Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.10103 · ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)

The impossibility of efficient Quantum weak coin flipping

Carl A. Miller

Published Jun 7, 2020• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

How can two parties with competing interests carry out a fair coin flip across a quantum communication channel? This problem (quantum weak coin-flipping) was formalized more than 15 years ago, and, despite some phenomenal theoretical progress, practical quantum coin-flipping protocols with vanishing bias have proved hard to find. In the current work we show that there is a reason that practical weak quantum coin-flipping is difficult: any quantum weak coin-flipping protocol with bias є must use at least exp( Ω (1/√є )) rounds of communication. This is a large improvement over the previous best known lower bound of Ω ( log log(1/є )) due to Ambainis from 2004. Our proof is based on a theoretical construction (the two-variable profile function) which may find further applications.

DOI
10.1145/3357713.3384276

Related papers

Cheat-Penalised Quantum Weak Coin-Flipping

Atul Singh Arora, Carl A. Miller, Mauro E. S. Morales +1 more

Coin-flipping is a fundamental task in two-party cryptography where two remote mistrustful parties wish to generate a shared uniformly random bit. While quantum protocols promising near-perfect security exist for weak coin-flipping -- when the parties want opposing outcomes -- it has been shown that they must be inefficient in terms of their round complexity, and it is an open question of how space efficient they can be. In this work, we consider a variant called cheat-penalised weak coin-flipping in which if a party gets caught cheating, they lose $Λ$ points (compared to $0$ in the standard definition). We find that already for a small cheating penalty, the landscape of coin-flipping changes dramatically. For example, with $Λ=0.01$, we exhibit a protocol where neither Alice nor Bob can bias the result in their favour beyond $1/2 + 10^{-8}$, which uses $24$ qubits and $10^{16}$ rounds of communication (provably $10^{7}$ times better than any weak coin-flipping protocol with matching security). For the same space requirements, we demonstrate how one can choose between lowering how much a malicious party can bias the result (down to $1/2 + 10^{-10}$) and reducing the rounds of communication (down to $25,180$), depending on what is preferred. To find these protocols, we make two technical contributions. First, we extend the point game-protocol correspondence introduced by Kitaev and Mochon, to incorporate: (i) approximate point games, (ii) the cheat-penalised setting, and (iii) round and space complexity. Second, we give the first (to the best of our knowledge) numerical algorithm for constructing (approximate) point games that correspond to high security and low complexity. Our results open up the possibility of having secure and practical quantum protocols for multiparty computation.

arXiv:2510.03218•Oct 3, 2025•0 citations

Physical Limitations of Quantum Cryptographic Primitives or Optimal Bounds for Quantum Coin Flipping and Bit Commitment

André Chailloux, Iordanis Kerenidis

Coin flipping and bit commitment are two fundamental cryptographic primitives with numerous applications. Quantum information allows for such protocols in the information theoretic setting where no dishonest party can perfectly cheat. The previously best-known quantum coin flipping and bit commitment protocol by Ambainis achieved a cheating probability of at most 3/4 [A. Ambainis, Proceedings of the $30$th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing, Washington, DC, IEEE Computer Society, 2001]. On the other hand, Kitaev showed that no quantum coin flipping or bit commitment protocol can have cheating probability less than $1/\sqrt{2}$ [A. Kitaev, Presentation at the $6$th Workshop on Quantum Information Processing (QIP), 2003]. Closing these gaps has been one of the important open questions in quantum cryptography. In this paper, we resolve both questions. First, we present a quantum strong coin flipping protocol with cheating probability arbitrarily close to $1/\sqrt{2}$. More precisely, we show how to use any weak coin flipping protocol with cheating probability $1/2+\varepsilon$ in order to achieve a strong coin flipping protocol with cheating probability $1/\sqrt{2}+O(\varepsilon)$. The optimal quantum strong coin flipping protocol follows from our construction and the optimal quantum weak coin flipping protocol described by [C. Mochon, arXiv:0711.4114, 2007]. Second, we provide the optimal bound for quantum bit commitment. On the one hand, we show a lower bound of approximately $\gamma \approx 0.739$, improving Kitaev's lower bound. On the other hand, we present an optimal quantum bit commitment protocol which has cheating probability arbitrarily close to $\gamma$. More precisely, we show how to use any weak coin flipping protocol with cheating probability $1/2 + \varepsilon$ in order to achieve a quantum bit commitment protocol with cheating probability $\gamma + O(\varepsilon)$. To obtain the final protocol, we then use the optimal quantum weak coin flipping protocol described by [C. Mochon, arXiv:0711.4114, 2007]. Unlike the previous protocol for coin flipping, our protocol uses quantum effects beyond the weak coin flip. To stress this fact, we additionally show that any classical bit commitment protocol with access to perfect weak (or strong) coin flipping has cheating probability at least 3/4.

SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2017•2 citations

Quantum weak coin flipping

Atul Singh Arora, Jérémie Roland, Stephan Weis

We investigate weak coin flipping, a fundamental cryptographic primitive where two distrustful parties need to remotely establish a shared random bit. A cheating player can try to bias the output bit towards a preferred value. For weak coin flipping the players have known opposite preferred values. A weak coin-flipping protocol has a bias є if neither player can force the outcome towards their preferred value with probability more than 1/2+є. While it is known that all classical protocols have є=1/2, Mochon showed in 2007 that quantumly weak coin flipping can be achieved with arbitrarily small bias (near perfect) but the former best known explicit protocol has bias 1/6 (also due to Mochon, 2005). We propose a framework to construct new explicit protocols achieving biases below 1/6. In particular, we construct explicit unitaries for protocols with bias down to 1/10. To go lower, we introduce what we call the Elliptic Monotone Align (EMA) algorithm which, together with the framework, allows us to construct protocols with arbitrarily small biases.

arXiv:1811.02984•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 20, 2019•13 citations

Quantum Weak Coin Flipping

Atul Singh Arora, Jérémie Roland, Stephan Weis

We investigate weak coin flipping, a fundamental cryptographic primitive where two distrustful parties need to remotely establish a shared random bit. A cheating player can try to bias the output bit towards a preferred value. For weak coin flipping the players have known opposite preferred values. A weak coin-flipping protocol has a bias $\epsilon$ if neither player can force the outcome towards their preferred value with probability more than $\frac{1}{2}+\epsilon$. While it is known that all classical protocols have $\epsilon=\frac{1}{2}$, Mochon showed in 2007 [arXiv:0711.4114] that quantumly weak coin flipping can be achieved with arbitrarily small bias (near perfect) but the best known explicit protocol has bias $1/6$ (also due to Mochon, 2005 [Phys. Rev. A 72, 022341]). We propose a framework to construct new explicit protocols achieving biases below $1/6$. In particular, we construct explicit unitaries for protocols with bias approaching $1/10$. To go below, we introduce what we call the Elliptic Monotone Align (EMA) algorithm which, together with the framework, allows us to numerically construct protocols with arbitrarily small biases.

•Jan 1, 2018•10 citations

Quantum weak coin flipping with a single photon

Mathieu Bozzio, Ulysse Chabaud, Iordanis Kerenidis +1 more

Weak coin flipping is among the fundamental cryptographic primitives which ensure the security of modern communication networks. It allows two mistrustful parties to remotely agree on a random bit when they favor opposite outcomes. Unlike other two-party computations, one can achieve information-theoretic security using quantum mechanics only: both parties are prevented from biasing the flip with probability higher than $1/2+\ensuremath{\epsilon}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ is arbitrarily low. Classically, the dishonest party can always cheat with probability 1 unless computational assumptions are used. Despite its importance, no physical implementation has been proposed for quantum weak coin flipping. Here, we present a practical protocol that requires a single photon and linear optics only. We show that it is fair and balanced even when threshold single-photon detectors are used, and reaches a bias as low as $\ensuremath{\epsilon}=1/\sqrt{2}\ensuremath{-}1/2\ensuremath{\approx}0.207$. We further show that the protocol may display a quantum advantage over a few-hundred meters with state-of-the-art technology.

