Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.06340 · Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

From quantum foundations to spontaneous quantum gravity – An overview of the new theory

Tejinder P. Singh

Published Sep 9, 2020• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Spontaneous localisation is a falsifiable dynamical mechanism which modifies quantum mechanics and explains the absence of position superpositions in the macroscopic world. However, this is an ad hoc phenomenological proposal. Adler’s theory of trace dynamics, working on a flat Minkowski space-time, derives quantum (field) theory and spontaneous localisation, as a thermodynamic approximation to an underlying noncommutative matrix dynamics. We describe how to incorporate gravity into trace dynamics, by using ideas from Connes’ noncommutative geometry programme. This leads us to a new quantum theory of gravity, from which we can predict spontaneous localisation and give an estimate of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole.

DOI
10.1515/zna-2020-0073

Related papers

THE CONNECTION BETWEEN "EMERGENCE OF TIME FROM QUANTUM GRAVITY" AND "DYNAMICAL COLLAPSE OF THE WAVE FUNCTION IN QUANTUM MECHANICS"

TEJINDER P. SINGH

There are various reasons to believe that quantum theory could be an emergent phenomenon. Trace dynamics is an underlying classical dynamics of noncommuting matrices, from which quantum theory and classical mechanics have been shown to emerge, in the thermodynamic approximation. However, the time that is used to describe evolution in quantum theory is an external classical time, and is in turn expected to be an emergent feature — a relic of an underlying theory of quantum gravity. In this essay we borrow ideas from trace dynamics to show that classical time is a thermodynamic approximation to an operator time in quantum gravitational physics. This prediction will be put to test by ongoing laboratory experiments attempting to construct superposed states of macroscopic objects.

arXiv:1005.2682•International Journal of Modern Physics D•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations

Critical emergence of quantum theory, spacetime and gravity from generalized trace dynamics

Tejinder P. Singh

Generalized trace dynamics (GTD) proposes a deterministic matrix dynamics of atoms of space-time-matter, or aikyons, whose near-equilibrium statistical mechanics yields quantum dynamics, while sufficiently large anti-self-adjoint fluctuations drive spontaneous localisation and the emergence of classical spacetime. The $E_8\times\omega E_8$ programme further proposes that an electroweak-neighbourhood breaking reorganises the split-bioctonionic and $SO(3,3)$ scaffolding into four-dimensional gravitational and weak sectors. This paper turns the often-used analogy with condensed matter into a quantitative, falsifiable effective framework. We distinguish four coupled but logically separate channels: a bosonic bifermionic localisation composite, a geometric soldering or Lorentz--Higgs composite, a gauge-invariant electroweak composite, and a matrix-valued finite-internal or flavour bridge. A source-dependent many-aikyon partition function defines their exact susceptibility matrix and Legendre effective action. A common transition occurs only if the smallest eigenvalue of the zero-frequency inverse susceptibility vanishes with support in all required channels, or if a first-order instability makes them jump together. This criterion also shows why quartic couplings inserted in a Landau potential do not by themselves establish a common continuous transition. We propose operational diagnostics for localisation, commutativity, simplicity, nonzero four-volume and spectral dimension; formulate the nonequilibrium problem in Schwinger--Keldysh language; define a projected fluctuation--dissipation defect; state the martingale condition required for Born probabilities; and identify Newton's constant with the long-wavelength stiffness of the ordered geometric phase. We connect the projected GTD kernel to objective-collapse benchmarks and to the dynamic structure factors measured in condensed matter, while keeping the collapse operator, amplification law and physical-time map as quantities to be derived. We separate the trace-dynamical temperature, cosmological temperature and renormalisation scale, and derive the clock-matching relation needed to compare them. Continuous, first-order and crossover scenarios are treated separately, including Kibble--Zurek scaling and the conditional gravitational-wave scale of an electroweak-neighbourhood first-order event. We also explain why neither standard CSL dynamics nor the Standard Model electroweak crossover by itself supplies the required thermodynamic criticality. A recent finite-Dirac stress test rules out one economical common Hermitian rank-two flavour truncation, motivating a full matrix order parameter. The result is a calculational programme rather than a completed derivation. Its primary next step is unambiguous: construct the regulated many-aikyon measure and compute the connected composite two-point matrix and projected Adler--Millard fluctuation kernel.

