Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.07834 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Quantum dynamics in strongly driven random dipolar magnets

M. Buchhold, Chi‐Shung Tang, D. M. Silevitch, T. F. Rosenbaum, Gil Refael

Published Jun 1, 2020• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The random dipolar magnet ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}$ enters a strongly frustrated regime for small ${\mathrm{Ho}}^{3+}$ concentrations with $x<0.05$. In this regime, the magnetic moments of the ${\mathrm{Ho}}^{3+}$ ions experience small quantum corrections to the common Ising approximation of ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}$, which lead to a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$-symmetry breaking and small, degeneracy breaking energy shifts between different eigenstates. Here we show that destructive interference between two almost degenerate excitation pathways burns spectral holes in the magnetic susceptibility of strongly driven magnetic moments in ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}$. Such spectral holes in the susceptibility, microscopically described in terms of Fano resonances, can already occur in setups of only two or three frustrated moments, for which the driven level scheme has the paradigmatic $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ shape. For larger clusters of magnetic moments, the corresponding level schemes separate into almost isolated many-body $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ schemes, in the sense that either the transition matrix elements between them are negligibly small or the energy difference of the transitions is strongly off-resonant to the drive. This enables the observation of Fano resonances, caused by many-body quantum corrections to the common Ising approximation also in the thermodynamic limit. We discuss its dependence on the driving strength and frequency as well as the crucial role that is played by lattice dissipation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.101.214201

Related papers

Tuning high-Q nonlinear dynamics in a disordered quantum magnet

D. M. Silevitch, Chi‐Shung Tang, G. Aeppli +1 more

Abstract Quantum states cohere and interfere. Atoms arranged imperfectly in a solid rarely display these properties. Here we demonstrate an exception in a disordered quantum magnet that divides itself into nearly isolated subsystems. We probe these coherent spin clusters by driving the system nonlinearly and measuring the resulting hole in the linear spectral response. The Fano shape of the hole encodes the incoherent lifetime as well as coherent mixing of the localized excitations. For the Ising magnet LiHo0.045Y0.955F4, the quality factor Q for spectral holes can be as high as 100,000. We tune the dynamics by sweeping the Fano mixing parameter q through zero via the ac pump amplitude as well as a dc transverse field. The zero crossing of q is associated with a dissipationless response at the drive frequency. Identifying localized two-level systems in a dense and disordered magnet advances the search for qubit platforms emerging from strongly interacting, many-body systems.

arXiv:1707.04952•Nature Communications•Sep 5, 2019•26 citations

Tunable Quantum Dynamics in a Disordered Magnet

Christopher R. Tang, D. M. Silevitch, G. Aeppli +1 more

Quantum memories depend on minimally-interacting, localized qubits. One approach is via localized many-body excitations, such as those found in the dilute Ising magnet, LiHo0.045Y0.955F4. Here clusters of several hundred spins bind together and can be resonantly excited. We use a non-linear pump-probe magnetic susceptibility technique, combining a strong longitudinal ac magnetic pump field to drive the system out of the linear regime and a weak probe field, to study the localized excitations. The pump field excites the clusters into resonance, the detailed shape of which provides insight into the lifetimes and the coherent quantum interference between different excitation channels. We tune the dynamics of the quantum degrees of freedom by sweeping the quantum mixing parameter through zero via the amplitude of the ac pump as well as a static external transverse field. The zero-crossing is associated with a dissipationless response at the drive frequency. The identification of points where localized degrees of freedom are minimally mixed with their environment in a dense and disordered, dipolar-coupled spin system implies control over the bath coupling of qubits emerging from strongly interacting many-body systems.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 8, 2018•0 citations

Local quantum critical behavior in magnetic Kondo impurity models with partially screened moment

Guang-Ming Zhang, Yu, Lu

In the strong coupling limit, an effective resonant level model is derived for the spin-1 underscreened Kondo impurity model. A local quantum critical behavior is induced by the formation of a bound state with partially screened magnetic moment, displaying a residual $Z_2$ symmetry, leading to a $δ$-resonance at the Fermi level in the impurity spectral function. As a consequence, a logarithmic singularity appears in the real part of the impurity dynamic spin susceptibility as a function of $\max (ω, T)$, with $ω$ as frequency, $T$ temperature. A small magnetic field breaks this $Z_2$ symmetry and suppresses the singularity. We also discuss the possible manifestation of such a quantum critical behavior in the spin-1/2 two Kondo impurity model and the single quantum dot system with even electron occupation.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412561•Dec 21, 2004•0 citations

