Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1910.00263 · Computer Graphics Forum

Quantum Coin Method for Numerical Integration

N. H. Shimada, Toshiya Hachisuka

Published May 21, 2020• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Light transport simulation in rendering is formulated as a numerical integration problem in each pixel, which is commonly estimated by Monte Carlo integration. Monte Carlo integration approximates an integral of a black‐box function by taking the average of many evaluations (i.e. samples) of the function (integrand). For N queries of the integrand, Monte Carlo integration achieves the estimation error of . Recently, Johnston [Joh16] introduced quantum super‐sampling (QSS) into rendering as a numerical integration method that can run on quantum computers. QSS breaks the fundamental limitation of the convergence rate of Monte Carlo integration and achieves the faster convergence rate of approximately which is the best possible bound of any quantum algorithms we know today [NW99]. We introduce yet another quantum numerical integration algorithm, quantum coin (QCoin) [AW99], and provide numerical experiments that are unprecedented in the fields of both quantum computing and rendering. We show that QCoin's convergence rate is equivalent to QSS's. We additionally show that QCoin is fundamentally more robust under the presence of noise in actual quantum computers due to its simpler quantum circuit and the use of fewer qubits. Considering various aspects of quantum computers, we discuss how QCoin can be a more practical alternative to QSS if we were to run light transport simulation in quantum computers in the future.

DOI
10.1111/cgf.14015

Related papers

Quantum Ray Tracing with Simulation

Xi Lu, Hongwei Lin

Rendering is a computer graphics process that generates images from a three-dimensional scene including models, lights and cameras. Ray tracing is a category of rendering algorithms that calculates pixel colors by simulating the physical movements of light rays such as reflections, refractions and scatterings. The core problem of ray tracing is a high-dimensional numerical integration, and the classical Monte Carlo ray tracing requires a big number of rays to reduce error. By leveraging the inherent parallelism of quantum computing, we propose a framework of quantum ray tracing algorithm, and do simulation experiments to prove that it has a quadratically faster error convergence than classical Monte Carlo ray tracing.

SPIN•Nov 14, 2022•3 citations

Quantum Ray Marching: Reformulating Light Transport for Quantum Computers

Logan Mosier, Morgan McGuire, Toshiya Hachisuka

The use of quantum computers in computer graphics has gained interest in recent years, especially for the application to rendering. The current state of the art in quantum rendering relies on Grover’s search for finding ray intersections in for M primitives. This quantum approach is faster than the naive approach of O(M) but slower than O(log M) of modern ray tracing with an acceleration data structure. Furthermore, this quantum ray tracing method is fundamentally limited to casting one ray at a time, leaving quantum rendering scales for the number of rays the same as non-quantum algorithms. We present a new quantum rendering method, quantum ray marching, based on the reformulation of ray marching as a quantum random walk. Our work is the first complete quantum rendering pipeline capable of light transport simulation and remains asymptotically faster than non-quantum counterparts. Our quantum ray marching can trace an exponential number of paths with polynomial cost, and it leverages quantum numerical integration to converge in O(1/N) for N estimates as opposed to non-quantum . These properties led to first quantum rendering that is asymptotically faster than non-quantum Monte Carlo rendering. We numerically tested our algorithm by rendering 2D and 3D scenes.

SIGGRAPH Asia Conference Papers•Dec 10, 2023•3 citations

The maximum-likelihood quantum amplitude estimation algorithm provides the best tradeoff between accuracy and circuit depth among quantum solutions for integral estimation

Marco Maronese, Massimiliano Incudini, Luca Asproni +1 more

The approximation of an integral with numerical integration methods is a relevant problem in many fields, from finance to chemistry. Monte Carlo methods are a family of methods widely used for numerical integration but which are not always applicable to industrial tasks. Instead, there are quantum computing methods such as Quantum Amplitude Estimation able to offer a speed-up compared to the Monte Carlo methods for numerical integration which promise a significant impact, especially in finance. The Quantum Amplitude Estimation algorithm is a fundamental quantum algorithm with the potential to achieve a quadratic speed-up. Unfortunately, being competitive over classical Monte Carlo methods would require hardware performances currently not available. Therefore, alternative methods have been developed in order to exploit fewer resources while maintaining an advantageous theoretical scaling. We present a comparison between the standard QAE algorithm and two NISQ-friendly versions of the QAE on a numerical integration task. The Monte Carlo technique of Metropolis-Hastings instead is used as a classical benchmark. The scaling of the different algorithms are evaluated in terms of estimation error as a function of the number of samples, computational time, and length of the quantum circuits required by the quantum solutions. The conclusion highlights that an alternative approach is preferable with respect to employng the phase estimation routine. Indeed, the maximum likelihood estimation guarantees the best trade-off between the length of the quantum circuits and the precision in the integral estimation.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•3 citations

