Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.11540 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Comment on ‘fluctuation-dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition’

Claude Godrèche

Published Dec 24, 2020• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Renewal processes generated by a power-law distribution of intervals with tail index less than unity are genuinely non-stationary. This issue is illustrated by a critical review of the recent paper by Barma, Majumdar and Mukamel (2019 J. Phys. A 52 254001), devoted to the investigation of the properties of a specific one-dimensional equilibrium spin system with long-range interactions. We explain why discarding the non-stationarity of the process underlying the model leads to an incorrect expression of the critical spin–spin correlation function, even when the system, subjected to periodic boundary conditions, is translation invariant.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/abd34a

Related papers

Non stationarity of renewal processes with power-law tails

Claude Godrèche

Renewal processes generated by a power-law distribution of intervals with tail index less than unity are genuinely non stationary, even when the system, subjected to periodic boundary conditions, is translation invariant. This issue is illustrated by a critical review of the recent paper by Barma, Majumdar and Mukamel 2019 J. Phys. A 52 254001, devoted to the investigation of the properties of a specific one-dimensional equilibrium spin system with long-range interactions. We explain why discarding the non-stationarity of the process underlying the model leads to an incorrect expression of the critical spin-spin correlation function.

•Sep 25, 2019•1 citation

Fluctuation-dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition

Mustansir Barma, Satya N. Majumdar, David Mukamel

Abstract Mixed order transitions are those which show a discontinuity of the order parameter as well as a divergent correlation length at the transition (critical) point. We show that the behavior of the order parameter correlation function along the transition line of mixed order transitions can change from normal critical behavior with power law decay, to fluctuation-dominated phase ordering as a parameter is varied. The defining features of fluctuation-dominated order are anomalous fluctuations which remain large in the thermodynamic limit, and correlation functions which approach a finite value through a cusp singularity as the separation scaled by the system size approaches zero. We demonstrate that fluctuation-dominated order sets in along a portion of the transition line of an Ising model with truncated long-range interactions which was earlier shown to exhibit mixed order transitions. We also argue that this connection may hold more generally.

arXiv:1902.06416•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 9, 2019•29 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Fluctuation-dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition’”

Mustansir Barma, Satya N. Majumdar, David Mukamel

Abstract Godrèche, in Comment on ‘Fluctuation dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition’ [2021 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 54 038001], has commented on our recent paper Fluctuation dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition (2019 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 52 254001). This comment concerns the prefactor of the cusp-like small-argument singularity of the scaled spin-spin correlation function at criticality. We remark that the approach used in our paper is adequate for computing the cusp exponent, which is what is really needed to establish fluctuation-dominated phase ordering. Computing the precise value of the prefactor of the cusp singularity is irrelevant for this purpose, or for the physics behind the relation between the mixed order phase transition and the fluctuation-dominated phase ordering—the understanding of which was the main purpose of our paper.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 24, 2020•0 citations

Comment on “Many-body localization in Ising models with random long-range interactions”

Andrii Maksymov, Noah Rahman, Eliot Kapit +1 more

This Comment is dedicated to the investigation of many-body localization in a quantum Ising model with long-range power-law interactions ${r}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, relevant for a variety of systems ranging from electrons in Anderson insulators to spin excitations in chains of cold atoms. It has earlier been argued [arXiv:cond-mat/0611387 (2005); Phys. Rev. B 91, 094202 (2015)] that this model obeys the dimensional constraint suggesting the delocalization of all finite-temperature states in the thermodynamic limit for $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\le}2d$ in a $d$-dimensional system. This expectation conflicts with the recent numerical studies of the specific interacting spin model of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)]. To resolve this controversy we reexamine the model of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)] and demonstrate that the infinite-temperature states there obey the dimensional constraint. The earlier developed scaling theory for the critical system size required for delocalization is extended to small exponents $0\ensuremath{\le}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\le}d$. The disagreements between the two works are explained by the nonstandard selection of investigated states in the ordered phase in the work of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)].

