Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1912.01027 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Disentangling quantum matter with measurements

Daniel Ben-Zion, John McGreevy, Tarun Grover

Published Mar 18, 2020• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Measurements destroy entanglement. Building on ideas used to study `quantum disentangled liquids,' we explore the use of this effect to characterize states of matter. We focus on systems with multiple components, such as charge and spin in a Hubbard model or local moments and conduction electrons in a Kondo lattice model. In such systems, measurements of (a subset of) one of the components can leave behind a quantum state of the other that is easy to understand, for example in terms of scaling of entanglement entropy of subregions. We bound the outcome of this protocol, for any choice of measurement, in terms of more standard information-theoretic quantities. We apply this quantum disentangling protocol to several problems of physical interest, including gapless topological phases, heavy fermions, and scar states in the Hubbard model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.101.115131

Related papers

Topological Phases and Strongly Correlated Fermions in Many-Body Systems

Daniel Ben-Zion

In this dissertation we study the properties of quantum many-body systems whose behavior is governed by strong correlation effects between large numbers of degrees of freedom. We begin with a review of various types of condensed matter settings and a general discussion of how interactions can lead to qualitatively new properties. In Chapter 2 we discuss a class of spin models which generate nontrivial realizations of a global symmetry, both in the presence and absence of topological order. In Chapter 3, we examine a model of a non-Fermi liquid. This model is built out of electron-like degrees of freedom and has a Fermi surface, yet has no stable quasiparticle excitations. In Chapter 4 we discuss some aspects of entanglement entropy in gapless multi-component systems, and suggest a way of measuring the topological properties of Kondo lattice wavefunctions.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Quantum disentangled liquids

Tarun Grover, Matthew P. A. Fisher

We propose and explore a new finite temperature phase of translationally invariant multi-component liquids which we call a 'Quantum Disentangled Liquid' (QDL) phase. We contemplate the possibility that in fluids consisting of two (or more) species of indistinguishable quantum particles with a large mass ratio, the light particles might 'localize' on the heavy particles. We give a precise, formal definition of this QDL phase in terms of the finite energy density many-particle wavefunctions. While the heavy particles are fully thermalized, for a typical fixed configuration of the heavy particles, the entanglement entropy of the light particles satisfies an area law; this implies that the light particles have not thermalized. Equivalently, but more intuitively, if the positions of all the heavy particles are measured , the projected wavefunction for the unmeasured light particles has as an area law entanglement entropy. Thus, in a QDL phase, thermal equilibration is incomplete, and the canonical assumptions of statistical mechanics are not fully operative. The definition of the QDL phase for heavy/light particles can be readily generalized to other cases with two (or more) conserved currents, such as spin/charge in a system of spin-1/2 fermions (as in a Hubbard model). Indeed, we argue that the finite energy-density eigenstates of the t – J model will generically be in such a spin/charge QDL, although the fate of the QDL in the large U Hubbard model is uncertain. We explore the possibility of QDL in water, with the light proton degrees of freedom becoming 'localized' on the oxygen ions. While we do not presently know whether a local, generic Hamiltonian can have eigenstates of the QDL form, if not, then the non-thermal behavior discussed here will exist as an interesting crossover phenomena at a time scale that diverges as the ratio of the mass of the heavy to the light particles also diverges.

arXiv:1307.2288•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Oct 9, 2014•141 citations

Measuring Entanglement in Condensed Matter Systems

M. Cramer, Martin Bodo Plenio, Harald Wunderlich

We show how entanglement may be quantified in spin and cold atom many-body systems using standard experimental techniques only. The scheme requires no assumptions on the state in the laboratory, and a lower bound to the entanglement can be read off directly from the scattering cross section of neutrons deflected from solid state samples or the time-of-flight distribution of cold atoms in optical lattices, respectively. This removes a major obstacle which so far has prevented the direct and quantitative experimental study of genuine quantum correlations in many-body systems: The need for a full characterization of the state to quantify the entanglement contained in it. Instead, the scheme presented here relies solely on global measurements that are routinely performed and is versatile enough to accommodate systems and measurements different from the ones we exemplify in this work.

