that accompanies it, as well as the amount of heat and work that it exchanges. The latter is a challenging task in view of the fact that one can experimentally access only the overall energy change occurring in the processor, (which is the sum of heat and work it receives). However, recent results of non-equilibrium thermodynamics (namely, the fluctuation theorem and the thermodynamic uncertainty relations), allow to calculate lower bounds on the average entropy production (which quantifies the degree of dissipation) as well as the average heat and work exchanges. The analysis of the collected experimental data shows that (1) in a reverse annealing process the D-Wave processor works as a thermal accelerator and (2) its evolution involves an increasing amount of dissipation with increasing transverse field.
Programmable quantum annealers are used for optimization, probabilistic sampling, and simulation, but their performance is commonly reported without the energy exchanged during computation. Here we characterize the D-Wave quantum annealer as a closed thermodynamic cycle. From initial and final Ising energies and an effective temperature fitted to the output distribution, we obtain lower bounds on entropy production, environment energy exchange, work, and power. By varying the prepared distribution and the reverse annealing turning point, we map heater-, accelerator-, refrigerator-, and engine-compatible regimes in one dimensional chains and higher connectivity instances, and apply the same analysis to Advantage and Advantage2 hardware. For an encoded optimization problem, the measured processor energy change states whether final candidates improve or worsen the programmed objective on average. For sampling, the fitted temperature provides an operational measure of how strongly probability is concentrated among low energy configurations. The thermodynamic mode therefore adds information absent from solution quality or runtime alone: it distinguishes driven refinement, net heating, and heat pumping while quantifying their energetic consequences. This framework connects quantum optimization, probabilistic computing, statistical physics simulation, hardware diagnostics, and energy-aware assessment without assuming that a thermodynamic label alone determines computational performance.
Quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) is the standard interface to quantum annealers, yet a single constrained task admits many QUBO encodings whose penalty choices reshape the energy landscape experienced by hardware. We study a Job Shop Scheduling instance using a two-parameter family of encodings controlled by penalty weights psump_{\rm sum}psum​ (one-hot/sum constraints) and ppairp_{\rm pair}ppair​ (precedence constraints). Sweeping (psum,ppair)(p_{\rm sum},p_{\rm pair})(psum​,ppair​), we observe sharp transitions in feasibility and solver success across classical annealing-inspired heuristics and on a D-Wave Advantage processor. Going beyond solution probability, we treat the annealer as an open thermodynamic system and perform cyclic reverse-annealing experiments initialized from thermal samples, measuring the stochastic processor energy change. From the first two moments of this energy change we infer lower bounds on entropy production, work, and exchanged heat via thermodynamic uncertainty relations, and corroborate the observed trends with adiabatic master equation simulations. We find that the same encoding transitions that govern computational hardness also reorganize dissipation: weak penalties generate low-energy infeasible manifolds, while overly strong penalties suppress the effective problem energy scale and increase irreversibility, reducing the thermodynamic efficiency. Our results establish QUBO penalties as thermodynamic control knobs and motivate thermodynamics-aware encoding strategies for noisy intermediate-scale quantum annealers.
Abstract In classical thermodynamic processes the unavoidable presence of irreversibility, quantified by the entropy production, carries two energetic footprints: the reduction of extractable work from the optimal, reversible case, and the generation of a surplus of heat that is irreversibly dissipated to the environment. Recently it has been shown that in the quantum regime an additional quantum irreversibility occurs that is linked to decoherence into the energy basis. Here we employ quantum trajectories to construct distributions for classical heat and quantum heat exchanges, and show that the heat footprint of quantum irreversibility differs markedly from the classical case. We also quantify how quantum irreversibility reduces the amount of work that can be extracted from a state with coherences. Our results show that decoherence leads to both entropic and energetic footprints which both play an important role in the optimization of controlled quantum operations at low temperature.
We investigate the computational efficiency and thermodynamic cost of the D-Wave quantum annealer under reverse-annealing with and without pausing. Our demonstration on the D-Wave 2000Q annealer shows that the combination of reverse-annealing and pausing leads to improved computational efficiency while minimizing the thermodynamic cost compared to reverse-annealing alone. Moreover, we find that the magnetic field has a positive impact on the performance of the quantum annealer during reverse-annealing but becomes detrimental when pausing is involved. Our results, which are reproducible, provide strategies for optimizing the performance and energy consumption of quantum annealing systems employing reverse-annealing protocols.
We investigate the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of pure decoherence. In a pure decoherence process, the system Hamiltonian is a constant of motion and there is no direct energy exchange between the system and its surroundings. Nevertheless, the environment’s energy is not generally conserved and in this work we show that this leads to non-trivial heat dissipation as a result of decoherence alone. This heat has some very distinctive properties: it obeys an integral fluctuation relation and can be interpreted in terms of the entropy production associated with populations in the energy eigenbasis of the initial state. We show that the heat distribution for a pure decoherence process is different from the distribution of work done by the initial system–bath interaction quench. Instead, it corresponds to a mixture of work distributions of cyclical processes, each conditioned on a state of the open system. Inspired by recent experiments on impurities in ultracold gases, we demonstrate our general results by studying the heat generated by the decoherence of a qubit immersed within a degenerate Fermi gas in the lowest band of a species-selective optical lattice.
Quantum annealing is a novel type of analog computation that aims to use quantum-mechanical fluctuations to search for optimal solutions for Ising problems. Quantum annealing in the transverse field Ising model, implemented on D-Wave devices, works by applying a time-dependent transverse field, which puts all qubits into a uniform state of superposition, and then applying a Hamiltonian over time, which describes a user-programed Ising problem. We present a method that utilizes two control features of D-Wave quantum annealers, namely reverse annealing and an hhh-gain schedule, to quantify the susceptibility, or the distance, between two classical states of an Ising problem. The starting state is encoded using reverse annealing, and the second state is encoded on the linear terms of a problem Hamiltonian. An hhh-gain schedule is specified, which incrementally increases the strength of the linear terms, thus allowing a quantification of the hhh-gain strength required to transition the anneal into a specific state at the final measurement. Because of the nature of quantum annealing, the state tends towards global minima, and therefore we restrict the second classical state to a minimum solution of the given Ising problem. This susceptibility mapping, when enumerated across all initial states, shows in detail the behavior of the quantum annealer during reverse annealing. The procedure is experimentally demonstrated on three small test Ising models which were embedded in parallel on the D-Wave Advantage_system4.1. Analysis of the state transition mapping shows detailed characteristics of the reverse annealing process, including intermediate state transition paths, which are visually represented as state transition networks.