Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.13306 · Physical Review Research

Geometry along evolution of mixed quantum states

Erik Sjöqvist

Published Mar 19, 2020• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The author examines the metric associated with the distance between spectral decompositions of infinitesimally close quantum states. Geodesics connecting arbitrary single qubit states explicitly show that the underlying geometry is highly curved. The metric can be applied to time-energy uncertainty, interferometry, and thermal magnetic systems. The Bures metric is obtained by extending the approach to the full decomposition freedom.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.2.013344

Related papers

Comparing metrics for mixed quantum states: Sjöqvist and Bures

Paul M. Alsing, Carlo Cafaro, Orlando Luongo +3 more

It is known that there are infinitely many distinguishability metrics for mixed quantum states. This freedom, in turn, leads to metric-dependent interpretations of physically meaningful geometric quantities such as complexity and volume of quantum states. In this paper, we first present an explicit and unabridged mathematical discussion on the relation between the Sj\"oqvist metric and the Bures metric for arbitrary nondegenerate mixed quantum states, using the notion of decompositions of density operators by means of ensembles of pure quantum states. Then, to enhance our comprehension of the difference between these two metrics from a physics standpoint, we compare the formal expressions of these two metrics for arbitrary thermal quantum states specifying quantum systems in equilibrium with a reservoir at nonzero temperature. For illustrative purposes, we show the difference between these two metrics in the case of a simple physical system characterized by a spin-qubit in an arbitrarily oriented uniform and stationary external magnetic field in thermal equilibrium with a finite-temperature bath. Finally, we compare the Bures and Sj\"oqvist metrics in terms of their monotonicity property.

arXiv:2303.01690•Physical Review A•May 17, 2023•16 citations

Complexity of pure and mixed qubit geodesic paths on curved manifolds

Carlo Cafaro, Paul M. Alsing

It is known that mixed quantum states are highly entropic states of imperfect knowledge (i.e., incomplete information) about a quantum system, while pure quantum states are states of perfect knowledge (i.e., complete information) with vanishing von Neumann entropy. In this paper, we propose an information geometric theoretical construct to describe and, to a certain extent, understand the complex behavior of evolutions of quantum systems in pure and mixed states. The comparative analysis is probabilistic in nature, it uses a complexity measure that relies on a temporal averaging procedure along with a long-time limit, and is limited to analyzing expected geodesic evolutions on the underlying manifolds. More specifically, we study the complexity of geodesic paths on the manifolds of single-qubit pure and mixed quantum states equipped with the Fubini-Study metric and the Sj\"oqvist metric, respectively. We analytically show that the evolution of mixed quantum states in the Bloch ball is more complex than the evolution of pure states on the Bloch sphere. We also verify that the ranking based on our proposed measure of complexity, a quantity that represents the asymptotic temporal behavior of an averaged volume of the region explored on the manifold during the evolution of the systems, agrees with the geodesic length-based ranking. Finally, focusing on geodesic lengths and curvature properties in manifolds of mixed quantum states, we observed a softening of the complexity on the Bures manifold compared to the Sj\"oqvist manifold.

arXiv:2209.10661•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Nov 8, 2022•15 citations

Geometric Aspects of Mixed Quantum States Inside the Bloch Sphere

Paul M. Alsing, Carlo Cafaro, Domenico Felice +1 more

When studying the geometry of quantum states, it is acknowledged that mixed states can be distinguished by infinitely many metrics. Unfortunately, this freedom causes metric-dependent interpretations of physically significant geometric quantities such as the complexity and volume of quantum states. In this paper, we present an insightful discussion on the differences between the Bures and the Sjöqvist metrics inside a Bloch sphere. First, we begin with a formal comparative analysis between the two metrics by critically discussing three alternative interpretations for each metric. Second, we explicitly illustrate the distinct behaviors of the geodesic paths on each one of the two metric manifolds. Third, we compare the finite distances between an initial state and the final mixed state when calculated with the two metrics. Interestingly, in analogy with what happens when studying the topological aspects of real Euclidean spaces equipped with distinct metric functions (for instance, the usual Euclidean metric and the taxicab metric), we observe that the relative ranking based on the concept of a finite distance between mixed quantum states is not preserved when comparing distances determined with the Bures and the Sjöqvist metrics. Finally, we conclude with a brief discussion on the consequences of this violation of a metric-based relative ranking on the concept of the complexity and volume of mixed quantum states.

