Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.05428 · Physical Review Letters

π -Corrected Heisenberg Limit

Wojciech Górecki, Rafał Demkowicz-Dobrzański, Howard M. Wiseman, Dominic William Berry

Published Jan 23, 2020• 89 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the precision $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\varphi}$ with which the parameter $\ensuremath{\varphi}$, appearing in the unitary map ${U}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}={e}^{i\ensuremath{\varphi}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}$, acting on some type of probe system, can be estimated when there is a finite amount of prior information about $\ensuremath{\varphi}$. We show that, if ${U}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}$ acts $n$ times in total, then, asymptotically in $n$, there is a tight lower bound $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}\ensuremath{\pi}/[n({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{+}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{-}})]$, where ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{+}$, ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{-}}$ are the extreme eigenvalues of the generator $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$. This is greater by a factor of $\ensuremath{\pi}$ than the conventional Heisenberg limit, derived from the properties of the quantum Fisher information. That is, the conventional bound is never saturable. Our result makes no assumptions on the measurement protocol and is relevant not only in the noiseless case but also if noise can be eliminated using quantum error correction techniques.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.124.030501

Related papers

Heisenberg Limit beyond Quantum Fisher Information

Wojciech Górecki

The Heisenberg limit provides a fundamental bound on the achievable estimation precision with a limited number of $N$ resources used (e.g., atoms, photons, etc.). Using entangled quantum states makes it possible to scale the precision with $N$ better than when resources would be used independently. Consequently, the optimal use of all resources involves accumulating them in a single execution of the experiment. Unfortunately, that implies that the most common theoretical tool used to analyze metrological protocols - quantum Fisher information (QFI) - does not allow for a reliable description of this problem, as it becomes operationally meaningful only with multiple repetitions of the experiment. In this thesis, using the formalism of Bayesian estimation and the minimax estimator, I derive asymptotically saturable bounds on the precision of the estimation for the case of noiseless unitary evolution. For the case where the number of resources $N$ is strictly constrained, I show that the final measurement uncertainty is $π$ times larger than would be implied by a naive use of QFI. I also analyze the case where a constraint is imposed only on the average amount of resources, the exact value of which may fluctuate (in which case QFI does not provide any universal bound for precision). In both cases, I study the asymptotic saturability and the rate of convergence of these bounds. In the following part, I analyze the problem of the Heisenberg limit when multiple parameters are measured simultaneously on the same physical system. In particular, I investigate the existence of a gain from measuring all parameters simultaneously compared to distributing the same amount of resources to measure them independently. I focus on two examples - the measurement of multiple phase shifts in a multi-arm interferometer and the measurement of three magnetic field components.

arXiv:2304.14370•Apr 27, 2023•7 citations

True precision limits in quantum metrology

Marcin Jarzyna, Rafał Demkowicz-Dobrzański

We show that quantification of the performance of quantum-enhanced measurement schemes based on the concept of quantum Fisher information (QFI) yields results that are asymptotically equivalent to those from the rigorous Bayesian approach, provided generic uncorrelated noise is present in the setup. At the same time, we show that for the problem of decoherence-free phase estimation this equivalence breaks down, and the achievable estimation uncertainty calculated within the Bayesian approach is larger by a factor of π than that predicted from the QFI even in the large prior knowledge (small parameter fluctuation) regime, where the QFI is conventionally regarded as a reliable figure of merit. We conjecture that an analogous discrepancy is present in the arbitrary decoherence-free unitary parameter estimation scheme, and propose a general formula for the asymptotically achievable precision limit. We also discuss protocols utilizing states with an indefinite number of particles, and show that within the Bayesian approach it is legitimate to replace the number of particles with the mean number of particles in the formulas for the asymptotic precision, which as a consequence provides another argument for proposals based on the properties of the QFI of indefinite particle number states leading to sub-Heisenberg precisions not being practically feasible.

arXiv:1407.4805•New Journal of Physics•Jan 9, 2015•144 citations

Precision limits for time-dependent quantum metrology under Markovian noise

Luca Previdi, Francesco Albarelli

We derive ultimate precision bounds for estimating parameters encoded in \emph{time-dependent} Hamiltonians in the presence of general Markovian noise, allowing for arbitrary adaptive protocols with fast controls and noiseless ancillas. Extending the minimization-over-purifications framework to time-varying continuous channels, we obtain a differential upper bound on the achievable quantum Fisher information (QFI) that can be evaluated at all times via semidefinite programming. For parameter-independent noise, we prove a universal long-time scaling law: if the coherent (noiseless) dynamics yields $Q_{\mathrm{coh}}(T)\sim T^{2k}$, then under Markovian noise the QFI scales at most as $Q(T)\sim T^{2k}$ in the DHNLS regime, whereas in the DHLS regime it is fundamentally limited to $Q(T)\sim T^{2k-1}$. We illustrate these behaviors on paradigmatic driven-qubit sensors, exhibiting $T^{4}$ and $T^{3}$ scalings under dephasing and spontaneous emission, respectively. Finally, we provide explicit continuous exact and approximate quantum error correction constructions -- supplemented by spin-squeezed probes -- that asymptotically saturate the bounds, establishing their tightness.

