Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.10930

GAMA: A Novel Algorithm for Non-Convex Integer Programs

Hedayat Alghassi, Raouf Dridi, SRIDHAR R. TAYUR

Published Jul 25, 2019• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Inspired by the decomposition in the hybrid quantum-classical optimization algorithm we introduced in arXiv:1902.04215, we propose here a new (fully classical) approach to solving certain non-convex integer programs using Graver bases. This method is well suited when (a) the constraint matrix $A$ has a special structure so that its Graver basis can be computed systematically, (b) several feasible solutions can also be constructed easily and (c) the objective function can be viewed as many convex functions quilted together. Classes of problems that satisfy these conditions include Cardinality Boolean Quadratic Problems (CBQP), Quadratic Semi-Assignment Problems (QSAP) and Quadratic Assignment Problems (QAP). Our Graver Augmented Multi-seed Algorithm (GAMA) utilizes augmentation along Graver basis elements (the improvement direction is obtained by comparing objective function values) from these multiple initial feasible solutions. We compare our approach with a best-in-class commercially available solver (Gurobi). Sensitivity analysis indicates that the rate at which GAMA slows down as the problem size increases is much lower than that of Gurobi. We find that for several instances of practical relevance, GAMA not only vastly outperforms in terms of time to find the optimal solution (by two or three orders of magnitude), but also finds optimal solutions within minutes when the commercial solver is not able to do so in 4 or 10 hours (depending on the problem class) in several cases.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1907.10930

Related papers

Graver Bases via Quantum Annealing with Application to Non-Linear Integer Programs

Hedayat Alghassi, Raouf Dridi, SRIDHAR R. TAYUR

We propose a novel hybrid quantum-classical approach to calculate Graver bases, which have the potential to solve a variety of hard linear and non-linear integer programs, as they form a test set (optimality certificate) with very appealing properties. The calculation of Graver bases is exponentially hard (in general) on classical computers, so they not used for solving practical problems on commercial solvers. With a quantum annealer, however, it may be a viable approach to use them. We test two hybrid quantum-classical algorithms (on D-Wave)--one for computing Graver basis and a second for optimizing non-linear integer programs that utilize Graver bases--to understand the strengths and limitations of the practical quantum annealers available today. Our experiments suggest that with a modest increase in coupler precision--along with near-term improvements in the number of qubits and connectivity (density of hardware graph) that are expected--the ability to outperform classical best-in-class algorithms is within reach, with respect to non-linear integer optimization.

arXiv:1902.04215•Feb 12, 2019•18 citations

Quantum annealing research at CMU: algorithms, hardware, applications

SRIDHAR R. TAYUR, Ananth Tenneti

In this mini-review, we introduce and summarize research from the Quantum Technologies Group (QTG) at Carnegie Mellon University related to computational experience with quantum annealing, performed in collaboration with several other institutions including IIT-Madras and NASA (QuAIL). We present a novel hybrid quantum-classical heuristic algorithm (GAMA, Graver Augmented Multi-seed Algorithm) for non-linear, integer optimization, and illustrate it on an application (in cancer genomics). We then present an algebraic geometry-based algorithm for embedding a problem onto a hardware that is not fully connected, along with a companion Integer Programming (IP) approach. Next, we discuss the performance of two photonic devices - the Temporal Multiplexed Ising Machine (TMIM) and the Spatial Photonic Ising Machine (SPIM) - on Max-Cut and Number Partitioning instances. We close with an outline of the current work.