arXiv:2312.02004•Quantum Reports•Feb 6, 2024•9 citations

Bures geodesics for non-faithful states and quantum speed limit

Sergio Carrasco, Dominique Spehner

The quantum speed limit establishes a bound on the minimal time required for a quantum system to evolve from a given initial state to a final state. When the mean energy variance is fixed this limitation is captured by the Mandelstam--Tamm bound. The fastest quantum evolution saturating this bound follows a geodesic arc connecting the two states. Such geodesics in the manifold of quantum states are explicitly known when the states are pure (Fubini-Study geodesics) and when they are mixed and given by faithful density matrices (Bures geodesics). In this article we obtain the explicit form of the Bures geodesic arcs joining two non-faithful density matrices, which may have different ranks. For pure states one recovers the Fubini-Study geodesics. A necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of the shortest geodesic arc is given. When the condition is not fulfilled there are infinitely many such arcs, all having length equal to the arccos Bures distance between the two states, in analogy with the arcs of great circles connecting the two poles of a sphere. We discuss the implications of our results for the quantum speed limit.

quant-pharXiv:2606.06759•Jun 8, 2026•0 citations

Geodesics for mixed quantum states via their geometric mean operator

Paul M. Alsing, Carlo Cafaro, Shannon M. Ray

We examine the geodesic between two mixed states of arbitrary dimension by means of their geometric mean operator. We utilize the fiber bundle approach by which the distance between two mixed state density operators $ρ_1$ and $ρ_2$ in the base space $M$ is given by the shortest distance in the (Hilbert Schmidt) bundle space $E$ of their purifications. The latter is well-known to be given by the Bures distance along the horizontal lift in $E$ of the geodesic between the $ρ_1$ and $ρ_2$ in $M$. The horizontal lift is that unique curve in $E$ that orthogonally traverses the fibers $F\subset E$ above the curve in $M$, and projects down onto it. We briefly review this formalism and show how it can be used to construct the intermediate mixed quantum states $ρ(s)$ along the base space geodesic parameterized by affine parameter $s$ between the initial $ρ_1$ and final $ρ_2$ states. We emphasize the role played by geometric mean operator $M(s) = ρ_1^{-1/2}\, \sqrt{ρ_1^{1/2}ρ(s)ρ_1^{1/2}}\,ρ_1^{-1/2}$, where the Uhlmann root fidelity between $ρ_1$ and $ρ(s)$ is given by $\sqrt{F}(ρ_1,ρ(s)) = Tr[M(s)\,ρ_1] = Tr[\sqrt{ρ_1^{1/2}ρ(s)ρ_1^{1/2}}]$, and $ρ(s) = M(s)\,ρ_1\,M(s)$. We give examples for the geodesic between the maximally mixed state and a pure state in arbitrary dimensions, as well as for the geodesic between Werner states $ρ(p) = (1-p) I/N + p\,|Ψ\rangle\langle Ψ|$ with $|Ψ\rangle = \{|GHZ\rangle, |W\rangle\}$ in dimension $N=2^3$. For the latter, we compare expressions in the limit $p\to1$ to the infinite number of possible geodesics between the orthogonal pure states $|GHZ\rangle$ and $|W\rangle$. Lastly, we compute the analytic form for the density matrices along the geodesic that connects two arbitrary endpoint qubit density matrices within the Bloch ball for dimension $N=2$.

arXiv:2404.04136•Apr 5, 2024•2 citations

Bures geodesics and quantum metrology

Dominique Spehner

We study the geodesics on the manifold of mixed quantum states for the Bures metric. It is shown that these geodesics correspond to physical non-Markovian evolutions of the system coupled to an ancilla. Furthermore, we argue that geodesics lead to optimal precision in single-parameter estimation in quantum metrology. More precisely, if the unknown parameter x is a phase shift proportional to the time parametrizing the geodesic, the estimation error obtained by processing the data of measurements on the system is equal to the smallest error that can be achieved from joint detections on the system and ancilla, meaning that there is no information loss on this parameter in the ancilla. This error can saturate the Heisenberg bound. Reciprocally, assuming that the system-ancilla output and input states are related by a unitary e−ixH with H a x -independent Hamiltonian, we show that if the error obtained from measurements on the system is equal to the minimal error obtained from joint measurements on the system and ancilla then the system evolution is given by a geodesic. In such a case, the measurement on the system bringing most information on x is x -independent and can be determined in terms of the intersections of the geodesic with the boundary of quantum states. These results show that geodesic evolutions are of interest for high-precision detections in systems coupled to an ancilla in the absence of measurements on the ancilla.