•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations

Critical emergence of quantum theory, spacetime and gravity from generalised trace dynamics

Tejinder P. Singh

Generalized trace dynamics (GTD) is a deterministic dynamics of aikyons (atoms of space-time-matter) whose near-equilibrium statistical mechanics yields quantum dynamics, while large anti-self-adjoint fluctuations drive spontaneous localisation and emergent classical spacetime. We separate two independent large limits: long-Connes-time coarse-graining of a finite system, which conditionally yields the quantum Ward identities, and the extensive many-aikyon/large-matrix limit required for a collective singularity. We turn the condensed-matter analogy of the E8 x omega E8 programme into a quantitative, falsifiable effective framework. Four coupled composite channels (bifermionic localisation, geometric soldering/Lorentz-Higgs, gauge-invariant electroweak, and matrix-valued flavour) define an exact susceptibility matrix and Legendre effective action, giving zero-mode and free-energy criteria for a common continuous or first-order transition. We pose the nonequilibrium problem in Schwinger-Keldysh form, define a projected fluctuation-dissipation defect and the martingale condition for Born probabilities, identify Newton's constant with the stiffness of the ordered geometric phase, and give conditions under which the Sakharov, constrained-BF, Jacobson, Padmanabhan and Verlinde descriptions of gravity are limits of one substrate. A regulated two-sector surrogate ensemble (a Myers-deformed geometric triple coupled to a matter matrix, with a Grassmann-regulated fermionic extension) shows that selected diagnostics are calculable: exact Adler-Millard charge conservation, a multi-channel first-order jump, a verified fluctuation-dissipation relation and its quench defect, and a fermionic spectral dimension d_s = 1.96 on the emergent two-sphere. The result is a calculational programme, not a completed derivation; the next step is the many-aikyon composite two-point matrix for GTD itself.

arXiv:2609.10571•Sep 2, 2026•1 citation

The Invariant Set Postulate: a new geometric framework for the foundations of quantum theory and the role played by gravity

T. N. Palmer

A new law of physics is proposed, defined on the cosmological scale but with significant implications for the microscale. Motivated by nonlinear dynamical systems theory and black-hole thermodynamics, the Invariant Set Postulate proposes that cosmological states of physical reality belong to a non-computable fractal state-space geometry I , invariant under the action of some subordinate deterministic causal dynamics D I . An exploratory analysis is made of a possible causal realistic framework for quantum physics based on key properties of I . For example, sparseness is used to relate generic counterfactual states to points p ∉ I of unreality, thus providing a geometric basis for the essential contextuality of quantum physics and the role of the abstract Hilbert Space in quantum theory. Also, self-similarity, described in a symbolic setting, provides a possible realistic perspective on the essential role of complex numbers and quaternions in quantum theory. A new interpretation is given to the standard ‘mysteries’ of quantum theory: superposition, measurement, non-locality, emergence of classicality and so on. It is proposed that heterogeneities in the fractal geometry of I are manifestations of the phenomenon of gravity. Since quantum theory is inherently blind to the existence of such state-space geometries, the analysis here suggests that attempts to formulate unified theories of physics within a conventional quantum-theoretic framework are misguided, and that a successful quantum theory of gravity should unify the causal non-Euclidean geometry of space–time with the atemporal fractal geometry of state space. The task is not to make sense of the quantum axioms by heaping more structure, more definitions, more science fiction imagery on top of them, but to throw them away wholesale and start afresh. We should be relentless in asking ourselves: From what deep physical principles might we derive this exquisite structure? These principles should be crisp, they should be compelling. They should stir the soul. Chris Fuchs ( Gilder 2008 , p. 335)

arXiv:0812.1148•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jul 29, 2009•52 citations

