Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.12434 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Quantum state tomography on a plaquette in the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Stephan Humeniuk

Published Sep 11, 2019• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Motivated by recent quantum gas microscope experiments for fermions in optical lattices, we present proof-of-principle calculations showing that it is possible to obtain the complete information about the quantum state on a small subsystem from equilibrium determinantal quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Both diagonal (in the occupation number basis) and off-diagonal elements of the reduced density matrix are calculated for a square plaquette, which is embedded in a much larger system of the two-dimensional Hubbard model, both at half filling and in the doped case. The diagonalization of the reduced density matrix is done by exploiting the point group symmetry and particle number conservation, which allows one to attach symmetry labels to its eigenvalues. Knowledge of the probabilities of plaquette occupation number configurations is useful for meticulous benchmarking of quantum gas microscope experiments. As the quantum state on the plaquette is exact and self-consistently embedded in an exact, correlated bath, the present approach connects to various cluster approximation techniques.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.100.115121

Related papers

Exact-diagonalization study of the Hubbard model with nearest-neighbor repulsion

Y. Ohta, Kenji Tsutsui, Wataru Koshibae +1 more

An exact-diagonalization technique on small clusters is used to study the ground states and single-particle excitations of the Hubbard model with on-site (U) and nearest-neighbor (V) Coulombic repulsive interactions. It is shown that the long-range charge-density-wave state realized in a half-filled two-dimensional square lattice for 4V\ensuremath{\gtrsim}U persists up to quarter filling, and that the doped carriers form a small Fermi surface that encloses an area corresponding to the number of doped carriers rather than the total number of electrons involved in the system. The present result offers a well-defined counterexample in the discussion of the Fermi-surface dimensions of strongly correlated electron systems, and may provide a complementary understanding of the large Fermi surface believed to exist in the ordinary Hubbard model.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 1, 1994•40 citations

Time and spatially resolved quench of the fermionic Hubbard model showing restricted equilibration

Florian Goth, Fakher F. Assaad

We investigate the quench of half-filled one-dimensional and two-dimensional fermionic Hubbard models to models without Coulomb interaction. Since the time propagation is Gaussian, we can use a variety of time-dependent quantum Monte Carlo methods to tackle this problem without generating a dynamical sign problem. Using a continuous time quantum Monte Carlo method, we achieve a system size of 128 sites in one dimension, and using a Blankenbecler-Scalapino-Sugar type algorithm, we were able to simulate $20\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}20$ square lattices. Applying these methods to study the dynamics after the quench, we observe that the final state of the system can be reasonably well described by a thermal single-particle density matrix that takes the initial single-particle conservation laws into account. The characteristic decay toward this limit is found to be oscillatory with an additional power law decay that depends on the dimensionality. This numerically exact result is shown to compare favorably to mean-field approximations as well as to perturbation theory. Furthermore, we observe the information propagation in the one-dimensional case in the charge-charge and spin-spin correlations and find that it is linear with a velocity of roughly $v\ensuremath{\approx}4$ in units of the hopping amplitude.

arXiv:1108.2703•Physical Review B•Feb 27, 2012•28 citations

Exact diagonalization of the one-dimensional hubbard model up to sixteen sites at half-filling

A. S. Olatinwo, N. Salako, A. Amosun

Numerical exact diagonalisation (ED) of the Hubbard model is traditionally constrained by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space. In this study, we implemented a symmetry-based ED framework to investigate the one-dimensional Hubbard model at half-filling for system sizes up to L=16. By exploiting particle number conservation, spin projection, and translation invariance, we significantly reduced the Hamiltonian dimension, enabling the resolution of ground state energies and dispersion relations without additional approximations. Our results confirmed the transition from a metallic to a correlated insulating regime with increasing on-site repulsion U. Furthermore, extending calculations from ten to sixteen sites revealed scaling trends that asymptotically approached the thermodynamic limit predicted by the Bethe Ansatz (𝐿= ∞). These results served as precise, reproducible benchmarks for validating approximate many-body techniques such as the Density Matrix Renormalisation Group (DMRG).