Quantum Quasi-Monte Carlo: a window for pre-asymptotic quantum advantage

Paolo Recchia, Zhan Yu, Kelvin Koor +1 more

Numerical integration with Monte Carlo methods is a central computational task in many scientific and industrial applications, including financial derivative pricing and risk management. Classical Monte Carlo algorithms are computationally demanding: achieving an accuracy $ε$ typically requires a number of function evaluations scaling as $O(1/ε^2)$. Quantum-accelerated Monte Carlo methods based on quantum amplitude estimation can in principle quadratically improve this dependence. However, \textit{quasi}-Monte Carlo methods have not been explored in the quantum context. In this work, we introduce a quantum quasi-Monte Carlo algorithm that combines low-discrepancy nets with quantum amplitude estimation. The proposed method prepares the quasi-random point set coherently in superposition. The method does not yield an asymptotic improvement over classical quasi-Monte Carlo, since the total error separates into a discretization error, determined by the finite net, and a quantum estimation error. Instead, we explore a pre-asymptotic advantage window: for a target accuracy that would classically require $2^q$ low discrepancy points, one can prepare a higher-resolution net of size $2^Q$, with $Q>q$, in superposition and reach the same accuracy using significantly fewer function queries. This window can be controlled by tuning the circuit resolution and amplitude-estimation parameters, making the approach relevant for practical regimes where the number of queries is finite rather than asymptotically large.

quant-pharXiv:2609.03625•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Exploring the Potential of Quantum Monte Carlo Method for Computational Fluid Dynamics Simulations

Ferdin Sagai Don Bosco, Rochisha Agarwal, Aakif Akhtar +4 more

Quantum computing is a very active and diverse area, with immense research and development occurring in quantum hardware design and algorithm creation for applications in various scientific fields. The key motivation behind such efforts is the potential for significant speed-up relative to simulations on classical computers. Quantum Monte Carlo Integration (QMCI) is a quantum algorithm that promises a quadratic advantage in terms of the required number of samples for a required accuracy over classical Monte Carlo Integration (MCI), which is a key statistical resource for integrating multi-dimensional space. In this study, we explore the reality of this potential, specifically for applications in Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). We perform an eigenvalue stability analysis for a 1D convection-diffusion equation, in which the coefficients depend on a random number. The quantum algorithm utilized uses quantum amplitude estimation (QAE) to accelerate the integral estimation process. Numerical values obtained from QMCI results are compared against numerical integration techniques, and acceptably low errors are observed. The performance of QMCI is compared against MCI by equating the number of oracle calls in QMCI with the number of samples required in MCI. No significant difference in this metric is observed, with QMCI requiring more oracle calls. This suggests that the expected quantum supremacy is not attainable for the considered numerical integration problem and its quantum-circuit implementation. Extension to available Noisy-Intermediate-Scale-Quantum (NISQ) hardware is expected to reveal more about the algorithm implementation and the simulator emulation. Potential future directions that can be explored in algorithmic development based on this preliminary research are outlined.

