Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.09620 · Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment

About the foundation of the Kubo generalized cumulants theory: a revisited and corrected approach

Marco Bianucci, Mauro Bologna

Published Apr 1, 2020• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract More than fifty years ago, in a couple of seminal works (Kubo 1962 J. Phys. Soc. Japan 17 1100–20; Kubo 1963 J. Math. Phys . 4 174–83) Kubo introduced the important idea of generalized cumulants, extending to stochastic operators this concept implicitly introduced by Laplace in 1810. Kubo’s idea has been applied in several branches of physics, where the result of the average process is a Lioville operator or an effective time evolution operator for the density matrix of spin systems or the reduced density matrix for boson-fermions etc. Despite this success, the theoretical developments in these Kubo works pose problems that were highlighted many years ago by Fox and van Kampen and never solved. These weaknesses and errors, in particular concerning the factorization property of exponentials of cumulants and the explicit expressions that give generalized cumulants in terms of generalized moments and vice-versa, caused some perplexity (and confusion) about the possible application of this procedure, limiting its use, in practice. In the present paper, we give a sound ground to the approach to cumulant operators, working in a general framework that shows the potentiality of the old Kubo idea, today not yet fully exploited. It results that, for the same moment operators, different definitions of generalized cumulants can be adopted. A general Kubo–Meeron closed-form formula giving cumulant operators in terms of moment operators cannot be obtained, but the reverse one, cumulants in terms of operators, is given and, noticeably, formally it does not depend on the specific nature of the moments, but just on the definition of the generalized cumulants.

DOI
10.1088/1742-5468/ab7755

Related papers

Generalized Cumulant Expansion Method

Ryogo Kubo

The moment generating function of a set of stochastic variables defines the cumulants or the semi-invariants and the cumulant function. It is possible, simply by formal properties of exponential functions, to generaiize to a great extent the concepts of cumulants and cumulant function. The stochastic variables to be considered need not be ordinary c -numbers but they may be q -numbers such as used in quantum mechanics. The exponential function which defines a moment generating function may be any kind of generalized exponential, for example an ordered exponential with a certain prescription for ordering q -number variables. The definition of average may be greatly generalized as far as the condition is fulfilled that the average of unity is unity. After statements of a few basic theorems these generalizations are discussed here with certain examples of application. This generalized cumulant expansion provides us with a point of view from which many existent methods in quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics can be unified.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jul 1, 1962•1,800 citations

Properties of tensorial free cumulants

Thomas Buc-d’Alché, Luca Lionni

In the past two years, several points of view have been proposed to address the question of the generalization of the theory of free probability to random tensors with different invariances, and it is unclear at this point whether they lead to the same notions of tensorial free cumulants and freeness. One way to approach this problem, developed by Collins, Gurau and the second named author for local unitary invariant random tensors, relies on finite size quantities involving averages over the invariance group, and whose asymptotics naturally possess the properties expected for tensorial generalizations of free cumulants of arbitrary orders. At this point, this approach has only been carried out for certain distributions, and for a subset of the moments that define such theories, and a more systematic and exhaustive study is lacking. This is the program initiated in this paper: we link this approach to the one proposed by Nechita and Park; extend a number of their results as well as those of the aforementioned paper to arbitrary orders of fluctuations, thereby generalizing higher order free cumulants; push further the study of distributions with larger invariance groups; detail the link with the asymptotics of the free-energies of the tensor HCIZ and BGW integrals; and provide formulae for tensorial free cumulants of products of tensors. Another important question is that of the definition of concrete distributions whose tensorial free-cumulants take non-trivial values. We compute the tensorial free cumulants for Gaussian random tensors with non-trivial covariances, and show that they provide such examples.

