Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.00267 · Foundations of Physics

Quantum Versus Classical Entanglement: Eliminating the Issue of Quantum Nonlocality

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Published Jan 21, 2020• 60 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We analyze the interrelation of quantum and classical entanglement. The latter notion is widely used in classical optic simulation of some quantum-like features of light. We criticize the common interpretation that “quantum nonlocality” is the basic factor differing quantum and classical realizations of entanglement. Instead, we point to the breakthrough Grangier et al. experiment on coincidence detection which was done in 1986 and played the crucial role in rejection of (semi-)classical field models in favor of quantum mechanics. Classical entanglement sources produce light beams with the coefficient of second order coherence $$g^{(2)}(0) \ge 1.$$ g(2)(0)≥1. This feature of classical entanglement is obscured by using intensities of signals in different channels, instead of counting clicks of photo-detectors. The interplay between intensity and clicks counting is not just a technicality. We elevate this issue to the high foundational level.

DOI
10.1007/s10701-020-00319-7

Related papers

Classical Entanglement: Lessons from Optics

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We analyze interrelation of quantum and classical entanglement. The latternotion is widely used in classical optic simulation of the quantum-likefeatures of light. We criticize the common interpretation that quantum nonlocalityis the basic factor differentiating these two sorts of entanglement. Instead,we point to the Grangier experiment on photon existence, the experimenton the coincidence detection. Classical entanglement sources produce lightbeams with the coefficient of second-order coherence g(2)(0) ≥ 1. This featureof classical entanglement is obscured by using intensities of signals indifferent channels, instead of counting clicks of photodetectors. Interplaybetween intensity and clicks counting is not just a technicality. We emphasizethe foundational dimension of this issue and its coupling with theBohr’s statement on individuality of quantum phenomena.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2024•0 citations

"Without in Any Way Disturbing the System": Illuminating the Issue of Quantum Nonlocality

Arkady Plotnitsky

In several recent communications (Khrennikov 2019a, b, c, 2020a, b), A. Khrennikov argued for "eliminating the issue of quantum nonlocality" from the analysis of quantum entanglement and quantum phenomena in general. He proposed to differentiate quantum and classical phenomena and entanglement not by their respective nonlocality and locality, as is common, but by the discreteness of quantum phenomena vs. the continuity of classical phenomena, supplemented by Bohr's complementarity in the case of quantum phenomena. As I argue here, however, the question may not be that of "eliminating the issue of quantum nonlocality" but instead of illuminating this issue, a task that can, I also argue, be pursued by relating quantum nonlocality to other key features of quantum phenomena. I suggest that the following features of quantum phenomena and quantum mechanics, distinguishing them from classical phenomena and classical physics--(1) the irreducible role of measuring instruments in defining quantum phenomena; (2) discreteness; (3) complementarity; (4) entanglement; (5) quantum nonlocality; and (6) the irreducibly probabilistic nature of quantum predictions--are all interconnected in defining quantum phenomena and distinguishing them from classical ones, so that it is difficult to give an unconditional priority to any one of them. To argue this case, I consider quantum phenomena and quantum mechanics from a nonrealist or, in terms adopted here, "reality-without-realism" (RWR) perspective. This perspective extends and gives new dimensions to Bohr's view, grounded in his analysis of the irreducible tole of measuring instruments in the constitution of quantum phenomena, with quantum measurement defined by the entanglements between the quantum object under investigation and the instrument used.

arXiv:1912.03842•Dec 9, 2019•10 citations

Entanglement: quantum or classical?

Dilip Paneru, Eliahu Cohen, Robert Fickler +2 more

From its seemingly non-intuitive and puzzling nature, most evident in numerous EPR-like gedanken experiments to its almost ubiquitous presence in quantum technologies, entanglement is at the heart of modern quantum physics. First introduced by Erwin Schrödinger nearly a century ago, entanglement has remained one of the most fascinating ideas that came out of quantum mechanics. Here, we attempt to explain what makes entanglement fundamentally different from any classical phenomenon. To this end, we start with a historical overview of entanglement and discuss several hidden variables models that were conceived to provide a classical explanation and demystify quantum entanglement. We discuss some inequalities and bounds that are violated by quantum states thereby falsifying the existence of some of the classical hidden variables theories. We also discuss some exciting manifestations of entanglement, such as N00N states and the non-separable single particle states. We conclude by discussing some contemporary results regarding quantum correlations and present a future outlook for the research of quantum entanglement.

arXiv:1911.02201•Reports on Progress in Physics•Apr 1, 2020•86 citations

Classical signal model reproducing quantum probabilities for single and coincidence detections