AIAA SciTech Forum•Jan 3, 2025•0 citations

Reduction of qubits in a quantum algorithm for Monte Carlo simulation by a pseudo-random-number generator

Koichi Miyamoto, Kenji Shiohara

It is known that quantum computers can speed up Monte Carlo simulation compared to classical counterparts. There are already some proposals of application of the quantum algorithm to practical problems, including quantitative finance. In many problems in finance to which Monte Carlo simulation is applied, many random numbers are required to obtain one sample value of the integrand, since those problems are extremely high-dimensional integrations, for example, risk measurement of credit portfolio. This leads to the situation that the required qubit number is too large in the naive implementation where a quantum register is allocated per random number. In this paper, we point out that we can reduce qubits keeping quantum speed up if we perform calculation similar to the classical one, that is, estimate the average of integrand values sampled by a pseudo-random-number generator (PRNG) implemented on a quantum circuit. We present not only the overview of the idea but also concrete implementation of PRNG and application to credit risk measurement. Actually, reduction of qubits is a trade-off against increase of circuit depth. Therefore, full reduction might be impractical, but such a trade-off between speed and memory space will be important in adjustment of calculation setting considering machine specs, if large-scale Monte Carlo simulation by quantum computer is in operation in the future.

arXiv:1911.12469•Physical Review A•Aug 27, 2020•40 citations
Abstract Light transport simulation in rendering is formulated as a numerical integration problem in each pixel, which is commonly estimated by Monte Carlo integration. Monte Carlo integration approximates an integral of a black‐box function by taking the average of many evaluations (i.e. samples) of the function (integrand). For N queries of the integrand, Monte Carlo integration achieves the estimation error of . Recently, Johnston [Joh16] introduced quantum super‐sampling (QSS) into rendering as a numerical integration method that can run on quantum computers. QSS breaks the fundamental limitation of the convergence rate of Monte Carlo integration and achieves the faster convergence rate of approximately which is the best possible bound of any quantum algorithms we know today [NW99]. We introduce yet another quantum numerical integration algorithm, quantum coin (QCoin) [AW99], and provide numerical experiments that are unprecedented in the fields of both quantum computing and rendering. We show that QCoin's convergence rate is equivalent to QSS's. We additionally show that QCoin is fundamentally more robust under the presence of noise in actual quantum computers due to its simpler quantum circuit and the use of fewer qubits. Considering various aspects of quantum computers, we discuss how QCoin can be a more practical alternative to QSS if we were to run light transport simulation in quantum computers in the future.
Rendering is a computer graphics process that generates images from a three-dimensional scene including models, lights and cameras. Ray tracing is a category of rendering algorithms that calculates pixel colors by simulating the physical movements of light rays such as reflections, refractions and scatterings. The core problem of ray tracing is a high-dimensional numerical integration, and the classical Monte Carlo ray tracing requires a big number of rays to reduce error. By leveraging the inherent parallelism of quantum computing, we propose a framework of quantum ray tracing algorithm, and do simulation experiments to prove that it has a quadratically faster error convergence than classical Monte Carlo ray tracing.
The use of quantum computers in computer graphics has gained interest in recent years, especially for the application to rendering. The current state of the art in quantum rendering relies on Grover’s search for finding ray intersections in for M primitives. This quantum approach is faster than the naive approach of O(M) but slower than O(log M) of modern ray tracing with an acceleration data structure. Furthermore, this quantum ray tracing method is fundamentally limited to casting one ray at a time, leaving quantum rendering scales for the number of rays the same as non-quantum algorithms. We present a new quantum rendering method, quantum ray marching, based on the reformulation of ray marching as a quantum random walk. Our work is the first complete quantum rendering pipeline capable of light transport simulation and remains asymptotically faster than non-quantum counterparts. Our quantum ray marching can trace an exponential number of paths with polynomial cost, and it leverages quantum numerical integration to converge in O(1/N) for N estimates as opposed to non-quantum . These properties led to first quantum rendering that is asymptotically faster than non-quantum Monte Carlo rendering. We numerically tested our algorithm by rendering 2D and 3D scenes.