arXiv:2605.01887•May 3, 2026•2 citations

Cumulant Expansions and Pressure Broadening as an Example of Relaxation

Antoine Royer

Pressure broadening by neutral atoms is treated in a time-dependent formalism making use of generalized cumulants due to Kubo. A thermal-equilibrium initial density matrix is assumed, unlike in previous theories by Baranger and Fano who neglect initial correlations between atoms; it is pointed out that the wings of the spectrum depend in an essential manner on these initial correlations. The treatment centers on a time-evolution operator $U(t)={({\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}\ensuremath{\rho})}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}\ensuremath{\rho}{e}^{\mathrm{it}{H}^{\mathrm{x}}}$ operating in the Liouville space of the radiating atom and governing its motion under the influence of the perturbing gas or bath {${\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}$ is the trace over bath coordinates, $\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\sim}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}H}$ is the density matrix, and ${H}^{\mathrm{x}}$ is the quantum-mechanical Liouvillian: ${H}^{\mathrm{x}}( )=[H, ( )]$; $H$ is the total Hamiltonian for the system radiator plus bath}; $U(t)$ is written as $U(t)={T}_{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}\mathrm{exp}[i\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{t}d{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}L({t}^{\ensuremath{'}})]$, $L(t)={H}_{s}^{\mathrm{x}}+R(t)$ (${T}_{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$ is a time-ordering operator), where the effect of the bath is contained in the time-dependent non-Hermitian perturbation $R(t)$ added to the Liouvillian ${H}_{s}^{\mathrm{x}}$ of the unperturbed radiator. The operator $R(t)$ is expanded in powers of a "reduced" density equal to the perturbing-gas density multiplied by the ratio of the fugacities corresponding to mutually interacting and noninteracting perturbing atoms, respectively; the terms of the expansion are expressed by means of generalized cumulants, and describe interactions of the radiator with clusters of perturbers. By setting $R(t)=\overline{R}+\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{R}(t)$, where $\overline{R}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\mathrm{lim}}_{T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}[(\frac{1}{T})\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{T}\mathrm{dtR}(t)]$, the spectrum is written as the sum of its impact approximation, determined by $\overline{R}$, plus a correction expanded in powers of $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{R}(t)$, which to first order in the gas density equals the one-perturber spectrum minus its singularities at the resonance frequencies.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1972•96 citations

Stochastic averaging of the time-evolution operator for quantum systems driven by Ornstein-Uhlenbeck colored noise: A nonperturbative cluster cumulant method

S. Guha, Goutam Sanyal, Seikh Hannan Mandal +1 more

We have developed in this paper a nonperturbative cluster-expansion strategy for generating the stochastically averaged time-evolution operator for quantum systems driven by Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) colored noise. The method induces a boson mapping of the (real or complex) stochastic variable f, and interprets the stochastic average of a pair of variables f at two different times as the expectation value of the time-ordered product of the associated bosons with respect to the boson vacuum \ensuremath{\Vert}${0}_{\mathit{B}}$〉. The stochastic evolution is thus mapped onto a deterministic evolution in an expanded Fock space. The evolution of the system from the groups of state of interest is monitored using our recently developed nonperturbative time-dependent multireference coupled-cluster (TDMRCC) method. In this, the evolution operator U is written in a factorized form ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}$${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}$, where ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}$ evolves in the space of the starting functions (model space) and ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}$ brings in the virtual functions. ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}$ and ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}$ are both written as normal ordered exponentials involving cluster operators. In the present context, the TDMRCC method translates into one for generating the evolution operator ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}$ for the Hamiltonian containing the additional boson variables, and the stochastic averaging of ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}$ is realized as the expectation value 〈${0}_{\mathit{B}}$\ensuremath{\Vert}${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}$\ensuremath{\Vert}${0}_{\mathit{B}}$〉.We call the TDMRCC method involving the expanded Fock space a cluster cumulant method. We have analyzed the relation of the cluster cumulant approach with the Fox-Kubo operator cumulant expansion and the method of marginal averages involving the Fokker-Planck operator of the OU process. It has been shown that an order by order expansion of our equations in the power of stochastic coupling generates the perturbative cumulant results of Fox and Kubo. It is also demonstrated that the traditional Fokker-Planck method of marginal averages uses a Kubo-Schr\"odinger operator which is related to our boson mapped Hamiltonian by a transformation which converts the Fokker-Planck operator \ensuremath{\Gamma} to a manifestly Hermitian form. However, the method of marginal averages involves a linear expansion of ${\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}$ in terms of eigenfunctions of \ensuremath{\Gamma}, while the cluster cumulant method uses a cluster expansion, which is nonlinear in the expansion parameters. The former is thus analogous to a configuration-interaction expansion, while the latter is analogous to a coupled-cluster strategy. The method is illustrated by applying it to a simple yet nontrivial problem, viz., a harmonic oscillator linearly perturbed by a (real or complex) stochastic variable. Survivalities of both the ground and the first excited states have been considered for a wide range of coupling strengths and noise correlation times. Our method provides exact results in this case; these have been used as benchmarks for assessing performance of the second- and fourth-order cumulant results.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Apr 1, 1993•1 citation