arXiv:2308.08706•Quantum•Apr 18, 2025•4 citations
The author examines the metric associated with the distance between spectral decompositions of infinitesimally close quantum states. Geodesics connecting arbitrary single qubit states explicitly show that the underlying geometry is highly curved. The metric can be applied to time-energy uncertainty, interferometry, and thermal magnetic systems. The Bures metric is obtained by extending the approach to the full decomposition freedom.
It is known that there are infinitely many distinguishability metrics for mixed quantum states. This freedom, in turn, leads to metric-dependent interpretations of physically meaningful geometric quantities such as complexity and volume of quantum states. In this paper, we first present an explicit and unabridged mathematical discussion on the relation between the Sj\"oqvist metric and the Bures metric for arbitrary nondegenerate mixed quantum states, using the notion of decompositions of density operators by means of ensembles of pure quantum states. Then, to enhance our comprehension of the difference between these two metrics from a physics standpoint, we compare the formal expressions of these two metrics for arbitrary thermal quantum states specifying quantum systems in equilibrium with a reservoir at nonzero temperature. For illustrative purposes, we show the difference between these two metrics in the case of a simple physical system characterized by a spin-qubit in an arbitrarily oriented uniform and stationary external magnetic field in thermal equilibrium with a finite-temperature bath. Finally, we compare the Bures and Sj\"oqvist metrics in terms of their monotonicity property.
It is known that mixed quantum states are highly entropic states of imperfect knowledge (i.e., incomplete information) about a quantum system, while pure quantum states are states of perfect knowledge (i.e., complete information) with vanishing von Neumann entropy. In this paper, we propose an information geometric theoretical construct to describe and, to a certain extent, understand the complex behavior of evolutions of quantum systems in pure and mixed states. The comparative analysis is probabilistic in nature, it uses a complexity measure that relies on a temporal averaging procedure along with a long-time limit, and is limited to analyzing expected geodesic evolutions on the underlying manifolds. More specifically, we study the complexity of geodesic paths on the manifolds of single-qubit pure and mixed quantum states equipped with the Fubini-Study metric and the Sj\"oqvist metric, respectively. We analytically show that the evolution of mixed quantum states in the Bloch ball is more complex than the evolution of pure states on the Bloch sphere. We also verify that the ranking based on our proposed measure of complexity, a quantity that represents the asymptotic temporal behavior of an averaged volume of the region explored on the manifold during the evolution of the systems, agrees with the geodesic length-based ranking. Finally, focusing on geodesic lengths and curvature properties in manifolds of mixed quantum states, we observed a softening of the complexity on the Bures manifold compared to the Sj\"oqvist manifold.
When studying the geometry of quantum states, it is acknowledged that mixed states can be distinguished by infinitely many metrics. Unfortunately, this freedom causes metric-dependent interpretations of physically significant geometric quantities such as the complexity and volume of quantum states. In this paper, we present an insightful discussion on the differences between the Bures and the Sjöqvist metrics inside a Bloch sphere. First, we begin with a formal comparative analysis between the two metrics by critically discussing three alternative interpretations for each metric. Second, we explicitly illustrate the distinct behaviors of the geodesic paths on each one of the two metric manifolds. Third, we compare the finite distances between an initial state and the final mixed state when calculated with the two metrics. Interestingly, in analogy with what happens when studying the topological aspects of real Euclidean spaces equipped with distinct metric functions (for instance, the usual Euclidean metric and the taxicab metric), we observe that the relative ranking based on the concept of a finite distance between mixed quantum states is not preserved when comparing distances determined with the Bures and the Sjöqvist metrics. Finally, we conclude with a brief discussion on the consequences of this violation of a metric-based relative ranking on the concept of the complexity and volume of mixed quantum states.
