Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.04027

Non-Associative Algebras and Quantum Physics -- A Historical Perspective

Manfred Liebmann, Horst Rühaak, Bernd Henschenmacher

Published Sep 7, 2019• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We review attempts by Pascual Jordan and other researchers, most notably Lawrence Biedenharn to generalize quantum mechanics by passing from associative matrix or operator algebras to non-associative algebras. We start with Jordan's work from the early 1930ies leading to Jordan algebras and the first attempt to incorporate the alternative ring of octonions into physics. Jordan's work on the octonions from 1932 till 1952 will be covered, discussing aspects of the exceptional Jordan algebra and how to express probabilities when working with the octonions and the exceptional Jordan algebra. From the 1950ies onwards Jordan and others also considered one-sided distributive systems like near-fields, near-rings, quasi-fields and exceptional Segal systems (the last two examples being not necessarily associative). As the set of non-linear operators forms a near-ring and even a near-algebra, this may be of interest for attempts to pass from a linear to a non-linear setting in the study of quantum mechanics. Moreover, ideas introduced in the late 1960ies to use non-power-associative algebras to formulate a theory of a minimal length will be covered. Lawrence Biedenharn's and Jordan's ideas related to non-power-associative octonionic matrix algebras will be briefly mentioned, a long section is devoted to a summary of Horst Rühaak's PhD thesis from 1968 on matrix algebras over the octonions. Finally, recent attempts to use non-associative algebras in physics will be described.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1909.04027

Related papers

An algebraic formulation of nonassociative quantum mechanics

Peter Schupp, Richard J. Szabo

Abstract We develop a version of quantum mechanics that can handle nonassociative algebras of observables and which reduces to standard quantum theory in the traditional associative setting. Our algebraic approach is naturally probabilistic and is based on using the universal enveloping algebra of a general nonassociative algebra to introduce a generalized notion of associative composition product. We formulate properties of states together with notions of trace, and use them to develop Gel’fand–Naimark–Segal constructions. We describe Heisenberg and Schrödinger pictures of completely positive dynamics, and we illustrate our formalism on the explicit examples of finite-dimensional matrix Jordan algebras as well as the octonion algebra.

arXiv:2311.03647•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 9, 2024•5 citations

A Review of The Algebraic Approaches to Quantum Mechanics. Appraisals on Their Theoretical Relevance

Antonino Drago

I review the various algebraic foundations of quantum mechanics. They have been suggested since the birth of this theory till up to last year. They are the following ones: Heisenberg-Born-Jordan (1925), Weyl (1928), Dirac (1930), von Neumann (1936), Segal (1947), T.F. Jordan (1986), Morchio and Strocchi (2009) and Buchholz and Fregenhagen (2019). Three cases are stressed: 1) the misinterpretation of Dirac foundation; 2) von Neumann conversion from the analytic approach of Hilbert space to the algebraic approach of the rings of operators; 3) the recent foundation of quantum mechanics upon the algebra of perturbation Lagrangians. Moreover, historical considerations on the go-and-stop path performed by the algebraic approach in the history of QM are offered. The level of formalism has increased from the mere introduction of matrices till up to group theory and C*-algebras. But there was no progress in approaching closer the foundations of physics; therefore the problem of discovering an algebraic formulation of QM organized as a problem-based theory and making use of no more than constructive mathematics is open.

arXiv:2102.00861•Jan 29, 2021•1 citation

The Jordan formulation of Quantum Mechanics: a review

Paul K. Townsend

This is a transcription of a conference proceedings from 1985. It reviews the Jordan algebra formulation of quantum mechanics. A possible novelty is the discussion of time evolution; the associator takes over the role of $i$ times the commutator in the standard density matrix formulation, and for the Jordan algebra of complex Hermitian matrices this implies a Hamiltonian of the form $H= i[x,y] + λ\mathbb{I}$ for traceless Hermitian $x,y$ and real number $λ$. Other possibilities for time evolution in the Jordan formulation are briefly considered.

arXiv:1612.09228•Dec 29, 2016•16 citations

On an Algebraic Generalization of the Quantum Mechanical Formalism

P. Jordan, J. v. Neumann, Eugene Paul Wigner

One of us has shown that the statistical properties of the measurements of a quantum mechanical system assume their simplest form when expressed in terms of a certain hypercomplex algebra which is commutative but not associative.1 This algebra differs from the non-commutative but associative matrix algebra usually considered in that one is concerned with the commutative expression ½(A × B + B × A) instead of the associative product A × B of two matrices. It was conjectured that the laws of this commutative algebra would form a suitable starting point for a generalization of the present quantum mechanical theory. The need of such a generalization arises from the (probably) fundamental difficulties resulting when one attempts to apply quantum mechanics to questions in relativistic and nuclear phenomena.