Ife Journal of Science•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Equation of state of the fermionic two-dimensional Hubbard model

J. P. F. LeBlanc, Emanuel Gull

We present results for the equation of state of the two-dimensional Hubbard model on an isotropic square lattice as obtained from a controlled and numerically exact large-cluster dynamical mean field simulation. Our results are obtained for large but finite systems and are extrapolated to infinite system size using a known finite-size scaling relation, and are supplemented by reliable error bars accounting for all sources of errors. We establish the importance of examining the decay of spatial spin correlations to determine whether a sufficiently large cluster has been used and with this in mind we present the energy, entropy, double occupancy, and nearest-neighbor spin correlations extrapolated to the thermodynamic limit. We discuss the implications of these calculations on pseudogap physics of the 2D Hubbard model away from half filling, where we find a strong behavioral shift in energy below a temperature ${T}^{*}$ which becomes more pronounced for larger clusters. Finally, we provide reference calculations and tables for the equation of state for values of doping away from half filling which are of interest to cold-atom experiments.

arXiv:1305.6798•Physical Review B•Oct 7, 2013•55 citations

Studies of Electronic Inhomogeneities in Strongly Correlated Systems Using Quantum Cluster Methods

Kun Fang

In order to understand various local phenomena related to electronic phase separation discovered recently in strongly correlated materials, quantum cluster methods are applied to a theoretical model, i.e., Hubbard model, which has successfully predicted basic properties of strongly correlated systems. Our calculations are performed at two levels: exact calculations based on the isolated small clusters via exact diagonalization and approximate calculations applied to large lattices using the variational cluster approximation (VCA).\nWe first study phase separation instabilities with the formation of a pairing gap in the two-dimensional Hubbard model for 8-site Betts clusters. The exact diagonalization method is applied to extract exact ground and excited states of the Hubbard model. The results show that the electronic states with one hole off half filling are unstable and they energetically prefer creating the spatial phase separation. The effect of next nearest hopping is also discussed in this part.\nWe studied the variation of the pairing when the out-of-plane correlation is present by adding an interacting apical site above the two-dimensional cluster plane. The calculations indicate that the out-of-plane correlation can be detrimental to the in-plane pairing effect. When it is not too strong to destroy electron pairs on the plane, the modulation of the apical site can drive the pairing gap to show a sinusoidal variation which is consistent with recent experimental discoveries.\nVariational cluster approximation is introduced to explore local properties of larger lattices. The local nematic state is studied in the square lattice using this method, which indicates that it is possible that the electronic states can locally break the C4 symmetry (90o$ rotational symmetry) to form a pattern where the electronic properties, such as charge and spin correlations, are different in x and y directions.\nThe spatial phase separation in the square and honeycomb lattices is also investigated by the variational cluster approximation. The study shows that Coulomb interaction and lattice geometry are both crucial for electronic phase separation. We propose that electronic phase separation is the result of an instability of the Fermi surface at the boundary of the first Brillouin zone of antiferromagnetic states.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Screened-interaction expansion for the Hubbard model and determination of the quantum Monte Carlo Fermi surface

