Topological phases of matter are generally characterized by topological properties of energy bands of a system. Their transitions under preserved symmetries occur through closing a gap of energy bands, leading to topologically protected edge states in energy spectra in topological phases. Here we predict a new topological phase that emerges through closing a gap of bands constructed by energy bands, instead of through closing an energy gap with preserved symmetries. From this perspective, topological phases may arise from topological properties of the "bands of bands" associated with their gap closure and corresponding edge states. We demonstrate this idea by studying a tight-binding model. We find that the Wannier bands constructed by energy bands exhibit a gap closure associated with a change of a winding number, while the energy bands remain gapped and trivial without any zero energy modes. In addition, the topological Wannier bands give rise to quantized edge polarizations. Since the emergence of this topological phase does not involve any energy gap closure, we expect its appearance under unitary time evolution. Indeed, this phase appears as we perform a quench dynamics. Our study opens a new direction for exploring topological phases beyond conventional energy band characterization.
Topological phases of matter are generally characterized by topological properties of energy bands of a system. Their transitions under preserved symmetries occur through closing a gap of energy bands, leading to topologically protected edge states in energy spectra in topological phases. Here we predict a new topological phase that emerges through closing a gap of bands constructed by energy bands, instead of through closing an energy gap with preserved symmetries. From this perspective, topological phases may arise from topological properties of the "bands of bands" associated with their gap closure and corresponding edge states. We demonstrate this idea by studying a tight-binding model. We find that the Wannier bands constructed by energy bands exhibit a gap closure associated with a change of a winding number, while the energy bands remain gapped and trivial without any zero energy modes. In addition, the topological Wannier bands give rise to quantized edge polarizations. Since the emergence of this topological phase does not involve any energy gap closure, we expect its appearance under unitary time evolution. Indeed, this phase appears as we perform a quench dynamics. Our study opens a new direction for exploring topological phases beyond conventional energy band characterization.
Topological states of matter are characterized by global topological invariants which change their value across a topological quantum phase transition. It is commonly assumed that the transition between topologically distinct noninteracting gapped phases of fermions is necessarily accompanied by the closing of the band gap as long as the symmetries of the system are maintained. We show that such a quantum phase transition is possible without closing the gap in the case of a three-dimensional topological band insulator. We demonstrate this by calculating the free energy of the minimal model for a topological insulator, the Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang model, and show that as the band curvature continuously varies, a jump between the band-gap minima corresponding to the topologically trivial and nontrivial insulators occurs. Therefore, this first-order phase transition is a generic feature of three-dimensional topological band insulators. For a certain parameter range we predict a reentrant topological phase transition. We discuss our findings in connection with the recent experimental observation of a discontinuous topological phase transition in a family of topological crystalline insulators.
The classification of distinct phases of matter is a central theme in condensed matter physics. A phase of matter can be viewed as an equivalence class of physical states that share a certain set of properties. In the case of topological quantum matter, these properties are associated with topological invariants that take specific values for each equivalence class. Perturbing a gapped state that corresponds to a given topological phase (i.e., smoothly deforming the Hamiltonian of the system) does not affect the topological invariant, as long as the bulk energy gap remains finite. The value of this invariant changes only if the system undergoes a quantum phase transition, which is signaled by the collapse of the gap. Full topological protection can only emerge in interacting systems and requires the presence of long-range entanglement, which is at the origin of intrinsic topological order. However, topological properties protected by symmetries emerge even in noninteracting systems and, perhaps surprisingly, can be described within the framework of good old band theory of solids. Systems belonging to this category are generically called topological insulators, after the class of materials that is largely responsible for the recent surge in research on topological matter. In addition, topological band theory considerations can also be applied to superconductors (and superfluids), as described at the mean-field level using Bogoliubov–de Gennes theory. This chapter summarizes the key ideas behind the topological classification of noninteracting systems and discusses the basic properties of various classes of topological insulators and superconductors. For in-depth discussions and related developments the reader is referred to a number of books [ 54 , 175 , 469 ] and review papers [ 23 , 239 , 240 , 421 ] specifically dedicated to this subject.