arXiv:1704.05127•Physical Review A•Nov 27, 2017•10 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Fluctuation-dissipation relations in the nonequilibrium critical dynamics of Ising models’ ”

Peter Mayer, Ludovic Berthier, Juan P. Garrahan +1 more

We have recently shown that in nonequilibrium spin systems at criticality the limit ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ of the fluctuation-dissipation ratio $X(t,{t}_{w})$ for $t⪢{t}_{w}⪢1$ can be measured using observables such as magnetization or energy [Phys. Rev. E 68, 016116 (2003)]. Pleimling argues in a Comment [preceding paper, Phys. Rev. 70, 018101 (2004)] on our paper that for such observables correlation and response functions are dominated by one-time quantities dependent only on $t$, and are therefore not suitable for a determination of ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$. Using standard scaling forms of correlation and response functions, as used by Pleimling, we show that our data do have a genuine two-time dependence and allow $X(t,{t}_{w})$ and ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ to be measured, so that Pleimling's criticisms are easily refuted. We also compare with predictions from renormalization-group calculations, which are consistent with our numerical observation of a fluctuation-dissipation plot for the magnetization that is very close to a straight line. A key point remains that coherent observables make measurements of ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ easier than the traditionally used incoherent ones, producing fluctuation-dissipation plots whose slope is close to ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ over a much larger range.

arXiv:cond-mat/0310545•Physical Review E•Jul 2, 2004•21 citations

Exact solution of a boundary time-crystal phase transition: Time-translation symmetry breaking and non-Markovian dynamics of correlations

Federico Carollo, Igor Lesanovsky

The breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry manifests, in Markovian open quantum systems, through the emergence of nonstationary dynamical phases. Systems that display nonequilibrium transitions into these phases are referred to as time crystals, and they can be realized, for example, in many-body systems governed by collective dissipation and long-ranged interactions. Here, we provide a complete analytical characterization of a boundary time-crystal phase transition. This involves exact expressions for the order parameter and for the dynamics of quantum fluctuations, which, in the time-crystalline phase, remains asymptotically non-Markovian as a consequence of the time-translation symmetry breaking. We demonstrate that boundary time crystals are intrinsically critical phases, where fluctuations exhibit a power-law divergence with time. Our results show that a dissipative time-crystal phase is far more than merely a classical nonlinear and nonstationary (limit cycle) dynamics of a macroscopic order parameter. It is rather a genuine many-body phase where the properties of correlations distinctly differ from those of stationary ones.