arXiv:1009.2956•Physical Review Letters•Jan 10, 2011•82 citations

Quantum Scaling In Many-Body Systems

M. A. Contínentino

Abstract The theory of quantum critical phenomena is introduced to study some current many-body problems in condensed matter physics. Renormalization group concepts are applied to strongly correlated electronic materials which are close to a zero-temperature instability. These systems have enhanced effective masses and susceptibility. Scaling arguments yield the exponents which govern the critical behavior of these quantities in terms of the usual critical exponents associated with a zero-temperature phase transition. We show the existence of a new energy scale, related to the quantum nature of the many-body instability, which can be generally associated with the setting of Fermi-liquid behavior with decreasing temperature in three-dimensional strongly interacting electronic systems. The theory of quantum critical phenomena is used to investigate the Kondo lattice problem, which provides a model to describe heavy-fermion systems and to introduce a scaling theory of the Mott transition with special emphasis on charge fluctuation effects. However, this report is not a review on heavy fermions and Mott insulators. The microscopic theories of these systems are still controversial and present some of the most challenging and instigating problems in condensed matter physics. This state of affairs stimulated the author to review and extend the scaling approach. The scaling theory we develop provides a powerful tool, based on the notion of universality, to understand the physical properties of correlated systems beyond the mean-field level. This is illustrated by our treatment of the one-dimensional Hubbard model, where, although the Fermi-liquid fixed point does not survive the fluctuations, the scaling approach is still useful. Finally, we discuss briefly how disorder affect our results.

World Scientific lecture notes in physics•Jan 1, 2001•208 citations

Entanglement as an Observer-Dependent Concept: An Application to Quantum Phase Transitions

Gerardo Ortíz, Rolando D. Somma, Howard Barnum +2 more

This paper addresses the following main question: Do we have a theoretical understanding of entanglement applicable to a full variety of physical settings? It is clear that not only the assumption of distinguishability, but also the few-subsystem scenario, are too narrow to embrace all possible physical settings. In particular, the need to go beyond the traditional subsystem-based framework becomes manifest when one tries to apply the conventional concept of entanglement to the physics of matter, since the constituents of a quantum many-body system are indistinguishable particles. We shall discuss here a notion of generalized entanglement, which can be applied to any operator language (fermions, bosons, spins, etc.) used to describe a physical system and which includes the conventional entanglement settings introduced to date in a unified fashion. This is realized by noticing that entanglement is an observer-dependent concept, whose properties are determined by the expectations of a distinguished set of observables without reference to a preferred subsystem decomposition, i.e., it depends on the physically relevant point of view. This viewpoint depends in turn upon the relationship between different sets of observables that determine our ability to control the system of interest. Indeed, the extent to which entanglement is present depends on the observables used to measure a system and describe its states. This represents a most conspicuous advantage as will be highlighted by the condensed-matter application we will discuss.

arXiv:quant-ph/0403043•Mar 4, 2004•10 citations

Defects in strongly correlated and spin-orbit entangled quantum matter

Michael Becker

The inherent complexity of interacting quantum many-body systems poses an outstanding challenge to both theory and experiment. Especially in the presence of strong electronic correlations, highly interesting and perplexing physical phenomena can occur. \nIn this thesis, we focus on three different examples of strongly correlated electron systems in which different types of defects occur. First, we investigate the Heisenberg-Kitaev model formulated on a triangular lattice. Using a mixture of numerical and analytical techniques we map out the entire phase diagram for the classical and quantum models. We provide an analytical foundation to the intriguing Z2-vortex ground state, in which strong spin-orbit coupling leads to the formation of a lattice of topological point defects. This state was observed previously in classical Monte Carlo simulations. We furthermore propose the iridate Ba3IrTi2O9 to be a prime candidate for the realization of such a state. \nThe second part deals with the physics of a defect in the form of a localized magnetic moment which is embedded into a metallic environment: the Kondo effect. Although this effect has been a cornerstone of condensed matter physics for more than 50 years, its properties in real-space are still not fully understood. What is the Kondo screening cloud---the extended many-body state of entangled conduction electrons? We present numerical results in 1D and 2D for the charge density oscillations created by the impurity. We find that the entire RG flow of the problem is recovered in these oscillations, elucidating the internal structure of the screening cloud. \nFinally, we investigate the competition between the Kondo effect and Majorana physics. Majorana bound states are highly interesting objects which exhibit unusual statistics and could be used as a building block of a topological quantum computer. Recently, signatures of their existence were observed in experiment, and we here examine how Kondo physics (which might play a role in real systems) interact with such Majorana bound states.