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Börje Nilsson, Sven Nordebo

We present a simple classical (random) signal model reproducing Born's rule. The crucial point of our approach is that the presence of detector's threshold and calibration procedure have to be treated not as simply experimental technicalities, but as the basic counterparts of the theoretical model. We call this approach threshold signal detection model (TSD). The experiment on coincidence detection which was done by Grangier in 1986 [22] played a crucial role in rejection of (semi-)classical field models in favour of quantum mechanics (QM): impossibility to resolve the wave-particle duality in favour of a purely wave model. QM predicts that the relative probability of coincidence detection, the coefficient g (2) (0), is zero (for one photon states), but in (semi-)classical models g (2) (0) ≥ 1. In TSD the coefficient g (2) (0) decreases as 1/ ε 2 d , where ε d > 0 is the detection threshold. Hence, by increasing this threshold an experimenter can make the coefficient g (2) (0) essentially less than 1. The TSD-prediction can be tested experimentally in new Grangier type experiments presenting a detailed monitoring of dependence of the coefficient g (2) (0) on the detection threshold. Structurally our model has some similarity with the prequantum model of Grossing et al. Subquantum stochasticity is composed of the two counterparts: a stationary process in the space of internal degrees of freedom and the random walk type motion describing the temporal dynamics.

arXiv:1112.5591•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 10, 2012•15 citations

Born's rule from measurements of classical signals by threshold detectors which are properly calibrated

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

The very old problem of the statistical content of quantum mechanics (QM) is studied in a novel framework. The Born's rule (one of the basic postulates of QM) is derived from theory of classical random signals. We present a measurement scheme which transforms continuous signals into discrete clicks and reproduces the Born's rule. This is the scheme of threshold type detection. Calibration of detectors plays a crucial role. Creation of such a detection model provides a possibility to represent the basic quantum phenomena as classical field phenomena completed by measurements with threshold type and properly calibrated detectors. Finally, the wave-particle duality has been resolved in favor of the purely wave description. It is well known that coincidence probability plays an important role in the debate on the possibility to reduce quantum theory (especially quantum optics) to classical field theory. Our model matches well the predictions of quantum theory and experiment. It violates the prediction of the classical field model which does not take into account the presence of threshold type detectors with proper calibration.

arXiv:1105.4269•Journal of Modern Optics•Feb 3, 2012•18 citations

A classical framework for nonlocality and entanglement

Gerhard Grössing, Siegfried Fussy, J Mesa Pascasio +1 more

Based on our model of quantum systems as emerging from the coupled dynamics between oscillating "bouncers" and the space-filling zero-point field, a sub-quantum account of nonlocal correlations is given. This is explicitly done for the example of the "double two-slit" variant of two-particle interferometry. However, it is also shown that the entanglement in two-particle interferometry is only a natural consequence of the fact that already a "single" two-slit experiment can be described on a sub-quantum level with the aid of "entangling currents" of a generally nonlocal nature.

