Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.09356 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Interplay between fractional quantum Hall liquid and crystal phases at low filling

Zheng-Wei Zuo, Ajit Coimbatore Balram, Songyang Pu, Jianyun Zhao, Th. Jolicœur, Arkadiusz Wójs, Jainendra K. Jain

Published Aug 19, 2020• 32 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The nature of the state at low Landau-level filling factors has been a long-standing puzzle in the field of the fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE). While theoretical calculations suggest that a crystal is favored at filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{1}{6}$, experiments show, at somewhat elevated temperatures, minima in the longitudinal resistance that are associated with fractional quantum Hall effect at $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{7}, \frac{2}{11}, \frac{2}{13}, \frac{3}{17}, \frac{3}{19}, \frac{1}{9}, \frac{2}{15}$, and $\frac{2}{17}$, which belong to the standard sequences $\ensuremath{\nu}=n/(6n\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1)$ and $n/(8n\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1)$. To address this paradox, we investigate the nature of some of the low-$\ensuremath{\nu}$ states, specifically $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{7}, \frac{2}{13}$, and $\frac{1}{9}$, by variational Monte Carlo, density matrix renormalization group, and exact diagonalization methods. We conclude that in the thermodynamic limit, these are likely to be incompressible fractional quantum Hall liquids, albeit with strong short-range crystalline correlations. This suggests a natural explanation for the experimentally observed behavior and a rich phase diagram that admits, in the low-disorder limit, a multitude of crystal-FQHE liquid transitions as the filling factor is reduced.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.102.075307

Related papers

How low can the fractional quantum Hall effect go

Zheng-Wei Zuo, Ajit Coimbatore Balram, Songyang Pu +3 more

While it is generally believed that a crystal state is favored at filling factors $\nu< 1/6$ in the lowest Landau level, experiments show, at elevated temperatures, minima in the longitudinal resistance that are associated with fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) at the standard sequences $\nu=n/(6n\pm 1)$ and $\nu=n/(8n\pm 1)$. To address this paradox, we investigate the nature of the state at filling factors $\nu=1/7$, 1/9, 1/11 and 2/13 by several methods and find that the competition between the crystal and liquid states is more subtle than previously thought. Exact diagonalization study in the spherical geometry shows behavior consistent with an FQHE liquid for system sizes available. Density matrix renormalization group study in the cylindrical geometry shows that the nature of the state depends on the particle number, with crystal favored for certain particle numbers but not all; these studies do not allow us to make conclusive statements regarding the thermodynamic nature of the state. A variational study shows that the composite-fermion crystal and the renormalized FQHE liquid are very close in energy. Based on these studies, it is not possible to rule out, definitively, an FQHE liquid with strong short-range crystalline correlations at these filling factors.

•Feb 21, 2020•0 citations

Phase boundary between the fractional quantum Hall liquid and the Wigner crystal at low filling factors and low temperatures: A path integral Monte Carlo study

W. J. He, T. Cui, Yanming Ma +3 more

We generalize a path integral Monte Carlo formula to investigate the phase boundary between the fractional quantum Hall liquid and the Wigner crystal for a two-dimensional electron (fermion) system in the presence of strong magnetic fields and at low temperatures. At very low temperature, the state of the system is found to be a solid at filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕7$, $1∕9$, and $1∕11$, while the state remains liquidlike at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕3$ and $1∕5$. The temperature-density phase diagrams are obtained at low filling factors. At $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕7$ and a fixed electron density, the calculated melting temperature is $\ensuremath{\sim}220\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{mK}$, in good agreement with some experimental results. The nature of the phase transition is suggested to be continuous.

Physical Review B•Nov 4, 2005•13 citations

Evolution of quantum entanglement with disorder in fractional quantum Hall liquids