The quantum speed limit establishes a bound on the minimal time required for a quantum system to evolve from a given initial state to a final state. When the mean energy variance is fixed this limitation is captured by the Mandelstam--Tamm bound. The fastest quantum evolution saturating this bound follows a geodesic arc connecting the two states. Such geodesics in the manifold of quantum states are explicitly known when the states are pure (Fubini-Study geodesics) and when they are mixed and given by faithful density matrices (Bures geodesics). In this article we obtain the explicit form of the Bures geodesic arcs joining two non-faithful density matrices, which may have different ranks. For pure states one recovers the Fubini-Study geodesics. A necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of the shortest geodesic arc is given. When the condition is not fulfilled there are infinitely many such arcs, all having length equal to the arccos Bures distance between the two states, in analogy with the arcs of great circles connecting the two poles of a sphere. We discuss the implications of our results for the quantum speed limit.
We examine the geodesic between two mixed states of arbitrary dimension by means of their geometric mean operator. We utilize the fiber bundle approach by which the distance between two mixed state density operators ρ1ρ_1ρ1​ and ρ2ρ_2ρ2​ in the base space MMM is given by the shortest distance in the (Hilbert Schmidt) bundle space EEE of their purifications. The latter is well-known to be given by the Bures distance along the horizontal lift in EEE of the geodesic between the ρ1ρ_1ρ1​ and ρ2ρ_2ρ2​ in MMM. The horizontal lift is that unique curve in EEE that orthogonally traverses the fibers F⊂EF\subset EF⊂E above the curve in MMM, and projects down onto it. We briefly review this formalism and show how it can be used to construct the intermediate mixed quantum states ρ(s)ρ(s)ρ(s) along the base space geodesic parameterized by affine parameter sss between the initial ρ1ρ_1ρ1​ and final ρ2ρ_2ρ2​ states. We emphasize the role played by geometric mean operator M(s)=ρ1−1/2 ρ11/2ρ(s)ρ11/2 ρ1−1/2M(s) = ρ_1^{-1/2}\, \sqrt{ρ_1^{1/2}ρ(s)ρ_1^{1/2}}\,ρ_1^{-1/2}M(s)=ρ1−1/2​ρ11/2​ρ(s)ρ11/2​​ρ1−1/2​, where the Uhlmann root fidelity between ρ1ρ_1ρ1​ and ρ(s)ρ(s)ρ(s) is given by F(ρ1,ρ(s))=Tr[M(s) ρ1]=Tr[ρ11/2ρ(s)ρ11/2]\sqrt{F}(ρ_1,ρ(s)) = Tr[M(s)\,ρ_1] = Tr[\sqrt{ρ_1^{1/2}ρ(s)ρ_1^{1/2}}]F​(ρ1​,ρ(s))=Tr[M(s)ρ1​]=Tr[ρ11/2​ρ(s)ρ11/2​​], and ρ(s)=M(s) ρ1 M(s)ρ(s) = M(s)\,ρ_1\,M(s)ρ(s)=M(s)ρ1​M(s). We give examples for the geodesic between the maximally mixed state and a pure state in arbitrary dimensions, as well as for the geodesic between Werner states ρ(p)=(1−p)I/N+p ∣Ψ⟩⟨Ψ∣ρ(p) = (1-p) I/N + p\,|Ψ\rangle\langle Ψ|ρ(p)=(1−p)I/N+p∣Ψ⟩⟨Ψ∣ with ∣Ψ⟩={∣GHZ⟩,∣W⟩}|Ψ\rangle = \{|GHZ\rangle, |W\rangle\}∣Ψ⟩={∣GHZ⟩,∣W⟩} in dimension N=23N=2^3N=23. For the latter, we compare expressions in the limit p→1p\to1p→1 to the infinite number of possible geodesics between the orthogonal pure states ∣GHZ⟩|GHZ\rangle∣GHZ⟩ and ∣W⟩|W\rangle∣W⟩. Lastly, we compute the analytic form for the density matrices along the geodesic that connects two arbitrary endpoint qubit density matrices within the Bloch ball for dimension N=2N=2N=2.
We study the geodesics on the manifold of mixed quantum states for the Bures metric. It is shown that these geodesics correspond to physical non-Markovian evolutions of the system coupled to an ancilla. Furthermore, we argue that geodesics lead to optimal precision in single-parameter estimation in quantum metrology. More precisely, if the unknown parameter x is a phase shift proportional to the time parametrizing the geodesic, the estimation error obtained by processing the data of measurements on the system is equal to the smallest error that can be achieved from joint detections on the system and ancilla, meaning that there is no information loss on this parameter in the ancilla. This error can saturate the Heisenberg bound. Reciprocally, assuming that the system-ancilla output and input states are related by a unitary e−ixH with H a x -independent Hamiltonian, we show that if the error obtained from measurements on the system is equal to the minimal error obtained from joint measurements on the system and ancilla then the system evolution is given by a geodesic. In such a case, the measurement on the system bringing most information on x is x -independent and can be determined in terms of the intersections of the geodesic with the boundary of quantum states. These results show that geodesic evolutions are of interest for high-precision detections in systems coupled to an ancilla in the absence of measurements on the ancilla.