Frontiers in Computer Science•Jan 5, 2024•3 citations

Multi-objective QUBO solver: bi-objective quadratic assignment problem

Mayowa Ayodele, Richard Allmendinger, Manuel López‐Ibáñez +1 more

Quantum and quantum-inspired optimisation algorithms are designed to solve problems represented in binary, quadratic and unconstrained form. Combinatorial optimisation problems are therefore often formulated as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimisation Problems (QUBO) to solve them with these algorithms. Moreover, these QUBO solvers are often implemented using specialised hardware to achieve enormous speedups, e.g. Fujitsu's Digital Annealer (DA) and D-Wave's Quantum Annealer. However, these are single-objective solvers, while many real-world problems feature multiple conflicting objectives. Thus, a common practice when using these QUBO solvers is to scalarise such multi-objective problems into a sequence of single-objective problems. Due to design trade-offs of these solvers, formulating each scalarisation may require more time than finding a local optimum. We present the first attempt to extend the algorithm supporting a commercial QUBO solver as a multi-objective solver that is not based on scalarisation. The proposed multi-objective DA algorithm is validated on the bi-objective Quadratic Assignment Problem. We observe that algorithm performance significantly depends on the archiving strategy adopted, and that combining DA with non-scalarisation methods to optimise multiple objectives outperforms the current scalarised version of the DA in terms of final solution quality.

arXiv:2205.13399•Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference (GECCO)•Jul 8, 2022•17 citations

Enhancing Quadratic Programming Solvers via Quadratic Nonconvex Reformulation

Cheng Zhu Lu, Fei Yu, Kang, Gaojian +4 more

In this paper, we consider solving nonconvex quadratic programming problems using modern solvers such as Gurobi and SCIP. It is well-known that the classical techniques of quadratic convex reformulation can improve the computational efficiency of global solvers for mixed-integer quadratic optimization problems. In contrast, the use of quadratic nonconvex reformulation (QNR) has not been previously explored. This paper introduces a QNR framework--an unconventional yet highly effective approach for improving the performance of state-of-the-art quadratic programming solvers such as Gurobi and SCIP. Our computational experiments on diverse nonconvex quadratic programming problem instances demonstrate that QNR can substantially accelerate both Gurobi and SCIP. Notably, with QNR, Gurobi achieves state-of-the-art performance on several benchmark and randomly generated instances.

arXiv:2508.20897•Aug 28, 2025•2 citations

A quantum constraint generation framework for binary linear programs

András Czégel, Boglárka G.-Tóth

Abstract We propose a new approach to utilize quantum computers for binary linear programming (BLP), which can be extended to general integer linear programs (ILP). Quantum optimization algorithms, hybrid or quantum-only, are currently general purpose, standalone solvers for ILP. However, to consider them practically useful, we expect them to overperform the current state of the art classical solvers. That expectation is unfair to quantum algorithms: in classical ILP solvers, after many decades of evolution, many different algorithms work together as a robust machine to get the best result. This is the approach we would like to follow now with our quantum ‘solver’ solutions. In this study we wrap any suitable quantum optimization algorithm into a quantum informed classical constraint generation framework. First we relax our problem by dropping all constraints and encode it into an Ising Hamiltonian for the quantum optimization subroutine. Then, by sampling from the solution state of the subroutine, we obtain information about constraint violations in the initial problem, from which we decide which coupling terms we need to introduce to the Hamiltonian. The coupling terms correspond to the constraints of the initial binary linear program. Then we optimize over the new Hamiltonian again, until we reach a feasible solution, or other stopping conditions hold. Since one can decide how many constraints they add to the Hamiltonian in a single step, our algorithm is at least as efficient as the (hybrid) quantum optimization algorithm it wraps. We support our claim with results on small scale minimum cost exact cover problem instances.

arXiv:2503.21222•EPJ Quantum Technology•May 19, 2025•1 citation

A Comparative Benchmark of Ising Machines, MIP Solvers, and Evolutionary Algorithms for Permutation Optimisation