Decoherence of macroscopic closed systems within Newtonian quantum gravity

Bernard S. Kay

A theory recently proposed by the author aims to explain decoherence and the thermodynamical behaviour of closed systems within a conservative, unitary framework for quantum gravity by assuming that the operators tied to the gravitational degrees of freedom are unobservable and equating physical entropy with matter - gravity entanglement entropy. Here we obtain preliminary results on the extent of decoherence this theory predicts. We treat first a static state which, if one were to ignore quantum gravitational effects, would be a quantum superposition of two spatially displaced states of a single classically well describable ball of uniform mass density in empty space. Estimating the quantum gravitational effects on this system within a simple Newtonian approximation, we obtain formulae which predict, for example, that as long as the mass of the ball is considerably larger than the Planck mass, such a would-be-coherent static superposition will actually be decohered whenever the separation of the centres of mass of the two ball-states exceeds a small fraction (which decreases as the mass of the ball increases) of the ball radius. We then obtain a formula for the quantum-gravitational correction to the would-be-pure density matrix of a non-relativistic many-body Schrödinger wavefunction and argue that this formula predicts decoherence between configurations which differ (at least) in the `relocation' of a cluster of particles of Planck mass. We estimate the entropy of some simple model closed systems, finding a tendency for it to increase with `matter-clumping' suggestive of a link with existing phenomenological discussions of cosmological entropy increase.

arXiv:hep-th/9810077•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Dec 1, 1998•57 citations

Probing quantum gravity effects with quantum mechanical oscillators

M. Bonaldi, A. Borrielli, Avishek Chowdhury +13 more

Abstract Phenomenological models aiming to join gravity and quantum mechanics often predict effects that are potentially measurable in refined low-energy experiments. For instance, modified commutation relations between position and momentum, that account for a minimal scale length, yield a dynamics that can be codified in additional Hamiltonian terms. When applied to the paradigmatic case of a mechanical oscillator, such terms, at the lowest order in the deformation parameter, introduce a weak intrinsic nonlinearity and, consequently, deviations from the classical trajectory. This point of view has stimulated several experimental proposals and realizations, leading to meaningful upper limits to the deformation parameter. All such experiments are based on classical mechanical oscillators, i.e., excited from a thermal state. We remark indeed that decoherence, that plays a major role in distinguishing the classical from the quantum behavior of (macroscopic) systems, is not usually included in phenomenological quantum gravity models. However, it would not be surprising if peculiar features that are predicted by considering the joined roles of gravity and quantum physics should manifest themselves just on purely quantum objects. On the basis of this consideration, we propose experiments aiming to observe possible quantum gravity effects on macroscopic mechanical oscillators that are preliminary prepared in a high purity state, and we report on the status of their realization. Graphical abstract