Annals of Mathematics•Jan 1, 1934•892 citations

Octonionic Projective Plane: Non-Associative Foundation for Quantum Mechanics — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Non-associative quantum mechanics based on octonions and the exceptional Jordan algebra h₃(O) replaces linear Hilbert spaces with the octonionic projective plane, requiring a fundamentally non-associative algebraic foundation for quantum theory. MATH: - Octonions (O): 8-dimensional normed division algebra, non-associative, alternative (x(xy) = (xx)y, (yx)x = y(xx)). - Exceptional Jordan algebra h₃(O): 27-dimensional algebra of 3×3 Hermitian matrices over O, with product A∘B = ½(AB+BA). - Octonionic projective plane OP²: points correspond to rank-1 idempotents in h₃(O); dimension 16, automorphism group F₄ (exceptional Lie group). - Key constants: No direct ratios (0.382, 0.618, etc.) appear; instead, the structure is governed by the octonion multiplication table (Fano plane) and the 7-sphere S⁷. CONNECTION: - The Fano plane (projective plane of order 2) underlies octonion multiplication — a finite geometry with 7 points and 7 lines, each line containing 3 points. Th Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations

Nonassociative quantum theory, emergent probability, and coquasigroup symmetry

Jens Köplinger, Джунушалиев Владимир Джумакадырович

This paper follows recent steps towards a nonassociative quantum theory and points out the mathematical structure behind the proposed modifications to conventional quantum theory. An N=1 supersymmetry model and a strong force glueball ansatz is highlighted. Using nonassociative complex octonion algebra, it is shown how the Lorentz Lie algebra can be understood as a four dimensional generalization of the algebra of spin-1/2 operators in physics. Probability is speculated to become an emergent phenomenon from some nonassociative geometry in which to better understand the fluxes involved. A prototype nonassociative quantum theory in one dimension is brought forward to illustrate how normed division algebras may aid in modeling isospin properties that are similar to observed field and particle symmetries in nature. This prototype is built from a principle of self-duality between types of active and passive transformations and supplied with a modified Born rule that models observation, similar to conventional quantum mechanics. Solutions on the complex numbers, quaternions and octonions are discussed. The Hopf coquasigroup structure of the octonionic eigenvalue relation is shown and advertised as a tool for future investigation into the complete solution set of the model.