arXiv:2002.09005•Physical Review A•Aug 19, 2020•21 citations

Fair Coin Flipping: Tighter Analysis and the Many-Party Case

Niv Buchbinder, Iftach Haitner, Nissan Levi +1 more

Abstract In a multi-party fair coin-flipping protocol, the parties output a common (close to) unbiased bit, even when some adversarial parties try to bias the output. In this work, we focus on the case of an arbitrary number of corrupted parties. Cleve [20] [STOC 1986] has shown that in any such m -round coin-flipping protocol, the corrupted parties can bias the honest parties’ common output bit by $$\Theta (1/m)$$ Θ ( 1 / m ) . For more than two decades, however, the best-known coin-flipping protocol was the one of Awerbuch, Blum, Chor, Goldwasser, and Micali [10] [Manuscript 1985], who presented a t -party, m -round protocol with bias $$\Theta (t/\sqrt{m})$$ Θ ( t / m ) . This was changed by the breakthrough result of Moran, Naor, and Segev [51] [Journal of Cryptology 2016], who constructed an m -round, two -party coin-flipping protocol with optimal bias $$\Theta (1/m)$$ Θ ( 1 / m ) . More recently, Haitner and Tsfadia [37] [SIAM Journal on Computing 2017] constructed an m -round, three -party coin-flipping protocol with bias $$O(\log ^3m / m)$$ O ( log 3 m / m ) . Still for the case of more than three parties, the best-known protocol remained the $$\Theta (t/\sqrt{m})$$ Θ ( t / m ) -bias protocol of [10]. We make a step toward eliminating the above gap, presenting a t -party, m -round coin-flipping protocol, with bias $$O\left( \frac{t^4 \cdot 2^t \cdot \sqrt{\log m}}{m^{1/2+1/(2^{t-1}-2)}}\right) $$ O t 4 · 2 t · log m m 1 / 2 + 1 / ( 2 t - 1 - 2 ) for any $$t\le \tfrac{1}{2} \cdot \operatorname {loglog}m$$ t ≤ 1 2 · loglog m . This improves upon the