Gökhan Esirgen, H.-B. Schüttler, C. Gröber +1 more

We develop a systematic self-consistent perturbative expansion for the self-energy of Hubbard-like models. The interaction lines in the Feynman diagrams are dynamically screened by the charge fluctuations in the system. Although the formal expansion is exact---assuming that the model under the study is perturbative---only if diagrams to all orders are included, it is shown that for large-on-site-Coulomb-repulsion-$U$ systems weak-coupling expansions to a few orders may already converge. In order to test the approximation at intermediate-to-high temperatures, we use the exact charge-fluctuation susceptibility from quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulation studies as input, which determines the exact screened interaction, and compare our results for the self-energy to the QMC results. We also make comparisons with fluctuation-exchange approximation. We show that the screened interaction for the large-$U$ system can be vanishingly small at a certain intermediate electron filling, and it is found that our approximation for the imaginary part of the one-particle self-energy agrees well with the QMC results in the low-energy scales at this particular filling. But the usefulness of the approximation is hindered by the fact that it has the incorrect filling dependence when the filling deviates from this value. We also calculate the exact QMC Fermi surfaces for the two-dimensional (2D) Hubbard model for several fillings. Our results near half filling show extreme violation of the concepts of the band theory; in fact, instead of growing, the Fermi surface vanishes when doped toward the half-filled Mott-Hubbard insulator. Sufficiently away from half filling, noninteractinglike Fermi surfaces are recovered. These results combined with the Luttinger theorem might show that diagrammatic expansions for the nearly-half-filled Hubbard model are unlikely to be possible; however, the nonperturbative part of the solution seems to be less important as the filling gradually moves away from one half. Results for the 2D one-band Hubbard model for several hole dopings are presented. Implications of this study for the high-temperature superconductors are also discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0105514•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 15, 2001•7 citations
Motivated by recent quantum gas microscope experiments for fermions in optical lattices, we present proof-of-principle calculations showing that it is possible to obtain the complete information about the quantum state on a small subsystem from equilibrium determinantal quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Both diagonal (in the occupation number basis) and off-diagonal elements of the reduced density matrix are calculated for a square plaquette, which is embedded in a much larger system of the two-dimensional Hubbard model, both at half filling and in the doped case. The diagonalization of the reduced density matrix is done by exploiting the point group symmetry and particle number conservation, which allows one to attach symmetry labels to its eigenvalues. Knowledge of the probabilities of plaquette occupation number configurations is useful for meticulous benchmarking of quantum gas microscope experiments. As the quantum state on the plaquette is exact and self-consistently embedded in an exact, correlated bath, the present approach connects to various cluster approximation techniques.
An exact-diagonalization technique on small clusters is used to study the ground states and single-particle excitations of the Hubbard model with on-site (U) and nearest-neighbor (V) Coulombic repulsive interactions. It is shown that the long-range charge-density-wave state realized in a half-filled two-dimensional square lattice for 4V\ensuremath{\gtrsim}U persists up to quarter filling, and that the doped carriers form a small Fermi surface that encloses an area corresponding to the number of doped carriers rather than the total number of electrons involved in the system. The present result offers a well-defined counterexample in the discussion of the Fermi-surface dimensions of strongly correlated electron systems, and may provide a complementary understanding of the large Fermi surface believed to exist in the ordinary Hubbard model.
We investigate the quench of half-filled one-dimensional and two-dimensional fermionic Hubbard models to models without Coulomb interaction. Since the time propagation is Gaussian, we can use a variety of time-dependent quantum Monte Carlo methods to tackle this problem without generating a dynamical sign problem. Using a continuous time quantum Monte Carlo method, we achieve a system size of 128 sites in one dimension, and using a Blankenbecler-Scalapino-Sugar type algorithm, we were able to simulate $20\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}20$ square lattices. Applying these methods to study the dynamics after the quench, we observe that the final state of the system can be reasonably well described by a thermal single-particle density matrix that takes the initial single-particle conservation laws into account. The characteristic decay toward this limit is found to be oscillatory with an additional power law decay that depends on the dimensionality. This numerically exact result is shown to compare favorably to mean-field approximations as well as to perturbation theory. Furthermore, we observe the information propagation in the one-dimensional case in the charge-charge and spin-spin correlations and find that it is linear with a velocity of roughly $v\ensuremath{\approx}4$ in units of the hopping amplitude.