Localization and transport in a strongly driven Anderson insulator

Kartiek Agarwal, Sriram Ganeshan, R. N. Bhatt

We study localization and charge dynamics in a monochromatically driven one-dimensional Anderson insulator focusing on the low-frequency, strong-driving regime. We study this problem using a mapping of the Floquet Hamiltonian to a hopping problem with correlated disorder in one higher harmonic-space dimension. We show that (i) resonances in this model correspond to adiabatic Landau-Zener (LZ) transitions that occur due to level crossings between lattice sites over the course of dynamics; (ii) the proliferation of these resonances leads to dynamics that appear diffusive over a single drive cycle, but the system always remains localized; (iii) actual charge transport occurs over many drive cycles due to slow dephasing between these LZ orbits and is logarithmic in time, with a crucial role being played by far-off Mott-like resonances; and (iv) applying a spatially varying random phase to the drive tends to decrease localization, suggestive of weak-localization physics. We derive the conditions for the strong-driving regime, determining the parametric dependencies of the size of Floquet eigenstates, and time scales associated with the dynamics, and corroborate the findings using both numerical scaling collapses and analytical arguments.

arXiv:1704.07390•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 10, 2017•36 citations

Energy-level statistics in strongly disordered systems with power-law hopping

Paraj Titum, Victor L. Quito, Sergey Syzranov

Motivated by neutral excitations in disordered electronic materials and systems of trapped ultracold particles with long-range interactions, we study energy-level statistics of quasiparticles with the power-law hopping Hamiltonian $\ensuremath{\propto}1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ in a strong random potential. In solid-state systems such quasiparticles, which are exemplified by neutral dipolar excitations, lead to long-range correlations of local observables and may dominate energy transport. Focusing on the excitations in disordered electronic systems, we compute the energy-level correlation function ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in a finite system in the limit of sufficiently strong disorder. At small energy differences, the correlations exhibit Wigner-Dyson statistics. In particular, in the limit of very strong disorder the energy-level correlation function is given by ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega},V)={A}_{3}\frac{\ensuremath{\omega}}{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}$ for small frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\ll}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}$ and ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega},V)=1\ensuremath{-}(\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{-}d){A}_{1}{\left(\frac{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}\right)}^{\frac{d}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}\ensuremath{-}{A}_{2}{\left(\frac{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}\right)}^{2}$ for large frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\gg}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}$, where ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}\ensuremath{\propto}{V}^{\ensuremath{-}\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{d}}$ is the characteristic matrix element of excitation hopping in a system of volume $V$, and ${A}_{1},{A}_{2}$, and ${A}_{3}$ are coefficients of order unity which depend on the shape of the system. The energy-level correlation function, which we study, allows for a direct experimental observation, for example, by measuring the correlations of the ac conductance of the system at different frequencies.

arXiv:1803.11178•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 16, 2018•1 citation

