Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1911.00343 · International Journal of Quantum Information

Bell inequalities, counterfactual definiteness and falsifiability

Justo Pastor Lambare

Published Apr 1, 2021• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We formally prove the existence of an enduring incongruence pervading a widespread interpretation of the Bell inequality and explain how to rationally avoid it with a natural assumption justified by explicit reference to a mathematical property of Bell’s probabilistic model. Although the amendment does not alter the relevance of the theorem regarding local realism, it brings back Bell theorem from the realm of philosophical discussions about counterfactual conditionals to the concrete experimental arena.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749921500180

Related papers

Counterfactual Definiteness and Local Causation

Brian Skyrms

Bell's Theorem is proved for locality and conservation formulated in terms of subjunctive conditionals with chance consequents, rather than the usual conditional probability formulation. This brings into sharp focus the minimal counterfactual assumptions needed for Bell's theorem.

Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1982•34 citations

Quantum non-locality—it ainʼt necessarily so...

Marek Żukowski, Časlav Brukner

Bell's theorem is 50 years old. Still there is a controversy about its implications. Much of it has its roots in confusion regarding the premises from which the theorem can be derived. Some claim that a derivation of Bell's inequalities requires just locality assumption, and nothing more. Violations of the inequalities are then interpreted as ``nonlocality'' or ``quantum nonlocality''. We show that such claims are unfounded and that every derivation of Bell's inequalities requires a premise -- in addition to locality and freedom of choice -- which is either assumed tacitly, or unconsciously, or is embedded in a single compound condition (like Bell's ``local causality''). The premise is equivalent to the assumption of existence of additional variables which do not appear in the quantum formalism (in form of determinism, or joint probability for outcomes of all conceivable measurements, or ``additional causes`'', or ``hidden variables'', ``complete description of the state'' or counterfactual definiteness, etc.). A certain irony is that perhaps the main message of violation of Bell's inequalities is that our notion of locality should be based on an operationally well-defined no-signalling condition, rather than on local causality.

arXiv:1501.04618•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 9, 2014•106 citations

What Bell proved: A reply to Blaylock

Tim Maudlin

Blaylock argues that the derivation of Bell’s inequality requires a hidden assumption, counterfactual definiteness, of which Bell was unaware. A careful analysis of Bell’s argument shows that Bell presupposes only locality and the predictions of standard quantum mechanics. Counterfactual definiteness, insofar as it is required, is derived in the course of the argument rather than presumed. Bell’s theorem has no direct bearing on the many worlds interpretation not because that interpretation denies counterfactual definiteness but because it does not recover the predictions of standard quantum mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 14, 2009•31 citations

A Bell Theorem with no locality assumption

Charles P. Tresser

We prove here a version of Bell Theorem that does not assume locality. As a consequence classical realism, and not locality, is the common source of the violation by nature of all Bell Inequalities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0608008•Aug 1, 2006•1 citation

PHYSICAL MEANING OF BELL TYPE INEQUALITIES

F. Selleri

When considering the experiments on Bell type inequalities one should bear in mind the practical and conceptual difference between the weak inequalities (WI, deduced from local realism alone) and the strong inequalities (SI, deduced with the help of additional assumptions): only the SI have been falsified experimentally. In this paper we will give the clearest illustration of the difference by: (1) using a new algebraic lemma in the proof of a WI from deterministic local realism; (2) summarising the general formulation of probabilistic local realism; (3) using again the lemma in the proof of the WI, this time from probabilistic local realism; (4) writing the four additional assumptions proposed by different authors; (5) applying the lemma to four independent proofs of a SI starting separately from each additional assumption.

Conference on the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Historical Analysis and Open Questions•May 1, 2000•1 citation

Time weakens the Bell's inequalities

Alejandro Andrés Hnilo

By taking into account that all real measurements are performed successively, during time, it is concluded that the violation of the Bell's inequalities in the Nature does not refute (even in an ideally perfect experiment) the theories holding to Local Realism, for an unavoidable additional assumption is involved. Yet, in order to be acceptable, such theories must predict different values for the factual and counterfactual time averages of probabilities or observables.

arXiv:1306.1383•Jun 6, 2013•5 citations
We formally prove the existence of an enduring incongruence pervading a widespread interpretation of the Bell inequality and explain how to rationally avoid it with a natural assumption justified by explicit reference to a mathematical property of Bell’s probabilistic model. Although the amendment does not alter the relevance of the theorem regarding local realism, it brings back Bell theorem from the realm of philosophical discussions about counterfactual conditionals to the concrete experimental arena.
Bell's theorem is 50 years old. Still there is a controversy about its implications. Much of it has its roots in confusion regarding the premises from which the theorem can be derived. Some claim that a derivation of Bell's inequalities requires just locality assumption, and nothing more. Violations of the inequalities are then interpreted as ``nonlocality'' or ``quantum nonlocality''. We show that such claims are unfounded and that every derivation of Bell's inequalities requires a premise -- in addition to locality and freedom of choice -- which is either assumed tacitly, or unconsciously, or is embedded in a single compound condition (like Bell's ``local causality''). The premise is equivalent to the assumption of existence of additional variables which do not appear in the quantum formalism (in form of determinism, or joint probability for outcomes of all conceivable measurements, or ``additional causes`'', or ``hidden variables'', ``complete description of the state'' or counterfactual definiteness, etc.). A certain irony is that perhaps the main message of violation of Bell's inequalities is that our notion of locality should be based on an operationally well-defined no-signalling condition, rather than on local causality.
Blaylock argues that the derivation of Bell’s inequality requires a hidden assumption, counterfactual definiteness, of which Bell was unaware. A careful analysis of Bell’s argument shows that Bell presupposes only locality and the predictions of standard quantum mechanics. Counterfactual definiteness, insofar as it is required, is derived in the course of the argument rather than presumed. Bell’s theorem has no direct bearing on the many worlds interpretation not because that interpretation denies counterfactual definiteness but because it does not recover the predictions of standard quantum mechanics.
When considering the experiments on Bell type inequalities one should bear in mind the practical and conceptual difference between the weak inequalities (WI, deduced from local realism alone) and the strong inequalities (SI, deduced with the help of additional assumptions): only the SI have been falsified experimentally. In this paper we will give the clearest illustration of the difference by: (1) using a new algebraic lemma in the proof of a WI from deterministic local realism; (2) summarising the general formulation of probabilistic local realism; (3) using again the lemma in the proof of the WI, this time from probabilistic local realism; (4) writing the four additional assumptions proposed by different authors; (5) applying the lemma to four independent proofs of a SI starting separately from each additional assumption.