•Jan 5, 2015•0 citations
Measurements destroy entanglement. Building on ideas used to study `quantum disentangled liquids,' we explore the use of this effect to characterize states of matter. We focus on systems with multiple components, such as charge and spin in a Hubbard model or local moments and conduction electrons in a Kondo lattice model. In such systems, measurements of (a subset of) one of the components can leave behind a quantum state of the other that is easy to understand, for example in terms of scaling of entanglement entropy of subregions. We bound the outcome of this protocol, for any choice of measurement, in terms of more standard information-theoretic quantities. We apply this quantum disentangling protocol to several problems of physical interest, including gapless topological phases, heavy fermions, and scar states in the Hubbard model.
In this dissertation we study the properties of quantum many-body systems whose behavior is governed by strong correlation effects between large numbers of degrees of freedom. We begin with a review of various types of condensed matter settings and a general discussion of how interactions can lead to qualitatively new properties. In Chapter 2 we discuss a class of spin models which generate nontrivial realizations of a global symmetry, both in the presence and absence of topological order. In Chapter 3, we examine a model of a non-Fermi liquid. This model is built out of electron-like degrees of freedom and has a Fermi surface, yet has no stable quasiparticle excitations. In Chapter 4 we discuss some aspects of entanglement entropy in gapless multi-component systems, and suggest a way of measuring the topological properties of Kondo lattice wavefunctions.
We propose and explore a new finite temperature phase of translationally invariant multi-component liquids which we call a 'Quantum Disentangled Liquid' (QDL) phase. We contemplate the possibility that in fluids consisting of two (or more) species of indistinguishable quantum particles with a large mass ratio, the light particles might 'localize' on the heavy particles. We give a precise, formal definition of this QDL phase in terms of the finite energy density many-particle wavefunctions. While the heavy particles are fully thermalized, for a typical fixed configuration of the heavy particles, the entanglement entropy of the light particles satisfies an area law; this implies that the light particles have not thermalized. Equivalently, but more intuitively, if the positions of all the heavy particles are measured , the projected wavefunction for the unmeasured light particles has as an area law entanglement entropy. Thus, in a QDL phase, thermal equilibration is incomplete, and the canonical assumptions of statistical mechanics are not fully operative. The definition of the QDL phase for heavy/light particles can be readily generalized to other cases with two (or more) conserved currents, such as spin/charge in a system of spin-1/2 fermions (as in a Hubbard model). Indeed, we argue that the finite energy-density eigenstates of the t – J model will generically be in such a spin/charge QDL, although the fate of the QDL in the large U Hubbard model is uncertain. We explore the possibility of QDL in water, with the light proton degrees of freedom becoming 'localized' on the oxygen ions. While we do not presently know whether a local, generic Hamiltonian can have eigenstates of the QDL form, if not, then the non-thermal behavior discussed here will exist as an interesting crossover phenomena at a time scale that diverges as the ratio of the mass of the heavy to the light particles also diverges.
We show how entanglement may be quantified in spin and cold atom many-body systems using standard experimental techniques only. The scheme requires no assumptions on the state in the laboratory, and a lower bound to the entanglement can be read off directly from the scattering cross section of neutrons deflected from solid state samples or the time-of-flight distribution of cold atoms in optical lattices, respectively. This removes a major obstacle which so far has prevented the direct and quantitative experimental study of genuine quantum correlations in many-body systems: The need for a full characterization of the state to quantify the entanglement contained in it. Instead, the scheme presented here relies solely on global measurements that are routinely performed and is versatile enough to accommodate systems and measurements different from the ones we exemplify in this work.