Kehinde O. Babaagba

Permutation problems, such as the Travelling Salesman Problem (TSP) and the Quadratic Assignment Problem (QAP), form a well-established class of combinatorial optimisation problems with broad applications in routing, assignment, and scheduling. Metaheuristics, particularly Evolutionary Algorithms (EAs), have been widely demonstrated to yield high-quality solutions for these problems. In parallel, classical commercial solvers based on Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP), including CPLEX and Gurobi, have also been extensively applied. In recent years, there has been growing interest in quantum, quantum-inspired, and quantum-hybrid approaches for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. This paper presents a comparative analysis of six optimisation solvers: Genetic Algorithm (GA), Estimation of Distribution Algorithm (EDA), CPLEX, Gurobi, Digital Annealer (DA), and a quantum-hybrid Nonlinear solver (NL), applied to permutation problems. We evaluate solver performance in terms of runtime, solution quality relative to optimality, and scalability across instances of TSP and QAP. Our results highlight the promising performance of the quantum-hybrid Nonlinear solver across all evaluation metrics.

Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion (GECCO Companion)•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations
Inspired by the decomposition in the hybrid quantum-classical optimization algorithm we introduced in arXiv:1902.04215, we propose here a new (fully classical) approach to solving certain non-convex integer programs using Graver bases. This method is well suited when (a) the constraint matrix AAA has a special structure so that its Graver basis can be computed systematically, (b) several feasible solutions can also be constructed easily and (c) the objective function can be viewed as many convex functions quilted together. Classes of problems that satisfy these conditions include Cardinality Boolean Quadratic Problems (CBQP), Quadratic Semi-Assignment Problems (QSAP) and Quadratic Assignment Problems (QAP). Our Graver Augmented Multi-seed Algorithm (GAMA) utilizes augmentation along Graver basis elements (the improvement direction is obtained by comparing objective function values) from these multiple initial feasible solutions. We compare our approach with a best-in-class commercially available solver (Gurobi). Sensitivity analysis indicates that the rate at which GAMA slows down as the problem size increases is much lower than that of Gurobi. We find that for several instances of practical relevance, GAMA not only vastly outperforms in terms of time to find the optimal solution (by two or three orders of magnitude), but also finds optimal solutions within minutes when the commercial solver is not able to do so in 4 or 10 hours (depending on the problem class) in several cases.
We propose a novel hybrid quantum-classical approach to calculate Graver bases, which have the potential to solve a variety of hard linear and non-linear integer programs, as they form a test set (optimality certificate) with very appealing properties. The calculation of Graver bases is exponentially hard (in general) on classical computers, so they not used for solving practical problems on commercial solvers. With a quantum annealer, however, it may be a viable approach to use them. We test two hybrid quantum-classical algorithms (on D-Wave)--one for computing Graver basis and a second for optimizing non-linear integer programs that utilize Graver bases--to understand the strengths and limitations of the practical quantum annealers available today. Our experiments suggest that with a modest increase in coupler precision--along with near-term improvements in the number of qubits and connectivity (density of hardware graph) that are expected--the ability to outperform classical best-in-class algorithms is within reach, with respect to non-linear integer optimization.
In this mini-review, we introduce and summarize research from the Quantum Technologies Group (QTG) at Carnegie Mellon University related to computational experience with quantum annealing, performed in collaboration with several other institutions including IIT-Madras and NASA (QuAIL). We present a novel hybrid quantum-classical heuristic algorithm (GAMA, Graver Augmented Multi-seed Algorithm) for non-linear, integer optimization, and illustrate it on an application (in cancer genomics). We then present an algebraic geometry-based algorithm for embedding a problem onto a hardware that is not fully connected, along with a companion Integer Programming (IP) approach. Next, we discuss the performance of two photonic devices - the Temporal Multiplexed Ising Machine (TMIM) and the Spatial Photonic Ising Machine (SPIM) - on Max-Cut and Number Partitioning instances. We close with an outline of the current work.
