Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.01324 · Physics Letters A

Mean field theory for the quantum Rabi model, inconsistency to the rotating wave approximation

Ghasem Asadi Cordshooli, Mehdi Mirzaee

Published Jan 27, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1016/j.physleta.2020.126287

Related papers

Bridging the gap between the Jaynes–Cummings and Rabi models using an intermediate rotating wave approximation

Yimin Wang, Jing Yan Haw

arXiv:1502.02806•Physics Letters A•Jan 6, 2015•31 citations

Mean field theory for non-equilibrium quantum fields

R. Jackiw

Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•May 1, 1989•12 citations

Geometric phases and the Rabi Hamiltonian

Jean-Paul Saucier Calderón, F. De Zela

We address Berry phases that have been predicted to appear when a two-level system interacts with a quantized field, including the vacuum state. The issue became controversial after it was argued that the appearance of such Berry phases is an artifact of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). As is widely believed, whenever the RWA applies, one may replace the Rabi model of a two-level system interacting with a quantized field by the analytically solvable Jaynes-Cummings model. Conflicting predictions of these two models under conditions that validate the RWA would signal a serious inconsistency of this approximation. We show that this is not the case and that claims to the contrary are inconsistent with analytical results concerning the Rabi model. We provide also numerical evidence supporting our analytical approach. Furthermore, we argue that the appearance of Berry phases in the addressed cases does not depend on adiabatic conditions nor on any particular Hamiltonian, but on the underlying vector space. Thus, the appropriate framework is given by the kinematic approach to geometric phases, which contains Berry's phase as a special case.

Physical Review A•Mar 10, 2016•5 citations

Spectral and dynamical validity of the rotating-wave approximation in the quantum and semiclassical Rabi models [Invited]

H. F. A. Coleman, E. K. Twyeffort Irish

Ultrastrong coupling (USC) in the quantum Rabi model, characterized by the breakdown of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA), has emerged as a topic of considerable interest and study. This critical reevaluation of the validity of the RWA concludes that the accepted definition of USC in terms of a fixed ratio of coupling to field frequency is inadequate. Connecting an improved spectral validity criterion with the derivation of the semiclassical limit suggests that the dynamical validity of the quantum RWA should be linked to that of the corresponding semiclassical model. This, however, is not supported by numerical calculations of coherent-state dynamics, which unambiguously demonstrate that spectral validity does not imply dynamical validity and reveal surprisingly complicated dependence on coupling and field amplitude.

arXiv:2403.17628•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jun 3, 2024•3 citations

Quantum Dynamics with Mean Field Interactions: a New Approach

László Erdős, Benjamin Schlein

arXiv:0804.3774•Journal of Statistical Physics•Mar 1, 2009•44 citations

Generalized rotating-wave approximation for the two-qubit quantum Rabi model

Yuyu Zhang, Qing‐Hu Chen

The generalized rotating-wave approximation (GRWA) is presented for the two-qubit quantum Rabi model. The analytical expressions in the zeroth-order approximation recover the previous adiabatic ones. The counter-rotating-wave terms can be eliminated by performing the first-order corrections. An effective solvable Hamiltonian with the same form as the ordinary RWA one is then obtained, giving very accurate eigenvalues and eigenstates. Energy levels in the present GRWA are in accordance with the numerical exact diagonalization ones in a wide range of coupling strengths. The population dynamics in the GRWA are in quantitative agreement with the numerical results and exhibit the absence of collapses clearly, revealing the effects of the counter-rotating wave.

arXiv:1410.1965•Physical Review A•Jan 8, 2015•38 citations
We address Berry phases that have been predicted to appear when a two-level system interacts with a quantized field, including the vacuum state. The issue became controversial after it was argued that the appearance of such Berry phases is an artifact of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). As is widely believed, whenever the RWA applies, one may replace the Rabi model of a two-level system interacting with a quantized field by the analytically solvable Jaynes-Cummings model. Conflicting predictions of these two models under conditions that validate the RWA would signal a serious inconsistency of this approximation. We show that this is not the case and that claims to the contrary are inconsistent with analytical results concerning the Rabi model. We provide also numerical evidence supporting our analytical approach. Furthermore, we argue that the appearance of Berry phases in the addressed cases does not depend on adiabatic conditions nor on any particular Hamiltonian, but on the underlying vector space. Thus, the appropriate framework is given by the kinematic approach to geometric phases, which contains Berry's phase as a special case.
Ultrastrong coupling (USC) in the quantum Rabi model, characterized by the breakdown of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA), has emerged as a topic of considerable interest and study. This critical reevaluation of the validity of the RWA concludes that the accepted definition of USC in terms of a fixed ratio of coupling to field frequency is inadequate. Connecting an improved spectral validity criterion with the derivation of the semiclassical limit suggests that the dynamical validity of the quantum RWA should be linked to that of the corresponding semiclassical model. This, however, is not supported by numerical calculations of coherent-state dynamics, which unambiguously demonstrate that spectral validity does not imply dynamical validity and reveal surprisingly complicated dependence on coupling and field amplitude.
The generalized rotating-wave approximation (GRWA) is presented for the two-qubit quantum Rabi model. The analytical expressions in the zeroth-order approximation recover the previous adiabatic ones. The counter-rotating-wave terms can be eliminated by performing the first-order corrections. An effective solvable Hamiltonian with the same form as the ordinary RWA one is then obtained, giving very accurate eigenvalues and eigenstates. Energy levels in the present GRWA are in accordance with the numerical exact diagonalization ones in a wide range of coupling strengths. The population dynamics in the GRWA are in quantitative agreement with the numerical results and exhibit the absence of collapses clearly, revealing the effects of the counter-rotating wave.