Linear response theory revisited. II. The master equation approach

K. M. van Vliet

We consider a system perturbed by an external field and subject to dissipative processes. From the von Neumann equation for such a system in the weak coupling limit we derive an inhomogeneous master equation, i.e., a master equation with dissipative terms and streaming terms, using Zwanzig’s projection operator technique in Liouville space. From this equation the response function, as well as expressions for the generalized conductivity and susceptibility, is obtained. It is shown that for large times only the diagonal part of the density operator is required. The various expressions are found to be in complete harmony with previous results (Part I) obtained via the van Hove limit of the Kubo–Green linear response formulas. In order to account for the properties at quantum frequencies, the evolution of the nondiagonal part in the weak coupling limit is also established. The complete time dependent behavior of the dynamic variables in the van Hove limit is expressed by B (t) =exp[−(Λd−iℒ0) t] B, where Λd is the master operator and L0 the Liouville operator in the interaction picture. The cause of irreversibility is discussed. Finally, the inhomogeneous master equation is employed to obtain as first moment equation a Boltzmann equation with streaming terms, applicable to quantum systems.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1979•81 citations

On the definition of the spin-free cumulant of the second-order reduced density matrix

Luis Laín, Alicia Torre, Roberto C. Bochicchio

This note deals with the appropriate definition for the spin-free cumulant of the second-order reduced density matrix. Our approach leads to a direct derivation of one of the proposals reported by Kutzelnigg and Mukherjee [J. Chem. Phys. 116, 4787 (2002)] and it points out its suitability.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 30, 2002•30 citations
Abstract More than fifty years ago, in a couple of seminal works (Kubo 1962 J. Phys. Soc. Japan 17 1100–20; Kubo 1963 J. Math. Phys . 4 174–83) Kubo introduced the important idea of generalized cumulants, extending to stochastic operators this concept implicitly introduced by Laplace in 1810. Kubo’s idea has been applied in several branches of physics, where the result of the average process is a Lioville operator or an effective time evolution operator for the density matrix of spin systems or the reduced density matrix for boson-fermions etc. Despite this success, the theoretical developments in these Kubo works pose problems that were highlighted many years ago by Fox and van Kampen and never solved. These weaknesses and errors, in particular concerning the factorization property of exponentials of cumulants and the explicit expressions that give generalized cumulants in terms of generalized moments and vice-versa, caused some perplexity (and confusion) about the possible application of this procedure, limiting its use, in practice. In the present paper, we give a sound ground to the approach to cumulant operators, working in a general framework that shows the potentiality of the old Kubo idea, today not yet fully exploited. It results that, for the same moment operators, different definitions of generalized cumulants can be adopted. A general Kubo–Meeron closed-form formula giving cumulant operators in terms of moment operators cannot be obtained, but the reverse one, cumulants in terms of operators, is given and, noticeably, formally it does not depend on the specific nature of the moments, but just on the definition of the generalized cumulants.
The moment generating function of a set of stochastic variables defines the cumulants or the semi-invariants and the cumulant function. It is possible, simply by formal properties of exponential functions, to generaiize to a great extent the concepts of cumulants and cumulant function. The stochastic variables to be considered need not be ordinary c -numbers but they may be q -numbers such as used in quantum mechanics. The exponential function which defines a moment generating function may be any kind of generalized exponential, for example an ordered exponential with a certain prescription for ordering q -number variables. The definition of average may be greatly generalized as far as the condition is fulfilled that the average of unity is unity. After statements of a few basic theorems these generalizations are discussed here with certain examples of application. This generalized cumulant expansion provides us with a point of view from which many existent methods in quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics can be unified.