quant-pharXiv:2605.18392•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Achieving the Heisenberg limit in quantum metrology using quantum error correction

Sisi Zhou, Mengzhen Zhang, John Preskill +1 more

Quantum metrology has many important applications in science and technology, ranging from frequency spectroscopy to gravitational wave detection. Quantum mechanics imposes a fundamental limit on measurement precision, called the Heisenberg limit, which can be achieved for noiseless quantum systems, but is not achievable in general for systems subject to noise. Here we study how measurement precision can be enhanced through quantum error correction, a general method for protecting a quantum system from the damaging effects of noise. We find a necessary and sufficient condition for achieving the Heisenberg limit using quantum probes subject to Markovian noise, assuming that noiseless ancilla systems are available, and that fast, accurate quantum processing can be performed. When the sufficient condition is satisfied, a quantum error-correcting code can be constructed that suppresses the noise without obscuring the signal; the optimal code, achieving the best possible precision, can be found by solving a semidefinite program.

arXiv:1706.02445•Nature Communications•Jan 2, 2018•328 citations

A Heisenberg limit for quantum region estimation

Michael Walter, Joseph M. Renes

The laws of quantum mechanics place fundamental limits on the accuracy of measurements and therefore on the estimation of physical parameters by a quantum system. In this work, we prove lower bounds on the size of confidence regions reported by any region estimator for a given ensemble of probe states and probability of success. Our bounds are derived from a previously unnoticed connection between the size of confidence regions and the error probabilities of a corresponding binary hypothesis test. In group-covariant scenarios, we find that there is an ultimate bound for any estimation scheme which depends only on the representation-theoretic data of the probe system, and we evaluate its asymptotics in the limit of many systems, establishing a general “Heisenberg limit” for region estimation. We apply our results to several scenarios, in particular to phase estimation, where our bounds strengthen the well-known Heisenberg and shot-noise scaling.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2014•1 citation

At the Limits of Criticality-Based Quantum Metrology: Apparent Super-Heisenberg Scaling Revisited

Marek M. Rams, Piotr Sierant, Omyoti Dutta +2 more

Contrary to claims that a fundamental limit of precision in quantum metrology can be broken in certain circumstances, a new analysis shows that this is not the case once one takes into account the time needed to perform the needed operations.