arXiv:0910.3347•Oct 18, 2009•2 citations
We review attempts by Pascual Jordan and other researchers, most notably Lawrence Biedenharn to generalize quantum mechanics by passing from associative matrix or operator algebras to non-associative algebras. We start with Jordan's work from the early 1930ies leading to Jordan algebras and the first attempt to incorporate the alternative ring of octonions into physics. Jordan's work on the octonions from 1932 till 1952 will be covered, discussing aspects of the exceptional Jordan algebra and how to express probabilities when working with the octonions and the exceptional Jordan algebra. From the 1950ies onwards Jordan and others also considered one-sided distributive systems like near-fields, near-rings, quasi-fields and exceptional Segal systems (the last two examples being not necessarily associative). As the set of non-linear operators forms a near-ring and even a near-algebra, this may be of interest for attempts to pass from a linear to a non-linear setting in the study of quantum mechanics. Moreover, ideas introduced in the late 1960ies to use non-power-associative algebras to formulate a theory of a minimal length will be covered. Lawrence Biedenharn's and Jordan's ideas related to non-power-associative octonionic matrix algebras will be briefly mentioned, a long section is devoted to a summary of Horst Rühaak's PhD thesis from 1968 on matrix algebras over the octonions. Finally, recent attempts to use non-associative algebras in physics will be described.
Abstract We develop a version of quantum mechanics that can handle nonassociative algebras of observables and which reduces to standard quantum theory in the traditional associative setting. Our algebraic approach is naturally probabilistic and is based on using the universal enveloping algebra of a general nonassociative algebra to introduce a generalized notion of associative composition product. We formulate properties of states together with notions of trace, and use them to develop Gel’fand–Naimark–Segal constructions. We describe Heisenberg and Schrödinger pictures of completely positive dynamics, and we illustrate our formalism on the explicit examples of finite-dimensional matrix Jordan algebras as well as the octonion algebra.
I review the various algebraic foundations of quantum mechanics. They have been suggested since the birth of this theory till up to last year. They are the following ones: Heisenberg-Born-Jordan (1925), Weyl (1928), Dirac (1930), von Neumann (1936), Segal (1947), T.F. Jordan (1986), Morchio and Strocchi (2009) and Buchholz and Fregenhagen (2019). Three cases are stressed: 1) the misinterpretation of Dirac foundation; 2) von Neumann conversion from the analytic approach of Hilbert space to the algebraic approach of the rings of operators; 3) the recent foundation of quantum mechanics upon the algebra of perturbation Lagrangians. Moreover, historical considerations on the go-and-stop path performed by the algebraic approach in the history of QM are offered. The level of formalism has increased from the mere introduction of matrices till up to group theory and C*-algebras. But there was no progress in approaching closer the foundations of physics; therefore the problem of discovering an algebraic formulation of QM organized as a problem-based theory and making use of no more than constructive mathematics is open.
This is a transcription of a conference proceedings from 1985. It reviews the Jordan algebra formulation of quantum mechanics. A possible novelty is the discussion of time evolution; the associator takes over the role of iii times the commutator in the standard density matrix formulation, and for the Jordan algebra of complex Hermitian matrices this implies a Hamiltonian of the form H=i[x,y]+λIH= i[x,y] + λ\mathbb{I}H=i[x,y]+λI for traceless Hermitian x,yx,yx,y and real number λλλ. Other possibilities for time evolution in the Jordan formulation are briefly considered.
One of us has shown that the statistical properties of the measurements of a quantum mechanical system assume their simplest form when expressed in terms of a certain hypercomplex algebra which is commutative but not associative.1 This algebra differs from the non-commutative but associative matrix algebra usually considered in that one is concerned with the commutative expression ½(A × B + B × A) instead of the associative product A × B of two matrices. It was conjectured that the laws of this commutative algebra would form a suitable starting point for a generalization of the present quantum mechanical theory. The need of such a generalization arises from the (probably) fundamental difficulties resulting when one attempts to apply quantum mechanics to questions in relativistic and nuclear phenomena.
FINDING: Non-associative quantum mechanics based on octonions and the exceptional Jordan algebra h₃(O) replaces linear Hilbert spaces with the octonionic projective plane, requiring a fundamentally non-associative algebraic foundation for quantum theory. MATH: - Octonions (O): 8-dimensional normed division algebra, non-associative, alternative (x(xy) = (xx)y, (yx)x = y(xx)). - Exceptional Jordan algebra h₃(O): 27-dimensional algebra of 3×3 Hermitian matrices over O, with product A∘B = ½(AB+BA). - Octonionic projective plane OP²: points correspond to rank-1 idempotents in h₃(O); dimension 16, automorphism group F₄ (exceptional Lie group). - Key constants: No direct ratios (0.382, 0.618, etc.) appear; instead, the structure is governed by the octonion multiplication table (Fano plane) and the 7-sphere S⁷. CONNECTION: - The Fano plane (projective plane of order 2) underlies octonion multiplication — a finite geometry with 7 points and 7 lines, each line containing 3 points. Th Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
This paper follows recent steps towards a nonassociative quantum theory and points out the mathematical structure behind the proposed modifications to conventional quantum theory. An N=1 supersymmetry model and a strong force glueball ansatz is highlighted. Using nonassociative complex octonion algebra, it is shown how the Lorentz Lie algebra can be understood as a four dimensional generalization of the algebra of spin-1/2 operators in physics. Probability is speculated to become an emergent phenomenon from some nonassociative geometry in which to better understand the fluxes involved. A prototype nonassociative quantum theory in one dimension is brought forward to illustrate how normed division algebras may aid in modeling isospin properties that are similar to observed field and particle symmetries in nature. This prototype is built from a principle of self-duality between types of active and passive transformations and supplied with a modified Born rule that models observation, similar to conventional quantum mechanics. Solutions on the complex numbers, quaternions and octonions are discussed. The Hopf coquasigroup structure of the octonionic eigenvalue relation is shown and advertised as a tool for future investigation into the complete solution set of the model.