Abstract The theory of quantum critical phenomena is introduced to study some current many-body problems in condensed matter physics. Renormalization group concepts are applied to strongly correlated electronic materials which are close to a zero-temperature instability. These systems have enhanced effective masses and susceptibility. Scaling arguments yield the exponents which govern the critical behavior of these quantities in terms of the usual critical exponents associated with a zero-temperature phase transition. We show the existence of a new energy scale, related to the quantum nature of the many-body instability, which can be generally associated with the setting of Fermi-liquid behavior with decreasing temperature in three-dimensional strongly interacting electronic systems. The theory of quantum critical phenomena is used to investigate the Kondo lattice problem, which provides a model to describe heavy-fermion systems and to introduce a scaling theory of the Mott transition with special emphasis on charge fluctuation effects. However, this report is not a review on heavy fermions and Mott insulators. The microscopic theories of these systems are still controversial and present some of the most challenging and instigating problems in condensed matter physics. This state of affairs stimulated the author to review and extend the scaling approach. The scaling theory we develop provides a powerful tool, based on the notion of universality, to understand the physical properties of correlated systems beyond the mean-field level. This is illustrated by our treatment of the one-dimensional Hubbard model, where, although the Fermi-liquid fixed point does not survive the fluctuations, the scaling approach is still useful. Finally, we discuss briefly how disorder affect our results.
This paper addresses the following main question: Do we have a theoretical understanding of entanglement applicable to a full variety of physical settings? It is clear that not only the assumption of distinguishability, but also the few-subsystem scenario, are too narrow to embrace all possible physical settings. In particular, the need to go beyond the traditional subsystem-based framework becomes manifest when one tries to apply the conventional concept of entanglement to the physics of matter, since the constituents of a quantum many-body system are indistinguishable particles. We shall discuss here a notion of generalized entanglement, which can be applied to any operator language (fermions, bosons, spins, etc.) used to describe a physical system and which includes the conventional entanglement settings introduced to date in a unified fashion. This is realized by noticing that entanglement is an observer-dependent concept, whose properties are determined by the expectations of a distinguished set of observables without reference to a preferred subsystem decomposition, i.e., it depends on the physically relevant point of view. This viewpoint depends in turn upon the relationship between different sets of observables that determine our ability to control the system of interest. Indeed, the extent to which entanglement is present depends on the observables used to measure a system and describe its states. This represents a most conspicuous advantage as will be highlighted by the condensed-matter application we will discuss.
The inherent complexity of interacting quantum many-body systems poses an outstanding challenge to both theory and experiment. Especially in the presence of strong electronic correlations, highly interesting and perplexing physical phenomena can occur. \nIn this thesis, we focus on three different examples of strongly correlated electron systems in which different types of defects occur. First, we investigate the Heisenberg-Kitaev model formulated on a triangular lattice. Using a mixture of numerical and analytical techniques we map out the entire phase diagram for the classical and quantum models. We provide an analytical foundation to the intriguing Z2-vortex ground state, in which strong spin-orbit coupling leads to the formation of a lattice of topological point defects. This state was observed previously in classical Monte Carlo simulations. We furthermore propose the iridate Ba3IrTi2O9 to be a prime candidate for the realization of such a state. \nThe second part deals with the physics of a defect in the form of a localized magnetic moment which is embedded into a metallic environment: the Kondo effect. Although this effect has been a cornerstone of condensed matter physics for more than 50 years, its properties in real-space are still not fully understood. What is the Kondo screening cloud---the extended many-body state of entangled conduction electrons? We present numerical results in 1D and 2D for the charge density oscillations created by the impurity. We find that the entire RG flow of the problem is recovered in these oscillations, elucidating the internal structure of the screening cloud. \nFinally, we investigate the competition between the Kondo effect and Majorana physics. Majorana bound states are highly interesting objects which exhibit unusual statistics and could be used as a building block of a topological quantum computer. Recently, signatures of their existence were observed in experiment, and we here examine how Kondo physics (which might play a role in real systems) interact with such Majorana bound states.