arXiv:1702.05660•Physical Review X•Apr 19, 2018•174 citations
We consider the precision \ensuremathΔ\ensuremathφ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremathΔ\ensuremathφ with which the parameter \ensuremathφ\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremathφ, appearing in the unitary map U\ensuremathφ=ei\ensuremathφ\ensuremathΛ{U}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}={e}^{i\ensuremath{\varphi}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}U\ensuremathφ​=ei\ensuremathφ\ensuremathΛ, acting on some type of probe system, can be estimated when there is a finite amount of prior information about \ensuremathφ\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremathφ. We show that, if U\ensuremathφ{U}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}U\ensuremathφ​ acts nnn times in total, then, asymptotically in nnn, there is a tight lower bound \ensuremathΔ\ensuremathφ\ensuremath≥\ensuremathπ/[n(\ensuremathλ+\ensuremath−\ensuremathλ\ensuremath−)]\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\varphi}\ensuremath{\ge}\ensuremath{\pi}/[n({\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{+}\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{-}})]\ensuremathΔ\ensuremathφ\ensuremath≥\ensuremathπ/[n(\ensuremathλ+​\ensuremath−\ensuremathλ\ensuremath−​)], where \ensuremathλ+{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{+}\ensuremathλ+​, \ensuremathλ\ensuremath−{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremathλ\ensuremath−​ are the extreme eigenvalues of the generator \ensuremathΛ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}\ensuremathΛ. This is greater by a factor of \ensuremathπ\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremathπ than the conventional Heisenberg limit, derived from the properties of the quantum Fisher information. That is, the conventional bound is never saturable. Our result makes no assumptions on the measurement protocol and is relevant not only in the noiseless case but also if noise can be eliminated using quantum error correction techniques.
The Heisenberg limit provides a fundamental bound on the achievable estimation precision with a limited number of NNN resources used (e.g., atoms, photons, etc.). Using entangled quantum states makes it possible to scale the precision with NNN better than when resources would be used independently. Consequently, the optimal use of all resources involves accumulating them in a single execution of the experiment. Unfortunately, that implies that the most common theoretical tool used to analyze metrological protocols - quantum Fisher information (QFI) - does not allow for a reliable description of this problem, as it becomes operationally meaningful only with multiple repetitions of the experiment. In this thesis, using the formalism of Bayesian estimation and the minimax estimator, I derive asymptotically saturable bounds on the precision of the estimation for the case of noiseless unitary evolution. For the case where the number of resources NNN is strictly constrained, I show that the final measurement uncertainty is πππ times larger than would be implied by a naive use of QFI. I also analyze the case where a constraint is imposed only on the average amount of resources, the exact value of which may fluctuate (in which case QFI does not provide any universal bound for precision). In both cases, I study the asymptotic saturability and the rate of convergence of these bounds. In the following part, I analyze the problem of the Heisenberg limit when multiple parameters are measured simultaneously on the same physical system. In particular, I investigate the existence of a gain from measuring all parameters simultaneously compared to distributing the same amount of resources to measure them independently. I focus on two examples - the measurement of multiple phase shifts in a multi-arm interferometer and the measurement of three magnetic field components.
We show that quantification of the performance of quantum-enhanced measurement schemes based on the concept of quantum Fisher information (QFI) yields results that are asymptotically equivalent to those from the rigorous Bayesian approach, provided generic uncorrelated noise is present in the setup. At the same time, we show that for the problem of decoherence-free phase estimation this equivalence breaks down, and the achievable estimation uncertainty calculated within the Bayesian approach is larger by a factor of π than that predicted from the QFI even in the large prior knowledge (small parameter fluctuation) regime, where the QFI is conventionally regarded as a reliable figure of merit. We conjecture that an analogous discrepancy is present in the arbitrary decoherence-free unitary parameter estimation scheme, and propose a general formula for the asymptotically achievable precision limit. We also discuss protocols utilizing states with an indefinite number of particles, and show that within the Bayesian approach it is legitimate to replace the number of particles with the mean number of particles in the formulas for the asymptotic precision, which as a consequence provides another argument for proposals based on the properties of the QFI of indefinite particle number states leading to sub-Heisenberg precisions not being practically feasible.
We derive ultimate precision bounds for estimating parameters encoded in \emph{time-dependent} Hamiltonians in the presence of general Markovian noise, allowing for arbitrary adaptive protocols with fast controls and noiseless ancillas. Extending the minimization-over-purifications framework to time-varying continuous channels, we obtain a differential upper bound on the achievable quantum Fisher information (QFI) that can be evaluated at all times via semidefinite programming. For parameter-independent noise, we prove a universal long-time scaling law: if the coherent (noiseless) dynamics yields Qcoh(T)∼T2kQ_{\mathrm{coh}}(T)\sim T^{2k}Qcoh​(T)∼T2k, then under Markovian noise the QFI scales at most as Q(T)∼T2kQ(T)\sim T^{2k}Q(T)∼T2k in the DHNLS regime, whereas in the DHLS regime it is fundamentally limited to Q(T)∼T2k−1Q(T)\sim T^{2k-1}Q(T)∼T2k−1. We illustrate these behaviors on paradigmatic driven-qubit sensors, exhibiting T4T^{4}T4 and T3T^{3}T3 scalings under dephasing and spontaneous emission, respectively. Finally, we provide explicit continuous exact and approximate quantum error correction constructions -- supplemented by spin-squeezed probes -- that asymptotically saturate the bounds, establishing their tightness.
Quantum metrology has many important applications in science and technology, ranging from frequency spectroscopy to gravitational wave detection. Quantum mechanics imposes a fundamental limit on measurement precision, called the Heisenberg limit, which can be achieved for noiseless quantum systems, but is not achievable in general for systems subject to noise. Here we study how measurement precision can be enhanced through quantum error correction, a general method for protecting a quantum system from the damaging effects of noise. We find a necessary and sufficient condition for achieving the Heisenberg limit using quantum probes subject to Markovian noise, assuming that noiseless ancilla systems are available, and that fast, accurate quantum processing can be performed. When the sufficient condition is satisfied, a quantum error-correcting code can be constructed that suppresses the noise without obscuring the signal; the optimal code, achieving the best possible precision, can be found by solving a semidefinite program.
The laws of quantum mechanics place fundamental limits on the accuracy of measurements and therefore on the estimation of physical parameters by a quantum system. In this work, we prove lower bounds on the size of confidence regions reported by any region estimator for a given ensemble of probe states and probability of success. Our bounds are derived from a previously unnoticed connection between the size of confidence regions and the error probabilities of a corresponding binary hypothesis test. In group-covariant scenarios, we find that there is an ultimate bound for any estimation scheme which depends only on the representation-theoretic data of the probe system, and we evaluate its asymptotics in the limit of many systems, establishing a general “Heisenberg limit” for region estimation. We apply our results to several scenarios, in particular to phase estimation, where our bounds strengthen the well-known Heisenberg and shot-noise scaling.