In the past two years, several points of view have been proposed to address the question of the generalization of the theory of free probability to random tensors with different invariances, and it is unclear at this point whether they lead to the same notions of tensorial free cumulants and freeness. One way to approach this problem, developed by Collins, Gurau and the second named author for local unitary invariant random tensors, relies on finite size quantities involving averages over the invariance group, and whose asymptotics naturally possess the properties expected for tensorial generalizations of free cumulants of arbitrary orders. At this point, this approach has only been carried out for certain distributions, and for a subset of the moments that define such theories, and a more systematic and exhaustive study is lacking. This is the program initiated in this paper: we link this approach to the one proposed by Nechita and Park; extend a number of their results as well as those of the aforementioned paper to arbitrary orders of fluctuations, thereby generalizing higher order free cumulants; push further the study of distributions with larger invariance groups; detail the link with the asymptotics of the free-energies of the tensor HCIZ and BGW integrals; and provide formulae for tensorial free cumulants of products of tensors. Another important question is that of the definition of concrete distributions whose tensorial free-cumulants take non-trivial values. We compute the tensorial free cumulants for Gaussian random tensors with non-trivial covariances, and show that they provide such examples.
Pressure broadening by neutral atoms is treated in a time-dependent formalism making use of generalized cumulants due to Kubo. A thermal-equilibrium initial density matrix is assumed, unlike in previous theories by Baranger and Fano who neglect initial correlations between atoms; it is pointed out that the wings of the spectrum depend in an essential manner on these initial correlations. The treatment centers on a time-evolution operator $U(t)={({\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}\ensuremath{\rho})}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}\ensuremath{\rho}{e}^{\mathrm{it}{H}^{\mathrm{x}}}$ operating in the Liouville space of the radiating atom and governing its motion under the influence of the perturbing gas or bath {TrB{\mathrm{Tr}}_{B}TrB​ is the trace over bath coordinates, $\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\sim}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\beta}H}$ is the density matrix, and Hx{H}^{\mathrm{x}}Hx is the quantum-mechanical Liouvillian: Hx()=[H,()]{H}^{\mathrm{x}}( )=[H, ( )]Hx()=[H,()]; HHH is the total Hamiltonian for the system radiator plus bath}; U(t)U(t)U(t) is written as $U(t)={T}_{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}\mathrm{exp}[i\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{t}d{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}L({t}^{\ensuremath{'}})]$, L(t)=Hsx+R(t)L(t)={H}_{s}^{\mathrm{x}}+R(t)L(t)=Hsx​+R(t) (${T}_{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}$ is a time-ordering operator), where the effect of the bath is contained in the time-dependent non-Hermitian perturbation R(t)R(t)R(t) added to the Liouvillian Hsx{H}_{s}^{\mathrm{x}}Hsx​ of the unperturbed radiator. The operator R(t)R(t)R(t) is expanded in powers of a "reduced" density equal to the perturbing-gas density multiplied by the ratio of the fugacities corresponding to mutually interacting and noninteracting perturbing atoms, respectively; the terms of the expansion are expressed by means of generalized cumulants, and describe interactions of the radiator with clusters of perturbers. By setting $R(t)=\overline{R}+\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{R}(t)$, where $\overline{R}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\mathrm{lim}}_{T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}}[(\frac{1}{T})\ensuremath{\int}{0}^{T}\mathrm{dtR}(t)]$, the spectrum is written as the sum of its impact approximation, determined by R‾\overline{R}R, plus a correction expanded in powers of $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{R}(t)$, which to first order in the gas density equals the one-perturber spectrum minus its singularities at the resonance frequencies.