arXiv:2110.00030•Physical Review A•Apr 22, 2022•67 citations
Abstract Renewal processes generated by a power-law distribution of intervals with tail index less than unity are genuinely non-stationary. This issue is illustrated by a critical review of the recent paper by Barma, Majumdar and Mukamel (2019 J. Phys. A 52 254001), devoted to the investigation of the properties of a specific one-dimensional equilibrium spin system with long-range interactions. We explain why discarding the non-stationarity of the process underlying the model leads to an incorrect expression of the critical spin–spin correlation function, even when the system, subjected to periodic boundary conditions, is translation invariant.
Renewal processes generated by a power-law distribution of intervals with tail index less than unity are genuinely non stationary, even when the system, subjected to periodic boundary conditions, is translation invariant. This issue is illustrated by a critical review of the recent paper by Barma, Majumdar and Mukamel 2019 J. Phys. A 52 254001, devoted to the investigation of the properties of a specific one-dimensional equilibrium spin system with long-range interactions. We explain why discarding the non-stationarity of the process underlying the model leads to an incorrect expression of the critical spin-spin correlation function.
Abstract Mixed order transitions are those which show a discontinuity of the order parameter as well as a divergent correlation length at the transition (critical) point. We show that the behavior of the order parameter correlation function along the transition line of mixed order transitions can change from normal critical behavior with power law decay, to fluctuation-dominated phase ordering as a parameter is varied. The defining features of fluctuation-dominated order are anomalous fluctuations which remain large in the thermodynamic limit, and correlation functions which approach a finite value through a cusp singularity as the separation scaled by the system size approaches zero. We demonstrate that fluctuation-dominated order sets in along a portion of the transition line of an Ising model with truncated long-range interactions which was earlier shown to exhibit mixed order transitions. We also argue that this connection may hold more generally.
Abstract Godrèche, in Comment on ‘Fluctuation dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition’ [2021 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 54 038001], has commented on our recent paper Fluctuation dominated phase ordering at a mixed order transition (2019 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 52 254001). This comment concerns the prefactor of the cusp-like small-argument singularity of the scaled spin-spin correlation function at criticality. We remark that the approach used in our paper is adequate for computing the cusp exponent, which is what is really needed to establish fluctuation-dominated phase ordering. Computing the precise value of the prefactor of the cusp singularity is irrelevant for this purpose, or for the physics behind the relation between the mixed order phase transition and the fluctuation-dominated phase ordering—the understanding of which was the main purpose of our paper.
This Comment is dedicated to the investigation of many-body localization in a quantum Ising model with long-range power-law interactions ${r}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, relevant for a variety of systems ranging from electrons in Anderson insulators to spin excitations in chains of cold atoms. It has earlier been argued [arXiv:cond-mat/0611387 (2005); Phys. Rev. B 91, 094202 (2015)] that this model obeys the dimensional constraint suggesting the delocalization of all finite-temperature states in the thermodynamic limit for $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\le}2d$ in a ddd-dimensional system. This expectation conflicts with the recent numerical studies of the specific interacting spin model of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)]. To resolve this controversy we reexamine the model of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)] and demonstrate that the infinite-temperature states there obey the dimensional constraint. The earlier developed scaling theory for the critical system size required for delocalization is extended to small exponents $0\ensuremath{\le}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\le}d$. The disagreements between the two works are explained by the nonstandard selection of investigated states in the ordered phase in the work of Li et al. [Phys. Rev. A 94, 063625 (2016)].
We have recently shown that in nonequilibrium spin systems at criticality the limit ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ of the fluctuation-dissipation ratio X(t,tw)X(t,{t}_{w})X(t,tw​) for t⪢tw⪢1t⪢{t}_{w}⪢1t⪢tw​⪢1 can be measured using observables such as magnetization or energy [Phys. Rev. E 68, 016116 (2003)]. Pleimling argues in a Comment [preceding paper, Phys. Rev. 70, 018101 (2004)] on our paper that for such observables correlation and response functions are dominated by one-time quantities dependent only on ttt, and are therefore not suitable for a determination of ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$. Using standard scaling forms of correlation and response functions, as used by Pleimling, we show that our data do have a genuine two-time dependence and allow X(t,tw)X(t,{t}_{w})X(t,tw​) and ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ to be measured, so that Pleimling's criticisms are easily refuted. We also compare with predictions from renormalization-group calculations, which are consistent with our numerical observation of a fluctuation-dissipation plot for the magnetization that is very close to a straight line. A key point remains that coherent observables make measurements of ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ easier than the traditionally used incoherent ones, producing fluctuation-dissipation plots whose slope is close to ${X}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}$ over a much larger range.
The breaking of the continuous time-translation symmetry manifests, in Markovian open quantum systems, through the emergence of nonstationary dynamical phases. Systems that display nonequilibrium transitions into these phases are referred to as time crystals, and they can be realized, for example, in many-body systems governed by collective dissipation and long-ranged interactions. Here, we provide a complete analytical characterization of a boundary time-crystal phase transition. This involves exact expressions for the order parameter and for the dynamics of quantum fluctuations, which, in the time-crystalline phase, remains asymptotically non-Markovian as a consequence of the time-translation symmetry breaking. We demonstrate that boundary time crystals are intrinsically critical phases, where fluctuations exhibit a power-law divergence with time. Our results show that a dissipative time-crystal phase is far more than merely a classical nonlinear and nonstationary (limit cycle) dynamics of a macroscopic order parameter. It is rather a genuine many-body phase where the properties of correlations distinctly differ from those of stationary ones.