Non-signaling proofs, motivated by quantum computation, have found applications in cryptography and hardness of approximation. An important open problem is characterizing the power of non-signaling proofs. It is known that non-signaling proofs with two provers are characterized by PSPACE and that non-signaling proofs with poly(n)-provers are characterized by EXP. However, the power of k-prover non-signaling proofs, for 2<k<(n) remained an open problem.
Non-signaling proofs, motivated by quantum computation, have found applications in cryptography and hardness of approximation. An important open problem is characterizing the power of non-signaling proofs. It is known that non-signaling proofs with two provers are characterized by PSPACE and that non-signaling proofs with poly(n)-provers are characterized by EXP. However, the power of k-prover non-signaling proofs, for 2<k<(n) remained an open problem.
We describe two generic ways to make multi-prover classical games resistant against entangled provers. The first uses quantum communication and a quantum verifier, the second adds an additional prover. This leads to several new results on the power of proof systems with entangled provers. We show that NEXP ⊆ QMIP1,s(2, 1) and NEXP ⊆ MIP1,s(3, 1) with soundness s = 1− 2− poly(n) and PSPACE ⊆ MIP1,s(2, 1) with soundness s = 1 − 1/ poly(n), providing the first non-trivial bounds in this setting. Moreover, our results imply that, unless P = NP, the value of entangled prover games cannot be computed by semi-definite programs that are polynomial in the size of the verifier’s system, a method that has been successful for more restricted quantum games. ∗also at CNRS & LRI, Univerite de Paris-Sud, Orsay, France †Partially supported by the European Commission under the Integrated Project Qubit Applications (QAP) funded by the IST directorate as Contract Number 015848 and by an Alon Fellowship of the Israeli Higher Council of Academic Research. ‡Part of this work was completed at Caltech. Supported by the National Science Foundation under Grants PHY-0456720 and CCF-0524828, by EU project QAP, and by NWO VICI project 639-023-302. Part of this research has been funded by the Dutch BSIK/BRICKS project. §Work partly done while at LRI, Univ. de Paris-Sud, Orsay.
We construct a 1-round delegation scheme (i.e., argument-system) for every language computable in time t = t ( n ), where the running time of the prover is poly ( t ) and the running time of the verifier is n · polylog ( t ). In particular, for every language in P we obtain a delegation scheme with almost linear time verification. Our construction relies on the existence of a computational sub-exponentially secure private information retrieval ( PIR ) scheme. The proof exploits a curious connection between the problem of computation delegation and the model of multi-prover interactive proofs that are sound against no-signaling (cheating) strategies , a model that was studied in the context of multi-prover interactive proofs with provers that share quantum entanglement, and is motivated by the physical principle that information cannot travel faster than light. For any language computable in time t = t ( n ), we construct a multi-prover interactive proof ( MIP ), that is, sound against no-signaling strategies, where the running time of the provers is poly ( t ), the number of provers is polylog ( t ), and the running time of the verifier is n · polylog ( t ). In particular, this shows that the class of languages that have polynomial-time MIP s that are sound against no-signaling strategies, is exactly EXP . Previously, this class was only known to contain PSPACE . To convert our MIP into a 1-round delegation scheme, we use the method suggested by Aiello et al. (ICALP, 2000), which makes use of a PIR scheme. This method lacked a proof of security. We prove that this method is secure assuming the underlying MIP is secure against no-signaling provers.
Interactive proof systems form an important complexity model that has been central to many prominent results in computational complexity theory, such as those on probabilistically checkable proofs, hardness of approximation, and fundamental cryptographic primitives. In this thesis, we study the quantum-enhanced version of interactive proof systems, in which each party has access to quantum computing resources. We focus on its power and limitations, which lead us to the following results. (*) We provide an alternative and conceptually simpler proof of Jain et al.’s recent breakthrough result, which demonstrates that the expressive power of quantum interactive proof systems coincides with that of its classical counterpart, and therefore PSPACE. (*) We determine the complexity of several variants of quantum competing-prover interactive proof systems, which introduce zero-sum games into interactive proof systems. In particular, we prove that the complexity class of two-turn quantum refereed games coincides with PSPACE, answering an important open problem of Jain et al.’s. Our result suggests that a more general model called double quantum interactive proof systems coincides with PSPACE, which subsumes and unifies all previous results on short refereed games. (*) We contribute to the study of two-prover quantum Merlin-Arthur games (QMA(2)), which exhibit an intriguing tradeoff between an intrinsic quantum ingredient, entanglement, and computational power. We prove a PSPACE upper bound for a variant of QMA(2) that is to date the most general one known in PSPACE. We also provide a quasi-polynomial time algorithm for optimizing linear functions over separable states, giving an alternative to the one proposed by Brandao et al. Our main technical contribution behind the above results is the equilibrium value method for obtaining space-efficient algorithms for a class of optimization problems that arise naturally in quantum computation. We also contribute to QMA-complete problems, where we demonstrate that the “Non-Identity Check” problem remains QMA-complete on circuits of poly-logarithmic depths, improving upon polynomial depths from previous results.
The study of interactive proofs in the quantum setting has yielded profound insights in complexity theory and quantum information. A curious feature of these results is that the advantage, in terms of computational power, of quantum models over their classical counterparts is usually due to entanglement phenomena rather than quantum communication with the verifier. For example, it is known that QIP = IP = PSPACE, and QMIP with unentangled provers is equal to NEXP = MIP; on the other hand, MIP* = RE. In this work we initiate the general study of (quantum) positional multi-prover interactive proofs ((Q)PMIP), in which provers and verifiers positioned in space communicate freely save for the constraints imposed by the speed of light. We investigate how the class of languages decidable by (Q)PMIPs depends on the arrangement of the verifiers and (honest) provers. In the case of classical PMIPs, we show a dichotomy: if the arrangement satisfies what we call the "min-ball" condition, then the class is NEXP, otherwise it is PSPACE. We then exhibit an arrangement that does not satisfy the min-ball condition for which there is a quantum PMIP for EXP in the no pre-shared entanglement model. Our construction is based on positional cryptography and MIPs with no-signaling soundness. We introduce a new positional primitive, the positional hardcore bit, which allows a pair of spatially separated players to transmit a random bit to a particular location while guaranteeing that it remains strongly unguessable elsewhere.