Theoretical studies of frustrated magnets with dipolar interactions

Pawel Stasiak

Several magnetic materials, in the first approximation, can be described by idealised theoretical models, such as classical Ising or Heisenberg spin systems, and, to some extent, such models are able to qualitatively expose many experimentally observed phenomena. But often, to account for complex behavior of magnetic matter, such models have to be refined by including more terms in Hamiltonian. The compound LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4, by increasing concentration of nonmagnetic yttrium can be tuned from a diluted ferromagnet to a spin glass. LiHoF_4 is a good realisation of the transverse field Ising model, the simplest model exhibiting a quantum phase transition. In the pure case the magnetic behaviour of this material is well described by mean-field theory. It was believed that when diluted, LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 would also manifest itself as a diluted transverse field Ising model which continue to be well described by mean-field theory, and, at sufficient dilution, at zero temperature, exhibit a quantum spin-glass transition. The experimental data did not support such a scenario, and it was pointed out that, to explain physics of LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 in transverse magnetic field, the effect of a transverse-field-generated longitudinal random field has to be considered. We explore this idea further in local mean-field studies in which all three parameters: temperature, transverse field and concentration can be consistently surveyed, and where the transverse-field-generated longitudinal random field is explicitly present in the effective spin-1/2 Hamiltonian. We suggest other materials that are possible candidates for studying quantum criticality in the transverse field Ising model, and in the diluted case, for studying the effects of transverse and longitudinal random fields. The compounds we consider are RE(OH)_3, where RE are the rare earth ions Tb^{3+}, Dy^{3+} and Ho^{3+}. Using mean-field theory, we estimate the values of the transverse magnetic field that, at zero temperature, destroy ferromagnetic order to be B_x^c=4.35 T, B_x^c=5.03 T and B_x^c=54.81 T for Ho(OH)_3, Dy(OH)_3 and Tb(OH)_3, respectively. We confirm that Ho(OH)_3 and Tb(OH)_3, similarly to LiHoF_4, can be described by an effective spin-1/2 Hamiltonian. In the case of Dy(OH)_3 there is a possibility of a first order phase transition at transverse field close to B_x^c, and Dy(OH)_3 cannot be described by a spin-1/2 effective Hamiltonian. While diluted dipolar Ising spin glass has been studied experimentally in LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 and in numerical simulations, there are no studies of the Heisenberg case. Example materials that are likely candidates to be realisations of the diluted dipolar Heisenberg spin glass are (Gd_xY_{1-x})_2Ti_2O_7, (Gd_xY_{1-x})_2Sn_2O_7 and (Gd_xY_{1-x})_3Ga_5O_{12}. To stimulate interest in experimental studies of these systems we present results of Monte of Carlo simulations of the diluted dipolar Heisenberg spin glass. By performing finite-size scaling analysis of the spin-glass correlation length and the spin-glass susceptibility, we provide a compelling evidence of a thermodynamical spin-glass transition in the model. Frustrated pyrochlore magnets, depending on the character of single ion anisotropy and interplay of different types of interaction over a broad range of energy scales, exhibit a large spectrum of exotic phases and novel phenomena. The pyrochlore antiferromagnet Er_2Ti_2O_7 is characterised by a strong planar anisotropy. Experimental studies reveal that Er_2Ti_2O_7 undergoes a continuous phase transition to a long-range ordered phase with a spin configuration that, in this thesis, is referred to as the Champion-Holdsworth state. Such results are not in agreement with the theoretical prediction that the ground state of the pyrochlore easy-plane antiferromagnet with dipolar interactions complementing the nearest neighbour exchange interactions, is not the Champion-Holdsworth state but the so-called Palmer-Chalker state. On the other hand, Monte Carlo simulations of the easy-plane pyrochlore antiferromagnet indicate a thermal order-by-disorder selection of the Champion-Holdsworth state. To answer the question of whether order-by-disorder selection can be the mechanism at play in Er_2Ti_2O_7, we performed Monte Carlo simulations of the easy-plane pyrochlore antiferromagnet with weak dipolar interactions. We estimate the range strengths of the dipolar interaction such that order-by-disorder selection of the Champion-Holdsworth state is not suppressed. The estimated value of the allowed strength of the dipolar interactions indicates that the model studied is likely insufficient to explain the physics of Er_2Ti_2O_7 and other types of interactions or quantum effects should be considered.

