Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.09354

Comment on "Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies"

Anthony Bordg, Yijun He

Published Nov 21, 2019• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We point out a flaw in the unfair case of the quantum Prisoner's Dilemma as introduced in the pioneering Letter "Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies" of Eisert, Wilkens and Lewenstein. It is not true that the so-called miracle move therein always gives quantum Alice a large reward against classical Bob and outperforms tit-for-tat in an iterated game. Indeed, we introduce a new classical strategy that becomes Bob's dominant strategy, should Alice play the miracle move. Finally, we briefly survey the subsequent literature and turn to the 3-parameter strategic space instead of the 2-parameter one of Eisert et al.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1911.09354

Related papers

Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies

Jens Eisert, Martin Wilkens, Maciej Lewenstein

We investigate the quantization of nonzero sum games. For the particular case of the Prisoners' Dilemma we show that this game ceases to pose a dilemma if quantum strategies are allowed for. We also construct a particular quantum strategy which always gives reward if played against any classical strategy.

arXiv:quant-ph/9806088•Physical Review Letters•Oct 11, 1999•1,069 citations

Comment on “Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies''

Simon C. Benjamin, Patrick M. Hayden

In a recent paper, Eisert et al. presented a quantum mechanical generalization of Prisoner's Dilemma. They asserted that the maximally entangled game exhibits a unique Nash equilibrium which yields a pay-off equivalent to cooperative behaviour. In this comment we show that their observation is incorrect: there is no Nash equilibrium in the space of deterministic quantum strategies.

arXiv:quant-ph/0003036•Physical Review Letters•Jul 19, 2001•170 citations

Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies. (arXiv:quant-ph/9806088v4 UPDATED)

Jens Eisert, Martin Wilkens, Maciej Lewenstein

We investigate the quantization of non-zero sum games. For the particular case of the Prisoners' Dilemma we show that this game ceases to pose a dilemma if quantum strategies are allowed for. We also construct a particular quantum strategy which always gives reward if played against any classical strategy.

•Mar 15, 2020•0 citations

Repeated Quantum Games and Strategic Efficiency.

Shoto Aoki, Kazuki Ikeda

Repeated quantum game theory addresses long term relations among players who choose quantum strategies. In the conventional quantum game theory, only single round quantum games or at most finitely repeated games have been studied, therefore nothing is known for infinitely repeated quantum game. Investigating infinitely repeated games is crucial since finitely repeated games does not much differ from single round games. In this work we establish the concept of general repeated quantum games and show the Quantum Folk Theorem, which claims that by iterating a game one can find an equilibrium strategy of the game and receive reward that is not obtained by a Nash equilibrium of the corresponding single round quantum game. A significant difference between repeated quantum prisoner's dilemma and repeated classical prisoner's dilemma is that the classical Pareto optimal solution is not always an equilibrium of the repeated quantum game when entanglement is sufficiently strong. In addition we present several concrete equilibrium strategies of the repeated quantum prisoner's dilemma.

•May 12, 2020•3 citations

Non-Classical Rules in Quantum Games

Piotr Frąckiewicz

Over the last twenty years, quantum game theory has given us many ideas of how quantum games could be played. One of the most prominent ideas in the field is a model of quantum playing bimatrix games introduced by J. Eisert, M. Wilkens and M. Lewenstein. The scheme assumes that players' strategies are unitary operations and the players act on the maximally entangled two-qubit state. The quantum nature of the scheme has been under discussion since the article by Eisert et al. came out. The aim of our paper was to identify some of non-classical features of the quantum scheme.

arXiv:2012.06915•Entropy•May 13, 2021•5 citations

Influence of the Asymmetry of the Strategy Spaces on the Properties of the Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma

Abd El Hakeem Abd El Naby, Heba A. Elrayes, Ahmed M. K. Tarabia +1 more

When it comes to global issues, interactions among participants are always asymmetric due to resource availability and environmental impacts. Therefore, it is important to analyze decision-making among participants with different strategies. We introduce quantum prisoner’s dilemma in asymmetric strategy spaces. The formulation with two dilemma strength parameters is considered, and the Eisert–Wilkens–Lewenstein quantization scheme is applied. The properties of Nash equilibrium are studied for all possible cases of the values of the dilemma strength parameters and for each level of asymmetry. A solution for the dilemma can be obtained only in some extreme limits where the environmental influence is the largest. Consequently, it is unlikely to find a solution to the dilemma in the quantum domain with asymmetric strategy spaces. Therefore, strategies need to be standardized when dealing with global issues.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Aug 4, 2022•5 citations
We point out a flaw in the unfair case of the quantum Prisoner's Dilemma as introduced in the pioneering Letter "Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies" of Eisert, Wilkens and Lewenstein. It is not true that the so-called miracle move therein always gives quantum Alice a large reward against classical Bob and outperforms tit-for-tat in an iterated game. Indeed, we introduce a new classical strategy that becomes Bob's dominant strategy, should Alice play the miracle move. Finally, we briefly survey the subsequent literature and turn to the 3-parameter strategic space instead of the 2-parameter one of Eisert et al.
Repeated quantum game theory addresses long term relations among players who choose quantum strategies. In the conventional quantum game theory, only single round quantum games or at most finitely repeated games have been studied, therefore nothing is known for infinitely repeated quantum game. Investigating infinitely repeated games is crucial since finitely repeated games does not much differ from single round games. In this work we establish the concept of general repeated quantum games and show the Quantum Folk Theorem, which claims that by iterating a game one can find an equilibrium strategy of the game and receive reward that is not obtained by a Nash equilibrium of the corresponding single round quantum game. A significant difference between repeated quantum prisoner's dilemma and repeated classical prisoner's dilemma is that the classical Pareto optimal solution is not always an equilibrium of the repeated quantum game when entanglement is sufficiently strong. In addition we present several concrete equilibrium strategies of the repeated quantum prisoner's dilemma.
Over the last twenty years, quantum game theory has given us many ideas of how quantum games could be played. One of the most prominent ideas in the field is a model of quantum playing bimatrix games introduced by J. Eisert, M. Wilkens and M. Lewenstein. The scheme assumes that players' strategies are unitary operations and the players act on the maximally entangled two-qubit state. The quantum nature of the scheme has been under discussion since the article by Eisert et al. came out. The aim of our paper was to identify some of non-classical features of the quantum scheme.
When it comes to global issues, interactions among participants are always asymmetric due to resource availability and environmental impacts. Therefore, it is important to analyze decision-making among participants with different strategies. We introduce quantum prisoner’s dilemma in asymmetric strategy spaces. The formulation with two dilemma strength parameters is considered, and the Eisert–Wilkens–Lewenstein quantization scheme is applied. The properties of Nash equilibrium are studied for all possible cases of the values of the dilemma strength parameters and for each level of asymmetry. A solution for the dilemma can be obtained only in some extreme limits where the environmental influence is the largest. Consequently, it is unlikely to find a solution to the dilemma in the quantum domain with asymmetric strategy spaces. Therefore, strategies need to be standardized when dealing with global issues.