The approximation of an integral with numerical integration methods is a relevant problem in many fields, from finance to chemistry. Monte Carlo methods are a family of methods widely used for numerical integration but which are not always applicable to industrial tasks. Instead, there are quantum computing methods such as Quantum Amplitude Estimation able to offer a speed-up compared to the Monte Carlo methods for numerical integration which promise a significant impact, especially in finance. The Quantum Amplitude Estimation algorithm is a fundamental quantum algorithm with the potential to achieve a quadratic speed-up. Unfortunately, being competitive over classical Monte Carlo methods would require hardware performances currently not available. Therefore, alternative methods have been developed in order to exploit fewer resources while maintaining an advantageous theoretical scaling. We present a comparison between the standard QAE algorithm and two NISQ-friendly versions of the QAE on a numerical integration task. The Monte Carlo technique of Metropolis-Hastings instead is used as a classical benchmark. The scaling of the different algorithms are evaluated in terms of estimation error as a function of the number of samples, computational time, and length of the quantum circuits required by the quantum solutions. The conclusion highlights that an alternative approach is preferable with respect to employng the phase estimation routine. Indeed, the maximum likelihood estimation guarantees the best trade-off between the length of the quantum circuits and the precision in the integral estimation.
Numerical integration with Monte Carlo methods is a central computational task in many scientific and industrial applications, including financial derivative pricing and risk management. Classical Monte Carlo algorithms are computationally demanding: achieving an accuracy εεε typically requires a number of function evaluations scaling as O(1/ε2)O(1/ε^2)O(1/ε2). Quantum-accelerated Monte Carlo methods based on quantum amplitude estimation can in principle quadratically improve this dependence. However, \textit{quasi}-Monte Carlo methods have not been explored in the quantum context. In this work, we introduce a quantum quasi-Monte Carlo algorithm that combines low-discrepancy nets with quantum amplitude estimation. The proposed method prepares the quasi-random point set coherently in superposition. The method does not yield an asymptotic improvement over classical quasi-Monte Carlo, since the total error separates into a discretization error, determined by the finite net, and a quantum estimation error. Instead, we explore a pre-asymptotic advantage window: for a target accuracy that would classically require 2q2^q2q low discrepancy points, one can prepare a higher-resolution net of size 2Q2^Q2Q, with Q>qQ>qQ>q, in superposition and reach the same accuracy using significantly fewer function queries. This window can be controlled by tuning the circuit resolution and amplitude-estimation parameters, making the approach relevant for practical regimes where the number of queries is finite rather than asymptotically large.
Quantum computing is a very active and diverse area, with immense research and development occurring in quantum hardware design and algorithm creation for applications in various scientific fields. The key motivation behind such efforts is the potential for significant speed-up relative to simulations on classical computers. Quantum Monte Carlo Integration (QMCI) is a quantum algorithm that promises a quadratic advantage in terms of the required number of samples for a required accuracy over classical Monte Carlo Integration (MCI), which is a key statistical resource for integrating multi-dimensional space. In this study, we explore the reality of this potential, specifically for applications in Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). We perform an eigenvalue stability analysis for a 1D convection-diffusion equation, in which the coefficients depend on a random number. The quantum algorithm utilized uses quantum amplitude estimation (QAE) to accelerate the integral estimation process. Numerical values obtained from QMCI results are compared against numerical integration techniques, and acceptably low errors are observed. The performance of QMCI is compared against MCI by equating the number of oracle calls in QMCI with the number of samples required in MCI. No significant difference in this metric is observed, with QMCI requiring more oracle calls. This suggests that the expected quantum supremacy is not attainable for the considered numerical integration problem and its quantum-circuit implementation. Extension to available Noisy-Intermediate-Scale-Quantum (NISQ) hardware is expected to reveal more about the algorithm implementation and the simulator emulation. Potential future directions that can be explored in algorithmic development based on this preliminary research are outlined.
It is known that quantum computers can speed up Monte Carlo simulation compared to classical counterparts. There are already some proposals of application of the quantum algorithm to practical problems, including quantitative finance. In many problems in finance to which Monte Carlo simulation is applied, many random numbers are required to obtain one sample value of the integrand, since those problems are extremely high-dimensional integrations, for example, risk measurement of credit portfolio. This leads to the situation that the required qubit number is too large in the naive implementation where a quantum register is allocated per random number. In this paper, we point out that we can reduce qubits keeping quantum speed up if we perform calculation similar to the classical one, that is, estimate the average of integrand values sampled by a pseudo-random-number generator (PRNG) implemented on a quantum circuit. We present not only the overview of the idea but also concrete implementation of PRNG and application to credit risk measurement. Actually, reduction of qubits is a trade-off against increase of circuit depth. Therefore, full reduction might be impractical, but such a trade-off between speed and memory space will be important in adjustment of calculation setting considering machine specs, if large-scale Monte Carlo simulation by quantum computer is in operation in the future.