arXiv:1210.4406•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•5 citations
Abstract We analyze the interrelation of quantum and classical entanglement. The latter notion is widely used in classical optic simulation of some quantum-like features of light. We criticize the common interpretation that “quantum nonlocality” is the basic factor differing quantum and classical realizations of entanglement. Instead, we point to the breakthrough Grangier et al. experiment on coincidence detection which was done in 1986 and played the crucial role in rejection of (semi-)classical field models in favor of quantum mechanics. Classical entanglement sources produce light beams with the coefficient of second order coherence g(2)(0)≥1.g^{(2)}(0) \ge 1.g(2)(0)≥1. g(2)(0)≥1. This feature of classical entanglement is obscured by using intensities of signals in different channels, instead of counting clicks of photo-detectors. The interplay between intensity and clicks counting is not just a technicality. We elevate this issue to the high foundational level.
We analyze interrelation of quantum and classical entanglement. The latternotion is widely used in classical optic simulation of the quantum-likefeatures of light. We criticize the common interpretation that quantum nonlocalityis the basic factor differentiating these two sorts of entanglement. Instead,we point to the Grangier experiment on photon existence, the experimenton the coincidence detection. Classical entanglement sources produce lightbeams with the coefficient of second-order coherence g(2)(0) ≥ 1. This featureof classical entanglement is obscured by using intensities of signals indifferent channels, instead of counting clicks of photodetectors. Interplaybetween intensity and clicks counting is not just a technicality. We emphasizethe foundational dimension of this issue and its coupling with theBohr’s statement on individuality of quantum phenomena.
In several recent communications (Khrennikov 2019a, b, c, 2020a, b), A. Khrennikov argued for "eliminating the issue of quantum nonlocality" from the analysis of quantum entanglement and quantum phenomena in general. He proposed to differentiate quantum and classical phenomena and entanglement not by their respective nonlocality and locality, as is common, but by the discreteness of quantum phenomena vs. the continuity of classical phenomena, supplemented by Bohr's complementarity in the case of quantum phenomena. As I argue here, however, the question may not be that of "eliminating the issue of quantum nonlocality" but instead of illuminating this issue, a task that can, I also argue, be pursued by relating quantum nonlocality to other key features of quantum phenomena. I suggest that the following features of quantum phenomena and quantum mechanics, distinguishing them from classical phenomena and classical physics--(1) the irreducible role of measuring instruments in defining quantum phenomena; (2) discreteness; (3) complementarity; (4) entanglement; (5) quantum nonlocality; and (6) the irreducibly probabilistic nature of quantum predictions--are all interconnected in defining quantum phenomena and distinguishing them from classical ones, so that it is difficult to give an unconditional priority to any one of them. To argue this case, I consider quantum phenomena and quantum mechanics from a nonrealist or, in terms adopted here, "reality-without-realism" (RWR) perspective. This perspective extends and gives new dimensions to Bohr's view, grounded in his analysis of the irreducible tole of measuring instruments in the constitution of quantum phenomena, with quantum measurement defined by the entanglements between the quantum object under investigation and the instrument used.
From its seemingly non-intuitive and puzzling nature, most evident in numerous EPR-like gedanken experiments to its almost ubiquitous presence in quantum technologies, entanglement is at the heart of modern quantum physics. First introduced by Erwin Schrödinger nearly a century ago, entanglement has remained one of the most fascinating ideas that came out of quantum mechanics. Here, we attempt to explain what makes entanglement fundamentally different from any classical phenomenon. To this end, we start with a historical overview of entanglement and discuss several hidden variables models that were conceived to provide a classical explanation and demystify quantum entanglement. We discuss some inequalities and bounds that are violated by quantum states thereby falsifying the existence of some of the classical hidden variables theories. We also discuss some exciting manifestations of entanglement, such as N00N states and the non-separable single particle states. We conclude by discussing some contemporary results regarding quantum correlations and present a future outlook for the research of quantum entanglement.
We present a simple classical (random) signal model reproducing Born's rule. The crucial point of our approach is that the presence of detector's threshold and calibration procedure have to be treated not as simply experimental technicalities, but as the basic counterparts of the theoretical model. We call this approach threshold signal detection model (TSD). The experiment on coincidence detection which was done by Grangier in 1986 [22] played a crucial role in rejection of (semi-)classical field models in favour of quantum mechanics (QM): impossibility to resolve the wave-particle duality in favour of a purely wave model. QM predicts that the relative probability of coincidence detection, the coefficient g (2) (0), is zero (for one photon states), but in (semi-)classical models g (2) (0) ≥ 1. In TSD the coefficient g (2) (0) decreases as 1/ ε 2 d , where ε d > 0 is the detection threshold. Hence, by increasing this threshold an experimenter can make the coefficient g (2) (0) essentially less than 1. The TSD-prediction can be tested experimentally in new Grangier type experiments presenting a detailed monitoring of dependence of the coefficient g (2) (0) on the detection threshold. Structurally our model has some similarity with the prequantum model of Grossing et al. Subquantum stochasticity is composed of the two counterparts: a stationary process in the space of internal degrees of freedom and the random walk type motion describing the temporal dynamics.
The very old problem of the statistical content of quantum mechanics (QM) is studied in a novel framework. The Born's rule (one of the basic postulates of QM) is derived from theory of classical random signals. We present a measurement scheme which transforms continuous signals into discrete clicks and reproduces the Born's rule. This is the scheme of threshold type detection. Calibration of detectors plays a crucial role. Creation of such a detection model provides a possibility to represent the basic quantum phenomena as classical field phenomena completed by measurements with threshold type and properly calibrated detectors. Finally, the wave-particle duality has been resolved in favor of the purely wave description. It is well known that coincidence probability plays an important role in the debate on the possibility to reduce quantum theory (especially quantum optics) to classical field theory. Our model matches well the predictions of quantum theory and experiment. It violates the prediction of the classical field model which does not take into account the presence of threshold type detectors with proper calibration.
Based on our model of quantum systems as emerging from the coupled dynamics between oscillating "bouncers" and the space-filling zero-point field, a sub-quantum account of nonlocal correlations is given. This is explicitly done for the example of the "double two-slit" variant of two-particle interferometry. However, it is also shown that the entanglement in two-particle interferometry is only a natural consequence of the fact that already a "single" two-slit experiment can be described on a sub-quantum level with the aid of "entangling currents" of a generally nonlocal nature.