Journal of Cryptology•Nov 6, 2025•0 citations
How can two parties with competing interests carry out a fair coin flip across a quantum communication channel? This problem (quantum weak coin-flipping) was formalized more than 15 years ago, and, despite some phenomenal theoretical progress, practical quantum coin-flipping protocols with vanishing bias have proved hard to find. In the current work we show that there is a reason that practical weak quantum coin-flipping is difficult: any quantum weak coin-flipping protocol with bias є must use at least exp( Ω (1/√є )) rounds of communication. This is a large improvement over the previous best known lower bound of Ω ( log log(1/є )) due to Ambainis from 2004. Our proof is based on a theoretical construction (the two-variable profile function) which may find further applications.
Coin-flipping is a fundamental task in two-party cryptography where two remote mistrustful parties wish to generate a shared uniformly random bit. While quantum protocols promising near-perfect security exist for weak coin-flipping -- when the parties want opposing outcomes -- it has been shown that they must be inefficient in terms of their round complexity, and it is an open question of how space efficient they can be. In this work, we consider a variant called cheat-penalised weak coin-flipping in which if a party gets caught cheating, they lose ΛΛΛ points (compared to 000 in the standard definition). We find that already for a small cheating penalty, the landscape of coin-flipping changes dramatically. For example, with Λ=0.01Λ=0.01Λ=0.01, we exhibit a protocol where neither Alice nor Bob can bias the result in their favour beyond 1/2+10−81/2 + 10^{-8}1/2+10−8, which uses 242424 qubits and 101610^{16}1016 rounds of communication (provably 10710^{7}107 times better than any weak coin-flipping protocol with matching security). For the same space requirements, we demonstrate how one can choose between lowering how much a malicious party can bias the result (down to 1/2+10−101/2 + 10^{-10}1/2+10−10) and reducing the rounds of communication (down to 25,18025,18025,180), depending on what is preferred. To find these protocols, we make two technical contributions. First, we extend the point game-protocol correspondence introduced by Kitaev and Mochon, to incorporate: (i) approximate point games, (ii) the cheat-penalised setting, and (iii) round and space complexity. Second, we give the first (to the best of our knowledge) numerical algorithm for constructing (approximate) point games that correspond to high security and low complexity. Our results open up the possibility of having secure and practical quantum protocols for multiparty computation.
Coin flipping and bit commitment are two fundamental cryptographic primitives with numerous applications. Quantum information allows for such protocols in the information theoretic setting where no dishonest party can perfectly cheat. The previously best-known quantum coin flipping and bit commitment protocol by Ambainis achieved a cheating probability of at most 3/4 [A. Ambainis, Proceedings of the 303030th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing, Washington, DC, IEEE Computer Society, 2001]. On the other hand, Kitaev showed that no quantum coin flipping or bit commitment protocol can have cheating probability less than 1/21/\sqrt{2}1/2​ [A. Kitaev, Presentation at the 666th Workshop on Quantum Information Processing (QIP), 2003]. Closing these gaps has been one of the important open questions in quantum cryptography. In this paper, we resolve both questions. First, we present a quantum strong coin flipping protocol with cheating probability arbitrarily close to 1/21/\sqrt{2}1/2​. More precisely, we show how to use any weak coin flipping protocol with cheating probability 1/2+ε1/2+\varepsilon1/2+ε in order to achieve a strong coin flipping protocol with cheating probability 1/2+O(ε)1/\sqrt{2}+O(\varepsilon)1/2​+O(ε). The optimal quantum strong coin flipping protocol follows from our construction and the optimal quantum weak coin flipping protocol described by [C. Mochon, arXiv:0711.4114, 2007]. Second, we provide the optimal bound for quantum bit commitment. On the one hand, we show a lower bound of approximately γ≈0.739\gamma \approx 0.739γ≈0.739, improving Kitaev's lower bound. On the other hand, we present an optimal quantum bit commitment protocol which has cheating probability arbitrarily close to γ\gammaγ. More precisely, we show how to use any weak coin flipping protocol with cheating probability 1/2+ε1/2 + \varepsilon1/2+ε in order to achieve a quantum bit commitment protocol with cheating probability γ+O(ε)\gamma + O(\varepsilon)γ+O(ε). To obtain the final protocol, we then use the optimal quantum weak coin flipping protocol described by [C. Mochon, arXiv:0711.4114, 2007]. Unlike the previous protocol for coin flipping, our protocol uses quantum effects beyond the weak coin flip. To stress this fact, we additionally show that any classical bit commitment protocol with access to perfect weak (or strong) coin flipping has cheating probability at least 3/4.