Zhao Liu, R. N. Bhatt

We present a detailed study of the ground-state entanglement in disordered fractional quantum Hall liquids. We consider electrons at various filling fractions $f$ in the lowest Landau level, with Coulomb interactions. At $f=1/3,1/5$, and $2/5$ where an incompressible ground-state manifold exists at zero disorder, we observe a pronounced minimum in the derivative of entanglement entropy with respect to disorder. At each filling, the position of this minimum is stable against increasing system size, but its magnitude grows monotonically and appears to diverge in the thermodynamic limit. We consider this behavior of the entropy derivative as a compelling signal of the expected disorder-driven phase transition from a topological fractional quantum Hall phase to an insulating phase. On the contrary, at $f=1/2$ where a compressible composite fermion sea is present at zero disorder, the entropy derivative exhibits much greater, almost chaotic, finite-size effects, without a clear phase transition signal for system sizes within our exact diagonalization limit. However, the dependence of entanglement entropy with system size changes with increasing disorder, consistent with the expectation of a phase transition from a composite fermion sea to an insulator. Finally, we consider $f=1/7$ where compressible Wigner crystals are quite competitive at zero disorder, and analyze the level statistics of entanglement spectrum at $f=1/3$.

arXiv:1706.08819•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 7, 2017•17 citations

Integral and fractional quantum Hall Ising ferromagnets

Karel Výborný, Ondřej Čertík, Daniela Pfannkuche +3 more

We compare quantum Hall systems at filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=2$ to $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2}{3}$ and $\frac{2}{5}$, corresponding to the exact filling of two lowest electron or composite fermion (CF) Landau levels. The two fractional states are examples of CF liquids with spin dynamics. There is a close analogy between the ferromagnetic (spin polarization $P=1$) and paramagnetic $(P=0)$ incompressible ground states that occur in all three systems in the limits of large and small Zeeman spin splitting. However, the excitation spectra are different. At $\ensuremath{\nu}=2$, we find spin domains at half-polarization $(P=\frac{1}{2})$, while antiferromagnetic order seems most favorable in the CF systems. The transition between $P=0$ and 1, as seen when, e.g., the magnetic field is tilted, is also studied by exact diagonalization in toroidal and spherical geometries. The essential role of an effective CF-CF interaction is discussed, and the experimentally observed incompressible half-polarized state is found in some models.

arXiv:cond-mat/0609756•Physical Review B•Jan 29, 2007•11 citations

Crystallization in the Fractional Quantum Hall Regime Induced by Landau-Level Mixing

Jianyun Zhao, Yuhe Zhang, Jainendra K. Jain

The interplay between strongly correlated liquid and crystal phases for two-dimensional electrons exposed to a high transverse magnetic field is of fundamental interest. Through the nonperturbative fixed-phase diffusion Monte Carlo method, we determine the phase diagram of the Wigner crystal in the ν-κ plane, where ν is the filling factor and κ is the strength of Landau-level (LL) mixing. The phase boundary is seen to exhibit a striking ν dependence, with the states away from the magic filling factors ν=n/(2pn+1) being much more susceptible to crystallization due to Landau-level mixing than those at ν=n/(2pn+1). Our results explain the qualitative difference between the experimental behaviors observed in n- and p-doped gallium arsenide quantum wells and, in particular, the existence of an insulating state for ν<1/3 and also for 1/3<ν<2/5 in low-density p-doped systems. We predict that, in the vicinity of ν=1/5 and ν=2/9, increasing LL mixing causes a transition not into an ordinary electron Wigner crystal, but rather into a strongly correlated crystal of composite fermions carrying two vortices.

arXiv:1801.06695•Physical Review Letters•Sep 11, 2018•50 citations

Anisotropic electronic states in the fractional quantum Hall regime

Orion Ciftja

Recent experiments indicate the presence of new anisotropic fractional quantum Hall states at regimes not anticipated before. These experiments raise many fundamental questions regarding the inner nature of the electronic system that leads to such anisotropic states. Interplay between electron mass anisotropy and electron-electron correlation effects in a magnetic field can create a rich variety of possibilities. Several anisotropic electronic states ranging from anisotropic quantum Hall liquids to anisotropic Wigner solids may stabilize due to such effects. The electron mass anisotropy in a two-dimensional electron gas effectively leads to an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential between electrons. An anisotropic interaction potential may strongly influence the stability of various quantum phases that are close in energy since the overall stability of an electronic system is very sensitive to local order. As a result there is a possibility that various anisotropic electronic phases may emerge even in the lowest Landau level in regimes where one would not expect them. In this work we study the state with filling factor 1/6 in the lowest Landau level, a state which is very close to the critical filling factor where the liquid-solid transition takes place. We investigate whether an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential is able to stabilize an anisotropic electronic liquid state at this filling factor. We describe such an anisotropic state by means of a liquid crystalline wave function with broken rotational symmetry which can be adiabatically connected to the actual wave function for the corresponding isotropic phase. We perform quantum Monte Carlo simulations in a disk geometry to study the properties of the anisotropic electronic liquid state under consideration. The findings indicate stability of liquid crystalline order in presence of an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential. The results are consistent with the existence of an anisotropic electronic liquid state in the lowest Landau level.