arXiv:2004.14371•The European Physical Journal D•Sep 1, 2020•21 citations
Abstract Spontaneous localisation is a falsifiable dynamical mechanism which modifies quantum mechanics and explains the absence of position superpositions in the macroscopic world. However, this is an ad hoc phenomenological proposal. Adler’s theory of trace dynamics, working on a flat Minkowski space-time, derives quantum (field) theory and spontaneous localisation, as a thermodynamic approximation to an underlying noncommutative matrix dynamics. We describe how to incorporate gravity into trace dynamics, by using ideas from Connes’ noncommutative geometry programme. This leads us to a new quantum theory of gravity, from which we can predict spontaneous localisation and give an estimate of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of a Schwarzschild black hole.
There are various reasons to believe that quantum theory could be an emergent phenomenon. Trace dynamics is an underlying classical dynamics of noncommuting matrices, from which quantum theory and classical mechanics have been shown to emerge, in the thermodynamic approximation. However, the time that is used to describe evolution in quantum theory is an external classical time, and is in turn expected to be an emergent feature — a relic of an underlying theory of quantum gravity. In this essay we borrow ideas from trace dynamics to show that classical time is a thermodynamic approximation to an operator time in quantum gravitational physics. This prediction will be put to test by ongoing laboratory experiments attempting to construct superposed states of macroscopic objects.
Generalized trace dynamics (GTD) proposes a deterministic matrix dynamics of atoms of space-time-matter, or aikyons, whose near-equilibrium statistical mechanics yields quantum dynamics, while sufficiently large anti-self-adjoint fluctuations drive spontaneous localisation and the emergence of classical spacetime. The E8×ωE8E_8\times\omega E_8E8​×ωE8​ programme further proposes that an electroweak-neighbourhood breaking reorganises the split-bioctonionic and SO(3,3)SO(3,3)SO(3,3) scaffolding into four-dimensional gravitational and weak sectors. This paper turns the often-used analogy with condensed matter into a quantitative, falsifiable effective framework. We distinguish four coupled but logically separate channels: a bosonic bifermionic localisation composite, a geometric soldering or Lorentz--Higgs composite, a gauge-invariant electroweak composite, and a matrix-valued finite-internal or flavour bridge. A source-dependent many-aikyon partition function defines their exact susceptibility matrix and Legendre effective action. A common transition occurs only if the smallest eigenvalue of the zero-frequency inverse susceptibility vanishes with support in all required channels, or if a first-order instability makes them jump together. This criterion also shows why quartic couplings inserted in a Landau potential do not by themselves establish a common continuous transition. We propose operational diagnostics for localisation, commutativity, simplicity, nonzero four-volume and spectral dimension; formulate the nonequilibrium problem in Schwinger--Keldysh language; define a projected fluctuation--dissipation defect; state the martingale condition required for Born probabilities; and identify Newton's constant with the long-wavelength stiffness of the ordered geometric phase. We connect the projected GTD kernel to objective-collapse benchmarks and to the dynamic structure factors measured in condensed matter, while keeping the collapse operator, amplification law and physical-time map as quantities to be derived. We separate the trace-dynamical temperature, cosmological temperature and renormalisation scale, and derive the clock-matching relation needed to compare them. Continuous, first-order and crossover scenarios are treated separately, including Kibble--Zurek scaling and the conditional gravitational-wave scale of an electroweak-neighbourhood first-order event. We also explain why neither standard CSL dynamics nor the Standard Model electroweak crossover by itself supplies the required thermodynamic criticality. A recent finite-Dirac stress test rules out one economical common Hermitian rank-two flavour truncation, motivating a full matrix order parameter. The result is a calculational programme rather than a completed derivation. Its primary next step is unambiguous: construct the regulated many-aikyon measure and compute the connected composite two-point matrix and projected Adler--Millard fluctuation kernel.
Generalized trace dynamics (GTD) is a deterministic dynamics of aikyons (atoms of space-time-matter) whose near-equilibrium statistical mechanics yields quantum dynamics, while large anti-self-adjoint fluctuations drive spontaneous localisation and emergent classical spacetime. We separate two independent large limits: long-Connes-time coarse-graining of a finite system, which conditionally yields the quantum Ward identities, and the extensive many-aikyon/large-matrix limit required for a collective singularity. We turn the condensed-matter analogy of the E8 x omega E8 programme into a quantitative, falsifiable effective framework. Four coupled composite channels (bifermionic localisation, geometric soldering/Lorentz-Higgs, gauge-invariant electroweak, and matrix-valued flavour) define an exact susceptibility matrix and Legendre effective action, giving zero-mode and free-energy criteria for a common continuous or first-order transition. We pose the nonequilibrium problem in Schwinger-Keldysh form, define a projected fluctuation-dissipation defect and the martingale condition for Born probabilities, identify Newton's constant with the stiffness of the ordered geometric phase, and give conditions under which the Sakharov, constrained-BF, Jacobson, Padmanabhan and Verlinde descriptions of gravity are limits of one substrate. A regulated two-sector surrogate ensemble (a Myers-deformed geometric triple coupled to a matter matrix, with a Grassmann-regulated fermionic extension) shows that selected diagnostics are calculable: exact Adler-Millard charge conservation, a multi-channel first-order jump, a verified fluctuation-dissipation relation and its quench defect, and a fermionic spectral dimension d_s = 1.96 on the emergent two-sphere. The result is a calculational programme, not a completed derivation; the next step is the many-aikyon composite two-point matrix for GTD itself.