We investigate weak coin flipping, a fundamental cryptographic primitive where two distrustful parties need to remotely establish a shared random bit. A cheating player can try to bias the output bit towards a preferred value. For weak coin flipping the players have known opposite preferred values. A weak coin-flipping protocol has a bias є if neither player can force the outcome towards their preferred value with probability more than 1/2+є. While it is known that all classical protocols have є=1/2, Mochon showed in 2007 that quantumly weak coin flipping can be achieved with arbitrarily small bias (near perfect) but the former best known explicit protocol has bias 1/6 (also due to Mochon, 2005). We propose a framework to construct new explicit protocols achieving biases below 1/6. In particular, we construct explicit unitaries for protocols with bias down to 1/10. To go lower, we introduce what we call the Elliptic Monotone Align (EMA) algorithm which, together with the framework, allows us to construct protocols with arbitrarily small biases.
We investigate weak coin flipping, a fundamental cryptographic primitive where two distrustful parties need to remotely establish a shared random bit. A cheating player can try to bias the output bit towards a preferred value. For weak coin flipping the players have known opposite preferred values. A weak coin-flipping protocol has a bias ϵ\epsilonϵ if neither player can force the outcome towards their preferred value with probability more than 12+ϵ\frac{1}{2}+\epsilon21​+ϵ. While it is known that all classical protocols have ϵ=12\epsilon=\frac{1}{2}ϵ=21​, Mochon showed in 2007 [arXiv:0711.4114] that quantumly weak coin flipping can be achieved with arbitrarily small bias (near perfect) but the best known explicit protocol has bias 1/61/61/6 (also due to Mochon, 2005 [Phys. Rev. A 72, 022341]). We propose a framework to construct new explicit protocols achieving biases below 1/61/61/6. In particular, we construct explicit unitaries for protocols with bias approaching 1/101/101/10. To go below, we introduce what we call the Elliptic Monotone Align (EMA) algorithm which, together with the framework, allows us to numerically construct protocols with arbitrarily small biases.
Weak coin flipping is among the fundamental cryptographic primitives which ensure the security of modern communication networks. It allows two mistrustful parties to remotely agree on a random bit when they favor opposite outcomes. Unlike other two-party computations, one can achieve information-theoretic security using quantum mechanics only: both parties are prevented from biasing the flip with probability higher than $1/2+\ensuremath{\epsilon}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ is arbitrarily low. Classically, the dishonest party can always cheat with probability 1 unless computational assumptions are used. Despite its importance, no physical implementation has been proposed for quantum weak coin flipping. Here, we present a practical protocol that requires a single photon and linear optics only. We show that it is fair and balanced even when threshold single-photon detectors are used, and reaches a bias as low as $\ensuremath{\epsilon}=1/\sqrt{2}\ensuremath{-}1/2\ensuremath{\approx}0.207$. We further show that the protocol may display a quantum advantage over a few-hundred meters with state-of-the-art technology.
Abstract In a multi-party fair coin-flipping protocol, the parties output a common (close to) unbiased bit, even when some adversarial parties try to bias the output. In this work, we focus on the case of an arbitrary number of corrupted parties. Cleve [20] [STOC 1986] has shown that in any such m -round coin-flipping protocol, the corrupted parties can bias the honest parties’ common output bit by Θ(1/m)\Theta (1/m)Θ(1/m) Θ ( 1 / m ) . For more than two decades, however, the best-known coin-flipping protocol was the one of Awerbuch, Blum, Chor, Goldwasser, and Micali [10] [Manuscript 1985], who presented a t -party, m -round protocol with bias Θ(t/m)\Theta (t/\sqrt{m})Θ(t/m​) Θ ( t / m ) . This was changed by the breakthrough result of Moran, Naor, and Segev [51] [Journal of Cryptology 2016], who constructed an m -round, two -party coin-flipping protocol with optimal bias Θ(1/m)\Theta (1/m)Θ(1/m) Θ ( 1 / m ) . More recently, Haitner and Tsfadia [37] [SIAM Journal on Computing 2017] constructed an m -round, three -party coin-flipping protocol with bias O(log⁡3m/m)O(\log ^3m / m)O(log3m/m) O ( log 3 m / m ) . Still for the case of more than three parties, the best-known protocol remained the Θ(t/m)\Theta (t/\sqrt{m})Θ(t/m​) Θ ( t / m ) -bias protocol of [10]. We make a step toward eliminating the above gap, presenting a t -party, m -round coin-flipping protocol, with bias O(t4⋅2t⋅log⁡mm1/2+1/(2t−1−2))O\left( \frac{t^4 \cdot 2^t \cdot \sqrt{\log m}}{m^{1/2+1/(2^{t-1}-2)}}\right) O(m1/2+1/(2t−1−2)t4⋅2t⋅logm​​) O t 4 · 2 t · log m m 1 / 2 + 1 / ( 2 t - 1 - 2 ) for any t≤12⋅loglog⁡mt\le \tfrac{1}{2} \cdot \operatorname {loglog}mt≤21​⋅loglogm t ≤ 1 2 · loglog m . This improves upon the