We have developed in this paper a nonperturbative cluster-expansion strategy for generating the stochastically averaged time-evolution operator for quantum systems driven by Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) colored noise. The method induces a boson mapping of the (real or complex) stochastic variable f, and interprets the stochastic average of a pair of variables f at two different times as the expectation value of the time-ordered product of the associated bosons with respect to the boson vacuum \ensuremath{\Vert}0B{0}_{\mathit{B}}0B​〉. The stochastic evolution is thus mapped onto a deterministic evolution in an expanded Fock space. The evolution of the system from the groups of state of interest is monitored using our recently developed nonperturbative time-dependent multireference coupled-cluster (TDMRCC) method. In this, the evolution operator U is written in a factorized form Uex{\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}Uex​UM{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}UM​, where UM{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}UM​ evolves in the space of the starting functions (model space) and Uex{\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}Uex​ brings in the virtual functions. Uex{\mathit{U}}_{\mathrm{ex}}Uex​ and UM{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{M}}UM​ are both written as normal ordered exponentials involving cluster operators. In the present context, the TDMRCC method translates into one for generating the evolution operator UB{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}UB​ for the Hamiltonian containing the additional boson variables, and the stochastic averaging of UB{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}UB​ is realized as the expectation value 〈0B{0}_{\mathit{B}}0B​\ensuremath{\Vert}UB{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}UB​\ensuremath{\Vert}0B{0}_{\mathit{B}}0B​〉.We call the TDMRCC method involving the expanded Fock space a cluster cumulant method. We have analyzed the relation of the cluster cumulant approach with the Fox-Kubo operator cumulant expansion and the method of marginal averages involving the Fokker-Planck operator of the OU process. It has been shown that an order by order expansion of our equations in the power of stochastic coupling generates the perturbative cumulant results of Fox and Kubo. It is also demonstrated that the traditional Fokker-Planck method of marginal averages uses a Kubo-Schr\"odinger operator which is related to our boson mapped Hamiltonian by a transformation which converts the Fokker-Planck operator \ensuremath{\Gamma} to a manifestly Hermitian form. However, the method of marginal averages involves a linear expansion of UB{\mathit{U}}_{\mathit{B}}UB​ in terms of eigenfunctions of \ensuremath{\Gamma}, while the cluster cumulant method uses a cluster expansion, which is nonlinear in the expansion parameters. The former is thus analogous to a configuration-interaction expansion, while the latter is analogous to a coupled-cluster strategy. The method is illustrated by applying it to a simple yet nontrivial problem, viz., a harmonic oscillator linearly perturbed by a (real or complex) stochastic variable. Survivalities of both the ground and the first excited states have been considered for a wide range of coupling strengths and noise correlation times. Our method provides exact results in this case; these have been used as benchmarks for assessing performance of the second- and fourth-order cumulant results.
We consider a system perturbed by an external field and subject to dissipative processes. From the von Neumann equation for such a system in the weak coupling limit we derive an inhomogeneous master equation, i.e., a master equation with dissipative terms and streaming terms, using Zwanzig’s projection operator technique in Liouville space. From this equation the response function, as well as expressions for the generalized conductivity and susceptibility, is obtained. It is shown that for large times only the diagonal part of the density operator is required. The various expressions are found to be in complete harmony with previous results (Part I) obtained via the van Hove limit of the Kubo–Green linear response formulas. In order to account for the properties at quantum frequencies, the evolution of the nondiagonal part in the weak coupling limit is also established. The complete time dependent behavior of the dynamic variables in the van Hove limit is expressed by B (t) =exp[−(Λd−iℒ0) t] B, where Λd is the master operator and L0 the Liouville operator in the interaction picture. The cause of irreversibility is discussed. Finally, the inhomogeneous master equation is employed to obtain as first moment equation a Boltzmann equation with streaming terms, applicable to quantum systems.