A new law of physics is proposed, defined on the cosmological scale but with significant implications for the microscale. Motivated by nonlinear dynamical systems theory and black-hole thermodynamics, the Invariant Set Postulate proposes that cosmological states of physical reality belong to a non-computable fractal state-space geometry I , invariant under the action of some subordinate deterministic causal dynamics D I . An exploratory analysis is made of a possible causal realistic framework for quantum physics based on key properties of I . For example, sparseness is used to relate generic counterfactual states to points p ∉ I of unreality, thus providing a geometric basis for the essential contextuality of quantum physics and the role of the abstract Hilbert Space in quantum theory. Also, self-similarity, described in a symbolic setting, provides a possible realistic perspective on the essential role of complex numbers and quaternions in quantum theory. A new interpretation is given to the standard ‘mysteries’ of quantum theory: superposition, measurement, non-locality, emergence of classicality and so on. It is proposed that heterogeneities in the fractal geometry of I are manifestations of the phenomenon of gravity. Since quantum theory is inherently blind to the existence of such state-space geometries, the analysis here suggests that attempts to formulate unified theories of physics within a conventional quantum-theoretic framework are misguided, and that a successful quantum theory of gravity should unify the causal non-Euclidean geometry of space–time with the atemporal fractal geometry of state space. The task is not to make sense of the quantum axioms by heaping more structure, more definitions, more science fiction imagery on top of them, but to throw them away wholesale and start afresh. We should be relentless in asking ourselves: From what deep physical principles might we derive this exquisite structure? These principles should be crisp, they should be compelling. They should stir the soul. Chris Fuchs ( Gilder 2008 , p. 335)
A theory recently proposed by the author aims to explain decoherence and the thermodynamical behaviour of closed systems within a conservative, unitary framework for quantum gravity by assuming that the operators tied to the gravitational degrees of freedom are unobservable and equating physical entropy with matter - gravity entanglement entropy. Here we obtain preliminary results on the extent of decoherence this theory predicts. We treat first a static state which, if one were to ignore quantum gravitational effects, would be a quantum superposition of two spatially displaced states of a single classically well describable ball of uniform mass density in empty space. Estimating the quantum gravitational effects on this system within a simple Newtonian approximation, we obtain formulae which predict, for example, that as long as the mass of the ball is considerably larger than the Planck mass, such a would-be-coherent static superposition will actually be decohered whenever the separation of the centres of mass of the two ball-states exceeds a small fraction (which decreases as the mass of the ball increases) of the ball radius. We then obtain a formula for the quantum-gravitational correction to the would-be-pure density matrix of a non-relativistic many-body Schrödinger wavefunction and argue that this formula predicts decoherence between configurations which differ (at least) in the `relocation' of a cluster of particles of Planck mass. We estimate the entropy of some simple model closed systems, finding a tendency for it to increase with `matter-clumping' suggestive of a link with existing phenomenological discussions of cosmological entropy increase.
Abstract Phenomenological models aiming to join gravity and quantum mechanics often predict effects that are potentially measurable in refined low-energy experiments. For instance, modified commutation relations between position and momentum, that account for a minimal scale length, yield a dynamics that can be codified in additional Hamiltonian terms. When applied to the paradigmatic case of a mechanical oscillator, such terms, at the lowest order in the deformation parameter, introduce a weak intrinsic nonlinearity and, consequently, deviations from the classical trajectory. This point of view has stimulated several experimental proposals and realizations, leading to meaningful upper limits to the deformation parameter. All such experiments are based on classical mechanical oscillators, i.e., excited from a thermal state. We remark indeed that decoherence, that plays a major role in distinguishing the classical from the quantum behavior of (macroscopic) systems, is not usually included in phenomenological quantum gravity models. However, it would not be surprising if peculiar features that are predicted by considering the joined roles of gravity and quantum physics should manifest themselves just on purely quantum objects. On the basis of this consideration, we propose experiments aiming to observe possible quantum gravity effects on macroscopic mechanical oscillators that are preliminary prepared in a high purity state, and we report on the status of their realization. Graphical abstract