T HE CLASSIFICATION OF DISTINCT PHASES OF MATTER is a central theme in condensed matter physics. A phase of matter can be viewed as an equivalence class of physical states that share a certain set of properties. In the case of topological quantum matter, these properties are associated with topological invariants that take specific values for each equivalence class. Perturbing a gapped state that corresponds to a given topological phase (i.e., smoothly deforming the Hamiltonian of the system) does not affect the topological invariant, as long as the energy gap remains finite. The value of this invariant changes only if the system undergoes a quantum phase transition, which is signaled by the collapse of the gap. Full topological protection can only emerge in interacting systems and requires the presence of long-range entanglement, which is at the origin of intrinsic topological order. However, topological properties protected by symmetries emerge even in noninteracting systems and, perhaps surprisingly, can be described within the framework of good old band theory of solids. Systems belonging to this category are generically called topological insulators, after the class of materials that is largely responsible for the recent surge in research activity on topological matter. In addition, topological band theory considerations can also be applied to superconductors (and superfluids), as described at the mean-field level using Bogoliubov-de Gennes theory. This chapter summaries the key ideas behind the topological classification of noninteracting systems and discusses the basic properties of various classes of topological insulators and superconductors. For in-depth discussions and related developments the reader is referred to a number of books [48, 402, 153] and review papers [211, 212, 357, 22] specifically dedicated to this subject.
Topological quantum phase transitions are characterized by changes in global topological invariants. These invariants classify many-body systems beyond the conventional paradigm of local order parameters describing spontaneous symmetry breaking. For noninteracting electrons, it is well understood that such transitions are continuous and always accompanied by a gap closing in the energy spectrum, given that the symmetries protecting the topological phase are maintained. Here, we demonstrate that a sufficiently strong electron-electron interaction can fundamentally change the situation: we discover a topological quantum phase transition of first-order character in the genuine thermodynamic sense that occurs without a gap closing. Our theoretical study reveals the existence of a quantum critical endpoint associated with an orbital instability on the transition line between a 2D topological insulator and a trivial band insulator. Remarkably, this phenomenon entails unambiguous signatures related to the orbital occupations that can be detected experimentally.
We consider two-dimensional topological insulators as prototypes of symmetry protected topological phases where spin-orbit coupling gives rise to the topological insulator phase. The appearance of additional non-topological terms might cause quantum phase transitions into trivial phases when this topologically trivial term overweights the spin-orbit coupling. Usually such a phase transition is associated with closing of the bulk gap. In contrast, time-reversal symmetry breaking terms immediately destroy the topological phase without closing of the bulk gap unless the axial spin symmetry remains preserved. These findings are discussed in the context of topological insulators in the presence of interactions.
Recent experiments began to explore the topological properties of quench dynamics, i.e., the time evolution following a sudden change in the Hamiltonian, via tomography of quantum gases in optical lattices. In contrast to the well-established theory for static band insulators or periodically driven systems, at present it is not clear whether, and how, topological invariants can be defined for a general quench of band insulators. Previous work solved a special case of this problem beautifully using Hopf mapping of two-band Hamiltonians in two dimensions. However, it only works for a topologically trivial initial state and is hard to generalize to multiband systems or other dimensions. Here we introduce the concept of loop unitary constructed from the unitary time-evolution operator and show its homotopy invariant fully characterizes the dynamical topology. For two-band systems in two dimensions, we prove that the invariant is precisely equal to the change in the Chern number across the quench, regardless of the initial state. We further show that the nontrivial dynamical topology manifests as hedgehog defects in the loop unitary and also as winding and linking of its eigenvectors along a curve where dynamical quantum phase transition occurs. This opens up a systematic route to classify and characterize quantum quench dynamics.