Numerical exact diagonalisation (ED) of the Hubbard model is traditionally constrained by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space. In this study, we implemented a symmetry-based ED framework to investigate the one-dimensional Hubbard model at half-filling for system sizes up to L=16. By exploiting particle number conservation, spin projection, and translation invariance, we significantly reduced the Hamiltonian dimension, enabling the resolution of ground state energies and dispersion relations without additional approximations. Our results confirmed the transition from a metallic to a correlated insulating regime with increasing on-site repulsion U. Furthermore, extending calculations from ten to sixteen sites revealed scaling trends that asymptotically approached the thermodynamic limit predicted by the Bethe Ansatz (𝐿= ∞). These results served as precise, reproducible benchmarks for validating approximate many-body techniques such as the Density Matrix Renormalisation Group (DMRG).
We present results for the equation of state of the two-dimensional Hubbard model on an isotropic square lattice as obtained from a controlled and numerically exact large-cluster dynamical mean field simulation. Our results are obtained for large but finite systems and are extrapolated to infinite system size using a known finite-size scaling relation, and are supplemented by reliable error bars accounting for all sources of errors. We establish the importance of examining the decay of spatial spin correlations to determine whether a sufficiently large cluster has been used and with this in mind we present the energy, entropy, double occupancy, and nearest-neighbor spin correlations extrapolated to the thermodynamic limit. We discuss the implications of these calculations on pseudogap physics of the 2D Hubbard model away from half filling, where we find a strong behavioral shift in energy below a temperature T∗{T}^{*}T∗ which becomes more pronounced for larger clusters. Finally, we provide reference calculations and tables for the equation of state for values of doping away from half filling which are of interest to cold-atom experiments.
In order to understand various local phenomena related to electronic phase separation discovered recently in strongly correlated materials, quantum cluster methods are applied to a theoretical model, i.e., Hubbard model, which has successfully predicted basic properties of strongly correlated systems. Our calculations are performed at two levels: exact calculations based on the isolated small clusters via exact diagonalization and approximate calculations applied to large lattices using the variational cluster approximation (VCA).\nWe first study phase separation instabilities with the formation of a pairing gap in the two-dimensional Hubbard model for 8-site Betts clusters. The exact diagonalization method is applied to extract exact ground and excited states of the Hubbard model. The results show that the electronic states with one hole off half filling are unstable and they energetically prefer creating the spatial phase separation. The effect of next nearest hopping is also discussed in this part.\nWe studied the variation of the pairing when the out-of-plane correlation is present by adding an interacting apical site above the two-dimensional cluster plane. The calculations indicate that the out-of-plane correlation can be detrimental to the in-plane pairing effect. When it is not too strong to destroy electron pairs on the plane, the modulation of the apical site can drive the pairing gap to show a sinusoidal variation which is consistent with recent experimental discoveries.\nVariational cluster approximation is introduced to explore local properties of larger lattices. The local nematic state is studied in the square lattice using this method, which indicates that it is possible that the electronic states can locally break the C4 symmetry (90o$ rotational symmetry) to form a pattern where the electronic properties, such as charge and spin correlations, are different in x and y directions.\nThe spatial phase separation in the square and honeycomb lattices is also investigated by the variational cluster approximation. The study shows that Coulomb interaction and lattice geometry are both crucial for electronic phase separation. We propose that electronic phase separation is the result of an instability of the Fermi surface at the boundary of the first Brillouin zone of antiferromagnetic states.
We develop a systematic self-consistent perturbative expansion for the self-energy of Hubbard-like models. The interaction lines in the Feynman diagrams are dynamically screened by the charge fluctuations in the system. Although the formal expansion is exact---assuming that the model under the study is perturbative---only if diagrams to all orders are included, it is shown that for large-on-site-Coulomb-repulsion-UUU systems weak-coupling expansions to a few orders may already converge. In order to test the approximation at intermediate-to-high temperatures, we use the exact charge-fluctuation susceptibility from quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulation studies as input, which determines the exact screened interaction, and compare our results for the self-energy to the QMC results. We also make comparisons with fluctuation-exchange approximation. We show that the screened interaction for the large-UUU system can be vanishingly small at a certain intermediate electron filling, and it is found that our approximation for the imaginary part of the one-particle self-energy agrees well with the QMC results in the low-energy scales at this particular filling. But the usefulness of the approximation is hindered by the fact that it has the incorrect filling dependence when the filling deviates from this value. We also calculate the exact QMC Fermi surfaces for the two-dimensional (2D) Hubbard model for several fillings. Our results near half filling show extreme violation of the concepts of the band theory; in fact, instead of growing, the Fermi surface vanishes when doped toward the half-filled Mott-Hubbard insulator. Sufficiently away from half filling, noninteractinglike Fermi surfaces are recovered. These results combined with the Luttinger theorem might show that diagrammatic expansions for the nearly-half-filled Hubbard model are unlikely to be possible; however, the nonperturbative part of the solution seems to be less important as the filling gradually moves away from one half. Results for the 2D one-band Hubbard model for several hole dopings are presented. Implications of this study for the high-temperature superconductors are also discussed.