Quantum and quantum-inspired optimisation algorithms are designed to solve problems represented in binary, quadratic and unconstrained form. Combinatorial optimisation problems are therefore often formulated as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimisation Problems (QUBO) to solve them with these algorithms. Moreover, these QUBO solvers are often implemented using specialised hardware to achieve enormous speedups, e.g. Fujitsu's Digital Annealer (DA) and D-Wave's Quantum Annealer. However, these are single-objective solvers, while many real-world problems feature multiple conflicting objectives. Thus, a common practice when using these QUBO solvers is to scalarise such multi-objective problems into a sequence of single-objective problems. Due to design trade-offs of these solvers, formulating each scalarisation may require more time than finding a local optimum. We present the first attempt to extend the algorithm supporting a commercial QUBO solver as a multi-objective solver that is not based on scalarisation. The proposed multi-objective DA algorithm is validated on the bi-objective Quadratic Assignment Problem. We observe that algorithm performance significantly depends on the archiving strategy adopted, and that combining DA with non-scalarisation methods to optimise multiple objectives outperforms the current scalarised version of the DA in terms of final solution quality.
In this paper, we consider solving nonconvex quadratic programming problems using modern solvers such as Gurobi and SCIP. It is well-known that the classical techniques of quadratic convex reformulation can improve the computational efficiency of global solvers for mixed-integer quadratic optimization problems. In contrast, the use of quadratic nonconvex reformulation (QNR) has not been previously explored. This paper introduces a QNR framework--an unconventional yet highly effective approach for improving the performance of state-of-the-art quadratic programming solvers such as Gurobi and SCIP. Our computational experiments on diverse nonconvex quadratic programming problem instances demonstrate that QNR can substantially accelerate both Gurobi and SCIP. Notably, with QNR, Gurobi achieves state-of-the-art performance on several benchmark and randomly generated instances.
Abstract We propose a new approach to utilize quantum computers for binary linear programming (BLP), which can be extended to general integer linear programs (ILP). Quantum optimization algorithms, hybrid or quantum-only, are currently general purpose, standalone solvers for ILP. However, to consider them practically useful, we expect them to overperform the current state of the art classical solvers. That expectation is unfair to quantum algorithms: in classical ILP solvers, after many decades of evolution, many different algorithms work together as a robust machine to get the best result. This is the approach we would like to follow now with our quantum ‘solver’ solutions. In this study we wrap any suitable quantum optimization algorithm into a quantum informed classical constraint generation framework. First we relax our problem by dropping all constraints and encode it into an Ising Hamiltonian for the quantum optimization subroutine. Then, by sampling from the solution state of the subroutine, we obtain information about constraint violations in the initial problem, from which we decide which coupling terms we need to introduce to the Hamiltonian. The coupling terms correspond to the constraints of the initial binary linear program. Then we optimize over the new Hamiltonian again, until we reach a feasible solution, or other stopping conditions hold. Since one can decide how many constraints they add to the Hamiltonian in a single step, our algorithm is at least as efficient as the (hybrid) quantum optimization algorithm it wraps. We support our claim with results on small scale minimum cost exact cover problem instances.
Permutation problems, such as the Travelling Salesman Problem (TSP) and the Quadratic Assignment Problem (QAP), form a well-established class of combinatorial optimisation problems with broad applications in routing, assignment, and scheduling. Metaheuristics, particularly Evolutionary Algorithms (EAs), have been widely demonstrated to yield high-quality solutions for these problems. In parallel, classical commercial solvers based on Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP), including CPLEX and Gurobi, have also been extensively applied. In recent years, there has been growing interest in quantum, quantum-inspired, and quantum-hybrid approaches for solving combinatorial optimisation problems. This paper presents a comparative analysis of six optimisation solvers: Genetic Algorithm (GA), Estimation of Distribution Algorithm (EDA), CPLEX, Gurobi, Digital Annealer (DA), and a quantum-hybrid Nonlinear solver (NL), applied to permutation problems. We evaluate solver performance in terms of runtime, solution quality relative to optimality, and scalability across instances of TSP and QAP. Our results highlight the promising performance of the quantum-hybrid Nonlinear solver across all evaluation metrics.