•Dec 18, 2009•1 citation
The random dipolar magnet LiHoxY1\ensuremath−xF4{\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}LiHox​Y1\ensuremath−x​F4​ enters a strongly frustrated regime for small Ho3+{\mathrm{Ho}}^{3+}Ho3+ concentrations with x<0.05x<0.05x<0.05. In this regime, the magnetic moments of the Ho3+{\mathrm{Ho}}^{3+}Ho3+ ions experience small quantum corrections to the common Ising approximation of LiHoxY1\ensuremath−xF4{\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}LiHox​Y1\ensuremath−x​F4​, which lead to a Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​-symmetry breaking and small, degeneracy breaking energy shifts between different eigenstates. Here we show that destructive interference between two almost degenerate excitation pathways burns spectral holes in the magnetic susceptibility of strongly driven magnetic moments in LiHoxY1\ensuremath−xF4{\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}LiHox​Y1\ensuremath−x​F4​. Such spectral holes in the susceptibility, microscopically described in terms of Fano resonances, can already occur in setups of only two or three frustrated moments, for which the driven level scheme has the paradigmatic \ensuremathΛ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}\ensuremathΛ shape. For larger clusters of magnetic moments, the corresponding level schemes separate into almost isolated many-body \ensuremathΛ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}\ensuremathΛ schemes, in the sense that either the transition matrix elements between them are negligibly small or the energy difference of the transitions is strongly off-resonant to the drive. This enables the observation of Fano resonances, caused by many-body quantum corrections to the common Ising approximation also in the thermodynamic limit. We discuss its dependence on the driving strength and frequency as well as the crucial role that is played by lattice dissipation.
Abstract Quantum states cohere and interfere. Atoms arranged imperfectly in a solid rarely display these properties. Here we demonstrate an exception in a disordered quantum magnet that divides itself into nearly isolated subsystems. We probe these coherent spin clusters by driving the system nonlinearly and measuring the resulting hole in the linear spectral response. The Fano shape of the hole encodes the incoherent lifetime as well as coherent mixing of the localized excitations. For the Ising magnet LiHo0.045Y0.955F4, the quality factor Q for spectral holes can be as high as 100,000. We tune the dynamics by sweeping the Fano mixing parameter q through zero via the ac pump amplitude as well as a dc transverse field. The zero crossing of q is associated with a dissipationless response at the drive frequency. Identifying localized two-level systems in a dense and disordered magnet advances the search for qubit platforms emerging from strongly interacting, many-body systems.
Quantum memories depend on minimally-interacting, localized qubits. One approach is via localized many-body excitations, such as those found in the dilute Ising magnet, LiHo0.045Y0.955F4. Here clusters of several hundred spins bind together and can be resonantly excited. We use a non-linear pump-probe magnetic susceptibility technique, combining a strong longitudinal ac magnetic pump field to drive the system out of the linear regime and a weak probe field, to study the localized excitations. The pump field excites the clusters into resonance, the detailed shape of which provides insight into the lifetimes and the coherent quantum interference between different excitation channels. We tune the dynamics of the quantum degrees of freedom by sweeping the quantum mixing parameter through zero via the amplitude of the ac pump as well as a static external transverse field. The zero-crossing is associated with a dissipationless response at the drive frequency. The identification of points where localized degrees of freedom are minimally mixed with their environment in a dense and disordered, dipolar-coupled spin system implies control over the bath coupling of qubits emerging from strongly interacting many-body systems.
In the strong coupling limit, an effective resonant level model is derived for the spin-1 underscreened Kondo impurity model. A local quantum critical behavior is induced by the formation of a bound state with partially screened magnetic moment, displaying a residual Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry, leading to a δδδ-resonance at the Fermi level in the impurity spectral function. As a consequence, a logarithmic singularity appears in the real part of the impurity dynamic spin susceptibility as a function of max⁡(ω,T)\max (ω, T)max(ω,T), with ωωω as frequency, TTT temperature. A small magnetic field breaks this Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry and suppresses the singularity. We also discuss the possible manifestation of such a quantum critical behavior in the spin-1/2 two Kondo impurity model and the single quantum dot system with even electron occupation.
We study localization and charge dynamics in a monochromatically driven one-dimensional Anderson insulator focusing on the low-frequency, strong-driving regime. We study this problem using a mapping of the Floquet Hamiltonian to a hopping problem with correlated disorder in one higher harmonic-space dimension. We show that (i) resonances in this model correspond to adiabatic Landau-Zener (LZ) transitions that occur due to level crossings between lattice sites over the course of dynamics; (ii) the proliferation of these resonances leads to dynamics that appear diffusive over a single drive cycle, but the system always remains localized; (iii) actual charge transport occurs over many drive cycles due to slow dephasing between these LZ orbits and is logarithmic in time, with a crucial role being played by far-off Mott-like resonances; and (iv) applying a spatially varying random phase to the drive tends to decrease localization, suggestive of weak-localization physics. We derive the conditions for the strong-driving regime, determining the parametric dependencies of the size of Floquet eigenstates, and time scales associated with the dynamics, and corroborate the findings using both numerical scaling collapses and analytical arguments.