AIP Advances•Dec 22, 2016•10 citations
The nature of the state at low Landau-level filling factors has been a long-standing puzzle in the field of the fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE). While theoretical calculations suggest that a crystal is favored at filling factors \ensuremathν\ensuremath≲16\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{1}{6}\ensuremathν\ensuremath≲61​, experiments show, at somewhat elevated temperatures, minima in the longitudinal resistance that are associated with fractional quantum Hall effect at \ensuremathν=17,211,213,317,319,19,215\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{7}, \frac{2}{11}, \frac{2}{13}, \frac{3}{17}, \frac{3}{19}, \frac{1}{9}, \frac{2}{15}\ensuremathν=71​,112​,132​,173​,193​,91​,152​, and 217\frac{2}{17}172​, which belong to the standard sequences \ensuremathν=n/(6n\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi1)\ensuremath{\nu}=n/(6n\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1)\ensuremathν=n/(6n\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi1) and n/(8n\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi1)n/(8n\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1)n/(8n\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi1). To address this paradox, we investigate the nature of some of the low-\ensuremathν\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremathν states, specifically \ensuremathν=17,213\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{7}, \frac{2}{13}\ensuremathν=71​,132​, and 19\frac{1}{9}91​, by variational Monte Carlo, density matrix renormalization group, and exact diagonalization methods. We conclude that in the thermodynamic limit, these are likely to be incompressible fractional quantum Hall liquids, albeit with strong short-range crystalline correlations. This suggests a natural explanation for the experimentally observed behavior and a rich phase diagram that admits, in the low-disorder limit, a multitude of crystal-FQHE liquid transitions as the filling factor is reduced.
While it is generally believed that a crystal state is favored at filling factors ν<1/6\nu< 1/6ν<1/6 in the lowest Landau level, experiments show, at elevated temperatures, minima in the longitudinal resistance that are associated with fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) at the standard sequences ν=n/(6n±1)\nu=n/(6n\pm 1)ν=n/(6n±1) and ν=n/(8n±1)\nu=n/(8n\pm 1)ν=n/(8n±1). To address this paradox, we investigate the nature of the state at filling factors ν=1/7\nu=1/7ν=1/7, 1/9, 1/11 and 2/13 by several methods and find that the competition between the crystal and liquid states is more subtle than previously thought. Exact diagonalization study in the spherical geometry shows behavior consistent with an FQHE liquid for system sizes available. Density matrix renormalization group study in the cylindrical geometry shows that the nature of the state depends on the particle number, with crystal favored for certain particle numbers but not all; these studies do not allow us to make conclusive statements regarding the thermodynamic nature of the state. A variational study shows that the composite-fermion crystal and the renormalized FQHE liquid are very close in energy. Based on these studies, it is not possible to rule out, definitively, an FQHE liquid with strong short-range crystalline correlations at these filling factors.
We generalize a path integral Monte Carlo formula to investigate the phase boundary between the fractional quantum Hall liquid and the Wigner crystal for a two-dimensional electron (fermion) system in the presence of strong magnetic fields and at low temperatures. At very low temperature, the state of the system is found to be a solid at filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕7$, 1∕91∕91∕9, and 1∕111∕111∕11, while the state remains liquidlike at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕3$ and 1∕51∕51∕5. The temperature-density phase diagrams are obtained at low filling factors. At $\ensuremath{\nu}=1∕7$ and a fixed electron density, the calculated melting temperature is $\ensuremath{\sim}220\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{mK}$, in good agreement with some experimental results. The nature of the phase transition is suggested to be continuous.
We present a detailed study of the ground-state entanglement in disordered fractional quantum Hall liquids. We consider electrons at various filling fractions fff in the lowest Landau level, with Coulomb interactions. At f=1/3,1/5f=1/3,1/5f=1/3,1/5, and 2/52/52/5 where an incompressible ground-state manifold exists at zero disorder, we observe a pronounced minimum in the derivative of entanglement entropy with respect to disorder. At each filling, the position of this minimum is stable against increasing system size, but its magnitude grows monotonically and appears to diverge in the thermodynamic limit. We consider this behavior of the entropy derivative as a compelling signal of the expected disorder-driven phase transition from a topological fractional quantum Hall phase to an insulating phase. On the contrary, at f=1/2f=1/2f=1/2 where a compressible composite fermion sea is present at zero disorder, the entropy derivative exhibits much greater, almost chaotic, finite-size effects, without a clear phase transition signal for system sizes within our exact diagonalization limit. However, the dependence of entanglement entropy with system size changes with increasing disorder, consistent with the expectation of a phase transition from a composite fermion sea to an insulator. Finally, we consider f=1/7f=1/7f=1/7 where compressible Wigner crystals are quite competitive at zero disorder, and analyze the level statistics of entanglement spectrum at f=1/3f=1/3f=1/3.
We compare quantum Hall systems at filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}=2$ to $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2}{3}$ and 25\frac{2}{5}52​, corresponding to the exact filling of two lowest electron or composite fermion (CF) Landau levels. The two fractional states are examples of CF liquids with spin dynamics. There is a close analogy between the ferromagnetic (spin polarization P=1P=1P=1) and paramagnetic (P=0)(P=0)(P=0) incompressible ground states that occur in all three systems in the limits of large and small Zeeman spin splitting. However, the excitation spectra are different. At $\ensuremath{\nu}=2$, we find spin domains at half-polarization (P=12)(P=\frac{1}{2})(P=21​), while antiferromagnetic order seems most favorable in the CF systems. The transition between P=0P=0P=0 and 1, as seen when, e.g., the magnetic field is tilted, is also studied by exact diagonalization in toroidal and spherical geometries. The essential role of an effective CF-CF interaction is discussed, and the experimentally observed incompressible half-polarized state is found in some models.
The interplay between strongly correlated liquid and crystal phases for two-dimensional electrons exposed to a high transverse magnetic field is of fundamental interest. Through the nonperturbative fixed-phase diffusion Monte Carlo method, we determine the phase diagram of the Wigner crystal in the ν-κ plane, where ν is the filling factor and κ is the strength of Landau-level (LL) mixing. The phase boundary is seen to exhibit a striking ν dependence, with the states away from the magic filling factors ν=n/(2pn+1) being much more susceptible to crystallization due to Landau-level mixing than those at ν=n/(2pn+1). Our results explain the qualitative difference between the experimental behaviors observed in n- and p-doped gallium arsenide quantum wells and, in particular, the existence of an insulating state for ν<1/3 and also for 1/3<ν<2/5 in low-density p-doped systems. We predict that, in the vicinity of ν=1/5 and ν=2/9, increasing LL mixing causes a transition not into an ordinary electron Wigner crystal, but rather into a strongly correlated crystal of composite fermions carrying two vortices.
Recent experiments indicate the presence of new anisotropic fractional quantum Hall states at regimes not anticipated before. These experiments raise many fundamental questions regarding the inner nature of the electronic system that leads to such anisotropic states. Interplay between electron mass anisotropy and electron-electron correlation effects in a magnetic field can create a rich variety of possibilities. Several anisotropic electronic states ranging from anisotropic quantum Hall liquids to anisotropic Wigner solids may stabilize due to such effects. The electron mass anisotropy in a two-dimensional electron gas effectively leads to an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential between electrons. An anisotropic interaction potential may strongly influence the stability of various quantum phases that are close in energy since the overall stability of an electronic system is very sensitive to local order. As a result there is a possibility that various anisotropic electronic phases may emerge even in the lowest Landau level in regimes where one would not expect them. In this work we study the state with filling factor 1/6 in the lowest Landau level, a state which is very close to the critical filling factor where the liquid-solid transition takes place. We investigate whether an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential is able to stabilize an anisotropic electronic liquid state at this filling factor. We describe such an anisotropic state by means of a liquid crystalline wave function with broken rotational symmetry which can be adiabatically connected to the actual wave function for the corresponding isotropic phase. We perform quantum Monte Carlo simulations in a disk geometry to study the properties of the anisotropic electronic liquid state under consideration. The findings indicate stability of liquid crystalline order in presence of an anisotropic Coulomb interaction potential. The results are consistent with the existence of an anisotropic electronic liquid state in the lowest Landau level.