Motivated by neutral excitations in disordered electronic materials and systems of trapped ultracold particles with long-range interactions, we study energy-level statistics of quasiparticles with the power-law hopping Hamiltonian $\ensuremath{\propto}1/{r}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ in a strong random potential. In solid-state systems such quasiparticles, which are exemplified by neutral dipolar excitations, lead to long-range correlations of local observables and may dominate energy transport. Focusing on the excitations in disordered electronic systems, we compute the energy-level correlation function ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in a finite system in the limit of sufficiently strong disorder. At small energy differences, the correlations exhibit Wigner-Dyson statistics. In particular, in the limit of very strong disorder the energy-level correlation function is given by ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega},V)={A}_{3}\frac{\ensuremath{\omega}}{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}$ for small frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\ll}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}$ and ${R}_{2}(\ensuremath{\omega},V)=1\ensuremath{-}(\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{-}d){A}_{1}{\left(\frac{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}\right)}^{\frac{d}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}\ensuremath{-}{A}_{2}{\left(\frac{{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}\right)}^{2}$ for large frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\gg}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}$, where ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{V}\ensuremath{\propto}{V}^{\ensuremath{-}\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{d}}$ is the characteristic matrix element of excitation hopping in a system of volume VVV, and A1,A2{A}_{1},{A}_{2}A1​,A2​, and A3{A}_{3}A3​ are coefficients of order unity which depend on the shape of the system. The energy-level correlation function, which we study, allows for a direct experimental observation, for example, by measuring the correlations of the ac conductance of the system at different frequencies.
Several magnetic materials, in the first approximation, can be described by idealised theoretical models, such as classical Ising or Heisenberg spin systems, and, to some extent, such models are able to qualitatively expose many experimentally observed phenomena. But often, to account for complex behavior of magnetic matter, such models have to be refined by including more terms in Hamiltonian. The compound LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4, by increasing concentration of nonmagnetic yttrium can be tuned from a diluted ferromagnet to a spin glass. LiHoF_4 is a good realisation of the transverse field Ising model, the simplest model exhibiting a quantum phase transition. In the pure case the magnetic behaviour of this material is well described by mean-field theory. It was believed that when diluted, LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 would also manifest itself as a diluted transverse field Ising model which continue to be well described by mean-field theory, and, at sufficient dilution, at zero temperature, exhibit a quantum spin-glass transition. The experimental data did not support such a scenario, and it was pointed out that, to explain physics of LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 in transverse magnetic field, the effect of a transverse-field-generated longitudinal random field has to be considered. We explore this idea further in local mean-field studies in which all three parameters: temperature, transverse field and concentration can be consistently surveyed, and where the transverse-field-generated longitudinal random field is explicitly present in the effective spin-1/2 Hamiltonian. We suggest other materials that are possible candidates for studying quantum criticality in the transverse field Ising model, and in the diluted case, for studying the effects of transverse and longitudinal random fields. The compounds we consider are RE(OH)_3, where RE are the rare earth ions Tb^{3+}, Dy^{3+} and Ho^{3+}. Using mean-field theory, we estimate the values of the transverse magnetic field that, at zero temperature, destroy ferromagnetic order to be B_x^c=4.35 T, B_x^c=5.03 T and B_x^c=54.81 T for Ho(OH)_3, Dy(OH)_3 and Tb(OH)_3, respectively. We confirm that Ho(OH)_3 and Tb(OH)_3, similarly to LiHoF_4, can be described by an effective spin-1/2 Hamiltonian. In the case of Dy(OH)_3 there is a possibility of a first order phase transition at transverse field close to B_x^c, and Dy(OH)_3 cannot be described by a spin-1/2 effective Hamiltonian. While diluted dipolar Ising spin glass has been studied experimentally in LiHo_xY_{1-x}F_4 and in numerical simulations, there are no studies of the Heisenberg case. Example materials that are likely candidates to be realisations of the diluted dipolar Heisenberg spin glass are (Gd_xY_{1-x})_2Ti_2O_7, (Gd_xY_{1-x})_2Sn_2O_7 and (Gd_xY_{1-x})_3Ga_5O_{12}. To stimulate interest in experimental studies of these systems we present results of Monte of Carlo simulations of the diluted dipolar Heisenberg spin glass. By performing finite-size scaling analysis of the spin-glass correlation length and the spin-glass susceptibility, we provide a compelling evidence of a thermodynamical spin-glass transition in the model. Frustrated pyrochlore magnets, depending on the character of single ion anisotropy and interplay of different types of interaction over a broad range of energy scales, exhibit a large spectrum of exotic phases and novel phenomena. The pyrochlore antiferromagnet Er_2Ti_2O_7 is characterised by a strong planar anisotropy. Experimental studies reveal that Er_2Ti_2O_7 undergoes a continuous phase transition to a long-range ordered phase with a spin configuration that, in this thesis, is referred to as the Champion-Holdsworth state. Such results are not in agreement with the theoretical prediction that the ground state of the pyrochlore easy-plane antiferromagnet with dipolar interactions complementing the nearest neighbour exchange interactions, is not the Champion-Holdsworth state but the so-called Palmer-Chalker state. On the other hand, Monte Carlo simulations of the easy-plane pyrochlore antiferromagnet indicate a thermal order-by-disorder selection of the Champion-Holdsworth state. To answer the question of whether order-by-disorder selection can be the mechanism at play in Er_2Ti_2O_7, we performed Monte Carlo simulations of the easy-plane pyrochlore antiferromagnet with weak dipolar interactions. We estimate the range strengths of the dipolar interaction such that order-by-disorder selection of the Champion-Holdsworth state is not suppressed. The estimated value of the allowed strength of the dipolar interactions indicates that the model studied is likely insufficient to explain the physics of Er_2Ti_2O_7 and other types of interactions or quantum effects should be considered.